r/reddit.com•
Dpressd

Thank you, reddit, you have saved my life.

tl;dr I created an AMA in which I talked about my suicidal feelings and a redditor correctly diagnosed and solved the problem here.

This is my story:

I was diagnosed with depression two years ago. Life was hell. Antidepressants didn't help enough and I wanted to kill myself. One day I decided to talk about it to the reddit community in this AMA and found incredible support and lots of suggestions for help. I tried to follow some of the suggestions but it was incredibly difficult, since I had no energy whatsoever.

Initially, I discarded one particular suggestion by redditor frinklestein because I thought it didn't apply to me. In his comment he explained how his wife's depression lifted when she got her IUS removed. I wasn't wearing an IUS, and though I was taking oral contraceptives, I had been doing so for 7 years, way before I got depressed. Also, all of my doctors knew I was taking it and none commented on it, so I really though the pill couldn't possibly have anything to do with my depression.

But frinklestein's comment got me thinking and since I was pretty desperate I thought I'd give it a try. I stopped taking the contraceptives 20 days ago and the change in my life has been huge. I know it is early to say this but I'm certain my depression is completely gone. I had forgotten how happiness felt, thought I would never feel it again. Now I feel it all the time. I have way more energy than I've had in years. Doing things and talking to people is not a challenge any more. My suicidal feelings have totally vanished. Life is beautiful and I can fully appreciate its beauty now. I was in utter hell and now I'm back. And all it took was to stop taking those damned pills.

Thank you, frinklestein, you have saved my life.

Edit: I have nominated frinklestein's comment for comment of the year. I think more people should know about this.

Posted Jan 5, 2010, 9:36 AM UTC · edited

1.8K547
kgen•

Nice try Catholic Church!

1.4K
harper247•

'But it seemed so plausible...' - Bill Hicks

151
deadapostle•

I am jumping onto the top comment to try and bring a point to Dpressd and anyone else suffering from depression who gets one of these moments.

Although it is quite possible that your depression was due to a chemical body change brought on by your birth control, it is incredibly more likely that you are in a manic phase that coincided with your cessation of taking your pills.

I am not intending to tell you this to try to sabotage your situation, but quite contrarily, in order to possibly help you in the event that you swing back in the other direction. Make sure you maintain any other medication you're currently on, continue seeing your doctor for this issue, and don't be ashamed or even worried if the depression comes back. Every little step along the way helps to get through it.

There is light at the end of the tunnel, but sometimes you just happen to be in a really bright lamp in the middle of it.

I am not a doctor, but I've seen a great many and been through this same shit for a long time. I've also been in places where I've thought I was cured for 6 months or more. It's kind of like being an alcoholic, in that you will always have depression, but it won't always rule your life.

122
slidepaw•

My wife had to stop oral contraception due to them exacerbating her depression... still has her moments but stopping them made an immense difference!

42
dopeydoe•

My wife too, they messed her around for 4 years, in the end we had a baby (accidentally, whoops!) and she went off them and now she is so much better, I hate that the pills side effects arent published enough, doctors should warn against it.... the convience was not worth it! just use a jimmy!

5
phlux•

But you should keep encouraging her to practice Oral Conception ;)

-2
Philosophile•

I must needs agree. In fact, the swing to "happiness" and feeling it all the time screams "manic episode" to me. I'm also not trying to say that this is not a genuine feeling or that you have not corrected your problems, OP, but rather that you need to keep your eye on things and not think that you're cured just yet (as you said, it's too soon).

First of all, like deadapostle said, stay on your medications (contraceptives excluded). In addition, please tell your PCP and/or Psychiatrist (which you definitely should be seeing considering the symptoms - they're specialists, they can help you better) exactly what you have told us - including detailed information about the contraceptive and your historical use of it. This will be a great help to the doctor in treating you, and thus the information needs to be shared with the doctor so that you are receiving the best treatment for what you're experiencing.

If it does turn out to be manic, you need to be ready for it by keeping that in the back of your head and not letting the depression take over and make you do something rash. Also, the doctor will know (if you did what I said), so you can adjust treatment toward disorders that are characterized by this type of symptom. That should help significantly if this does turn out to be just a bright lamp in the middle of the tunnel. Remember that hope is never lost - this comes from someone who was without hope for a long time - and make sure no matter what you seek help before doing anything, remembering that your mind is not thinking rationally in those depression situations.

I wish you the best of luck, and I truly hope the contraceptive was the cause of your depression so you can be past it forever.

22
redrobot5050•

I just want to upvote this comment because hope is never lost is incredibly true. Also, I want to upvote this comment because its like the 4 or 5th comment in a thread all giving good advice. No 4chan style "just end it all, faggot" comments. I mean, its the internet, people can be dicks, but the people who take time out of their day in a thread like this take suicidal conditions like this dearly. I just wanted to give everyone an internet fist bump for being decent human beings and caring about strangers you'll probably never meet.

13
deadapostle•

I am deadapostle and I endorse this message.

6
penguinv•

the doctor will know

MUHAhahahaa

3
qrios•

Really? You take a look at the symptoms over the internet and decide you have enough information to get the OP worried about BD? Based on the information given, there are plenty of other possible reasons for the magnitude of the change. Maybe the gradual growth of a brain tumor has started fucking with parts that regulate endorphine and dopamine levels. You don't see anyone bringing that sort of thing up.

If you had an overwhelming level of evidence to come to your conclusion, then bringing it up is excusable. Otherwise, assume it's due to the logically sound possibility of a hormonal imbalance, and avoid saying things that will add to OPs stress (after all, the condition being dealt with is emotional). OP has already shown she is the type of person to seek help. "Watch out, you might get really depressed again" doesn't help one bit.

Question for OP: How are you sleeping since the depression has resided?

0
microsofat•

Since you are addressing the OP, I would post your reply directly to this thread since the OP will see it in their inbox.

10
deadapostle•

At your suggestion, I took it upon myself to direct message Dpressd. That was a good idea.

1
qrios•

Nice try, Big Pharma!

3
deadapostle•

How did you know that was my rapper name?

1
[deleted]•

It is not "incredibly more likely" that she is bipolar than that the pill made her ill. I understand that you are trying to help but statistics combined with what she says herself makes your interpretation unreasonable.

More than 1 out of 100 women get the following side effects from birth control pills: head ache, edema, nausea, irregular periods, stomach cramps, sore breasts, yeast infection, irritability, depression.

More than 1 out of a 1000 women get severe nausea, acne, high or low blood pressure, vaginal infections, vomiting, hair loss, increased body hair, rashes, migraine, decreased sex drive, mood swings, changes in appetite, weight gain.

More than 1 out of 10000 women get asthma, loss of hearing, breast discharge, blood clots.

2
deadapostle•

My interpretation is actually not unreasonable. She said that she had been taking the birth control for years before the depression began. She also has only been off of birth control for 20 days, which is too short of a time period to declare that she's "cured."

My interpretation was that she wasn't necessarily out of the woods, not that she absolutely wasn't out of the woods.

As far as stats go, 10% of American adults suffer from depression. 1% of American adults suffer from manic depression.

Therefore, 1:10 American adults who suffer from depression are bipolar. That ratio is a hell of a lot more likely than her getting a specific side effect when 1:100 get one or more of nine.

Just the same, my comment wasn't about spouting statistics, but from a combination of my education on the subject, my own personal experience, and observations of the experiences of my friends and family.

Combining what she said leads me to believe with even greater certainty that I am correct. I am glad that she has a positive group of friends that can help her get through it.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
[deleted]•

I hate Fox News with a passion. It's terrible stuff. That said, go make your own thread. That's not what this one is about. If you aren't here to add something to this particular discussion, then go away.

1
libbrichus•

Oh it was a rant by Bill Hicks edited and customized for reddit. But okay, people don't seem to be getting it so I've removed it and posted it here.

5
DpressdOP•

LOL I'm using condoms now :)

66
twodaylife•

Now your boyfriend's going to be the one that's depressed.

123
Wenix•

Maybe they can switch every 7th year.

23
deusnefum•

Sounds like a Biblical Law.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
chimx•

i lol'd

-2
PersonalPostAlias•

I've had the same experience with three types of birth control, I loved your story dearly and I'm incredibly happy the problem is fixed! I also want to point out (though I'm sure you are aware) that there are very effective non-hormonal birth controls such as the copper IUD and the cap. I'm considering both at the moment and am excited to be protected AND happy. Future goodluck to you :)

22
[deleted]•

The hormonal IUD, rather than copper, has worked wonderfully for us! Keep it in mind too. My understanding is that it releases a miniscule dose of hormones directly rather than percolating through the whole body. Lasts for 5 years.

1
somekindacyborg•

I, however, have had the opposite problem. I used the hormonal IUD and finally had it removed because it was causing so many hormonal problems, including depression. I had it removed over 6 months ago and I'm still trying to get back to normal. If the OP had trouble with other hormone therapies I absolutely would not recommend any other forms of hormones. I went back to my good old copper IUD and I'm so glad I did.

2
sockpuppets•

Giggity.

14
[deleted]•

right now?

13
ninjaspy123•

Affirmative, Celtic. I spied on her and checked it out.

6
NickDouglas•

I heartily recommend an IUD. They're very safe but hardly ever used in the U.S. Very popular in Europe.

6
phanboy•

It seems weird taking female birth control advice from someone named "Nick."

11
NickDouglas•

Look dude, if you don't like my advice I can refer you to my colleague Dr. Spaceman.

No, it's pronounced "speh-cheh-men."

1
PeriodBlood•

Wife had this done. Totally recommend it.

5
lizzybees•

It's very difficult to get an IUD in the US unless you've already had kids. A lot of doctors still believe (despite recommendations from WHO and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists to the contrary) that you have to have had at least one child in order to be eligible for a IUD.

Mirena, which is the most popular IUD in the US, specifically recommends usage only after having at least one child.

5
makeithappen•

but mirena is hormonal...which was OP's prob in the first place.

3
hurricaneheta•

Try planned parenthood, they told me i could get one no prob, i have never had kids. Paragard (the non-hormonal copper IUD) may not have specific recommendations on having had children or not. go to http://www.paragard.com/ or http://www.plannedparenthood.org/health-topics/birth-control/iud-4245.htm. Good luck...

1
px403•

Not sure how into this you would be, but you might try reduced dosage pills (talk to a doctor etc). If you are putting enough hormones into your body that it is starting to effect your mood, then you have way more than are required to stop you from getting pregnant.

I also saw a few pamphlets for estrogen free temporary contraceptives like Mirena etc, which looked pretty interesting, but I don't know anyone who has tried it, so again, talk to a doctor (planned parenthood doctors know their shit, and don't get kickbacks from antidepressant companies).

1
pillage•

Why not ask your doctor if he can prescribe alternate birth control methods? There are many different ones and it seems unlikely that they will all make you depressed.

0
piepiePIEpie•

you will get depressed again once you pop out a baby- guarantee it!

-5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-9
w1sh3s•

I have nominated this the comment of the year.

47
cocoon56•

of 2010 ?

27
ClemsonPoker•

Not a lot of competition so far, and only 360 days to go.

9
hob196•

Looks like your karma ran over their dogma!

35
dubyabinlyin•

Every sperm is sacred.

28
whoami9•

Theres no way that swallowed sperm counts as wasted.

25
ClemsonPoker•

This is just a little too vague.

3
dops•

python mate, and not the language

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
keniaren•

Let me anoint you...

18
[deleted]•

Every sperm is great.

8
dudewhatthehellman•

if a sperm is wasted, god gets quite irate.

9
DanWallace•

Stop it! Stop this nonsense right now! This is silly and it has to stop!

9
davethegr8•

Let the heathens spill theirs

2
PoopedEm•

Then God would have a field day with what is drying inside a tube sock next to my bed.

1
BeautifulSnowflake•

I can confirm this! If you look through a microscope, you'll see that each sperm cell has a tiny halo!

1
CornFedHonky•

Every sperm is scared.

FTFY

-12
rsabo5•
1
CornFedHonky•

I was aware of the context, I was referring to the scare tactics the Catholic Church uses. Apparently it was a bad joke. Sorry.

-1
dopameme•

but finklestein doesn't sound catholic...

19
creon•

at first i was like awwww... then I was like OMGROFLOL in one comment

8
nonpareilpearl•

LOL :)

Laughter aside, I would also like to point out that the OP never said she wasn't on another contraceptive - just that she stopped taking whatever she was taking at the time. ;)

3
serendib•

No comment has made me laugh this hard in a long time

1
[deleted]•

I went from being touched to laughing out loud in about 3 seconds. A tip of the hat to you sir.

0
iissqrtneg1•

I have nominated kgen's comment for comment of the year.

0
eLoko•

sometimes they sneak away... we did in mexico... lols

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
karnoculars•

This thread about depression just got...

•–•

... crucified.

-1
cajual•

Don't resurrect terrible meme's.

-1
PhilRawr•

This story shows exactly what Reddit is all about, other than just the jokes and taking the piss out of thing. Good to hear that you are well again, and I will definitely nominate the comment for comment of the year . :)

188
[deleted]•

[deleted]

82
CuilRunnings•

Apparently the downvotes mean that the main purpose of this website is to diagnose people's mental illnesses.

35
redAppleCore•

Nah it's not a one or the other situation. The culmination of funny pictures of cats, interesting articles, the comments that can at times diagnose a mental illness that makes it great. I can go a lot of places if all I want are links.

2
CuilRunnings•

But for things like funny pictures of cats, if that's what you're interested in, can't you go to one of the million websites for that? I don't consider them particularly informative or valuable for their artistic qualities. I come here for the links and comments, I wish people would find other forums for depression or pictures of animals that wouldn't pop up in my pursuit of knowledge.

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
MisterMeat•

Upvote for a cheeseburger?

3
CuilRunnings•

At least this is posted in self.reddit. AskReddit has become so bad that I'm thinking about unsubscribing. And that's sad because there are actually some insightful questions in there! I'm glad people like the OP get help, but I'm not sure if that's the right forum.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

22
belletti•

It truely is heartwarming, but we can still do those thongs, right?

-7
accelerape•

definately?

Remember it like this: finite, infinite, definite

17
[deleted]•

Thank you. This is one of my biggest pet peeves!

4
BeautifulSnowflake•

It's definately one of mine!

2
bdfortin•

Its definately won of the thigns I can tolarate about grammer natzis.

0
sizlak•

I used to have a pet peeve, it got hitted by a car and died. It was truley rediculous how baddly I felt.

0
[deleted]•

Defiantly.

2
charliegotmolested•

HAPPY HAPPY, JOY JOY.

15
[deleted]•
2
GreenGlassDrgn•

-GREEEEE!- :)

2
DCGaymer•

Upvoted Comment for Ren and Stimpy memories.

-1
AppleAtrocity•

I was having migraines for years. I saw several doctors who all had a different idea of why. Last guy I saw told me to go off my pill. Problem solved. It causes a lot of issues that people never think of.

131
[deleted]•

A man goes to the doctor with chronic migraines. He's miserable because they cloud his thinking, he's lost several jobs, he's divorced - he's on the verge of suicide.

After an exam, the doc tells him the problem is that his testicles are pressed into the base of his spine, creating the pain. Unfortunately, the only real treatment would be castration.

The man considers it for a moment, then is hit with another migraine and tells the doc to get the paperwork - he'll do anything.

After the surgery, the man tells his doctor it's amazing - he's never felt better. He walks out with a smile on his face.

On his way home, he feels that he's in such a good mood he's going to buy a new suit to celebrate his new start on life. He walks into an expensive tailor shop. As he walks in, the tailor looks over and says "48 broad jacket, 17" collar, 34" sleeve, 34" waist and 32" inseam."

The man stops, shocked. "That's incredible," he says, "you nailed it - just by looking at me?"

The tailor looks at him drily "my family have been tailors for six generations. Did you want shoes? We have some nice size 12 Louis Vuittons that just came in."

The man's excited. "Oh yes, please."

The tailor then said "if you'd like, I can also custom order you some size 34 silk boxers."

The man grinned. "Gotcha! I wear size 32 briefs."

The tailor looked at him accusingly. "Don't be silly," he replied, "if you wore size 32 briefs they'd crush your testicles into the base of your spine and you'd have massive migraines."

So - good thing you're a chick. :-)

452
Prysorra•

...... :-(

56
[deleted]•

Awesome :) Perfectly sums up the medicine industry..

28
NerveAgent•

off topic.... Do you really drive a carrier?

11
[deleted]•

I did. I hope your user name isn't as descriptive...

18
NerveAgent•

Sweet! Can i ask what the largest storm you guys can sail through is?

I'm a former Marine and No i didnt work with BIOCHEM. Juat liked the name.

6
phrenq•

No way this could ever happen. Nobody wears a 48 broad jacket and has a 34" waist.

Edit: maybe this guy

8
[deleted]•

I had a 47" chest and 34" waist once upon a time.

5
munchee•

before you drop that 32 brief, right?

1
GodDamnModernMusic•
3
[deleted]•

Fuck those guys, they were a fucking nightmare (on difficulty level of same name).

1
[deleted]•

Wouldn't a 48 broad jacket mean a 44 inch chest measurement? If so, that's not a particularly far-out measurement for chest/waist - I'm 46'/36' and while I'm big, I'm not big enough that you'd look twice on the street...

2
szorg•

POWERTHIRST!

1
tilds•

Actually, this guy.

1
Manitcor•

ahhh classic

5
Mcdz•

Shit... I wear size 32 briefs!

2
brownmatt•

Why would anyone sane wear underwear a size down from his waist size?

2
[deleted]•

You're that "but why would a priest and a rabbi walk into a bar?" guy, aren't you?

2
brownmatt•

Just wondering if I'm missing something!

2
[deleted]•

I've been having wicked headaches lately.

1
Lurking_Grue•

Do you write for C&H?

1
[deleted]•

I hate to say it, but whenever I read a post on r/askreddit or r/advice from a woman about their mood, migraines, weight gain... etc. (or from men asking advice about women with such issues) My first thought is birth control. Every time I mention it, someone comes in with "Why is it every time a woman has a problem men assume it's hormonal?"

Here is why: While men's hormones are fucked up all the time, women at least have a cyclical kind of thing.... if you can time problems on a calandar... well...

If a woman is on birth control, they are fucking with their hormones in a big way. But the point is, HORMONES MATTER. They are carefully balanced by your body and the slightest imbalance can cause very severe problems of all kinds... mood changes just being among the subtlest. (though if those mood problems result in suicide...)

There is nothing wrong with birth control. It is one of the most important medical advancements of all time. However, there can be far-reaching side effects for messing with such integral parts of your body's chemistry. While any drugs can have weird side effects, most women who are fertile and sexually active (in the developed world at least) are on birth control.

People seldom think to consider it, but with so many options as far as BC go, it seems a shame for it to have bad side effects for any woman.

My girlfriend (now wife) was on the Depo-Provera shot for a round or two. She turned into a world class bitch... a completely different personality. Moody, irritable... constant aches, pains, headaches, stomach upset, she put on quite a bit of weight ... she would lash out in public (sometimes in very embarrassing ways). It very nearly destroyed our relationship (we're talking at least 3 mos of this). She decided to change her regimen and returned to her normal self.

A similar thing happened on more conventional birth control years later... she would have wild mood swings... I suggested she might want to change back to her old birth control... She was livid I would suggest such a thing... Where did I get off telling her what to do with her body...but I honestly just had her best interest in mind. I didn't want to see a side effect fuck her up (and fuck up our relationship). I didn't care if I had to take all pregnancy prevention into my hands... I let her know that (and subtly reminded of the shot ordeal). She eventually switched pills and a couple months later was back to her old self. She later thanked me for being honest with her about it.

I only share this because I think it sucks that there is no pill for men and women always shoulder the brunt of pregnancy prevention. There are very many types of BC and every woman's body is different. Doctors (and most patients) don't give hormonal balance the respect it deserves but it can really affect a person's life in a big way and shouldn't ever be dismissed.

102
[deleted]•

[deleted]

30
[deleted]•

I have 3 cycles, 1 for commuting and 2 for mountain biking.

62
iama33•

same here :)

1
[deleted]•

Hrm.... maybe this could this explain why I go through a cycle of pwnage and noobage on Modern Warfare 2.

41
bski1776•

That makes an unbelievable amount of sense.

27
[deleted]•

Thank you. I might make a little project to observe my moodiness/sex drive/sullenness over time and see if I can't anticipate some of my funks.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
masgrada•

The testosterone regulation through feed back is not a cycle. Testosterone cycles of this sort are typically only referred to in body building because during this time there is a period of time that the body must re-regulate itself for new hormones. Men with a normal hormonal balance should not see these 'cycles' and if a man is seeing cycles there may be a good indication of something wrong thus should be visiting his doctor.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

It's an impressive looking graph I bet.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

16
[deleted]•

Yea, the last time I suggest even on Reddit that birth control was responsible for my depression, weight gain, acne, suicidal problems, etc, I got my fair share of comments telling me it was just puberty. This happened about 10 years ago, I haven't even considered using the stuff in a long long time.

The problem is that people who use this stuff think it's miraculous, and there are no consequences. The same thing is going to happen when we start synthesizing "smart drugs", and the same happens now with adderall and the like.

But people don't want to hear that. They want a little pill to fix everything, and not have to worry about anything besides remembering to take it. And some women get shots instead, so they don't have to remember to take a pill.

Some birth control makes a woman not have her period! And they market this like it's something amazing!

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
degustibus•

Indeed, how dare interference with nature and the act essential to the survival of humanity have unwanted consequences!!!

-1
sockpuppets•

The world is already overpopulated. You're just upset they're not all Anglo-American Christians.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Jonathan_the_Nerd•

I think it sucks that there is no pill for men

That will change.

1
desidesidesidesi•

I agree with you completely! BC messed me up. The doc made me try 4 kinds and after that, I gave up. It took me more than a year for my body to "reset". Eff BC, it's not for every woman. I am never taking it again...EVER.

1
AppleAtrocity•

I am on Depo but I have heard the horror stories. The problem with it is (and you found out the hard way) once you get the shot it's in your system for 3 months. You can't just quit taking it and feel better in a couple days. I'm glad you got everything figured out, but I bet those 3 months were hell on earth.

1
notcaptainkirk•

I only share this because I think it sucks that there is no pill for men and women always shoulder the brunt of pregnancy prevention.

Well, women do have the ultimate choice to bring a pregnancy to term or to terminate.

-1
degustibus•

Supposedly consequence free promiscuity and sex outside of a loving relationship open to new life don't actually provide fulfillment for (m)any people for long. We have a decadent civilization which has largely quit reproducing. Adolescence is no longer a stage of development.
You and your wife have been having sex for how many years now without children? Are you planning on dying childless or waiting until the risks of birth defects are at their highest and you're guaranteed to be elderly parents of teens? Bravo to you for being able to have sex with your woman without that pesky consequence that most previously welcomed as beautiful blessings, but no amount of pharmaceuticals will fill the void in your woman when she realizes that she gave up her chance to be a mother to be your exclusive playtoy (that is until you grow tired of her and want consequence free sex with a younger woman).

-14
pmh160•

Are you serious with this comment? I can only hope that you're trolling. Not every person wants to be a baby factory and/or caretaker. How dare you judge someone for making a choice that is theirs alone to make. I suppose you're in favor of teenagers reproducing as soon as their bodies are physically mature since hundreds of years ago teenagers having children was welcomed as a beautiful blessing.

Take your repressed sexual bullshit and GTFO.

4
locke-peter•

read their old comments, fundy nuttiness

3
sockpuppets•

Nice try, religious woman whose husband left her for a younger woman.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
degustibus•

You apparently have a special definition of tolerance if you think it means not responding critically to comments on Reddit.

Petrok decided to talk about his experiences with his girlfriend (now wife) and his opnions on the importance of respecting hormonal balance. I pointed out that never having a child has consequences and that new life isn't given the respect it deserves. Lots of women are miserable because they're valued only as sexual partners and never given an oppurtunity to mature into more than just outlets for male libido. In theory there are occassionally men and women with perfectly matched libidos who will enjoy sex for decades and want nothing more out of their relationship...

Lots of people shouldn't have children, but anytime a married man says he doesn't ever want children I'm reminded of something a woman told me: "Marriage without children is a leash without a dog."

-1
IYKWIM_AITYD•

If you think "this civilization" has largely quit reproducing you're seriously delusional. Wait a tick...I just read the rest of your comment. You are seriously delusional.

2
degustibus•

The evidence supports my considered opinion. Your diagnosis appears faulty.

The essential facts of demographic decline discussed in all four are not in doubt. Global fertility rates have fallen by half since 1972. For a modern nation to replace its population, experts explain, the average woman needs to have 2.1 children over the course of her lifetime. Not a single industrialized nation today has a fertility rate of 2.1, and most are well below replacement level.

In Ben Franklin’s day, by contrast, America averaged eight births per woman. American birth rates today are the highest in the industrialized world — yet even those are nonetheless just below the replacement level of 2.1. Moreover, that figure is relatively high only because of America’s substantial immigrant population. Fertility rates among native born American women are now far below what they were even in the 1930s, when the Great Depression forced a sharp reduction in family size.

source

-1
1esproc•

most previously welcomed as beautiful blessings

Ever notice how in many places in North America (specifically urban centers), cost of living has outpaced inflation? A lot of people make the choice to not go into a serious, life changing event like having a child when they're financially unstable (i.e., no assets like property). More power to them for being responsible adults, not with their heads in the cloud thinking they can afford children.

2
locke-peter•

downvoted for being a herald of the "God intended you to..." crowd. there is no supposed to anything. you attempting to push your agenda on them via guilt is both unproductive and largely adolescent in its logical debate skill level.

consequently, Abrahamic God can suck it. He's illogical, inconsistent, and canonically speaking absent for the last 2000 years. (about 1400 for you muslims) He seemed pretty talkative and engaging previously. what? did he get tired of his Sims game? and I'm not going into it in great detail but the three main virtues of God do NOT logically hold up in this universe. Being omnipotent, omniscient, and omni-benevolent do not jive with a universe that we're told is filled with evil and sin and even though God made it all, and us, that way, He might still send us to be tortured FOREVER just because He feels like it. Oh, and let's not forget all the crazy ass rules He seemed to pull out of His Ass. Worst. Father. EVAR.

and what are you going to have to say when we master biology/genetics in the next few decades? it is only a matter of time then potentially no more birth defects and horrible genetic diseases. and who cares if they die childless? that's their decision. AND they had a loving relationship for a while (I wouldn't have stuck around with a crazy, mood-swinging bitch). and furthermore, I think that whenever they get around to having the kids they are definitely going to welcome them as a blessing no questions asked. and further-furthermore why are you insulting the woman by implying that she's being strung along like a retarded patsy with no idea that she's not getting more fertile? she's aware of her bio-clock, trust me.

and I just read over some of your comments. wow, are you a fundy freak. you did hear about the two female mice having offspring a few years ago right? gay couples can adopt or find a surrogate mother/sperm donor. and several recent studies have found that what matters most is a supportive loving environment for those kids, not the gender/sexuality of the people who care for them. and further reading of your comments shows a tendency towards all kinds of logical fallacies left and right (though it seems to just be "right"). while one might argue that you're contributing some Devil's Advocate around here with your opinions, it would only be useful if they were informed, well considered, and logical. do us all a favor and just lurk here.

2
[deleted]•

You assume incorrectly we have no children.

Sometimes when you assume you only make an ass out of yourself,

2
[deleted]•

An old co-worker of mine is Uraguayan, and they eat a tonne of BBQ. His dad was getting debilitating migraine headaches for years and they couldn't figure it out. He'd get one, be out for the count for a 2 days during which he'd just be in bed, then he'd feel better. A few days later, same thing. After a while of this, he was fine for 2 weeks. First consecutive 2 weeks he'd had of being fully functional for as long as he could remember. Then another migraine hit. When he got better, he and his wife sat for hours trying to go over every little thing they'd done and what had changed.

The only thing they could think of, was that they had bought organic chicken in a small town nearby right before he was fine. The night he got sick was the night they ran out and his wife made grocery store-bought chicken. She jumped in the car and booted it out to the farm to buy more organic and sure enough, another two weeks of being fine. He hasn't touched the factory farmed supermarket stuff for years and has been fine ever since.

25
[deleted]•

I also suffer/suffered from chronic migraines. We are talking about debilitating pain, and in bed, no lights, no sound, nothing, for an entire day. My vision would blur to the point I could barely navigate to the bathroom when I needed to hurl. After years of living with this, and trying to medicate it uselessly, I finally went to a homeopath (my cooky mothers idea). Guess what, he nailed it right away. Ran a few magic tests by having me hold some bottles of different common allergens and pressing my arm and weird shit. After about 15 minutes he just said "Stop drinking Budweiser products, and swimming in chlorine pools." Asked why, and he said, "because you are allergic to rice based beers, and chlorine." Being someone who was on a swim team AND drank bud light occasionally, this kind of made sense, yet he was unaware of either of these issues. I gave him no information up from. It's also worth noting, that other than the headaches, I was not on any medications or had any other preexisting medical conditions.

I swam in a pool everyday, but didn't get headaches everyday, which was weird. Asked at school to make sure it was a chlorine pool. Nope. They used a different type of system, as this was a brand new high school, and a brand new pool (1996). What I later found out, is I did get migraines most of the time after swimming in a chlorine pool, via it getting into my ears/nose/mouth/etc. So every time I was competing and swimming in another high school's pool (older) it was chlorinated, and it induced a migraine the following day on most occasions.

Next was the beer. Stopped drinking Budweiser, which I didn't even know were rice based at the time. Boom, no more migraines from beer, as long as I didn't drink Budweiser. Most other domestics do not contain rice, so most of the other major labels were fine. As a side not, eating rice is fine, it was something that only came out as a result of using the rice in the brewing process for beer.

Between those two things, I've gone from having migraines 1 to 2 times a week, to maybe getting 3-5 a year. The 3-5 a year, I'm positive are as results of eating/ingesting something that I have an allergic reaction to, that represents itself as a migraine. I only get them when eating at other peoples houses, trying new beverages or food, or when I went out to new restaurants. In my day to day routine and what I eat/drink though, I can completely avoid them.

It's funny that your co-worker had an almost identical experience. I'm to the point now when people tell me they have migraines to go to this homeopath guy I saw, as he has cured 3 of my other family members (we all got them for somewhat different reasons, but chlorine was a common). I've sent co-workers, friends, and anyone who tells me they have migraines or any chronic issue like that that has no apparent rhyme or reason for occurring, and when the traditional medical world has failed them.

Since reddit hates homeopaths, and so do I (I think most of it is placebo, but in my case it certainly wasn't), I should also point out this guy was a PhD Physician, Chiropractor, Kinesiologist, and practiced some Homeopathy. However, for determining what was causing my migraines, he never ran any medical tests, or poked me with a single needle. It was simply holding some different vials of concentrate, and him testing reflexes and stuff. Fucking witchcraft, but I am a successful functional human being who isn't lying in bed 2 days a week anymore.

27
enginbeeringSB•

As a side not, eating rice is fine, it was something that only came out as a result of using the rice in the brewing process for beer.

Just curious, what about rice wines, like sake?

5
[deleted]•

Not a big whine drinker, and never had sake, as blasphemous as that may seem. I've never drank sake because ever since I learned of my issues, I've just assumed it would have the same affect, and never really wanted to risk a day of hell as a result of trying it.

1
fourlights•

Glad you had a successful experience with this homeopath. As an unrelated clarification, I wanted to point out that medical doctors do not actually have PhD degrees. "Ph.D." stands for philosophiae doctor, Teacher of Philosophy, and is the most common terminal degree awarded in research, other scholarly, and some creative fields. Medical doctors earn an "M.D." which stands for Medicinae Doctor, Teacher of Medicine.

(Similarly, judges earn a "J.D." or Juris Doctor, Doctor of Jurisprudence; the field of music performance conveys a "D.M.A." or Doctor of Musical Arts. Etc.)

4
[deleted]•

Re-reading my post I realize I interchanging PhD and MD as if they meant the same.

Thanks for the clarification.

1
ecochef•

I'm a big fan of naturopaths, I had this great Dr. (western med, eastern med, reflexology, herbalism, Chinese medicine, chiropractor, accupuncture, this dude was certified in almost every modality from well known institutions) and he would literally stare at me for a few moments, hold my arm up, talk to himself, and then say- "stop eating so many pistachios; they are messing up your adrenal glands and making you very congested". And literally the entire month before I went on some weird pistachio binge where I was eating handfuls a day. That's some wild shit, but it's true. And it works. It's not hocus pocus, it's intuition. What Dr did you go to & in what city? I like keeping track of effective naturopaths. Thanks!

3
[deleted]•

He operates out of an office in the suburbs of Minneapolis/St. Paul, in Minnesota. If you want more info I'd send you his information, but do not want to post it for all to see.

Sounds similar to the Dr you described, he was an MD, nutritionist, chiro, etc. He determined things in my diet that needed to be cut out by having me hold vials of concentrate whatever, and then he'd hold my arm out, press on it, some acupuncture points and the like, and make a decision right there. He has a shelf with probably 100 bottles or so of various concentrates of things that people are commonly allergic to. Dairy, yellow 5, chlorine, fluoride, etc.

If my insurance paid for those types of visits I would probably go to him much more often, but since it doesn't, he's just my secret weapon for when the traditional medical field can't solve my problems.

3
[deleted]•

god damn you are living in one hell of a fairy world. On a side note, I have some insurance to protect against the world ending, just drop me a PM to finalize yours.

1
diggexpat•

Intuition is bullshit. The guy is not psychic, for fucks sake. You probably had pistachio dust under your fingernails and he did a cold read. Glad to hear it worked for you, though.

-1
[deleted]•

Do not discount the Placebo effect.

I fail to see how your doctor's qualifications or methods have anything to do with you experiencing or not experiencing a clear placebo effect.

I find it hard to believe your doctor (of any qualification) nailed the very two items that you affected you directly with "no information" to go on.

2
Jubinator•

I find migraines are a very interesting topic (probably because I was plagued by them when I was around 13). I think they are an area where western medicine currently doesn't have a sound explanation for and therefore the best the doctors can do is pain management. I think in my case this was in fact detrimental, I was given Tylenol with Codeine and, I realized years later, developed a dependence on them, for several months in a row, I would get a migraine every day at lunch time which would go away after taking the tylenol. These Migraines were in addition to the ones that I would get at seemingly random times (in these instances the Tylenol would not help one bit).

In an effort to remedy the situation, I tried various other alternative options, I went to a chiropractor, as well as another practitioner of alternative medicine (although to this day, I don't know of what type - she basically just massaged me). Anyway, the later introduced me to the concept of migraine triggers. Although she didn't identify my trigger, some time after seeing her, I realized that oranges (a food which I used to love), would trigger migraines.

Anyway, I find migraine triggers fascinating, because they seem to be unique to each individual. Also, they don't seem to be allergies (at least from my understanding), although it is often times easier to describe them as such. I have heard that (when talking about foods) they tend to be things you love, or things you hate (although I am not sure if this is true or not, but in my case is was).

I think for anyone who is suffering from Migraines a common theme seems to be that there is an environmental trigger. The best thing you can do is try and find out what it is and to limit your exposure to it.

TL;DR - I also suffered from migraines and identified oranges as the trigger. Environmental triggers seem to be a common theme among those who suffer from migraines.

2
[deleted]•

I find it interesting too. It's been great reading a lot of other peoples stories about migraines and triggers, starting with the BBQ Sauce one. It seems in that case, yours, and mine (chlorine), that we did all have a trigger that was pretty close to us, and probably from a young age. It seems chlorine for me later turned into a trigger, cause I had been swimming in pools from a very young age, and developed the debilitating migraines around 13/14 as well, but was never a problem before hand. Must be all those damn hormones.

The bud light trigger I'm completely OK with avoiding.

1
DublinBen•

I think swimming pools would be an easy source to blame for a swimmer, not that he didn't figure out your problem.

2
[deleted]•

Glad you're better! When I went veg 15 years ago I really became conscious about what was in the food I was eating. Some things people ingest without thinking is nuts. I eat lots of shit that's bad for me but I'm aware of it and am doing it by my own volition, not by ignorance.

Anyway, for giggles once I decided to eat food devoid of crazy chemicals for a week or two. Not raw food per se, I still ate regular chips (potatoes, oil, salt) for example. Two weeks in, I was working late and the only thing in the snack machine was BBQ chips. I wolfed them down and was doubled over in pain. I went back to shitty food the next day; while it was troubling overly processed food would do that, what was more troubling was how avoiding it would cause a reaction like that.

1
cyantist•

What's wrong with nuts!?

J/k, I know they're bad for your teeth.

0
helm•

Many people drink Budweiser and it can be easy to detect a swimmer's build. Homeopathy was probably a ruse for things he noticed by other means.

0
watt•

The question is - why ordinary doctors don't have a clue then.

3
anon36•

must...contain...the outbreak...!!!...

2
[deleted]•

If that is how you feel, great. I wouldn't rule it out, as I even said I am suspicious of homeopathy, and certainly do not see homeopaths other than that occasion. Keep in mind by the time I saw him I was not a swimmer anymore, when I was a swimmer is when my migraines started getting more active, we assumed it was stress or whatever, and I left the team after only 6 months on it. I didn't see the homeopath til 4 years later, after the MD community failed me. I am a tall and skinny person, and always have been. If anyone ever complimented me on my "build" I would laugh.

The kicker is, though, he solved my problems with one 30 minute session for $75, whereas the traditional medical community failed me for years trying to diagnose it and put me on pills for it, and it cost my family a lot of money in copays (which were larger than the homeopaths entire fee). Guess what? Didn't need pills, just needed to stop putting the stuff in my body that was causing it, what a novel idea.

So I guess my point is; even if you want to write off my experience as bullshit, he still did what numerous MD's could not. He solved my problem, and they did not.

1
milescroc•

The pill causes a lot of problems that doctors often gloss over. I was on the pill for most of my 20s. Had no sex drive whatsoever, was perpetually tired, figured it was just ("just") depression. I went to a hormone specialist who measured my hormones. Turns out the levels of my sex hormone binding globulins were wacked — which is a possible side effect of the pill, and explains why I had absolutely no interest in sex.

I've been off the pill for about a year and a half now, and honestly, I have never felt better. I also have a sex drive now, but it took a good year for that to return. And in some women, it never does.

It angers me that I went to multiple doctors who pooh-poohed my concerns, and that no doctor ever told me that the pill could do that to me. I think there's some inherent sexism there, too — that losing our sex drive is no big deal for women.

Is the pill a great thing? Yes, of course. But it's not for me. I think that more women need to consider all the risks of hormonal contraception. Just because most young women are on the pill, doesn't mean it's the best choice.

(I do miss having clearer skin, though...)

14
raindiva1•

I figured out about a year ago that my Bc was making my depression flare up (it's been under control for the better part of a decade now). Also, the thing that really made me lose my fucking mind was skipping periods! Wow, it turned me into a crazy person when I would actually have the period. It was as though the PMS was building up, waiting to rear its ugly head. I'm not kidding. They even do a joke about it on snl that is so true. http://www.hulu.com/watch/10234/saturday-night-live-annuale

3
dmach27•

my wife was also getting bad headaches, at one point it was making her so dizzy she couldn't walk. Fortunately, our doctor's first question was if she was on the pill, and if she was, to stop. Immediately her headaches were gone.

We had fun with the pill, but totally not worth the trouble it caused. Glad to hear your issue was solved too.

9
llamaspit•

I've been investigating similar issues. There's a growing push for functional or nutritional medicine, and I have to say I'm getting on the bandwagon. Here's my understanding so far.

Doctors are not trained well enough in nutrition. Their goal is to treat specific problems, and that's why you get a drug for this and a drug for that. But they aren't taught to look at the body as an entire system.

Your brain works well or not largely based on what you do to your body. Hormones, types of sugars, vitamins, minerals, is it so hard to believe that deficiencies or imbalances in these affect your brain function, mood, etc.? I know it sounds fundamental, but the medical community is not set up to treat the body as a whole.

We all know what happens to a diabetic or hypoglycemic when their blood sugar is out of control - it can range from "feeling foggy" to coma, or worse. What if you're B12 or Omega-3 deficient? What if you're pumping your body full of hormones? Have an undiagnosed gluten sensitivity? We can accept the sugar/diabetes thing, why haven't we embraced these other things as well?

Obviously, I'm not a doctor. But I do know we take drugs too freely. The only difference in these drugs between "desired effects" and "side effects" are those labels. The truth is, we don't know what many of the drugs do to us. I'm not against drugs, I just think we shouldn't use them as a first line of defense. Wouldn't it be better to address the "why" before trying to repair the problem?

Such as it is with birth control. Why do we need to mess with hormones? We've switched to condoms here (an age issue - the pill is more dangerous after 35), and they work very well. Ok, sensitivity, blah, blah, I'll make that sacrifice for balanced hormones in my partner ANY DAY OF THE WEEK. But we've gotten far too used to taking a pill, or inserting a device, or messing with our bodies in such a way that it undermines our overall wellbeing.

Sorry for the rant, I'm very interested in the subject and have been learning. I'm really glad you discovered the root of your problem.

This is the book I've been reading - http://www.amazon.com/UltraMind-Solution-Broken-Brain-Healing/dp/1416549714/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1262715992&sr=8-1 Cheesy title, writing isn't the best, but lots of good info. And a lot of it is similar to the stuff Dr. Weil teaches.

5
tomatopaste•

Why do we need to mess with hormones?

Because condoms kill spontaneity and some of us experience no sensation through them.

Also, the hormone shift from the pill is less than a woman's natural monthly shift. If one causes problems, try one of the hundreds of other formulations.

1
[deleted]•

Ultrathin condoms help with that.

1
tomatopaste•

What makes you think I wasn't talking about ultra-thin condoms?

1
llamaspit•

Hm. Killing spontaneity vs. potential damage to your system. If I were a woman, I'd risk spontaneity before I'd risk having adverse effects from modifying my hormones.

How long does it take for you or your partner to put on a condom anyway?

1
tomatopaste•

potential damage to your system

Pfffft. Phenomenally unlikely "damage to your system". Come on, look at the statistics on this. A tiny, tiny percentage of women have a bad reaction to a form of the pill. From what I've seen, they never try another one and just go around spreading fear.

Maybe you don't mind stocking, locating, and putting on condoms. My girlfriend and I do. I'm going to let others decide which they prefer.

By the way, good job completely ignoring the male sexual satisfaction side of things. I find that to be pretty universal of the fear-spreading naturalistic-fallacy-believers as well.

0
celestec•

It causes a lot of issues that people never think of

Including breast cancer

To summerize the article: the New England Journal of Medicine found that the hormones in hormone replacement therapy (the same as in birth control) probably cause breast cancer.

tl;dr: It you are taking the pill, stop. I'd rather have kids than cancer.

3
bleepitybleep•

HRT caused my mom's breast cancer. Luckily for me, I've not needed it. Tried it but when I found out mom had cancer I quit it. Boom. I feel fine. Yeah I get hotflashes, oh what fun.

Who wants to take Premarin anyway, which is short for pregnant mare piss!?!

All BC, when I was coming along, made me feel constantly pregnant. NO thanks

Meds are crazy, be careful.

1
[deleted]•

If you haven't looked into it already, check out IUDs as a possible alternative to the pill.

3
AppleAtrocity•

I am on Depo Provera which works well for me. There are some crazy horror stories about it though too.

1
[deleted]•

Yeah, everybody's body chemistry is different, good that you found something that works for you. It seems to me that IUDs use a lot less hormones, or none at all, depending on what you get, and I figure that would be a lot less disruptive. Anecdotal evidence seems to bear that out but I, in my maleness, can't speak from personal experience.

2
killerstorm•

It causes a lot of issues that people never think of.

Hormonal pills fuck with human's body. Who'd guess that?

2
Laura_Borealis•

There was a really interesting article speaking to how pheromones and smells help people choose partners.

Experiments suggest that BC pills not only slightly change a woman's pheromones, but also make her smelling men's pheromones 'fuzzy,' resulting in her choosing a man less chemically compatible. Scientists extrapolated to wonder if this is why divorce rates are higher now, because women are on BC before marriage, then go off to have children afterwards.

I'm not advocating abstinence in this case, but I wouldn't consider hormonal BC for myself.

Anyhow, if you like, you can read the article here: http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1704672-2,00.html

2
[deleted]•

I'm dating a girl that has the same issue. It does worry me as condoms aren't 100% effective, but I understand her position.

2
[deleted]•

perhaps you should look at the non-hormonal Paragard IUD. More effective than condoms or the Pill.

1
[deleted]•

So...wanna have sex?

73
DpressdOP•

My libido has certainly come back, but I'm sorry to report I'm happily married.

Edit: I meant I'm ecstatic to report ;)

124
[deleted]•

If you're sorry to report that, isn't that good news for me? Giggity giggity!

97
DpressdOP•

Ok, have an edit.

67
DevoALMIGHTY•

Now it's time for a new login. :)

8
Tylerdurdon•

Haha!! Nice fix. I hope all of the joys of life continue to shine for you, and am happy you found the cause. Thanks for the laugh.

4
ro4ers•

Why do you hate Peta Wilson?

3
[deleted]•

What?

1
arnedh•

Which sounds better than depressedly married. Chaste hug from me to you, I'm happy for you and hope you are permanently on the plus side from now on.

I'll just drop this into the thread: http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn2457-semen-acts-as-an-antidepressant.html

19
quodestveritas•

Give her that Christian Side Hug!

19
melodeath31•

My thoughts exactly

0
knitmensch•

Glad to hear it. I experienced a similar change in libido when I went off hormonal contraceptives (and switched to barrier methods! Geez, some people will jump on any excuse to bash religions! Not Catholic or even Christian, just tired of that.) Depression hasn't been my issue, but the hormones are certainly enough to sway brain chemistry. You go, Dpressd.

1
[deleted]•

What about the proposed BJs? That's not sex, is it?

-7
DpressdOP•

Frinklestein definitely deserves one. We should make a petition to his wife.

12
[deleted]•

Damn! And, here I was thinking I was going to get in on the action.

Damn you, Frinlestein! YOU DAMN DIRTY APE!

1
Whisper•

We need to stop making women responsible for contraception.

(Yes, I know, Whisper the vehement anti-feminist just said that. When you're finished dying of shock, I'll go on.)

Seriously, their parts are not only a DNA dispenser, but also a life support system and hormonal clock. It's complicated, and messing with it has consequences. Our bits are simpler and easier to interrupt.

I see no reason why a deposit with a reliable storage service, followed by a quick vasectomy, shouldn't be a rite of passage into adulthood for every young male in our society.

50
HeWhoWas•

I'd much prefer it if there was a male contraceptive pill. Not only would I KNOW that I'm incapable of impregnating someone, double the protection never hurt anyone. Also, invasive, and often permanent, surgery is a far fucking cry from taking a pill that can be stopped at any time.

69
grantmclean•

Smoke pot. My sperm count is so low I can't get anyone pregnant.

17
Drakom88•

You're doing it wrong.

11
grantmclean•

Saved me from having a baby with a bipolar ex-gf. I'm satisfied.

5
elmer_the_arse•

you can be my cuckold then

1
pluis•

The problem with the whole pill thing is that it messes with your hormones, which is risky. Depression is one risk, cancer and bloodclots are others. I don't think those risks would be less for males (say, suppressing your testosterone levels might cause you to lose your sex drive, get moobs and unwanted hair growth.. You'd not be a happy puppy, I think).

Pills are also less reliable than surgery- diarrhea or vomiting may cause to pill to be expelled before it can do its job. Also, antibiotics usually prevent purely hormone based anticonception from working.

If I had a chance, I'd get surgery now (nut I am a 26 y.o. woman and no doctor will operate on me for another ten years, or so, because they're afraid I might change my mind).

The permanency of the surgery is not problematic either if you follow Whisper's suggestion of storing a batch of sperm elsewhere for IV procedures once you do want children, right?

13
Little_Kitty•

Actually in men one approach is administration of exogenous testosterone (not the suppression). This is the same as injecting steroids, but it is done at normal physiological levels. Given that many men have low levels of testosterone (especially as they age), this can improve mental health and physical fitness. It's difficult to go too far unintentionally, but IIRC it's nowhere near as effective as a contraceptive.

1
feathers•

I don't think I want children, but I wouldn't get surgery either. It's just too invasive, expensive and risky for me, especially if I change my mind somewhere down the line...which, knowing myself, I will.

So I take the pill, and suffer the side effects (some weight gain, moodiness, upset stomach and fainting spells) without complaining all that much...but it sure would be nice if the guys could take on SOME of the responsibility of not making babies. Sure, condoms exist, but at the cost of enjoying sex...which is why I'm taking pills in the first place. Still, I've heard good things about male hormonal birth control treatments, and while they may not be as ideal as the RISUG treatment in testing, I've also heard that the biggest roadblock to the popularity of these products is the lack of a receptive audience.

That is, pharmaceutical companies who have dumped millions into development of male hormonal birth control products have just stopped testing because they're convinced men wouldn't take them.

From men's comments on this topic there seems to be a discrepancy, but looking at the male population as a whole (opposed to the male population of reddit) there may be some truth there. It's just rather frustrating/annoying, to think that women either have to bear both the pains of preventing children OR the pains of bearing children. ("A strange game. The only winning move is not to play.")

tl;dr = Too bad men don't (generally?) take birth control, that would be really nice.

1
feng_huang•

Goddammit. I've been looking forward to these for a while. I didn't realize that the projects were abandoned over a year ago.

Maybe they're still working on the shot. I'd still do that, even though I'd have to go to the doctor to get it.

1
zip_000•

IV isn't exactly cheap or easy. I'd much rather do it the old fashioned way and have to take pills. Of course, I'm a guy, so it is my wife taking the pills.

I'd take them myself if it was an option, but it doesn't really appear to be. Of course if you're having severe side effects like the OP, then stopping is clearly the correct choice.

0
rayofash•

They're working on it. Right now there are monthly injections you can take. They're also working on a robotic device that seems pretty awesome.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
wuy3•

There is some recent research into male contraceptives (pills, etc) but the problem is one of numbers. Its millions of sperm vs a single egg, there's complications in that for sure. And I bet lack of interest from big pharma is a contributor as well (which I guess results from cultural rejection of male contraceptives besides the condom).

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
quodestveritas•

You know, my boyfriend and I were talking about jizz+freeze+snip as a birth control strategy. The problem is, I don't know how quality frozen jizz is in terms of producing top-notch babies. Have you ever eaten thawed peas? They're gross. I wonder if there are adverse effects on freezing sperm, too.

20
Telecaster22•
18
davelog•

This explains SO much about Thanksgiving dinners when I was a kid.

1
otakucode•

Sperm are pretty tiny and fragile, any damage done to them would be readily apparent from inspection... it's extremely unlikely they could sustain much damage and retain motility, sort of natural quality control. Peas get nasty because the water inside them freezes, expands, and breaks cellular barriers. That specific problem wouldn't affect frozen sperm, but I would also be interested in seeing what studies have found with possible reduction in motility and viability of frozen sperm.

Even if a person opts not to get the vasectomy, freezing sperm at age 12 or 13 might be a good policy as the genetic quality of sperm degrades with age, and as we as a society delay reproduction further and further away from puberty, the genetic damage has a much larger chance of increasing. Women should probably have eggs frozen at that age also, as they suffer the same, if not more, genetic damage over time.

9
[deleted]•

and as we as a society delay reproduction further and further away from puberty,

FWIW, the answer isn't to freeze sperm; it's to stop geriatrics from having kids. My wife was a preschool teacher for ten years, and it's just anecdotal, but she insists there is a direct correlation between brattiness and parents' age. Effectively, when a 45 year old has kids, very often they act like they've just had grandchildren. (No tolerance, spoiling them, no discipline, etc)

I have said this before and many redditors laugh, but I firmly believe it - if you happen to be married young, go ahead and have kids right away, because your life is still unstable, so throwing more stuff at it just mixes in. If you wait, say, ten years, then your life is established and comfortable, and kids become a distraction you resent. Result - kids that are raised by public schools and daycares.

11
zip_000•

I'd basically agree, though for different reasons. I think it is better to have kids younger, not because you will resent them, but because children are exhausting. My wife and I are in our early 30's with a 2 year old, and I have to say, I am tired pretty much all the time since the kid was born...first from not sleeping through the night, then from running around to keep him from hurting himself, and now from running around keeping him from hurting himself and others.

I think you having kids in your mid 20's is the ideal time: you're relatively stable in terms of income (or often are anyway) and you still have some youthful energy.

3
[deleted]•

interesting. Perhaps we should just standardize child-rearing procedures so we could get more than anecdotal evidence

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
quodestveritas•

Thanks for the insight.

1
idclip•

Yeah, you're probably right. I heard they thawed Walt up and his drawings now look like this.

2
asciilifeform•

I see no reason why a deposit with a reliable storage service, followed by a quick vasectomy, shouldn't be a rite of passage into adulthood for every young male in our society.

Try this one.

That particular study was inconclusive, but the fact that vasectomy patients quickly start to produce antibodies to their own sperm is well-known. The idea that there might be a down-side to this is not too far a stretch of the imagination.

On the other hand, everybody dies of something.

I do agree that fertility should default to "off", but I am dissatisfied with the state of the art.

12
[deleted]•

The other thing you haven't considered is cost. You're talking a fairly cheap pill vs a mildly price surgery, a sperm storage cost and artificial insemination (possible several times depending on success and amount of kids desired) costs.

0
gmpalmer•

Holy cow -- what? I wouldn't trust my DNA with anyone, let alone a corporation. How about encouraging people to have responsible sexual activity? I know that's all unpopular and shit, but really, folks -- just because it feels good doesn't mean it is good -- otherwise we'd all have heroin pumps and drink from sugar tubes.

6
leachyboy2001•

Who doesn't have a sugar tube?

2
adrianmonk•

I see no reason why a deposit with a reliable storage service, followed by a quick vasectomy, shouldn't be a rite of passage into adulthood for every young male in our society.

Including gay males? What about people who are celibate (they do exist)? What about people who want to have a kid?

5
[deleted]•

I have no idea what point you're trying to make.

4
adrianmonk•

What use would a gay guy have for a vasectomy? Are any of his lovers going to get pregnant?

If some men don't have any have any need at all for a vasectomy, why should it be a rite of passage for "every young male"?

7
[deleted]•

I think you're taking the term "every" too literally. No one is saying it should be mandated by law.

3
[deleted]•

yes, for all, why not? People who want to have a kid ought to learn some self restraint first anyway

0
adrianmonk•

Could you explain what you mean by restraint? If you mean it's good to wait until you're a little older to have kids, then I'd like to point out that it's none of your business what age someone else chooses to have a kid as long as they're personally ready for the responsibility, etc. And even if someone does want to wait a few years before having a kid, there are other methods of contraception available, and it should be their own choice which method they use, not some rite of passage social ritual that they're pressured into.

2
[deleted]•

The problem is that you are selfishly thinking of the hormonal desires of individuals, not the future of our species. All this worry over global warming would be neatly solved by reducing world population by a billion or 3. However, it is clear that short-sighted animal desires are heavily defended rights, and the future of the human species is secondary.

2
stone_fox•

I completely agree with you and I've been saying it for a long time: hormonal contraception is not the answer.

Something which looks promising to me is RISUG. A fully-reversible, no-side-effect, 100% effective non-hormonal one-time procedure.

Men have been using it for 15 years with zero side effects + no children. They've reversed it in primates successfully, but for some reason research on it has stopped.

5
Ciacco•

The picture of the guy in that article looks like an expression of "I'm so happy you have enabled me to have even more sex with my wife. Joy of joys."

0
[deleted]•

Frankly we should have to do this, and then pass parenting and finance classes, and establish a stable life before being allowed access to it too.

2
thoughtdancer•

I recommend Aristoi by Walter Jon Williams: has this concept at play in it.

Good luck finding a copy, though. I believe it's out of print.

2
Whisper•

Coincidentally, I had just finished reading it when I wrote that original comment.

1
thoughtdancer•

I wondered if maybe you had. Great book, imho.

1
otakucode•

The best solution would be some sort of 100% (or damn close) reversible procedure. I've thought this for a long time, that research should try to find something that can be done at the beginning of puberty and then un-done once the person decides they wish to have children. It would solve many social problems.

1
[deleted]•

Little butterfly valves on the tubes in the scrotum.

7
otakucode•

Genius!

0
columbine•

Vasectomy is not an acceptable alternative to the oral contraceptive, sorry. If an oral contraceptive with similar efficacy was developed for men, and with less serious side-effects, I'd agree with you. But vasectomy is a long, long way from that. It's a relatively serious surgical procedure whose reversal is not fool-proof, and assumption that it's not always reversible means forcing unnecessary IVF (with all its costs and complications) on couples who do want children. Nobody who intends to have children in the future should ever get a vasectomy.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
hans1193•

Orgasms are not the same after a vasectomy, and IVF is fucking expensive,

1
[deleted]•

Orgasms are not the same?

Where did you get that from? It's just not true.

1
Sugarat•

If orgasm felt the same after a vasectomy as before it, they'd be more popular.

0
[deleted]•

what is this, what do you mean

1
Sugarat•

I mean vascectomy's are not without side effects and I would never endorse getting one. There's a reason vascectomy reversal is so popular.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Sugarat•

You'd like to say? Or you can honestly say? Lots and lots of testimonials exist from men who say different. Personally, it's not even a consideration for me.

1
yurigoul•

Vasectomy can not be undone or has a very, very slim chance of being undone after a number of years (I believe 10 years or less).

I tried to find a link to something I once heard, but could not find it: A certain tribe gave men a hole at a certain place in their penis so the sperm could no longer come out at the end - thereby reducing the risk of pregnancy.

This could also be some urban legend but if this technique could be improved it does the thing vasectomy does without the risk of being infertile at the moment you actually want to have children.

0
Ciacco•
3
[deleted]•

Hear, Hear!

0
hans1193•

Upvoted like crazy for saying something popular that sounds like it should be correct but is totally inaccurate... typical reddit. Female birth control just has to interrupt a cycle once a month, male birth control requires constant hormonal suppression which is much harder to acomplish and much harder on the body... and no one has figured out a safe way to do this. Its not some huge sexist conspiracy.

http://health.howstuffworks.com/male-bc-pill.htm

0
gmpalmer•

Wrong. Female chemical birth control interrupts a CONSTANT cycle. It replaces the woman's natural hormonal balance with an artificial one that comes with all sorts of consequences, not the least of which is borderline insanity.

2
hans1193•
1
gmpalmer•

That article is misleading at best. The pill still has to interrupt a whole HOST of processes to prevent ovulation (and it still doesn't work all the time -- google breathrough ovulation).

More to the point, however, is that just because the male pill would interrupt constant production doesn't mean the female pill doesn't.

In fact, the "dangers" and "difficulties" inherent in the male pill ought to point out to us the dangers and difficulties inherent in the female pill as well.

1
Tinkyy•

Wrong. Actually you're so wrong that I'm going to let someone else enlighten you.

0
springboks•

Not everything needs to be solved by a pill. Don't fuck with your hormones men or women...put a rubber on guys. They come in colors, easy to use, safe for you and your partner. When in doubt, double bag that shit.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
pinano•

[citation needed]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

Erm,(comparatively) limited clinical trials have been done with it. There needs to be a lot more work done on it in order for it to be brought into the US. It's a lot easier to get such treatments out here as the requirements for medical trials and the regulations for medicine are less restricted here (India). It's not because of the feminist lobby.

1
[deleted]•

That's great to hear.

One thing you might find is that you occasionally slip back in to your depressed state of mind during your recovery. The important thing to remember is that you now know you're strong enough to pull yourself out the other side and continue getting better. Over time it will happen less and less often, and wont last as long. Eventually you'll be able to see it coming and give yourself a mental slap round the face.

26
DpressdOP•

I'm sure you're right, this feeling of being on top of the world can't last forever. However, I have great support from my husband and family and I'm sure I'll pull through. Thanks for the advice, I'll try to remember it when the going gets tough.

18
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
llamaspit•

I don't want to sound like a commercial for this book, but it's relevant http://www.amazon.com/UltraMind-Solution-Broken-Brain-Healing/dp/1416549714/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1262715992&sr=8-1

Research your nutritional balance. It has a profound affect on your brain function. You might find, as I have been finding, that correcting certain things in your lifestyle - the chemicals in your body, your hormones, vitamin and mineral intake - is actually more powerful than we're led to believe by drug companies. Drugs are good and have a purpose, but should be used when other, less intrusive, methods have failed. That's my opinion.

Check it out - if not that book, check out other sources relating to functional medicine and nutritional medicine, and as you encounter controversies in the research, always consider the source. There are those who would profit from calling this "alternative" treatment, rather than validating it. I don't mean to sound cynical, it's just really hard to weed through propaganda and the like to get to good information.

1
biodebugger•

I struggled for many years with a problem which had some similarities to what you describe. I don't know if what's happening to you is at all similar, but in case it might help...

I experienced times of depression, low energy, etc. which would occasionally flip suddenly to feeling high energy "on top of the world". The darkest time, and the only time I felt suicidal, was during my one attempt at taking birth control pills. I don't remember one of those flips happening when I stopped taking the HBC, but it did sometimes happen after stopping other drugs.

My current explanation for these flips involves the effect of various levels of toxins in the body. In my case I believe the culprit was cholinesterase inhibitors, but I suspect other types of substances can have similar effects.

Our livers are amazing at breaking down and getting rid of these substances. However, if it can't keep up for some reason, levels of these toxins can build up. At low to medium levels, they may stimulate an increased level of adrenal release that can be invigorating. This is what caffeine does (at least in reasonable amounts). At higher levels you may feel worn out and depressed (aka "adrenal fatigue").

If your ability to deal with these toxins is impaired and/or your intake of them increases, they can build up to the fatigue zone. If your ability to deal with them increases and/or your intake decreases, the level may fall to the stimulating zone. I believe this is what was happening to me when these flips occurred.

The interesting bit that makes me think your situation may be related is that high estrogen levels, such as are caused by hormonal contraceptives, can affect how well the body breaks down and clears out toxic substances. For example, this paper talks about how HBC slows down the elimination of caffeine. All sorts of medications suppress particular detoxification pathways, but it appears that estrogen could affect how well the liver deals with stuff in general.

If this effect is contributing to what is happening to you, the "top of the world" feeling may slowly fade and leave you in a more normal endocrine state. The unexpected struggle that came along with this for me was that I had to relearn how to deal with motivation now that my body wasn't constantly telling me that everything was an emergency. Despite that, life is definitely much better now.

I'm very happy that you're dong so much better and have a good support system to be with you through whatever the future may hold.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

22
LOLTofu•

Same here. And, of course, once I got off HBC, I feel like I hear about other women having the same problems everywhere. While I was on it, I couldn't figure out why I was such a miserable bitch all the time. Now I'm on a non-hormonal IUD which comes with its own little array of problems, but none of them are emotional. Hooray!

6
notcaptainkirk•

Just FYI, vasectomies are not 100% effective and can recanulate so make sure your husband is getting his semen tested regularly for sperm or else you could have a big surprise down the road.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
barkybarkbark•

Wow, this is a great story. Congrats to you!

This reminds me of a lump I had in my neck when I was 21. One of my glands was swollen and I was convinced I was going to die from Leukemia or Lymphoma, etc. I went to a doctor, a surgeon, another doctor. No one thought it was cancer, but no one had an explanation.

Fast forward 12 years. I was 33 and I had a TERRIBLE pain in my face and front tooth. I mean hammer and nail in the face, crying excruciating pain. I went to the dentist and he drilled a tiny hole in the back of my front tooth and relived pressure and did a root canal.

Apparently this is what happened: when I was 5 years old I fell and my mouth hit the ground causing my tooth to be slightly injured. Tiny microfissure cracks unseen to even dental X-rays let bacteria slip into my tooth. By 21 this VERY low grade infection was being responded to by my immune system. By 33 the infection was severe enough due to widening of the cracks, thinning of the enamel to require needing a root canal.

Anyone, 3-days after getting the root canal at 33, the left gland that had been swollen since my early 20s was gone and has not returned in over 5 years.

21
Andoo•

Yeah, depression sucks

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
gliscameria•

Stop punching her in the face. Trust me, it works.

10
Xexx•

I don't think such serious measures are required in this case, perhaps we should go over alternative options?

2
ShrimpCrackers•

Dear Reddit: I am utterly depressed because I have to use condoms now that my wife stopped taking contraceptives. She has suggested that I get my tubes tied...

19
[deleted]•

non-hormonal IUD is what you need

13
[deleted]•

Everybody needs to upvote this suggestion. I came here to say this.

3
DanWallace•

Improvised Underwear Device?

3
pingveno•

If designed correctly, that would be very good birth control.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
blmurch•

I know you're trolling, but really, VCF is a useful contraceptive.

1
Sugarat•

Not as effective as the pill or condom and most places recommend using another contraceptive also. So the whole 'birth control that neither of you can feel' claim is leaving out a tiny little detail, namely that it's not as effective.

1
seasmucker•

I found it kinda foamy and smelly. And kinda hard to put in. A lot of them ended up on fingers.

1
[deleted]•

tell her to get HER tubes tied!

-2
[deleted]•

My girlfriend (yes, she's real... wanna fight about it?) had the same problem. She was on the NuvaRing, and her mood swings were just unbearable (for both of us). She took it out and switched to a non-hormone IUD, and her whole demeanor changed almost overnight. We're both grateful, both for the change in her mood and for a much more reliable form of birth control.

Hormonal birth control works for some women, but for my girlfriend, it just didn't work. Dpressd's case is obviously significantly worse, but I worry about how many women out there are suffering from similar symptoms without even considering that it might be the high doses of hormones they're being sold by the pharmaceutical industry. Oral contraception isn't for everyone, and I hope that doctors and other reproductive health professionals are doing a good job of warning women about the possibility of serious mental health side effects.

13
notcaptainkirk•

but I worry about how many women out there are suffering from similar symptoms without even considering that it might be the high doses of hormones they're being sold by the pharmaceutical industry

Drug companies do not make much money off of BCP. Just FYI.

2
[deleted]•

Define "much money."

1
king_of_blades•

An amount constituting a significant part of one's total wealth.

1
[deleted]•

Well played, sir.

1
PoopedEm•

Big Pharma still makes about 18 cents on the dollar, so there still pretty high above the corporate average.

1
[deleted]•

But they make money of the anti depressants people have to buy as a consequence.

1
otakucode•

Going to check into a non-hormonal IUD now?

12
[deleted]•

Paragard non-hormonal IUD works wonderfully (and cheaper after 1 year than the pill!)

7
LOLTofu•

Let's not pretend it's completely side-effect free, though. My periods are enormous, operatic, epic affairs now, and not in the fun way. It solved all the emotional problems I had with HBC (being depressed, no libido, quick temper) but it really did create a host of new difficulties. More manageable difficulties, certainly (I'd rather be in teeth-gritting pain than dark depression any day), but my obgyn did not adequately prepare me for what I was in for.

8
anothernameagain•

I know that one of the side effects of Paragard is that your periods can get awful. I just want to chime in that I've had a Paragard for almost 2 years and my periods have actually become FAR more manageble and almost pain free since I got it. I have no explanation for this - my periods to begin with were crippling. I know it doesn't help you any, but I just want to put it out there that Paragard can have the opposite effect. It is certainly possible also that it will make it more painful, or make no noticable change to your period as well.

6
LOLTofu•

You lucky, lucky lady. I guess getting Paragard is a bit of a gamble, but my gynecologist didn't really warn me well about the extreme possibilities. She also told me insertion would only feel like "a bad period cramp", so I should have seen this coming.

2
Sugarat•

Those have side effects also.

2
quodestveritas•

Seconded. I am a bit of a nutcase to begin with, but man oh man did hormonal BC make me go batshit.

11
randomletters•

Thirded. I took BC for a few years with no problems then went off for a year during an anti-man phase. When I tried to go back on them, I was nothing short of homicidal.

4
resiros•

Now don't forget to change that nickname, 'haP' would be a possibility :P

11
muhal•

Placebo?

11
Manitcor•

doubtful, birth control pills are nasty stuff. they hijack the reproductive system's normal processes by flooding the body with additional hormones to prevent ovulation.

these same hormones are responsible for your sex drive, certain mood states and who knows what else (most doctors will tell you we don't fully understand how any of this really works).

Anytime someone has a change or issue that is hard to nail down, it is always good to eliminate outside factors that are jerking body chemistry around before running off and prescribing more drugs, treatments or surgeries.

Medicine is part science fact part scientific investigation with a bit of intuition from experience/knowledge thrown in. In cases where the doctors have no clue good ones will start trying to isolate certain test cases (just as if your debugging something) to try and prove or disprove certain possibilities. When I first came to understand this I began to think most doctors are quacks. The truth is, to mess with someones body with what little knowledge we have, you gotta have some balls.

There are still quack doctors but in my experience the quacks are the ones who think they know the problem every time and don't stop to actually think or try to accurately diagnose an issue. They also tend to be quite happy to give you a prescription for some powerful drug, not explain that it will kill your sex drive or leave you puking at 4am, pat you on the head and send you on your way.

With all that said, the OP could still possibly use birth control, but they may need to change the type or dose. Not all birth control is equal and they all have a different balance. As you get older your chemistry changes so something that worked well when you were 21 might cause depression when you are 30.

13
ItMeansYouAre•

(just as if you're debugging something)

1
Manitcor•

if your a spelling or grammar Nazi take a look at my post history and you can have a field day.

be careful, it has put some English majors in the hospital due to brain implosion ;-)

2
ItMeansYouAre•

if you're a spelling or grammar Nazi take a look at my post history and you can have a field day.

:(

2
Meta8•

Could be. The real question is, does it matter?

5
columbine•

Of course it matters. We use contraceptives for a very good reason, to prevent unwanted pregnancies. If people stop taking contraceptives based on anecdotal placebos like this case may possibly be, we're going to end up with more unnecessary abortions and unplanned children.

0
Meta8•

I understand what you mean, but that's not at all what I meant. By saying "Placebo?", you're asking if maybe OP got better truly because she thinks stopping the pill helped her. I'm saying that your question doesn't matter to her case, because her health improved and that's what matters in the end.

Simple misunderstanding. :)

1
outhere•

Congrats! Might I also add that I was on the verge of divorce about 2 years ago because my wife's sex drive was non-existent. We had experienced a normal sex life for many years, but gradually her drive just diminished into nothing. Even though she had been on the pill for well over a decade with no problems, she decided to "take a break" on the advice of a friend and within a week she was as horny as teenager.

She's off the pill permanently and our sex life is back to normal. (With the occasional abnormal ;)

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

A friend of mine once said: "Don't change your girlfriend, change her birthcontrol"

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
DpressdOP•

Thank you. I think it's a bit early to say I'm "cured" and I was going to wait a bit more, but I saw that it's time for the redditor of the year awards and I thought he really deserves it!

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
dropcode•

You should also maybe consider the possibility of new-onset bipolar disorder. The way this post reads, makes me feel that it could be a real possibility. In a 2005 study called "The Use of Placebo in Clinical Trials on Bipolar Disorder: A New Approach for an Old Debate" by the clinical institute of psychiatry and psychology, it was found that placebos are very effective against bipolar disorder, it logically follows that quitting the oral contraceptives might not actually be a full solution.

This isn't an attempt to diminish your recovery. I just don't want to see you fall back into depression after an extended manic episode, as highs and lows can be even more difficult to cope with than depression alone.

9
radioheart•

Upvoted for insight.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
jules_siegel•

Have you discussed this with your parents ... or anyone else who might be able to help you?

13
penguinv•

Figure out who you are and towards what you are going. Ger busy with what you are interested in. See this as a chosen time to concentrate, like Alyosha in The Brothers Karamazov.

Exercise, study, get strong, do sports or make model airplanes or a model UN. Pretend you chose this situation.

I hope you see my comment. What I am saying is, you see you got lemons? then make lemonade! In your later life it will be 'money in the bank.'

All the best to you buddy.

1
Andoo•

career?

-1
gliscameria•

It's the lack of boobs and vagina in your proximity. Boarding school are for future mass murderers and pedophiles... mostly. Being sent away from your family in highschool to live with a bunch of guys is bad news. You are all hopped up on hormones and really don't have a father figure or support group to really care and keep you inline. I almost went to a boarding school when I was a younger... glad I didn't. The trouble I got into with girls replaced what trouble I would have gotten into with more dangerous things. Best of luck man.

-1
shapechanger•

As a male with diagnosed depression, I find myself wishing I had birth control to get off of. In any case, I'm glad you found such a simple solution to such a crushing problem.

8
[deleted]•

see a doc?

1
penguinv•

Chinese medicine. Experience. Shop around. It's overall as effective as Western.

Good luck. I responded because I heard the power of your words.

1