r/reddit.com•
[deleted]

Reddit, fix your fucking comment system. It is unusably slow.

[deleted]

Posted Feb 28, 2010, 5:15 PM UTC

437485
Orbitrix•

first of all, its the whole website not the comments system.

secondly: Fuckbuddy, fix your fucking sense of entitlement, its unusually high.

(seriously? did you really have to add 'fucking' and come off like a 15 year old douche who thinks he's owed something?)

462
chroniq•

indeed the reddit dev team has been more than forward with their problems and everytime we bitch and moan they almost always deliver. Is it so much to ask nicely?

149
Orbitrix•

exactly, im sure they're working on a solution... patience.... reddit doesnt owe anyone anything.

57
tracekill•

Well I wouldn't go that far. I say they owe me about 1 year of my life back.

65
ParadoX_•

Psssshhhtt, only one year. n00b!

53
[deleted]•

People tend to forget Reddit is a business. It's owned by a media enterprise, and isn't some independent congregate run off a server in some guy's basement.

21
PROBABLY_DRUNK•

sad chuckle

3
[deleted]•

reddit doesnt owe anyone anything

does that mean I can start blocking ads again ?

12
Orbitrix•

absolutely! That would be a much better strategy then asking them 'to fucking fix it'

1
mrmaster2•

I think part of the problem is that the mods have announced several "solutions" that will make the site run faster.

In fact, the opposite seems to be occurring, I've never seen any site load as slow as Reddit has recently been.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
darwin2500•

The staff at Reddit do earn a living, they get paid real money for keeping the site up. Who do they owe for that?

1
Orbitrix•

their advertisers. and they're only able to charge their advertisers as much as they do because of us, the users who visit the site. I see where you are going with this. They still dont owe us a dime... we arent forced into using their website... its as simple as that. Stop whining and leave reddit will send a bigger message than any whiny post will....

2
lurkervizzle•

well, at the end of the day, they are a business (especially given conde nast), and they do owe us customer service. even more so given that our content is what they're selling.

1
Orbitrix•

They aren't selling our content, if that were true they would have to have page-view/click based reddit owned advertisements on the page of each individual link. Reddits advertising model isnt even directly linked to pageviews/clicks in general. This isnt google AdSense, most peoples assumptions about reddit advertising are wrong. Nobody forces you to share your content here either. A good number of people dont even share original content. Its an extremely flawed argument. You give up plenty your rights by submitting to their terms of service by signing up for an account anyways. Dont like it? dont use it. Whining gets us nowhere. You wana fix it? Reddit is open source... download the code and host it on your own server if you think you can do better. and dont bitch unless you have a solid solution. That's all i've been trying to say. I dare someone to link me to one single constructive comment in any of the 4 self posts about todays slowness.

2
mrmaster2•

Ok here goes: Hey guys, can you fix the server and comment system so the site doesn't take 30 seconds every time you click on a link?

Thanks.

4
lrony•

everytime we bitch and moan they almost always deliver.

Because we bitch and moan. Asking nicely gets you nowhere.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mipadi•

Hey now, maybe he is a 15-year-old douche bag who thinks he's owed something!

72
Orbitrix•

very likely, it isnt a school day afterall

25
mipadi•

That's why every day should be a school day.

19
Scarker•

It when you're on The Magic School Bus. CUE THEME SONG.

3
KeyserSosa•

You're correct, Orbitrix, on all accounts.

Gory details of what is currently wrong: We have 5 cache machines running memcachedb that decided to start pegging their respective disks today. These caches serve as db-speedups and have all of our precomputed listings in them. Our site monitor indicates that the problem has been building since Thursday, but it was ever so slow and unnoticeable until some time early this morning when the disks started thrashing. Our supposition is that something index-like got to be too big for RAM. We're working on fixing it

Pre-emptive: "But wait! Reddit is just text! Shouldn't you guys be better than this? I could do better than this!" Yes, we are all text, but all dynamically generated text. Profiling of our code in python indicates that our biggest bottlenecks are "getattr" and "socket.read". The site is heavily cached at an element level (per comment, link, or box) along with a page cache if you aren't logged in.

For the last three months we've also been growing at 20% per month, and even with added capacity, we've encountered bottlenecks (like this one) that are non-obvious.

tldr: we know today is bad. We are working on fixing it. There will be downtime, and we'll try to give everyone advanced warning.

55
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
MercurialAlchemist•

Thanks for the update, and good luck with the fixes. If I can make a suggestion: a pinned post from an admin on the front page would do wonders to alleviate concerns.

3
Orbitrix•

Thanks KeyserSosa... i got a little carried away bashing all the whiners, but i really dont understand why people think you arent aware of the situation... getting whiny immature posts onto the frontpage isnt going to change anything. But I guess people have to get their frustration out somehow.... Anyways, thanks for the update! I have no problem being patient for as long as it takes.

3
monocasa•

There will be downtime

I guess that I'll actually be getting some work done today. : P

1
[deleted]•

Hey, Thursday was my birthday! I bet people were coming here to wish me a happy birthday and that's what was causing all the problems!

So as you can see, it was all just one big misunderstanding, I apologize for birthing on Thursday 22 years ago.

1
RockerSocker•

Now tell us what's being done about the whole Saydrah situation.

0
Ewingo401•

Thanks for letting us know something. But I'm going to have to downvote you for agreeing with Orbitrix...that guy is kind of a prick. Otherwise, carry on.

Edit: Orbitrix isn't really kind of a prick and I take it back.

-1
Orbitrix•

c'mon man, im not that bad :(... i admit i got carried away, shouldnt have been accusing people of being immature 15 year olds.... but honestly, thats all thats going on in this whole thread... immaturity and frustration... completely fruitless i might add.... i'd even go as far to say that the popularity of this thread is a huge contribution to the slowness...

2
Ewingo401•

Ah, fair enough. You've appealed to my sensible side. I'll edit the comment and give my upvote back.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

49
kingtrewq•

Did you read the comment you responded to? Orbitrix was saying that he was complaining in a rude manner. Instead of just saying Reddit your comment is slow, He is demanding it be fixed immediately for him.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

12
kingtrewq•

This is a different situation most complaints aren't worded to aggressively.

-2
mtheoryx•

Some people are just rude. Welcome to life.

Just because he complained in a douchey way does not invalidate the complaint itself.

I, too, have noticed the comments pages are extraordinarily slow-loading today. Can we fix this?

^^ See, different tone, exact same point. Does my complaint deserve more attention than OP's?

4
anonid•

I think in 2010, it's not a crazy thing to feel entitled to...

It took about 30 sec for a single word to load after I clicked this thread. On a Sunday afternoon. If I ever dare click a link from anywhere in reddit, even in a 3-comment thread, it takes 15+ sec to reload that 95% empty reddit page after I click back.

This is a text site, with a search function that doesn't even work. There are people running message boards with graphic-heavy posts and and 100,000 unique visitors per day and everything loads in under one second.

WHEN THE SEARCH DOESN'T WORK, THE SPAM FILTER RANDOMLY BLOCKS LEGITIMATE POSTS (BUT IF YOU KEEP SPAMMING, IT'LL GET THROUGH) AND THE WEBPAGES WITH THIRTY WORDS ON THEM TAKE 20 SEC TO LOAD.... It's time to start swearing. Somebody on reddit has no freaking clue how to run a website.

13
Ewingo401•

Fuck you man, this problem has gone on for WEEKS. The time for being nice is over.

11
nitrousconsumed•

You know, you can always go somewhere else if you're just gonna complain. If you like being here, then just stfu and wait until they fix it.

-10
Ewingo401•

I'll ask you the same question I asked Orbitrix. What is so wrong with expecting a legit issue to be fixed in a timely manner?

5
Orbitrix•

and i'll answer you the same way: because reddit doesnt owe you jack fucking shit.... you dont pay for their service, and they arent required to provide it to you. it isnt a 'product' its a FREE service. So, there for, there is no expectation that they should fix anything... To ask nicely is one thing... to "demand reddit fucking fix it" is something completely different.... leme guess, ur about 15, 16 years old? entitlement is a very common misconception at that age

-13
king_felix•

Love it or leave it.

-2
[deleted]•

Wait. I'm confused; are we talking about Reddit or our genitals now?

0
Orbitrix•

so... dont use reddit, go use digg.... nobodys holding a gun to your head

-15
Ewingo401•

So I should use an inferior product because reddit can't fix their shit? Let me ask you an honest question. What is so wrong about expecting a legit issue to be fixed in a timely manner?

4
Orbitrix•

because reddit doesnt owe you jack fucking shit.... you dont pay for their service, and they arent required to provide it to you. it isnt a 'product' its a FREE service. So, there for, there is no expectation that they should fix anything... To ask nicely is one thing... to "demand reddit fucking fix it" is something completely different.... leme guess, ur about 15, 16 years old? entitlement is a very common misconception at that age

-9
[deleted]•

nobodys holding a gun to your head

Speak for yourself there buddy.

4

FIRST OF ALL, FUCK YOU AND YOUR LITTLE THEORY! SERIOUSLY? DID YOU HAVE TO ADD A PARENTHETICAL POSTSCRIPT TO YOUR POST? THIS SHIT HAS GOTTEN WAY OUT OF HAND! I DEMAND MY COMPLAINTS BE RECOGNIZED BECAUSE I AM OWED IT FOR A LIFETIME OF CRAVING SOME FORM OF ACCEPTANCE FOR MY SHITTY OPINIONS!

CRAWL UP YOUR OWN SHITHOLE AND SIT THERE FOR A FEW DAYS SO YOU CAN UNDERSTAND WHAT IT'S LIKE TO LISTEN TO YOUR SHIT. MAYBE THEN YOU COULD EMPATHIZE WITH OUR FUCKING PLIGHT! I WILL FACEFUCK YOU INTO COMPLIANCE WITH MY IDEALS! THIS FUCKING SHIT HAS GONE ON LONG ENOUGH!

9
[deleted]•

HAVE YOU CONSIDERED THAT IT'S NOT THAT THE SITE IS RUNNING SLOW BUT SUPER_SUPER FAST? THAT IT ONLY APPEARS SLOW BECAUSE IT'S LOADING AND RELOADING COMMENTS BEFORE YOU'RE EVEN AWARE OF DOING IT YOURSELF.

I SEE THINGS AT 36 FRAMES PER SECOND AND PERSONALLY SURFING REDDIT RECENTLY HAS FELT A BIT LIKE THIS.

2
[deleted]•

Dude, check out his username.

2
Orbitrix•

i lol'd, upvoted

-2
tomg288374•

User fuckbuddy is clearly in the wrong. In contrast, good redditors know that administering the reddit site takes a lot of hard work and that the only true free things on the internet are copyrighted mp3s and movie torrents.

8
PeachWombat•

It seems like it worked, though. This is the first post about slowness that I see make it to the top.

8
Orbitrix•

yea lol i just responded to Nerdlinger having the same epiphany. Its still immature and above the reddit community though. I like reddit because we aren't lame like that...

-2
mtheoryx•

I like reddit because we aren't lame like that

I like Reddit because most of its users truly believe that, whether it's fact or fantasy...

1
PeachWombat•

Oh, I agree. I don't like it and don't like the fact that THIS is what worked, merely making an observation.
And it remains to be seen if admins would actually grace it with a response, they have their plate full with that whole Saydrah business.

1
Orbitrix•

i wouldnt really say "it worked". the sites still slow... Im pretty sure the admins dont need a snarky article to make it to the front page for them to know theres a problem... this guys basicly just karma whoring off the problems

1
tsuga•

Its still immature and above the reddit community though. I like reddit because we aren't lame like that...

yea lol

That, right there? That's some funny shit.

1
Work45•

The content has also become much worse. People at my work use reddit and they are always saying, "Hey did you see this?" I haven't, when I go and check its because I'm not subscribed to some weird subreddit. If I do subscribe to that subreddit I'm spammed with horrible shit.

I just want good stuff on my front page, I don't want to constantly check other subreddits to see if there is a really funny video. If there is a funny video put it on my frontpage. And give me a way to turn off all self posts.

3
2xyn1xx•

I had the same problem so now I have my Reddits in one tab and r/all in another. It's actually working really well; it's like I have two Reddits.

2
Orbitrix•

so... dont use reddit, go use digg.... nobodys holding a gun to your head

-7
Work45•

This is called constructive criticism. I am using digg a lot more lately, but I think reddit has more potential, so I'd like to see it get better. The whole point of this site is the comments and stories that are submitted, check my profile, I've helped build this site, even if only a little.

1
Orbitrix•

Link me to one single constructive criticism about these issues? The admins have known about the slowness for well over a month and have been working on a solution. All i see is immature whining and people thinking they're somehow entitled to reddit. Getting some snarky self post to the front page isnt going to tell the admins anything they dont already know. Infact most of the solutions to this problem are WELL over the heads of these whiners.

1
[deleted]•

No, but if the community is part of the business, they probably wouldn't want to ignore these things. It is rude, but for reddit and sites like reddit, the community make the site as well as the other aspects. I am not going to get into all the contributing factors, be I think everyone can agree we all add to this place in some capacity.

I don't think we should dispel this dudes complaint.

3
Workaphobia•

Sense of fucking entitlement? I use fucking reddit. Fuck, don't fucking tell me fucking what to fucking expect from it.

Seriously though, I'm a user of a website, and despite the number of times a day I hit refresh, I can still choose not to come here. So don't tell me it's an unwarranted sense of entitlement when I want the page to come up in under half a minute.

3
Orbitrix•

precisely, instead of piling onto the immaturity that is killing the reddit vibe and asking them to 'fucking fix it' people can just go use something else.... its pretty simple, and will send a bigger message. If every lame person with a sense of reddit entitlement left to use another site to 'send a message' not only would the servers stop being slow, but we'd have a lot less lame people here lol....

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
[deleted]•

+8 for entitlement

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Orbitrix•

You're absolutely correct, but im pretty sure reddit doesnt need a snarky article to make it to the front page to know their servers are fucked. Im sure they're well aware of the situation. The biggest impact you can have is to not come to reddit if you dont enjoy the quality of their service... it'd send them a message that they better get their shit fixed, or they'll keep losing users. In the meanwhile things would be less low for the rest of us :)

-1
sammyc•

I agree, the use of "fucking" comes across as rude, yet I still up-voted this submission. This is how I justify it:

The Reddit admins have always seemed really keen (in comparison to other websites) to improve the site and listen to the users. If they were volunteers building this by themselves, this post would be totally out of line, but the fact is that Reddit is owned by Conde Nast. Now, if we were to submit quiet complaints about this, they could quite easily be overlooked. However, which such a post on the homepage, it cannot be ignored, and the reddit admins themselves can use it as direct evidence that the problem needs fixing and campaign to Conde Nast for new severs/optimization experts, whatever is needed.

I may have invented an entirely ridiculous and contrived situation in my head just there.

1
ShawnGupta•

So use the word fucking more often to get more money?

1
Crimeth•

Sorry, but I think a website should at least be functional. I agree with fuckbuddy and don't mind his tone at all.

1
Orbitrix•

instead of him bitching, why doesn't he submit a patch? The code for all of Reddit is posted online. If he knows that its so simple to fix, then he should fix it for all of us instead of whining. Im pretty sure the admins dont need a snarky immature article to make it to the front page for them to know their website is slow. They have been well aware for many weeks. The biggest impact you could have is to stop bitching, and stop using reddit... then they'd be like "fuck we're losing avertising revenue and users, we better fix our shit" All this post is doing is karma whoring off the situation and frustration of all the users and providing a platform for a bunch of whiners. I agree i wish the site were fixed, and it should work... but this isnt going to accomplish anything. Except for maybe killing the reddit vibe... this isnt digg.. we try not to be immature and lame... its hard sometimes, but dammit, we try.

2
vitaminrad•

You need to enhance your calm, dude.

1

everyone on reddit thinks their owed something

1
[deleted]•

I came her to say exactly what you said, right down to the word entitlement. Thanks.

0
Orbitrix•

yea, the weekends bring out all the teenagers... cant wait for school to start again... its all these youngins on weekend thats probably making the site slow

-7
[deleted]•

Well, there is obviously some sort of problem, but I personally don't usually fix things for people who say fuckity fuck fuck fuckenschplitt.

0
mtheoryx•

Well fuck.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
Orbitrix•

:'( lol

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
mtheoryx•

Louis C.K. is great and all, but you can't cite his standup routine as a business model.

Perhaps that argument would apply to free radio when referring to ads or something, but you owe it to your users to at least make a site usable.

Over 30 seconds to load a page with 3 comments is not acceptable, regardless how much the user pays for it. (hint: we do pay for it, via our eyeballs on ads, this ain't a fucking charity they're running here)

2
tibbon•

Right- instead of him bitching, why doesn't he submit a patch? The code for all of Reddit is posted online. If he knows that its so simple to fix, then he should fix it for all of us instead of whining.

-1
owlmanatt•

secondly: Fuckbuddy, fix your fucking sense of entitlement, its unusually high.

(seriously? did you really have to add 'fucking' and come off like a 15 year old douche who thinks he's owed something?)

sup pot, kettle here.

-6
MeGusta•

(Pssst--I think he was using OP's phrasing. It's a rhetorical style.)

13
KKJS•

Whoosh

5
Orbitrix•

its called MOCKING... you'll see i used the same sentance structure almost word for word as him.... WHOOOSH ... way to let that one slip right over your head

Reddit, fix your fucking comment system. It is unusably slow.

Fuckbuddy, fix your fucking sense of entitlement. It is unusually high.

get it? i guess not

-10
owlmanatt•

You reply to getting called out on being an asshole by being an asshole?

YEAH YOU WERE TOTALLY BEING SARCASTIC AND AREN'T A DOUCHEBAG AT ALL DOHOHO

-1
Orbitrix•

its called IRONY... yea.. i was being sarcastic in an ironic way... and not a douchebag at all...

-3
mapoftasmania•

It's so slow that I'm opening comments in another tab and going back to browse the front page while I wait 30 seconds for it to load.

224
v13•

Only 30? Shit that's fast!

158
dghughes•

In my day we had to wait a 30 minutes and walk backwards up a hill in the snow.

66
[deleted]•

In my day we had to wait overnight for FIDONet to retrieve our messages from another BBS long distance and pay back the SysOp for the 1 minute phone call.

EDIT: No, seriously: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-3145680396796021272#

15
AlSweigart•

Right. I had to get up in the morning at ten o'clock at night half an hour before I went to bed, boot up my computer with a heavy crank, download twenty-nine hours a day at the telegraph office, and pay telegraph owner for permission to use my own semaphore flags, and when we got home, our ISP would Ping-of-Death us and dance about on our dropped packets singing Hallelujah.

10
[deleted]•

Bitch please, I was cruising ARPANET while you were still in diapers.

9
frequentSeas•

In my day the internet wasn't invented.

2
[deleted]•

In my day, we didn't even HAVE the Internet. Sometimes, letters took over a week (yes a WEEK) to arrive!

1
davidreiss666•

I own that documentary on DVD. Memories.

1
Drluv•

BBSs were cool.

1
ddrt•

I've been waiting 24 years to say this: Get off my lawn.

4
PanglossAlberta•

Please don't tell me you're only 24. . .

1
wickedcold•

Ah yes, I had a 14.4k modem too....

3
IWasHereFirst•

Luxury! 14.4K modems were screamingly fast compared to the acoustic couplers we had to use.

3
rebel•

I only had a 1200 baud modem youngster!

2
SarahC•

I had a chain of mercury lines between me and the exchange...

Your speaker would whack into the end, and the vibrations would travel through the mercury to the exchange, where a little magnet was moved through a coil, and they'd generate the audio signal from that.

That was before long lengths of wire were invented, obviously.

1
in_my_day•

Don't even get me started...

3
youenjoymyself•

And don't forget checking out the pond only to find out most of it is frozen. Had time to dry off and warm up while waiting for this page to show.

1
v0-z•

My greasemonkey scripts wont even load :(

3
[deleted]•

brb

8
ertemplin•

It's so slow that I'm opening comments in another tab and going back to browse the front page while I wait 300 seconds for it to load.

4
DeafPuppy•

Is anyone else getting excited when it only takes 150 seconds? It feels like a reward or something, like you did something right and the reddit gods are pleased.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
ZeppelinJ0•

I watched an entire power play waiting for this thread to load, it's pretty bad today

1
DeathIsTruth•

haha guess I'm not the only one doing that...I thought it was my connection or computer. But normal pages do load faster...

1
Crath•

Is it just me or is the entire site unusably slow right now?

185
Pixelpaws•

It's not just you. I've had various up/down votes not count because they timed out or something, even on the front page.

42
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
BearJew•

If you're bored of browsing reddit today because of it's slowness, maybe you could check DebateZone and post something. It will be fun, I promise.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
zone•

I think it twice before opening a comment page/self post... It's like "is the title of this submision THAT intesting for waiting +1 minute for it to load?" The worst thing is that it hangs my whole system.. Pentium III here. I can't no even do anything else till it loads. It's so frustraiting. I really wanna use the site but it is beyond annoying now..

23
Gaget•

I'm upvoting out of pity. Pentium III? Jebus.

12
p1mrx•

Hey, at least it's not a Pentium 4.

12
scientologist2•

he could heave upgraded to this old time server board

The Soyo SY-6KD is Soyo's flagship Dual Processor Pentium II LX motherboard, sporting 4 DIMM slots, 5 PCI slots (1 can be used for an I20 Upgrade), and 2 ISA slots

1
[deleted]•

And then somebody responds to your post and, what with having already invested your time, you just know that you're going to have to waste another minute replying to him even though he didn't really add anything.

<shakes head> It's FRUSTRATING! </shakes head>

1
SarahC•

I hate it when you have to respond to someone but they don't really add anything to the discussion too!

That's what you said, right?

5
[deleted]•

It happens a lot.

2
[deleted]•

ProTIP: none of your votes on reddit 'count'

0
duhblow7•

it's been like this for close to a month. all those upgrades and the site got even slower. you'll see my reddit usage taper off dramatically in the last couple weeks.

6
OMouse•

Aren't they using EC2 or some bullshit "cloud" thingy now? Whatever happened to running your own smooth-running servers?

3
adpowers•

How many times must the admins confirm that EC2 and "the cloud" isn't the problem.

http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/b6uba/why_is_reddit_so_slow_lately/c0l9xc9

I saw a comment from an admin the other month saying that their growth rate is pretty high right now and their architecture wasn't scaling to meet the ~30% monthly growth rate (or whatever it was).

11
[deleted]•

saying that their growth rate is pretty high right now

They mostly come at night. Mostly.

5
SarahC•

Not only that, last week I was watching a submitted comment create a range of errors : 504........ 503........... Ooooo! 504 again!

Right now, at least the pages appear - eventually.

1
LeazZ•

Reddit Announcer: "We seem to be experimenting some techmological differences."

1
LeazZ•

Reddit Announcer: "We seem to be experimenting some... techmological, uh.. differences."

1
ratbastid•

Knock knock.
Who's there?
.
.
.
.
.
.
Reddit.

131
HunterTV•

Reddit

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

who?

60
invictusmaneo•

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

Nevermind, I left and went to a different website.

98
[deleted]•

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Liar. You came back. We always come back.

67
Scarker•

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

Tha

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

503 Service Unavailable

No server is available to handle this request.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

t's true.

37
LWRellim•

Not always...

If it continues, people will give up.

0
jerrygofixit•

503 Service Unavailable.

8
jolalajou•

007 James Bond

6
DIYromania•

Wha?

-1
mtheoryx•

buffering... buffering... buffering...

2
[deleted]•

It's to entice you guys into upgrading to Reddit Gold.

130
McGlockenshire•

[This comment available to Reddit Gold members only.]

(e: This post was made a few years before Reddit Gold actually became a thing. It's based on an old 4chan meme. Real Reddit Gold does not restrict content in this way.)

107
[deleted]•

[deleted]

48
exscape•

I still can't see the text. :(

18
[deleted]•

Platinum Redditers not only see the text but they get a link to the 'Glockenshire Annual Jimson Joint and Wool Fest' photos.

19
Scarker•

Reddit Gold? Clearly you haven't heard of Reddit Olympiad, it's the best one. They send bacon to your hou**[This has been a preview of Reddit Olympiad. To read the full comment, please click here for full membership.]**

13
bdfortin•

This link is active for Reddit Gold members only.

9
Scarker•

Damn it, I wish I could pay the $5.99.

3
davidreiss666•

Fuck Reddit Gold. Reddit Platinum is where it's at!

2
ACSlater•

Aren't you guys kind of ashamed to still be pawning off a 4chan meme from 2 years ago on another website?

-5
SarahC•

Not at all...

4chan's like a mine for diamonds. Shit comes out most of the time, but occasionally a diamond appears... it's up to the rest of the net to keep hold of those diamonds before they're washed away by more shit...

4chan is the mine.

Reddit is the filter.

3
lllama•

So Reddit is drenched in shit. I think I like that analogy.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
danchan22•

It's so slow, I'm still waiting for this page to load so I can comment on how slow it is.

81
negascout•

HOW slow is it?

edit: oh, the rest of your comment hadn't loaded I see it now

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

73
Chr0me•

Correlation != causation.

Reddit's monthly pageviews have also increased 3-4x since moving to EC2.

32
pdclkdc•

i thought the whole point of EC2 was to allow the site to easily grow to handle that type of usage increase.

amazon is great idea, but it seems like half the sites that switch to it gets shitty inconsistent performance.

12
Chr0me•

I can't speak for Reddit, but I do follow their development pretty closely:

Reddit wasn't originally written to take advantage of automatic scaling features of EC2. For example, the system doesn't automatically spin-up additional app servers when they're needed. Someone has to push at button at Reddit HQ to make that happen. However they are working to eventually make it automatic.

I don't know about "half the sites" that switch has issues. I do a lot of work with EC2 and Pylons (hence my interest in Reddit's tech). You have to think about the system architecture differently (instances are ephemeral, EBS speeds up and slows down randomly, etc). But once you take that stuff into account, plus all the advantages, performance can be fine.

Bottom line: The issues with Reddit are more attributable to their phenomenal growth than the switch to EC2. But being on EC2 adds some additional challenges. Give them time to work the kinks out.

5
mkrfctr•

Reddit must construct additional Pylons, got it.

1
norm_•

The new buzzword is "Cloud."

3
joemoon•

Scalability is very hard, regardless of whether or not you use EC2 (or another "cloud service"). Cloud computing is not a silver bullet, it has pros and cons like everything else. Reddit decided that the pros were better than the cons, and I tend to agree with them from a technical standpoint. If you want some more details, see jedberg's pycon talk: http://pycon.blip.tv/file/3257303/

1
mtheoryx•

It's also almost an entirely text-based site.

3
OMouse•

It's increased because we have to keep hitting the fucking reload button. I hit it 4 times just to load this one page and I hit it twice on every other comment page that I clicked :-|

1
[deleted]•

Because we have to reload it 3-4 more times to get the content to load.

1
semanticist•
1
mtheoryx•

I'm gonna be the asshole and point out a very simple fact (and probably be downvoted to hell by mindless masses):

Digg scales just fine.

They have more graphics, more users, generally more bullshit on each page... yet, they scale just fine.

So, perhaps... just maybe Reddit is not doing something correctly. I know, hard to believe, but trust me, it is within the realm of possibility.

10
forkqueue•

Of course reddit isn't doing something correctly - nobody wants their site to be slow.

The hard bit is working out what that something is, and what to modify so it is correct.

WRT digg - it seems to me (and I haven't used digg for 3 years or so) that each article gets far less comments than on reddit. That would make it rather easier to scale.

I suspect the fact that digg now uses Cassandra for large parts of its site is a large part of why it performs so much better. Switching to noSQL for parts of the site is not going to be a quick or easy task though.

2
jedberg•

digg is a far less complex site than reddit. Images are easy to scale -- high transaction rates are not.

reddit is a far more customized user experience than digg -- on par with a site like Facebook, which has about 1000 times as many servers.

1
duhblow7•

gateway time outs.

service unavailable.

searches returning zero results, for common topics.

over 30 seconds for page loads.

7
lotictrance•

I wish there was a real elephant. That would be cool.

7
redmongrel•

Oh shit did they switch to Amazon S3 cloud storage? Anyone could have told them how bad THAT sucks - I can't believe they wouldn't know better... must have been a hell of a deal.

4
mtheoryx•

It's not S3 storage that's a problem. That works pretty well. It's the EC2 compute service.

1
redmongrel•

Thanks, I didn't realize they were necessarily distinguishable. I do know we had a content provider before moving to Box that moved to S3 and the whole platform turned slow as shit. Guess that coulda been EC2 as well.

1
jedberg•

EC2 works great. That isn't the problem.

1
jedberg•

We moved to EC2 in May 2009. They have nothing to do with this problem. In fact, being on EC2 is the only thing that saved us.

3
nevesis•

And the problems started around then...

Just kidding. Thank you for the reply. I'll believe you about Reddit but continue to harbor suspicions about EC2 sucking! :)

1
muahdib•

Also, they lost all my comments apart from three yesterday, which I've made the last years. The comments are still in the fora though.

1
muahdib•

when they switched to Amazon.

When did that happen? I haven't read that in the news anywhere. For my own I've experienced a slow down of reddit during the last weeks I think until it became totally unbearable today.

I haven't yet understood neither the infra structure nor the API used for EC2, but as far I've grasped it not really a grid computing service as e.g. google app engine, which I do understand somewhat, at least concepts like map-reduce which is an amazingly nice (functional programming style) way of doing massively parallel computation without knowing much about parallel computation. On the other hand, reddit is not really about massively parallel computation. It's merely about joining information from multiple sources into one database, and then extract information from that database, so the database concept is very important. Google uses a custom made database, I don't know if that is available through the app engine though.

For my own I thought the problem had something to do with caching because reddit recently started appear as wildly different addresses on different networks. (all being aliases for reddit.com.edgesuite.net).

1
nailz1000•

Whut? What is that about?

0
speaker219•

They recently moved to amazon's EC2 service, which is basically xen virtual machines. And it's slow, apparently. http://blog.reddit.com/2010/01/why-did-we-take-reddit-down-for-71.html

2
joemoon•

And it's slow, apparently.

Did you even read the blog post? A direct quote: "Any slowness that reddit has been experiencing is our fault, not theirs."

3
rq60•

they were just being nice.

3
jedberg•

The move wasn't recent -- it happened in May 2009.

2
speaker219•

Sorry. Didn't mean to spread misinformation... my mistake D:

2
exscape•

First sentence:

As most of you know, we moved reddit to EC2 back in May of 2009.

Yeah. Recently.

1
ObligatoryResponse•

The fan went out on my graphics card and now I get bluescreens whenever I try to play games or otherwise stress the graphics card. MS really screwed the pooch with XP; it's totally unstable. I might have to upgrade to Win7; maybe things won't be so bad. WTF Microsoft!

1
[deleted]•
2
almbfsek•

I wish they have chosen Linode over EC2. It's not cloud but it's fucking fast.

0
joemoon•

Just in case someone takes this comment seriously, almbfsek is either trolling or is grossly misinformed. The hardware provider (Linode vs Amazon) has nothing to do with the scalability problems reddit has been experiencing. Jedberg talks about it in detail here: http://pycon.blip.tv/file/3257303/

4
almbfsek•

I wasn't trolling, I was referring to this: http://journal.uggedal.com/vps-performance-comparison edit: I use neither btw, I'm not a linode employee or something nor the fella that made the benchmark.

-3
libcrypto•

Plus, they wouldn't have to serve pages to all the folks behind firewalls that block Linode because it's just one big Chinese crack launchpad. (Linode is flatly lying about the Google intrusion, in my estimation: I see a tremendous number of Linode-owned IPs as the sources of breakin attempts, even now.)

-3
[deleted]•

Maybe you should drop Linode some abuse mail instead of spouting conspiracy theories?

3
libcrypto•

I'm afraid you don't know the difference between speculation and a conspiracy theory. I'm merely speculating (note, "in my estimation"). A conspiracy theory is a horse of a very different color.

However.

I send out plenty of abuse mail, and believe me, Linode ain't the only source of trouble that gets a note from me. Generally, the only responders are universities, and they're usually quite contrite and surprised.

Mark my words: 2-3 years from now, vhost abuse will be at epidemic levels, and you'll be hearing plenty about it in the news, not just some dude you don't know on reddit.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
nevesis•

I was going to reply to your comment and correct your misinformation but this page took 20 minutes to load and I forgot what I was going to say.

2
SarahC•
-1
joemoon•

Reddit has addressed it:

http://blog.reddit.com/2010/01/why-did-we-take-reddit-down-for-71.html

http://pycon.blip.tv/file/3257303/

tl;dr Scaling is very hard. Amazon's EC2 service has pros and cons.

Your accusation is (at best) completely ignorant.

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mtheoryx•

Reddit has addressed it

Page load times have been fucked for over a month.

Perhaps you don't understand what 'addressed' means?

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
opnwyder•

I think there would be twice as many comments on this issue but half the people fell asleep waiting for the coments page to open.

68
boozinf•
              ------------- 
             /             \ 
reddit >>>>>      shark     >>>>>> reddit
3
[deleted]•

I got a 503 on first attempt to load this story.

1
misterdave•

It's got noticeably worse in the last hour or so. Probably something broke somewhere, be patient, it'll get repaired!

61
anonymousgangster•

making website is hard work

8
pdclkdc•

... except this has been happening off and on for weeks. is it that something broke several times, or that something larger is going on?

5
alesis•

Ah the joys of using the Amazon cloud. Often it rains and the servers get all wet.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-5
washer•

I just got a reddit Gold™ account, and I won't stand for this shit!

31
Gackt•

Fuck me, I paid for a friggin platinum account and the promised faster speeds are a lie..

2
mtheoryx•

In the fine print, they say "up to" for the speeds.

2
canada432•

I doubt its a simple fix. Its been getting steadily worse for several months now. I'm not sure if its from the recent additions being inefficient, or possibly the growing number of users, or maybe even the number of subreddits with custom themes. Whatever it is, it likely requires some pretty handy hardware upgrades or extensive code optimization, which is bound to take a while.

20
nevesis•

It all started when they sold their servers and moved to Amazon's cloud hosting.

17
jedberg•

I doubt that. We moved to EC2 in May 2009.

EC2 has nothing to do with why the site is slow. In fact, it is the only thing that saved us.

2
maryjayjay•

Reddit runs on the Amazon EC2 cloud.

9
jedberg•

... which has absolutely nothing to do with why the site is/was slow. In fact, that is the only thing that saved us.

1
adamdecaf•

Then donate money so Reddit can buy better/more servers.

5
rightc0ast•

What about those of us who have supported their charities, their advertisers (yeah, that's me, the guy who gets the thank you for not using adblock ad every 5th reload. ;), and their redditads and amazon page? Do we get to complain, and maybe ... just maybe, even say it's almost enough and they have to choose at this point between fixing it now, or losing users who don't want to go to a site that makes Digg look like greased lightning?

I think we should be actively voicing our displeasure. It's your tool here to help the parent company throw resources into the problem. Politely I suppose, of course ... but don't reply to displeased commenters with things like that. I can assure you that when there is a meeting and these people are looking at the number of these threads, the displeased comments will help fix it more than allowing the parent company, or whoever makes the choices, to say something like, "but look, 54% of the comments are telling people to STFU or give us more money!"

7
adamdecaf•

You're absolutely right, anyone who has donated or participated should be able to voice their annoyance at the slowness. What reddit doesn't need is 40 new threads about how slow the comments are, one giant thread about how slow they are would do the same as 40, only the 40 actually puts more stress on the servers.

I'm sure the admins will get on and make an announcement about what's wrong and what we can do to help.

0
mtheoryx•

Reddit is not a charity.

And they aren't buying better/more servers. They don't own any servers anymore.

My eyeballs on Reddit's ads is the only "donation" I'll ever give to Reddit... especially when the site performs like shit, and anyone who dares to complain is met with "reddit doesn't owe you shit"

They don't owe me shit? They why would I donate to them? It goes both ways, you see.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
fas2•

God you're pretentious. The least you could do is asking a little more nicely for all the hard work the admins do.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-9
TheTwilightPrince•

Well you're here aren't you? So it's clearly "usable"

2
nwalker85•

I don't understand so I'm just going to yell!

1
thedkl•

say please

0
AngryBadger•

Your Mother never taught you to say please?

"I don't understand why it keeps happening" - no that's right you don't. You don't have a clue about the effort it takes maintaining and running a site like this, so why don't you tone down your demands and try and be a bit more understanding.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
Spacksack•

Are you entitled to your free reddit service? Will you make a fuss and leave? Maybe this is the solution.

-10
ratbastid•

I pay for my reddit service by being an eyeball-provider-for and occasional clicker-on-of reddit's advertising products.

That said, you still get more flies with honey. I'm sure the admins are aware of how creaky Reddit is this morning. No need to yell about it.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
SurferDude•

I would absolutely pay a small fee each month to stay on reddit. As it is, I already bought the iReddit program.

That said, reddit is only useful if comments are easily and quickly accessible.

6
MeAndMyHand•

Shhh!!!

Don't give the government any ideas!

1
zdiggler•

WE provide the Content for this site. Without US there wont' be Reddit.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
kornork•

Yeah, who is this asshat? How can someone demand anything like that?

-1
loveinatrashcan•

You're getting downvoted, but I agree.

If I got something for free, and there was something wrong with it, I wouldn't approach them with such an ungrateful attitude.

2
hoffnutsisdope•

Hey everyone it's Sunday. Go outside for a few hours while they fix it.

Lol yea right... FIX IT NOW FOR THE LOVE OF GOD!!!!

41
grillcover•

Between the two lines of your comment, I looked outside at the gross black snow and puddles and said, "Fuck that"

I'm glad to see you come around!

17
chibigoten•

It's COLD outside. NO!

4
Zoned•

..and mostly covered in knee-deep snow!!

3
[deleted]•

That's a lie. It's only the top bit that's knee-deep.

4
forsalebypwner•

Hey, why don't we just spend the morning at Chur... oh wait, never mind.

3
jaymz168•

A few hours? It's been like this all week.

2
[deleted]•

Finally, someone else is speaking up! Let me go into the comments and --- five minutes later, staring at white screen -- oh fuck.

33
Popenator•

Loading...

19
magusg•

Dammit, I still can't see your comment.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
redditkid•

Well, I guess we could all go hang out on Digg

18
[deleted]•

Don't joke about things like that.

13
He11razor•

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOoooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

0
mikeromanul•

Burn, unbeliever!

-1
Daysofclark•
17
ShapkaSamosranka•

What's more amusing is how embarrassed you are about your bookmarks bar.

It's ok to use Yahoo Mail.

18
strolls•

If the yellow circle on the left hand side is part of the Norton antivirus suite then he's right to be ashamed.

13

But there's a gmail checker on the status bar.

2
xenofon•

heh, I can make out the Rotten Tomatoes logo

1
Daysofclark•
1
PROBABLY_DRUNK•

he should have blurred out the default search provider too.. I mean really.. wikipedia?

0
portugal_the_man•

Why not go all the way and blur the entire image.

2
djepik•

I got that too :(

3
buba1243•

Clicked your link in a new tab when I closed that it went to my next open tab which was the same error.

2
Scarker•

28/02/10 NEVER FORGET THE DAY SHIT BLEW UP

12
Rubin0•

I have way too many days to remember.

5
jerstud56•

I can't hardly remember what day it is, let alone days I need to remember.

1
Firebert010•

I have switched to tabbed browsing because it takes so long for one link to load, so I just put them on the back burner per se.

No website should be like this, not to mention one of the most active news sites there is.

It won't take long before enough pissed off people make something happen.

10
[deleted]•

I posted this reply 3 days ago

10
GAMEOVER•

The fix is really simple, just type "slow comments" into the reddit search and... oh... right.

9
LWRellim•

Type it into where?

Oh, that "search" thingee, the one that doesn't work.

0
vicegrip•

I've noticed a couple posts of late that I've made that don't appear in my personal history but to which I have replies in my message box.

8
Alanna•

I've experienced the same thing. Is there a place to report it?

1
FillInTheBlank•

The admins. Message them.

1
Alanna•

I would! if the site weren't so damn slow... grrrr! :(

1
vicegrip•

Downvoted .. and no explanation of why.

Well, I guess I'll add why I posted this then. I noticed this problem that appears to be a bug to me and I replied here on the thought that it could be an error that on a widescale could explain some of the slowness reported here.

-1
zdiggler•

Not to mention quality of front page articles lately. hmmm..

8