r/SubredditDrama•
[deleted]

[recap] The Tale of /r/LGBT - Part IV

##If you have not read Part I, Part II or Part III already then please read them first.##


##LordGaGa attempts to become a mod of /r/LGBT##

LordGaGa attempted to become a moderator of /r/LGBT. LordGaGa offers to help defuse the drama in /r/LGBT; by giving such advice as:

  • Making a peace offering with /r/LGBT

  • Giving some banned users a second chance

RobotAnna responds stating that they have plans later already and that in actual fact Reddit has a PR problem, not the moderators of /r/LGBT.

Later on, in the irc #subredditdrama, the moderators of /r/LGBT SilentAgony and rmuser enter to talk to LordGaGa (Manator in irc) about her plans and whether she should become a mod of /r/LGBT. The full logs are here but here is a version with the important talk highlighted.

SilentAgony states that there are another two moderators in line to be offered a position of /r/LGBT and that they have a 'plan' in the works already. LordGaGa responds that their plan will not work due to the publication of these [recap] posts. Link

SilentAgony responds saying that in fact /r/subredditdrama and LordGaGa are actually encouraging the drama and the [moderators of r/LGBT are being held hostage or being blackmailed.] LordGaGa responds saying then when you actually take seriously they'll talk but at the moment she doesn't care and asks to be banned again. Link

At this point, rmuser enters the irc. A person in the irc asks whether rmuser thinks that LordGaGa should be a mod of /r/LGBT. rmuser responds with a resounding no. It's then asked if rmuser and SilentAgony had decided before they entered . The answer is yes, they will not make LordGaGa a moderator. Link

rmuser then admits that making RobotAnna a moderator was a mistake and asks whether any in the irc have any suggestions on what to do with /r/LGBT. Someone responds that they should drop the sources of the drama and cut all ties. This means that they should revert to how /r/LGBT was previously before the announcement and also remove RobotAnna as a moderator. Link

rmuser admits that she now understands the seriousness of the situation and is aware of how deeply people care about /r/LGBT. She carries on talking and reveals that they are indeed looking for new moderators and are reaching out quite far in order to find them. Furthermore, she understands that she has little to no clout within the community. LordGaGa responds that this isn't true. Link

In a turn, LordGaGa kicks rmuser and SilentAgony from the irc and states that she is tired of trying to be nice, that they were just ignoring her, putting her weight behind /r/ainbow and that she should just be banned from /r/LGBT again. LordGaGa continues talking about how the moderators of /r/LGBT just don't care or give a shit about their subreddit. Link


###This is all the drama that has happened so far but I'm sure the epic saga will continue...###


##Miscellaneous##

##SilentAgony Halloween costume drama##

Four months ago SilentAgony submitted a post in /r/LGBT of her halloween costume. The post caused such a stir that it was linked too by /r/bigotryshowcase. Furthermore, it spawned other threads about how hurtful SilentAgony had been to the /r/LGBT community as a result of her costume.

In the thread, SilentAgony, dressed as a drag queen, here, was buried under an avalaunch of comments deriding how insensitive she had been to trans people. Here are the top comments of that thread. In the thread SilentAgony states that she didn't do it to be supportive.

In her usual fashion SilentAgony responds to it negatively and berates users who commented:

Rmuser then steps in to defend SilentAgony**[1 2 3 4]**. Furthermore, rmuser states that the post will not be removed.

Laurelai also stuck up for SilentAgony about the post. Later on, SilentAgony does admit that she should not have posted it without context.


Posted Mar 8, 2012, 8:34 PM UTC · edited

7456
[deleted]•

[deleted]

17
Epistaxis•

I'm only pointing out typos because these posts should be archived for posterity:

LordGaGa offers to help diffuse the drama

I assume you mean defuse, like to remove the fuse of a bomb, and not diffuse, like to spread it around, although LGG certainly does the latter too.

in fact r/subredditdrama and LordGaGa are in fact encouraging

You said "in fact" twice.

LordGaGa should be a mod r/LGBT

of

Now for a more substantial issue: is it relevant to mention the fact that LGG resigned as a mod of SRD shortly after the IRC kerfluffle? I thought the general consensus was that these events were related, but Her Lordship hasn't really been around to answer our questions or heartfelt pleas for her return.

Keep up the great work!

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Epistaxis•

'Diffuse' is an actual word.

Sure, but I think you meant a different word.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
stopscopiesmedoesn't even go here•

I believe LordGaGa resigning was partially related to the irc conversation.

see my r/subredditdramadrama post if you haven't already. The criticism in the thread was what prompted the resignation

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
zahlman•

Also:

LordGaGa offers to help defuse the drama in r/LGBT; by drama by giving such advice as:

1
Inequilibrium•
2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mossadi•

I'm a big fan of your recaps, but I think the LordGaGa part is unnecessarily wordy. It provides a thorough description of a conversation that could simply be linked to. This would likely have been better served as an addition to part III.

Nevertheless I always appreciate the effort you put into these and for that reason I enthusiastically upvoted it :).

1
avenirweiss•

I just noticed here where rmuser defends SA's Halloween costume that she asks someone why they find it offensive. I know that I've been yelled at and told that you just aren't allowed to ask someone why they find something offensive. You just have to take their word for it because you don't have that same life experience. Maybe because rmuser is also trans*, that question's now allowed to be asked? Bleh.

edit: missed a couple letters

14
Inequilibrium•

The hypocrisy in just the first sentence of that comment is astounding. Trans people shouldn't have to explain themselves constantly, right? Talk about derailing.

6
zahlman•

While I agree that it's hypocritical, I would ask that you please not implicitly accept the bizarre definition of "derailing" (the one that includes such horrible things as expecting people to provide evidence for their claims) promulgated by SRS-style activists.

6
Inequilibrium•

That's called "irony". I wasn't seriously accepting that definition, only making fun of it.

6
zahlman•

<3

1
eternalkerri•

five thousand years from now, archaeologists will find this cached on a server somewhere and study this and wonder,

"Were they really that worried about pixels?"

10
gagaoolala•
2
goldflakes•

Meh. Pixels cure diseases. Not these pixels, these pixels are dramatic and stupid. But other pixels are very important. It will more likely be a study in reverted persecution complexes in early 21st century progressive movements.

2
Atreus11•

on a side note of the giant irc conversation, "YOU LIKE RACIST JOKES, YOU MUST BE A RACIST"

8
zahlman•

A racist, you know, like on Top Gear.

10
Atreus11•

silly, europeans can't be racists, that's only americans!

5
Daemon_of_Mail•

I've only seen like 1 or 2 episodes of Top Gear. I still don't understand this reference.

2
GAMEOVERVerified &amp; Zero time banner contestant•

The hosts, in particular Jeremy Clarkson, make a point of being tremendous cocks at times, often saying things like global warming is a farce. To the uninitiated this sounds like Clarkson's a colossal moron, but he's admitted that it's an act. The more you watch the show the more you start to recognize that they're playing to the camera because it's just more entertaining that way.

SRS has taken this to be their circlejerk mantra whenever anyone claims something they find offensive is a joke and not meant to be taken literally.

6
zahlman•

They've specifically taken the quote from a Stewart Lee sketch in which he satirizes Top Gear, sort of SRS style (except with hatred directed specifically at the Top Gear cast instead of at privileged groups).

I made this to commemorate the meme.

3
The_MessiahAnita HUSSEIN Sarkeesian•

I wonder what Jeremy Clarkson's reaction to srs would be?

1
stopscopiesmedoesn't even go here•

http://www.reddit.com/r/SubredditDramaDrama/comments/qjy0u/a_user_denounces_the_creation_of_a_questionable/

I made a post about it and catrolean showed up and she was still mad about it. Funny stuff

1
avenirweiss•

I'm SURE they're reaching out quite far for new moderators. I've heard that the Fempire has huge tracts of land...

Also, has anyone else noticed how they go from saying that moderating is insanely difficult and time consuming to moderating to something they can do in five minutes while waiting for water to boil? I know SA said that second part, though I don't have the exact link, atm...

6
GAMEOVERVerified &amp; Zero time banner contestant•

They have to pretend to walk that line between martyrdom and not admitting their detractors get under their skin. I swear it's like they never matured past middle school.

2
GeneticAlgorithm•

Honest question: I'm guessing this refers to the costume with a green dress and holding a pumpkin? If so, what was wrong with it? Why was it offensive?

4
strolls•

Because it looks like a M2F trans woman who is having trouble passing.

Passing = looking like a woman
(or like a man in the case of a F2M trans man).

Trans women get a staggering amount of abuse for this - they get mocked for being "a man in a dress", called "freaks" and assaulted. They get assaulted very fucking regularly. Basically, they have to be afraid of using public toilets, in case someone decides they're a "pervert" and decides to beat the shit out of them.

I just can't interpret Silent Agony's dress-up as anything but a direct insult to trans women, and I'm staggered that trans women are standing up for her. I mean, I guess that's their right, and I guess maybe the justification is "I didn't mean it that way" and they're accepting that, but it's staggeringly insensitive. And, y'know, comments about trans people that are merely uninformed and insensitive made by anyone else are [deleted] in r/lgbt, so it just doesn't make any sense to me.

22
zahlman•

AFAICT, the ones who are standing up for her are the same ones who always stood up for her, and the ones who didn't stand up for her are now influential trans members of the r/ainbow community.

5
GeneticAlgorithm•

TIL. Thanks.

3
Daemon_of_Mail•

To be fair, I was blanking out on the thread for a while. I had to have someone ELI5 to me.

1
NowISeeTheFunnySide•

It's basically blackface for trans persons is the way I understand it.

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
vlf_fata•

I didnt expect that amount of hate for what seemed to be a seemingly innocent post. The idea itself is kind of funny. I guess the post was aimed at the wrong audience

-1
zahlman•

Basically, imagine if there were a subreddit for discussing issues of racial diversity, and a moderator who happened to be white did a hallowe'en costume in blackface, and tried to pass it off as hipster-ironic.

14
orthogonality•

"Some of her best friends are black transsexual."

3
Himmelreich•

You're speaking, you must remember, to a person who thinks 'does it have a penis' to be sufficient grounds for misgendering a person.

2
waxninnocence•

Ah, that's an interesting way to look at it. How does dressing in drag fit into the equation?

1
Epistaxis•

LordGaGa would be a fine mod for r/lgbt, but there are some reasons why it might be inappropriate for her to mod that and SRD at the same time, at least until things presumably settle down in r/lgbt. I almost hope she doesn't have to choose.

4
wolfsktaag•

i dont think lordgaga would go over all that well over there. they seem to be wanting at least one gay male mod. understandable i guess, cuz that subreddit is probably 80% gay male.

trans people are a minority within the minority that is LGBT. if they appoint laura, then robotana, then lordgaga, it will look like they are using T as the primary requirement of modship; discriminating against other people

7
[deleted]•

They are all white lesbians. Yay diversity!

6
Epistaxis•

they seem to be wanting at least one gay male mod.

Why do you say that?

2
wolfsktaag•

because ive seen highly upvoted comments requesting that in the drama threads linked in SRD

6
Epistaxis•

That's a good reason. I guess I missed those, even though I've been watching all related threads.

2
robotrock1382•

all these people take themselves way too seriously.

3
scrash•

Shouldn't u mention LordGaga said she was going to delete any mention of the chat in SRD?

2
[deleted]•

I just read through all four parts of the recap on this.

As a frequenter of r/lgbt, I've casually observed all this drama across a number of different subreddits over the past few months but have participated in none of it.

Personally, I was always of the mindset of, like, "Shut up! It's only the internet, guys!" I think overall, for whatever reason, r/lgbt just seems to be an inherently dramatic, overly-sensitive subreddit to begin with - or, at least, some of the people who are most active over there are.

This is not to ignore the fact that the mods are clearly abusing their power and making it less fun for everyone around. I hope they are ultimately ousted so it can go back to being somewhat normal and happy.

2
TroubleEntendre•

I just want to thank you for your dilligence in keeping up with this. This is one for the ages.

1
rmuser•

rmuser then admits that making RobotAnna a moderator was a mistake

rmuser admits no such thing.

-5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
eternalkerri•

you just talked about yourself in the third person.

9
espanabarca•

The ego of that guy ...

1