[recap] The great SubredditDrama banfest and modocalypse of Labor Day 2012: syncretic's tale

Background

There had always been some concern about the effect that being linked in SubredditDrama has on a thread, and accusations that SubredditDrama's subscribers share a common agenda and vote in linked threads as a bloc. See e.g. syncretic's "Have we become no better than SRS? Are we now just another downvote brigade?" back in February:

There is no reason this subreddit should be raiding other subreddits and downvoting comments made by users to -25 karma while upvoting the other side to +50 karma. That, my friends, is a downvote brigade. That is unacceptable.

We are better than that.

syncretic was not yet a moderator then, but u/ZeroShift, the increasingly silent top mod of SubredditDrama, agreed:

We were never meant to be a downvote brigade. Ever. However, it would be naive of me to think that it'd never turn in to one. With this stated, I could not have said it better myself syncretic.


syncretic's troubled rise to power

Some time later (June-July), u/syncretic, mod of the SFWporn network who had recently and controversially taken over r/TheoryOfReddit, became proactive about possible doxxing and was added as a moderator by u/creepig, along with others because ZeroShift was overburdened. This was not well received by the community, which saw him as a zealous censor and drama magnet: "So, SRD hating syncretic is a mod here now?". As creepig explained:

If we're going to change the perception that SRD is a downvote brigade, who better to provide feedback than someone who has suffered from the supposed brigade? If it doesn't work out, we'll let him go.

Even then, higher-ranking u/BritishEnglishPolice chided both creepig and syncretic for arguing publicly. syncretic christened his new position by banning someone, and brainstormed about rules that could "force SRD to become more of a catalog of drama instead of someone's personal army."

In response, r/ThePopcornStand spun off as a subreddit for drama with "no power user mods, no downvote brigades", or as the SubredditDrama moderators called it, "unmoderated drama" (but ThePopcornStand's moderators reject that phrase).

See LetsBeNicer's recap.


Gearing up for more aggressive moderation

A few days later, syncretic announced that all removals and bans would now be publicly logged in r/DramaLog. Top reply: "Fantastic. You still shouldn't be a mod." Then criticism of specific bans.

Next day at ThePopcornStand, "Hi guys. Syncretic banned me. Looks like I'll be finding drama here now."

There's no reasoning with him. He simply declared me a troll and shut me down.

syncretic proceeded to defend his actions in that ThePopcornStand thread, which became dramatic enough that it was posted back to SubredditDrama. Top reply: "I can't believe he is a mod for this subreddit."


A new policy appears

In an extremely controversial SubredditDrama post (Aug. 22), mod u/eternalkerri jumped in with a surprising admonition:

Do not post in these linked threads!

I will be watching, and I will ban hammer the shit out of you if I catch you.

I have messaged the mods of the involved parties and if any unusual activity is reported by them of a user, you will be hammer timed.

Ironically, all the downvotes buried the warning. The next day, creepig posted an official announcement:

Are you going to start banning people for posting in drama threads?

Short answer: Maybe.

...

Henceforth, if you make a post in a drama thread with the obvious intent of stirring the shit, you're gone.

...

(Also no, I'm not going to demod syncretic, stop asking.)


syncretic takes decisive action as promised

So here's what I've reconstructed about how things went down this weekend. A moderator of drama-hotspot r/lgbt sent a modmail to SubredditDrama with a list of "SRD users" who "invaded" r/LGBTOpenModmail. (This information courtesy of then-SRD moderator u/TwasIWhoShotJR, who "edited the name of the sender out because they don't really need any shit from us", but specified "it was a normal one, not a crazy one", i.e. not SilentAgony or rmuser, nor RobotAnna, in case you're keeping score at home.)

So: syncretic posted an announcement in SubredditDrama that "The following users have been banned for pissing on the popcorn", listing nearly all the same ones as in the modmail. Another subscriber complained: "Why is Syncretic banning people for violating a rule that they didn't break?";

out of a total of 14 users banned, only 3 of them actually broke the rule they were banned for violating


Dirty laundry

SubredditDrama's subscribers were outraged, but even a moderator, TwasIWhoShotJR, criticized: "Ugh. This is a hot mess." He proceeded to share what he knew about how the decision was made and implemented among the moderators (which was surprisingly little, perhaps), and even disagreed with the premise of the new policy:

I will only ban people for using slurs, hate speech, and dox in our own sub.

What happens in someone else's sub is not my problem.

syncretic posted a lengthy announcement defending his actions, "In response to my controversial mod actions as of late", which I will not try to summarize. Once again, negative reaction from the community, and even from fellow mod TwasIWhoShotJR. The entire exchange is deleted, allegedly by BritishEnglishPolice.


A great purge

u/BritishEnglishPolice, a.k.a. BEP, is a "power user" who moderates more large subreddits than anyone can keep track of - and therefore has plenty of other things to do. But the brouhaha in SubredditDrama was such a cacophony that it awakened the elder god from its slumber. He/she (conflicting gender information going around) removed all lower-ranking moderators, which included creepig, syncretic, eternalkerri, and TwasIWhoShotJR. Though BEP has been silent, this information comes to us through [censored username], who was temporarily (?) added as a moderator after PM'ing BEP about TwasIWhoShotJR and syncretic's modfight, which [censored username] also posted in SubredditDramaDrama. u/Cptn_Sisko was also reinstated "while everything gets sorted out".


Aftermath

u/AlyoshaV, (in)famous for "Smile! You're on SubredditDrama!" bots, formally requested ownership of SubredditDrama because it "refuse[s] to ban users who invade other subreddits from links there, highest active mod only cares about avoiding internal conflict".

r/AntiSRS, where people go to complain about r/ShitRedditSays (allegedly much overlap with SubredditDrama), took note.

More to come, I'm sure...


EDIT 1: started Aftermath, and trimmed a bit to get back below character limit

EDIT 2: clarified syncretic's history

EDIT 3: eternalkerri and u/Daemon_of_Mail have been reinstated as mods

EDIT 4, two years later: censored a defunct username by request, to prevent doxxing

Posted Sep 3, 2012, 5:47 PM UTC · edited

9456
joke-away•

/u/syncretic, long associated with r/TheoryOfReddit

No. Only recently associated with r/theoryofreddit, which he turned into a shitshow after being handed it by blackstar9000. His real claim to fame was the SFWPorn network, which he used to plug all over the fucking place in the form of a question about it. This spam was especially annoying in r/theoryofreddit, where it was obvious that "is there anything we could be doing better in the SFWPorn network?" asked bi-weekly was just a veiled plug. Anyway, I'd replace r/theoryofreddit with r/pornoverlords in your post, other than that it's a very good summary.

22
[deleted]•

I thought you were kidding at first about the SFWPorn network tactic.

Then I saw this.

13
joke-away•

Hahaha, yes, exactly. Also interesting to note, lately he's tried to get his fingers into everything meta for some reason. He was given the ToR modship, started r/metahub, r/askmoderators, etc. It's might be he's just apeing violentacrez, who started and moderates r/help and r/modclub in addition to his NSFWPorn empire.

12
FeetsBeneets•

Ballsy move creating a sub to set himself up as an authority on moderation right after this fiasco in SRD.

6
EpistaxisOP•

Ah yes, that's my recollection as well. Edited. Thanks!

6
joke-away•

:D

3
kate500•

jeesh I am still such a noob here. I had no idea Syncretic was part of the SFWPorn (not that it will really make a difference to me, I like what I like, just hate not knowing stuff like that, being as I am so nosy.), I subscribe to several of them, and actually like them a lot.

r/pornoverlords looks like fun spare time reading:)

2
joke-away•

Hey, don't get me wrong, SFWPorn subreddits are pretty great. But they're also super-specific to content that reddit works great for: content that all takes the same (very short) amount of time to judge, that rarely has political issues associated with it. The content-focus of the subreddits dodges all the problems that reddit makes for moderators. It's not the same as subreddits for discussion or articles at all. I tried to make this point to him but it didn't get through, he seems to think that the success of the SFWPorn network makes him a great moderator. It does, for that kind of content, but one look at theoryofreddit and the present drama in SRD is enough to see that a forum with discussion and conflicting viewpoints and mucho meta talk, it's a very different beast to moderate than what's essentially a crowd-sourced album of pretty pictures.

6
kate500•

Yes, you are absolutely correct.
I enjoy some of those subs for the simple reasons that I love great photographs, particularly those of the specific areas I am personally interested in, for example; historyporn and abandonedporn (large overlap there) and humanporn. I get to look at these, often smile, read a few (frequently interesting) comments, and be on my way.

It is a relaxing and often lovely break. Sort of a dessert were we speaking of a meal, or perhaps an amuse-bouche.

Would I want those as my full meal? Hell no. I want my brain to actually be engaged for the most part. I am a bit of an assorted news addict, I often (believe it or not) read and digest without commenting. I get very annoyed when I need to wade through thigh high reams of crap to get to the nuggets of intelligent discussion.

I very much agree with your extremely well written and communicative lines above.
joke-away all you want, but "It's not the same as subreddits for discussion or articles at all." is the truth. Thanks for the well written info.

5
joke-away•

Heh, no problem, I'm glad I was able to summon a moment of lucidity for once.

1
FeetsBeneets•

They're also a pretty drastic misuse of the word "porn".

2
redditbots•

^About

18
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
redditbots•

The formatting is going to stick for a while. Sorry :(

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
kate500•

I'd hate to be you right now kind redditbots sir!

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
eightNote•

Dear mister moderator, on the topic of recaps and flakes, I would love to see the flair be a link to the recap, if that's possible

3
FeetsBeneets•

Damn, this goes all the way back. I was around for most of this and I'm still compelled to read it all.

11
EpistaxisOP•

I did this and it kept me pretty busy.

7
kate500•

amazing patience.

3
eightNote•

What about syncretic drama from a couple days ago, with banning misterandriston?

3
FeetsBeneets•
3
MisterAndristson•

Not to seem egotistical, but I think that was partly a catalyst for this. I could be wrong, but after that meta thread no less than an hour later he did the big banning. It seemed to me at least like he was trying to redeem himself, or show that while he made mistakes he could do the right thing.

The best thing to do if you're a mod and the community is ganging up on you, is to not be too visible for a few days until it settles down. It seems like everything after was just adding fuel to the fire.

I didn't even want everyone to be removed as a mod, even syncretic. I just wanted to be treated fairly. What a mess this turned into.

4
SamWhite•

Superb recap, really good work. I love that the internet has something akin to historians now, carefully archiving and indexing the stupid crap that happens when you mix thousands of anonymous people together.

8
DoughnutHole•

Somebody give this man a flair!

7
[deleted]•

Wow, that stirred up some shit. Haha. For what it's worth, I did come into that thread from SRD. Considering how small that subreddit is, the assumptions that the LGBT mods made weren't all that unreasonable. In my defense, I would like to point out that I wasn't participating in the drama, just clarifying for that guy/gal what the mod was talking about.

This whole thing is silly, though. Banning people from SRD does nothing to stop them from following SRD links and participating in the drama. Even commenting in the SRD thread can be done easy enough with an alt, so it was a pretty pointless move.

If anything, we should have been banned from LGBTOpenModMail. Kinda strange that we weren't, considering the mods' ban-happy reputation.

5
kate500•

Thank's for the recap. Look's like good work, though I have to go lie down for a while now:)

4
leaffall•

Wonderful recap. I was away for the weekend, so trying to follow this on my own was difficult. Nicely done!

4
alexoobers•

u/AlyoshaV certainly has a nose for drama.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
PinkBalloons•

This whole drama feast is very likely all centered around laurelai, the thread that spawned the claims of brigading was one laurelai was involved with (the suck my cock thread), the mod that produced the list of users was likely greenduch (laurelai's current host and fuck buddy), and most of the people on the list seem to have been people who argued with laurelai recently, also Castilla (rumoured to be a laurelai alt) seems to have been involved in the drama peripheral to srd.

2
DarrkRook•

Wonderful recap. I just woke up and had no idea what was going on, so this was a huge help.

3
kate500•

I needed to save this, it just gets better and better! Epistaxis, you are now one of my officially favorite people on reddit:)

I appreciate all the time/work/energy you are putting into this, and thanks too to those that are adding to this lovely popcorn.
Yum.

3
erythro•

allegedly much overlap with subreddit drama

Srd is alledged with overlap with asrs as well as srs, mr and lgbt

We've got many from all sides, and don't let anyone tell you otherwise

Also, good work on the post

3
redditbots•

^About

2
MestR•

Did you break? You posted twice.

7
Skwink•

All of this drama is overloading redditbots.

5
redditbots•

Yes I did break. I tried to strike but failed. Old script reinstated.

5
BipolarBear0•

Great recap, mate. I hope JR, syncretic, creepig and BEP sort this out soon.

2
thegoogs•

You're truly doing God's work.

1
dubsideofmoon•

This seems biased in parts but it has been very informative.

1
EpistaxisOP•

Which parts? I want it to be neutral even though I have opinions. I have tried to capture the general feelings about syncretic et al. without passing judgment myself, but I'm not sure if I succeeded.

5
dubsideofmoon•

I don't know. I thought I saw some things I didn't like. Either you changed them or I was being nitpicky and now I'm being more reasonable.

2
EpistaxisOP•

Okay. Thanks for following up.

2
Strange_Dragons•

So ... am I going to be un-banned? :)

1