r/lgbt•
SilentAgony

LGBs of r/lgbt, let's talk

Let's talk about why we come here.

You could discuss Maggie Gallagher's latest idiotic statement anywhere, right? You could go to work and talk about Neil Patrick Harris's adopted kids and how cute you think his husband is. You could discuss the girl that you had a crush on until she found out you were a lesbian and would no longer talk to you with the neighbors. Maybe you could go on r/funny and tell them about how when you came out as bi, your mom said you were probably really just gay or mad at women/men.

But you don't. You come here, and the reason you come here is because you want your experiences to be heard and discussed with other people who have a cursory knowledge of homo/bi/pan sexuality and still see you as just anyone else. You know that if you go somewhere else, you're likely to wade through a lot of excrement before you can discuss anything useful if you don't give up first, and that the wading will leave you feeling exhausted and dirty. It might even be worse than that. Maybe your neighbors run the homeowner's association and, since hearing that you're gay, want to propose insidious guidelines to force you out. Perhaps somebody at work would decide that you might look at them in the bathroom and has told Human Resources about your "sexual harassment" or maybe everyone you know is mostly nice but just sometimes can't resist knocking the conversation off the rails with "doesn't butt sex hurt?" or "who's the butch and who's the bitch?" Of course some of us have been very lucky to have relatively open-minded people in our surroundings, and with only a few months or weeks of patient gaysplaining, they no longer say stupid things, but they will still never fully understand what it's like to be 14 years old and wonder why they have crushes on their friends instead of the opposite sex the way they were taught it was supposed to happen, or what it's like just to want a family like everyone else and know that even the most basic aspects of achieving this, like finding a home together, will be riddled with sometimes insurmountable hurdles.

As a community, we take it for granted that the people here will understand these things and not make idiotic evolutionary or religious arguments about why we should consider that maybe the status quo is good for us.

When rmuser and I instated the new guidelines, it was because we could no longer ignore the fact that the longstanding policy of community self-moderation had been effective only in creating this environment for LGBs. Dozens upon dozens of trans people who badly wanted to feel like a part of our community had appealed to us. For a long time, we simply insisted they downvote and for a long time, it worked. However, as the community grew to over 36,000, this tactic lost effectiveness and the trans members of our community felt even more overwhelmed by yet another environment that had promised trans inclusiveness and delivered nothing but another cisnormative burden at their feet.

Consider how you would have felt if threads during the DADT repeal had been filled with appeals to consider the feelings of soldiers who don't wish to serve with gays or how you'd feel if threads about the Boy Scouts of America were filled with "won't somebody please think of the straight children?" Most of us would have no problem identifying such sentiments as concern trolling. However, when it happened to trans women in the Girl Scouts posts, many readers were quick to defend exactly these things with the mantra "but it's just a different opinion!" Frankly, rmuser and I were disgusted to see the same minimizing, patronizing language that NOM, Exodus, and Fox News hide behind when they're being unapologetic homophobes by our own and against our own.

The red flair was an attempt to moderate and sidestep the inevitable influx of alt accounts. It was meant to let our readers know that this person meant harm without silencing anyone. We hate to silence people, and we really hate chasing down dozens of alt accounts. We flaired 3 people out of 36,000 (that's 1 in 12,000). One was talked to and agreed not to do it again. His flair was removed. There are now two people flaired (1 in 18,000). They seem to be everywhere because they are two heavy commenters, but they are still only two. We had hoped that was all we would have to do because this is a well-meaning community which, we hope, wants to extend the same comfortable environment to our trans members, but we suppose time will tell.

We know some don't like it, but we're sticking to our guns. We will likely err on the side of allowing too much, and we know we will probably not achieve a completely safe space, but reporting will help us sort them out. We will not back down. This community will be moderated.

Thank you.

Posted Jan 17, 2012, 7:43 PM UTC

63291
JRutterbush•

The issue isn't with cracking down, I don't think... it seems to be with the method. Passive-aggressive labels just don't seem very... professional, or mature. Completely ignoring the worry about possible abuse (which may or may not be warranted, I don't know you two well enough by far) there's the matter of decorum. Standing around mocking the people that are causing problems isn't going to do anything worthwhile, especially when they're still free to cause trouble with their posts.

Really, I think simple bans would do the job much better, and much more cleanly. Little red labels just seems to me like a schoolyard response. "Oh yeah? Well... you're a poopy-face!"

I don't doubt for a second that you guys mean well, I just don't think this is the way to go about things.

123
Omegastar19•

This. I can only shake my head as i read the wall of text of the OP. People were not complaining about whether something needed to be done, people were complaining about the METHOD that the mods decided to use.

So here we have a wall of text that does not address the issue at all. I don't understand how the mods could have entirely missed the point of the uproar.

And that last part? Wow, really nice. The mods are certainly making themselves popular by stating that they basically don't give a fuck about the opinions of other people; they are just going to do what they like. You know, why did they even bother writing this wall of text when they don't want to discuss it anyway?

Edit: In fact, why did SilentAgony name the thread "let's talk" when she expressively states in her wall of text that she has no intention of discussing the matter.

54
[deleted]•

That's how a teacher or parent would talk to you. 'Let's Talk' really means 'shut the fuck up and listen this is how it's done'.

38
sammythemc•

"I support your goal but disagree with your methods" is fundamentally unproductive if you don't couple it with an alternative. What would you do if you were a mod? Because people would complain just as much about banning.

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
netcrusher88Spirit•

I get what you're saying, but I also get what SilentAgony is saying about alt accounts. It's stupid easy to make an account on reddit. Ban a troll and a dozen sockpuppets pop up. Label them and more often they'll go away. Or shape up, if they're just assholes.

Not always. And I do personally prefer outright bans. But I get the idea, and I've seen it work.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

20
netcrusher88Spirit•

Good question. I don't know. Like I said, I've seen it work, albeit on other sites. And not always. I don't really understand it.

7
JRutterbush•

But labels won't deter multiple accounts any more than banning would. If a troll can just get a new account to avoid a ban, what's keeping them from just getting a new account to avoid a label as well?

The point here isn't what we're doing to them, it's how doing this to them makes us look. It makes us look like bratty kids who resort to name-calling instead of proper conflict-resolution. At the same time, it's no more effective than banning them. That's where I see a problem, not the idea of fighting back in the first place.

20
SgtPsycho•

Agreed, it is not about the trolls, it is about us and the way we are perceived in the community, and how we perceive ourselves.

Great reply.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
JRutterbush•

What sort of tools does vBulletin have that work better than bans?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
JRutterbush•

Hmm... infraction points seem like an interesting mechanic. Perhaps the flair could be used for that: a simple highlighted number that refers to how many times that person has received complaints, rather than a passive-aggressive label that could mean anything, or nothing.

But Reddit does have a reputation system: comment karma.

4
SgtPsycho•

Agreed. Putting offensive labels on people and making them wear them as a mark of shame is like making the naughty kid wear a dunce hat or do degrading things.

It achieves nothing and does nothing to change their behaviour. In fact, and mentioned multiple times, if they are a troll, they are being fed attention and the limelight, which is exactly what they crave. It's totally, unambiguously counter-productive and worthless.

I advocate jacobheiss' suggestion but would be satisfied (unhappy, but I would accept) the text labels removed and the names coloured, or a small icon placed against known offenders as a warning.

6
scoooot•

mocking

I'm sorry. I just really don't see what the mods did as "mocking".

6
JRutterbush•

Really? Because that's exactly what it is. It's placing a label on someone else so that the entire subreddit can see and react accordingly.

9
scoooot•

I agree. They placed a label on someone so that the entire subreddit can see and react accordingly. They didn't Tease or laugh at in a scornful or contemptuous manner, which is what the word "mock" means.

9
JRutterbush•

Problem is that a label like that serves no other purpose than mockery. It doesn't solve the problem, not in the slightest. The only real purpose it serves is to let us all know who we're "better than". If you want to stop a troll from trolling, ban them. Giving them a Troll Title won't do anything but make them happy.

9
musclerunner•

Repeated referring to others as "cis gay" as derogatory was mocking in every use of the term. Mod has shown consistency of putting others down. It's sad, victimlike behavior.

1
scoooot•

That may be the case, but my point was that the flair was not mocking. Also, I don't think it's OK to put others down for displaying "victimlike" behaviour, whatever that means. It smacks of bullying.

-4
HolyMintnessAsk me about my herb garden•

Reddit has its problems. Big problems, in some cases, but I thought r/lgbt was safe. It was a place where I could be entertained and not feel so alone.

If you dislike the moderation/red flair that's fine, I'm pretty neutral about it myself, but the amount of people who have used it as an excuse to spout bile about transgendered people is horrific. There have been comments I've wanted to argue against but have been unable due to the fact that answering it would distress me too much. I've seen transphobic comments in the past and downvoted them and assumed they were the minority. I guess I was wrong.

I don't give a damn about flair. I do give a damn about trans people being belittled and people using this to spew hatred, as if they've been looking for a way to say these things before.

I'm cisgendered for god's sake and feel a little like crying. I have no fucking idea what it must be like for a transgendered person to read such insults.

Act like adults. Act like decent human beings.

This was my safe space, but I don't feel safe anymore.

90
shanoxilt•

There are no safe spaces; there are only spaces which haven't yet revealed their danger.

14
[deleted]•

You can come to /r/daww. If you're feeling down, it's a safe place for everyone to celebrate their love of kittens and red pandas.

It doesn't solve the problem. But it's the best virtual hug I can give you.

12
HolyMintnessAsk me about my herb garden•

Aww thank you ^_^ I've obviously calmed down a lot now, and it's nice to know people care..

3
ebcubeHarmony•

In a subreddit where no one has flair (I mean good flair) having one instantly marks you as a friend of the mods.

Too bad. I almost believed you for a second.

-28
CheeseyxPansexual Genderqueer/Cactus•

It was open a while back for anyone, that's how I got mine. In no way have I had any direct contact with the mods here.

18
greenduchRainbow Velocity Raptor of Justice•

Actually, they had a thread a while back where people could request flair. It has nothing to do with being "a friend of the mods".

17
leavenworth•

Not only has your point been disproven, but what is mutually exclusive about feeling horrified by certain comments and being a friend of the mods?

7
HolyMintnessAsk me about my herb garden•

There was a 'post here to get flair' 24 hour post a while back. Anybody could get one if they posted. I don't think I've ever talked to the mods in person, but nice try :-)

3
ButterflySammy•

TL;DR - we don't care if you don't like the hostile environment created by branding people.

89
ButterflySammy•

I think this thread should be upvoted, whether you agree or not this thread deserves attention.

An upvote isn't a vote of support, it is a vote for people who don't browse the new queue knowing what the official response is.

24
netcrusher88Spirit•

Gods you folks who whine about SRS (or, about borrowing a page from the SRS modbook) all the time are funny.

-13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
netcrusher88Spirit•

Ah. Well I apologize then.

red-flairing trolls is a tradition on r/shitredditsays (commonly abbreviated SRS, which I guess needs disambiguation on this reddit). A lot of the r/ainbow splinter group thinks it's making r/lgbt more like r/srs. I think they're stupid.

My point is, the claimed purpose of r/srs is "upvote so everyone sees this bullshit", so it's ironic for someone critical of the current changes to say exactly that.

Combined with someone in one of the early big r/ainbows threads calling for a preemptive ban on everyone associated with (read: posting on, I guess) r/srs, I see a pattern and it amuses me.

-13
rampantdissonanceI'm not funny. I'm Bi-larious!•

You're missing the point. Regardless of what you think of SRS, it's an undeniable fact that LGBT is not SRS. They have different goals, different tones, and different moderation policies. They explicitly say no discussion as part of the rules. Naturally, this community will have a problem with moderation policies that resemble that subreddit.

4
[deleted]•

By branding people for their hostile actions?

It's not the same as branding people for their identities.

20
Pit-trout•

No, it’s not the same at all. But it is a counterproductive way of dealing with shitposters, for lots of reasons that other people have gone into in detail: it draws more attention to their posts; it gives them a victim card to play; it makes many good posters (not just the shitposters) feel afraid to express their opinions…

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
J0lt•

As opposed to the hostile environment created by noticible sections of the community acting towards trans issues in ways that would be wholly unacceptable here if it were towards LGB people.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
SilentAgonyOPLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

Discussion or comics about homophobia/biphobia/transphobia/oppression has never been moderated.

-10
ebcubeHarmony•

Your double standard is so obvious that my eyes are fucking bleeding. You should have a red flair that says "EYEPHOBIC" just to be sure.

7
SgtPsycho•

Except when moderators feel the person discussing the issue is a troll.

See: endless discussions about banned words.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
scoooot•

By the same tolken, couldn't your comment be characterized as you not caring if T's aren't given the same welcome here as LGB's?

I'm not saying this is the case. I am saying that your statement is just as unfair and false.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
scoooot•

I have already said that I do not believe that.

You have, however, mischaracterized OP's statement in a totally unfair way.

5
Cythrosi•

I find that most communities begin to decline the moment the administrators of it begin going down the path that these two now are. Make me sad for /r/lgbt since this place was one of the places I would regularly check for new info about the LGBT community and learn more about it. Now it's just argumentative, dogmatic and downright hostile to any sort of opposing viewpoint. Even /r/politics is more civil than this.

6
psychedelia88466•

Responding to hate and wilful ignorance with civility is no virtue; hostility to bigotry is no vice.

2
Cythrosi•

The moderators appropriate response would be to remove the user causing the problems and end the issue. I'm not saying that the mods just have to straight up ignore *phobic posts. But they should not antagonize and behave like high schoolers as a response. It makes the issue worse.

The path the moderators are going down right now is one where they are very publicly pursuing a very negative and unpopular policy, even with good intentions. And by refusing to acknowledge or budge on the policy, they are going to set themselves up for a never ending public battle that will continue to persist in this community because they have now created a fractured community full of "us vs them mentality."

That never ends well.

0
[deleted]•

I'm with you- lets keep throwing trans people under the bus.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
[deleted]•

Sorry Ive just feel like there's been a lot of hostility towards trans people lately. And the people who question our identities are being defended because it's 'free speech' or ' just disagreeing'... Sigh.

6
jaunty_jawa•

Disagreeing with the method of "moderation" != defending people who say ignorant things

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
ebcubeHarmony•

You want to play red flair? Let's fucking play red flair.

The reason they were red tagged is because we wanted them to be heard - to stay a part of the community and continue contributing.

I feel like I don't have to explain why that is bullshit.
http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/ojw9s/but_now_i_want_a_red_tag/c3hw28z

I'm not a transphobe.

I have the sudden urge to link to derailingfordummies.com as well. Must... resist... mental... retardation...
http://www.reddit.com/r/ShitRedditSays/comments/oiucs/rlgbt_starts_moderating_out_the_rampant/c3hnhpj

Okay well then let's just take your anecdotal evidence as the real data.

http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/ofy6e/i_bat_for_both_teams_but_sometimes_homosexuals/c3he5jv

So if I want to have children with a man, and my own gender, that makes me a homophobe?

Oh, fuck off.
http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/ofy6e/i_bat_for_both_teams_but_sometimes_homosexuals/c3h4dg8

I tire of being accused of twisting people's words.

To stop doing so would be a great step in the right direction. http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/ofy6e/i_bat_for_both_teams_but_sometimes_homosexuals/c3h4fal

Please refrain from harassing people here. Calling homosexuality a choice is homophobia.

http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/o9mfl/lgbt_redditors_i_need_your_help_with_a_family/c3fm5x8

Red flair is literally the Holocaust.

Nothing to do here.
http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/okmxo/this_is_why_i_will_be_unsubscribing_from_both/c3i2igx

The way that essentially identical posts are treated can vary wildly, depending on when it's posted, who sees it, information cascades, likely whether people are hungry or have just eaten

OMG SO TRANSPHOBIC
http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/oiib2/what_did_moonflower_actually_do/c3hlaq8

We're not interested in disrupting debate - we err on the side of caution and allow a whole lot of hatred and obvious provocation

Unless they want us to educate people. The worst crime in the world. You know what the nazis did? Community college. How dare them.
http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/oio0k/holy_shit_peeps_chill_out/c3hl23p

This is the sort of overt lying and misrepresentation that isn't getting that flair removed any time soon.

http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/oggdt/from_handsoff_to_active_defense_moderating_an/c3h7ddu

And now, my favourite one, the pal of the mods and mod over at r/transgender:

  • Laurelai - Troll. Cisphobic. Heterophobic. Hateful. Overall asshole and liar. Actively trying to destroy r/ainbow and to turn every other subreddit into r/ShitRedditSays.

EDIT: http://www.reddit.com/r/LaurelaiWatch/

I'm going to mostly refrain from commenting on such bullshit and just link:

"white cismale circlejerk" http://www.reddit.com/r/transgender/comments/okm90/meta_regarding_changes_in_rlgbt/c3i76f0
http://www.reddit.com/r/transgender/comments/okm90/meta_regarding_changes_in_rlgbt/c3i6ssn
"not insulting him" (check the context) http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/ojcj7/the_red_branding_is_really_childish_and_makes_me/c3i198n
http://www.reddit.com/r/transgender/comments/okm90/meta_regarding_changes_in_rlgbt/c3i0emx
http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/ojcj7/the_red_branding_is_really_childish_and_makes_me/c3hzwvx
http://www.reddit.com/r/ainbow/comments/ojvfa/what_did_mlk_think_about_gay_people_cnn_belief/c3hzm2e
"i banned you and you called me a cunt" http://www.reddit.com/r/ainbow/comments/ojvfa/what_did_mlk_think_about_gay_people_cnn_belief/c3hzd17
"we really can't stand him [violentacrez]" http://www.reddit.com/r/SRSDiscussion/comments/okamc/right_im_out_rant/c3hz8vq
http://www.reddit.com/r/ainbow/comments/ojxc5/dear_rainbow/c3hyvwy
"i'll discuss anything with anyone in a calm manner" (quite a jewel) http://www.reddit.com/r/ainbow/comments/ojxc5/dear_rainbow/c3hz1ln
"i'm glad you're all leaving r/lgbt" http://www.reddit.com/r/ainbow/comments/ojvfa/what_did_mlk_think_about_gay_people_cnn_belief/c3hwieg
"most or your community are cissexist" http://www.reddit.com/r/ainbow/comments/ojjy7/500_readers_in_12_hours_time_for_an_introduction/c3hvtlm
"safe space for transphobia" (derp) http://www.reddit.com/r/ainbow/comments/ojjy7/500_readers_in_12_hours_time_for_an_introduction/c3hvhjr
"now fuck off" (in a calm manner) http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/ojcj7/the_red_branding_is_really_childish_and_makes_me/c3huob6
"each person that [...] unsubscribes from r/lgbt [...] is transphobic" (lolwat) http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/ojcj7/the_red_branding_is_really_childish_and_makes_me/c3hudqt
"you are full of shit" (in a calm manner) http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/ojs7p/and_the_truth_comes_out_all_the_complaints_about/c3hu7ld
"yet another transphobe from r/gaymers" http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/ojs7p/and_the_truth_comes_out_all_the_complaints_about/c3hu3q2
"mr straight white male" (not cisphobic, but...) http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/ojcj7/the_red_branding_is_really_childish_and_makes_me/c3htzcd
"cis people don't get a say" (not cisphobic, but...) http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/oj03i/can_you_guys_remove_the_red_flair_from_peoples/c3htm7i
"we get to decide if your (sic) included if we think you are a good enough ally" http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/oj03i/can_you_guys_remove_the_red_flair_from_peoples/c3htk0k
"i have a lot of friends who aren't cissexist bigots" http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/ojcj7/the_red_branding_is_really_childish_and_makes_me/c3htgsn
I don't have arguments, therefore answering with one word will make me seem intelligent! http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/oj03i/can_you_guys_remove_the_red_flair_from_peoples/c3hp3fo

Well, I got bored already. You can go on without me, I'm sure.

64
Inequilibrium•

Oh man. I was sort of liking that post at first, then I got to Laurelai, and suddenly it became my favourite thing to come out of this entire debacle. /r/LaurelaiWatch is an amazing idea, I probably have a lot to contribute from what I've seen (and had said to me) in the last couple of days. So much hate, so much hypocrisy, so much outright lying (especially about /r/gaymers and /r/ainbow).

And now this kind of person is a mod. Someone who basically tells anyone who disagrees with her to "fuck off". I'd hoped that SA and rmuser would learn something from this and that things would start to get a little bit better here. But no, it looks like they're only going to get worse. The prophecy marches forward. I'm so fucking out of here.

Edit: Oh, are you banned from /r/transgender yet? I'm fairly sure Laurelai gives no-warning bans to anyone who implies that maybe /r/gaymers isn't actually transphobic, or that nobody can point to any evidence that they are.

Edit 2: HOLY SHIT. I think we have a winner. This is an r/transgender mod, folks.

19
zahlman...wat•

Oh god it keeps getting worse.

Someone else points out:

You're transgender, and here you are belittling someone for having doubts about their gender identity?

Holy shit. That's...that's like, ten steps below Uncle Tom right there. That's a black person joining the KKK.

Which gets replied to thus:

No they didn't answer the question, in fact they avoided answering it, please learn english comprehension.

Riiiiight. After like three paragraphs of explanation of why Inequilibrium doesn't feel the classic cis/trans model applies, and another paragraph pointing out that it shouldn't matter anyway.

And then we get this classic:

You arent gay, you are bi. Im bi myself, you are speaking from a position of privilege. It is easier to be bi in the real world than it is to be gay.

Really? Really? So I guess all these people complaining about "bi erasure" are just whining and attention-whoring? Seriously, what the everloving fuck is this shit? (Also, lol at the part where she implicitly claims the same "privilege".)

5
straight_ally•

Ho.ly.fuck.

I knew she was fucking bad, but that just blows my mind.

How much fucking NERVE do you have to have to tell somebody else what they are, and what they aren't, for them- then tell them how their gayness doesn't count?

4
ebcubeHarmony•

Just so you know, yes, of course I'm banned from r/transgender, though I'll admit I said something to her on the lines of "you have your head stuck too deep on your ass"

And, as a reminder, now she isn't just a r/transgender mod. She is now a mod here. The fact that this comment thread is still alive should look like a miracle to you guys.

4
EnterpriseE1701E•

I love you.

16
ebcubeHarmony•

I get that a lot.

15
[deleted]•

This is amazing, I wish I could up vote it more!

6
avenirweiss•

This needs more upboats than the Catalogue of Ships....

1
matriarchythe oncoming storm•

You literally don't understand the definition of words, do you? Is this why you're so adamant about having the community handhold you through queer, trans*, and hate speech 101?

-9
zahlman...wat•

That's rich, coming from the crowd who genuinely believe that bigotry towards a privileged group is impossible; that being asked to defend a claim, combined with motivation for doubting the claim, is a "strawman"; and that people who don't agree with your methods are automatically "concern trolls".

6
RobotAnnaVery Cute, Just Like Miku•

lmfao get out

-26
TheAlou•

Red flair does absolutely nothing to stop transphobia from occurring. It is a horrible policy that should be removed and you both should apologize for instituting it. The fact that one person was already wrongfully given red flair out of three shows that you guys won't use this power well and it will only be abused.

50
[deleted]•

The last thing you are getting from OP is an apology.

40
mariesoleil•

Oh, I totally remember an apology for her Halloween costume, don't you?

oh, wait.

28
NoahTheDuke•

Oh jesus, I just remembered that debacle. Why am I still subscribed again?

13
Infuser•

What was the Halloween costume incident?

6
mariesoleil•

SilentAgony made a self post on this subreddit a couple days after Halloween which included a pic of her Halloween costume. By her explanation she was dressed as a man trying to dress as a woman. She had very obvious beard shadow, toilet paper hanging out of her shirt as if she were stuffing, and poorly done makeup. Some people thought it was funny. Some people thought it was cool gender play. Some thought it was hurtful to trans women because most of us have a fear of looking like a "man in a dress" and that it was unclear that the costume was supposed to be a man in drag and not a trans woman.

13
TheAlou•

I'm hoping they will see that a majority of the people don't like this policy and admit that they were wrong. Hopefully they'll listen to reason.

-1
Pit-trout•

Wait. How does

One was talked to and agreed not to do it again. His flair was removed.

amount to “wrongfully given red flair”?

I agree the flair is totally counterproductive, and the mods are being pointlessly stubborn about it. But we don’t need to twist their words to make this case.

9
TheAlou•

http://www.reddit.com/r/lgbt/comments/oj03i/can_you_guys_remove_the_red_flair_from_peoples/c3hr6el?context=3

Here's a post I made a day or so ago about the user who's flair was removed. He was given red flair for posts (according to rmuser, link within the post I linked here) debating with another user about whether it was our responsibility to educate other users. His red flair was something like "needs to be educated. (paraphrase)" It was a blatant misuse of the policy and shows that it won't be used in a good way. It wasn't a transphobic comment in any way whatsoever, it was a disagreement with a mod. I believe he was wrongfully given the red flair, which is why it was removed, because the mods eventually realized they wrongfully gave it to him as well. It's been abused once, it'll be abused again and should not be the policy of this subreddit.

10
Pit-trout•

Ah, thanks. I hadn’t seen the background on that case; I take your point now.

2
TheAlou•

No worries, should have been a bit more descriptive. :)

1
FollowerofLoki•

As one of the people who was starting to feel increasingly uncomfortable in /r/lgbt because of the anti-trans sentiments, thank you.

38
My_Faithful_Student•

As a trans person the only people who have made me feel uncomfortable in /r/LGBT are Silentagony and rmuser.

57
FollowerofLoki•

I'm not going to argue with you. I like what rmuser and Silentagony have done. That's all.

10
My_Faithful_Student•

I wasn't trying to start an argument with you. I'm glad that you feel more comfortable in /r/LGBT but we should be trying to make everyone comfortable in LGBT and the new policies have made people (including trans people) uncomfortable posting here.

28
dementedsnake~❤~•

EVERYONE! Stop politely disagreeing! Don't you know we're supposed to be attacking each other and throwing red paint everywhere? (shakes head) People!?

6
catamorphism•

I disagree -- homophobes and transphobes shouldn't be comfortable here.

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

17
FollowerofLoki•

I could care less about the red flair. It's the fact that the mods have decided to make an attempt to crack down on people who have been antagonistic and trolling trans people for quite some time.

28
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
FollowerofLoki•

I'm not arguing about this. And I made no opinions, other than I like that rmuser and SilentAgony are trying to curb the transphobic people.

13
dementedsnake~❤~•

So, you can care a smaller amount than you do now? How much do you care? A lot? A little? All you've really said is that you don't not care, but you didn't say how much you do care. I'm a little confused about how much you care about the red flair then. Care to elaborate?

-5
radicalfree•

Are you being pedantic, or would you like me to explain the idiomatic expression "I could care less" for you?

3
JulianMorrisonloading ⚥ ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬚⬚•

I feel safer because of all the people who will have second thoughts about posting transphobia as a result.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
JulianMorrisonloading ⚥ ⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬛⬚⬚•

They speak about things such as (in the USA) federal ENDA (currently ignored, and last time they tried they took us out because we're just too icky) while federal DADT and DOMA seem to be prioritized, New York passing both gay ENDA and gay marriage but failing yet again to pass trans ENDA, plenty of fuss about Prop. 8 in California but negligible fuss about a trans woman's marriage being annulled in Texas, and so forth.

In other words, shit be real, yo.

14
SgtPsycho•

It's a punitive example. Once others who are borderline-misbehaving see it, the idea is that they will pull into line.

5
ffmusicdj•

This is going to get way downvoted : /

I spoke a few days ago about my experience of not going through MtF and the responses I got PMed to me from members of the community were grotesque, they were EXTREMELY UNSUPPORTIVE.

Whoever these trolls are, they have turned SPECIFICALLY THE PEOPLE OF REDDIT transgenders into really mean and bitter people who just don't like different opinions.

I sent the moderators complaint that I was being harassed by transgender people here they ignored it, which makes me believe that the LGBT moderators favor transgender, so much so that they will allow them to misbehave as a means of acceptance.

Branding people is only proof of this, whose to say that I won't be branded because I thought the current MtF procedure wasn't for me? All it will take is a few angry transgenders who dont agree with me, they'll say that I'm doing "harm" the the transgender community, make claims that they they know more about being a transgender than me, and I will be marked.

I support my LGB and my T in my community, but never at the cost of giving someone in the community censorship for accepted, never.

I advise the moderators to tell people to use the BLOCK feature. It works wonders, thats exactly what I ended up doing when those transgenders sent memessages, BRANDING PEOPLE IS NOT OKAY.

30
SgtPsycho•

This is so offensive. You should be getting support and brotherhood here, we should be the last people to attack you, not the first.

To all you people who send cruel, bigoted and insulting private messages, fuck you*. If you have something to say, have the courage to say in the open where we can (and will) call you out on your bullshit.

*And this is not something I say lightly, or often.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
NoahTheDuke•

transgenders

What the fuck? It's not a noun, it's an adjective.

but never at the cost of giving someone in the community censorship for accepted, never.

That doesn't make any sense.

0
ffmusicdj•

Nope, not interested.

And the second part, the lgbt mods gave some people here the ability to pin "troll" on someone, anyone that they don't agree with, just so this person feels "safe", and thats not okay. You don't like me using that as a noun? Whatever, Hope that helps.

4
SilentAgonyOPLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

Yeah, we didn't used to moderate anything. We're moderating now. If people harass you now, we'll look into it. No need for "THIS IS GOING TO GET DOWNVOTED" martyrdom. Nobody is being branded ffs, they're simply being labeled as trolls when they troll and having their labels removed when they agree to stop trolling.

-3
TheAlou•

brand: verb (used with object)

to label or mark with or as if with a brand.

Source: Dictionary.com

This does nothing to stop trolling or transphobia. It is stupid policy that allows you to to return any hatred (or different opinions, as of the one person who had flair and no longer does) with more hatred. A guaranteed way for people who are spouting hate to receive more attention and continue any hateful remarks. Remarks, that get massively downvoted by other users.

5
[deleted]•

Nobody is being branded ffs, they're simply being labeled as trolls when they troll and having their labels removed when they agree to stop trolling.

If I label someone as a "faggot" by putting a sign on their back when they enter my store, would you be OK with that?

-7
scoooot•

That is a ridiculous thing to say. It is not OK that you made that comparison, between the phrase "concern troll" and a violent homophobic slur.

11
[deleted]•

Are you suggesting that my hypothetical label would have negative consequences for the labelled person?

I don't see how you can be OK with one negative label and not OK with another. Perhaps I could give you a list of labels and you could tell me which ones are OK and which ones aren't.

1
SilentAgonyOPLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

Won't somebody think of the poor oppressed homophobes.

1
TwasIWhoShotJRScience, Technology, Engineering•

So, the red flair..oh the red fucking flair. Am I the only one who isn't really concerned about the red flair? Someone..anyone..please tell me they too do not care that two people have red flair.

Kind of related topic, have you considered adding more mods? Two mods for a community of this size just seems to be a bit lacking.

28
[deleted]•

[deleted]

16
TwasIWhoShotJRScience, Technology, Engineering•

Basically. More mods would make it easier to deal with a community of this size that is...how do I say? as volatile as this sub can get?

But the more mods you add, the more open the subreddit becomes to mod drama, which is not just the best drama, but also drama that can end a sub in totality.

8
Cythrosi•

Except too few mods can also lead to drama like this, where the one or two mods make a incredibly unpopular decision and the community has no form of recourse. A larger moderation pool can provide a better check and makes it so more people can ask the question "should we really do this?"

You have to balance having so many mods that the chance of one going batshit insane is too great, but also make sure you have enough to provide enough representation to the community at large they are in charge of.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
TwasIWhoShotJRScience, Technology, Engineering•

Well I mean, it can't be that hard. Just check the filter every once and awhile and remove stuff that is obviously a troll or just someone being an asshole.

1
ebcubeHarmony•

Adding more mods? I hope not. Considering the trust circle of the current mods, the new mods would probably start the fourth reich.

7
[deleted]•

I love how telling gay men not to be overtly transphobic is the "fourth reich" now.

If that's your idea of the fourth reich, I think it sounds awesome.

-4
zahlman...wat•

telling gay men not to be overtly transphobic

That's some damn strong rose-tint in your glasses IMO.

5
[deleted]•

How, exactly, is that "rose-tinted glasses"?

Is it such a tremendously strenuous concept for gay men that one should just not expect otherwise?

-1
[deleted]•

HEY, FRIEND! I'VE GOT TO SAY THAT I THINK THIS IS BACKWARD AND WRONG.

GOOD LUCK, THOUGH!

28
ratta_tata_tatPretty Peacock•

I, as a gay transmale, appreciate all you have done to make this community more trans inclusive. I whole-heartedly do not believe in the red flair but it is your community in the end. People can throw a hissy fit but no matter what , in the end, it is the mods decision to do what they want to do.

22
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
ratta_tata_tatPretty Peacock•

There is a difference between revolting in reality and revolting on an internet forum. One has a LOT more impact to the people behind it than the other.

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
ratta_tata_tatPretty Peacock•

Which is why people are doing it. You can't do that shit with politics in real life that easily. Thus, once again, what the mods decide to do is up to them. If it crashes the community then well...There are others popping up.

3
Inequilibrium•

Yep, and it's our decision to leave if we feel the environment here has become hostile and oppressive, to such an extent that we're stepping on eggshells whenever we comment in a thread where mods are present.

2
adlibitum•

I respect the need to make this place more trans-friendly, but I have to say that I don't feel that this was an effective way of doing it.

I think that a lot of the issues that come up really could be minimized by encouraging people to read up before posting. I know that I would support going the way of r/fitness, and having the community engage in an "LGBT FAQ" to link above all posts (not just in the sidebar, no one reads that).

I realize that there's a "transgender 101" link in the sidebar, but I do think that a community project that could be linked to any time someone makes those kinds of trans-unfriendly posts would make r/lgbt feel more like a cohesive group, and less like rabble that needs to be restricted from above.

People on r/lgbt, generally, want to be educated, want to be sensitive. We're already kinda an ingroup. I think that if the response to subtle transphobia was consistently a link to the "transgender FAQ" section of something that we had put together as a community, people would just inherently be more likely to support the FAQ than the original comment, even if they wouldn't have recognized it as offensive in the first place.

20
[deleted]•

[deleted]

16
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
[deleted]•

Truly? Are you truly using the "We only did it to 2 people" argument? I hope anybody reading your comment realizes the idiocy of what you argued there. We don't care how many people it was. It could be 200, or 1. The outrage should not only be the same, I daresay it would be.

So, transphobia is A-OK. Saying people who have repeatedly made transphobic comments have behaved unacceptably is "fucked up", a cause for "outrage" and "hostile".

Classy.

Fuck you. Honestly, fuck you. Don't turn this on the people who realize something fucked up is going on here. We can be in favor of trans-inclusion and against what you and rmuser did. Don't pretend for a second that the same people who are transphobic are the same ones arguing against what you did.

Frankly, it doesn't mean much if someone notionally thinks trans people should be included in a space (how nice of them) if they also think cis gay men should be able to abuse them until they feel so uncomfortable they leave.

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
[deleted]•

One apologized, and the other wasn't being transphobic.

A cis gay man who has defended, with tens of thousands of words, the right of people to be transphobic in this subreddit, thinks it wasn't transphobic. Colour me shocked.

Except one doesn't imply the other, which was my point. Make some more false connections please.

It most certainly does.

If the community won't police itself (which /r/lgbt had very abjectly failed to do), you've got two options: police it, or watch it become a circlejerk of the most privileged while everyone else leaves. It's spent the last year becoming the latter until the mods changed course.

You've vehemently defended the latter option in comment after comment in this thread. It really doesn't matter if you think trans people should notionally be included if you value cis gay men's desire to be transphobic over their desire to feel comfortable in the space.

-2
ebcubeHarmony•

Stop targeting it as if it were LGB versus T when you know it isn't. Almost every LGB accepts, embraces and loves the T. I know I do. I'm not going to accept your whining victimistic bullshit, nor your attempts at targeting the whole LGB community of r/LGBT as transphobic. I don't understand why would anyone take more bullshit from the admins of this subreddit. You perfectly know that our issue is with your offensive attempts at thought policing.

You are a disgusting, horrible human being. Stop being brainwashed by the insane side of the r/transgender community and look at the beautiful, accepting community you are tearing apart. Please.

14
--Rosewater--•

"Almost every LGB accepts, embraces and loves the T."

That's stretching it. LGB is in general more supportive than cis persons, but I wouldn't say that applies to "almost every" LGB.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ApproachingMarsScience, Technology, Engineering•

You have posted this like five times, I don't know what you even expect of it considering all it proves is that you missed the point to begin with and continue to do so.

9
ebcubeHarmony•

The point being to shun everyone who is cis outside of this subreddit, because we are not marginalized enough, as well as every trans* who is sane enough to see the mods' bullshit.

1
ApproachingMarsScience, Technology, Engineering•

If you are cis and feel as though a comic pointing out something that really does happen, on a regular basis, is YOU being marginalized, it isn't the mods of r/LGBT who are insane.

8
radicalfree•

The point being to shun everyone who is cis outside of this subreddit

Lol.

That must be it.

1
[deleted]•

Almost every LGB accepts, embraces and loves the T. I know I do.

Banning people for overt transphobia is "thought policing".

Beep. Try again.

1
[deleted]•

Can you also address the T's of LGBT who are opposed to your policy of red flaring troublemakers?

14
SilentAgonyOPLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

We didn't implement this policy in an attempt to please all transgender people. We implemented it in an effort, as I said, to create the sort of safe environment for transgender people here that the LGBs already enjoy, but just because we're doing it for the sake of trans inclusiveness doesn't mean we handed out veto pens to all the trans members of the subreddit.

-6
[deleted]•

I definitely didn't think anything related to your comment about veto pens. I do not have such a polarized view of what it means to be LGBT.

That having been written, I was alluding more to how the moderators here have ignored repeated comments relating to why banning is more appropriate than red flagging certain members. Those comments didn't come from "LGBs," and to the extent that they did, they came from cis and trans "LGBs."

I suppose either situation would have been over-ridden by anti-trans trolls in any event.

6
Feuilly•

Favouring educating ignorant people is not trolling.

When you make that claim, you're the one that sounds like the troll. Which is especially disturbing since you're supposed to be a mod.

12
Pixelpaws•

We know some don't like it, but we're sticking to our guns.

In other words, you're acknowledging that the community strongly disagrees with you and that you don't care. Thanks for the honesty.

12
spreague92•

I'm still trying to catch up on the Red Flair Debacle, so please bear with me.

My big concerns are that flair was sudden and without warning. Were moonflower and onetimer warned before the flair was added? I read the comment that led to moonflower's flair and it seemed fairly sudden (not saying I approve of/agree with the comment). If that was the case, then I will be worried that one of my comments might be misinterpreted and I will be flagged without having a chance to explain myself. Once the flair is there, people will remember it even if it is later removed. I don't want that stigma simply for being momentarily inarticulate.

9
SilentAgonyOPLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

Were moonflower and onetimer warned before the flair was added?

Repeatedly, ad nauseum, for weeks.

-2
spreague92•

Thanks for responding to my question :)

I meant a specific warning that you would enforce a punishment other than being banned (there's that momentary inarticulateness!). My big thing is that a person should only be subjected to punishments they should have reasonably known about.

Of course, my fears would be allayed somewhat if I knew the procedure for implementing the red flair from here on out. If I made a comment that could be interpreted as transphobic, would I receive a warning before being flaired? I'm somewhat okay with punishing malicious comments, but using red flair to punish ignorance seems excessive.

8
SilentAgonyOPLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

You would most likely receive repeated warnings, as the rest did. You'd also be told the terms for its removal.

-7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
[deleted]•

Are you moonflower or onetimer?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
SilentAgonyOPLike Maddow, only Cuddlier•

This is exactly the boring alt-chasing I was talking about.

-4
Cythrosi•

It's one of the responsibilities of being a moderator. It fucking sucks, but it comes with the title.

1
[deleted]•

We will not back down.

So you don't want discussion. You just want to air your viewpoint and say goodbye to those who disagree with you.

Ya, you're definitely an angry overlord. Goodbye.

9
Casey234•

As I have said in my thread on the subject, I appreciate the efforts towards curbing transphobia on this sub reddit, I think the methods used were merely feeding the trolls rather than accomplishing anything constructive. The backlash against trans posters because of these actions is something that worries me. I've seen more than a few posts essentially blaming the trans posters, so I am entirely unsure if this will create a safer environment.

"Herpy derp, r/lgbt was fine until then uppity trannies!"

8
[deleted]•

he backlash against trans posters because of these actions is something that worries me. I've seen more than a few posts essentially blaming the trans posters, so I am entirely unsure if this will create a safer environment.

The mods asked people to stop being transphobic, and backed it up with actions when said people did not desist. If someone's so very not transphobic that, in that situation, their response is to vigorously back up the people being called out for transphobic behaviour, I think we know pretty clear where they sat all along.

And if they, say, leave this space and fuck off to r/ainbow, then I call that a win.

-3
butyourenice•

In this thread: every comment continues to piss and moan about this policy.

Whatever, SilentAgony I think you and I have butted heads but please don't misinterpret this as in bad faith: I agree with this policy. It will make me consider how my words can be interpreted without just stopping me from speaking altogether. If that helps even one person feel more comfortable here, good. I have no sympathy for the bigots, and I trust the mods' discretion.

8†
My_Faithful_Student•

If that helps even one person feel more comfortable here, good.

It also makes many people (including trans people) feel uncomfortable, not good.

6
Niea•

And no one has explained why. I'm a bit confused as to why people have a problem with it. Especially if it gets to the point of making you feel uncomfortable.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
matriarchythe oncoming storm•

It also makes many people (including trans people) feel uncomfortable, not good.

As a trans* person, I can only speak for myself. This is wonderful and has been a long time overdue. Bigots offended for being correctly labeled a bigot is not something to shed a tear over, and is in no way comparable to actual intolerance.

3