r/self•
flossdaily

A violation of trust and community values.

*[This is an open letter to Azured and kleinlb00, though I want it noted that neither of them wanted the following information to be made public.

I sat on it all day trying to decide if I could be as forgiving as them. I cannot.

I'm still just a furious as I was when I found Azured's detective work in my inbox 14 hours ago.]*

re: Thought you should know

Dear Azured and Kleinlb00,

Having seen Azured's evidence, I'm left with little doubt that karmanaut, bechus, and earlyworm_ are all controlled by the same person, "Roy".

As the record will show, I got out of the karma collecting business as quickly as I got into it- and that was several months ago. This has nothing to do with reddit's point system. The issues here are the much more fundamental ones of personal trust, and our values as an online community.

For me, it boils down to the simple face that while Roy was playing the role of upstanding moderator and model reddit citizen, he was simultaneously using his alternate account to herd hate-fueled mobs against redditors that threatened to make him share the spotlight.

Per your inquiry, I was a new name and face. To this day, I maintain that I have never made an alter (though I did contemplate creating one for purposes of this post. I decided that the hypocrisy of that outweighed the appeal of poetic justice). It's quite well documented, actually... you can pretty much mark the time and date I switch to reddit from digg (6 months ago).

I did have a meteoric rise, though I wasn't aiming for karma, per se- I won't deny that I found the attention rewarding. Who wouldn't? But, that rise ended in discouragement when I hit months of negativity and hate from an angry mob.

At the time, I had figured that reddit had just had its fill of me- which was fair enough. Perhaps I'd just warn out my welcome.

What hadn't occurred to me was that one of reddit's most influential users had launched a strategic campaign to sink me, all the while consoling me in private and offering kind words about how he dealt with the same sort of thing.

Roy's incitements created an environment which made it impossible to keep contributing to reddit in the way that had been so enjoyable for me. The short stories helped me make a name for myself here have completely disappeared from reddit, and I've focus primarily on catering to a small group of friends in my very obscure subreddit.

I was going through a serious depression at the time, and my main source of solace and comfort was the reddit community. When my stories here were so well received, the overwhelming support and encouragement I received from reddit gave me a renewed sense of purpose, and opened up for me the possibility of actually pursuing a writing career.

When all the hate started and the atmosphere soured, reddit stopped being a welcoming place for me. I blamed myself and slunk off to a corner, reducing my contributions here drastically over the following weeks, and remaining at that low plateau for months to the present day.

I knew that the accusations Roy had made against me were untrue, but I truly believed that I must have been doing something which caused the floodgates of negativity to open. It hurt me on a personal level that I didn't think was possible on an internet community... but that's what happens when you invest so much time and energy and genuine affection into a place like reddit.

If I had know the truth, that the hate-storm that swelled up against me was not an honest and spontaneous reaction to my behavior, but rather had been artificially rallied and amplified by Roy to protect his record as karmanaut- I think I could have laughed it off, and would still be one of the most active contributors of content to reddit. Instead, I took it as a clear signal that the majority of reddit would just as well prefer if I got lost. Now I'm enjoying the quiet life of has-been user who rarely contributes anything more than a brief paragraph or two in the comments of whatever hits the front page, and a painfully slow episodic serial story for the folks who continued to make me feel welcome.

I can't fairly say that Roy ruined reddit for me... but I think he certainly ruined me for reddit.

Recently he tried to do the same thing to Azured. The comment's (now deleted) by earlyworm_ (also now deleted) were designed to curb Azured's popularity and success on reddit. By fostering an attitude of resentment and hate.

Who knows how many other people he sandbagged in the past, or how many more he will target in the future?

I guess the kicker for me, and the reason that I can't be a bigger person and keep this to myself, is that while Roy was busy using earlyworm_ to spread lies and destroy my reputation, he was simultaneously asking me for help as karmanaut (and eventually his real life persona) in editing his law school paper. I stayed up for 8 hours that night pouring over every sentence and giving him detailed notes on every conceivable aspect of it.

He violated a personal trust when he asked me for professional academic help, all the while soiling my relationship with this community, and poisoning the one area of my life that was actually giving me joy in that tough time.

-flossdaily

Posted Jul 2, 2010, 7:07 AM UTC · edited

132268
Psychologist101•

I honestly don't know what happened (comments or otherwise), what I can say though, your short stories are great, You're are an astute commenter, i friended you a long time ago just to read your comments, and I can't wait for your book to come out to buy it.

As it has been said before "haters gonna hate" and "jerks will be jerks"

190

You're

Had to be done.

60
[deleted]•

You are one of my favorite people on Reddit because you are consistent.

25
paul_miner•

Also,

poring

2
SquareWheel•

I don't get it, what's that have to do with mining?

0
turkeypants•

Mine your pores for goop.

0
karmanaut•

I posted this below, but I figured it will never be read because my side of the story isn't welcome here:

As much as I hate being drawn into Reddit drama (I have even changed accounts recently because people were bothering me so much under karmanaut), I feel the need to explain how ridiculous this is.

I am not earlyworm. Despite the plethora of evidence that he submitted my comments to best of twice... that means nothing. Who is he? I don't know. I have never really noticed him, except for when he made flossdaily's hate thread. The one that I supposedly made to bring down flossdaily under an anonymous name? Oh, I guess the fact that I was in the thread, under my own name doesn't matter; I still needed a throwaway account. In fact, I flat-out told flossdaily what I thought of him. And it's still true. I feel like I was polite and trying to point out that commenting just to sell a book is close to spamming (yes, I know flossdaily linked this to his own subreddit, so I'm sure I will be downvoted for that, if not everything else).

As for who earlyworm is, I don't know.

  • Someone I know from reddit under an alternate account? Maybe. I have thought of a few people it could be.

  • Azured himself? Who knows. He claims this is his first username and only lurked for a week, which I don't believe for a second. He also told me that he comments for the karma, not to enjoy it. I can back that up with screenshots, if I cared. As for why he would spread shit about himself, I don't know. Someone left me a comment once saying "you're not someone on Reddit until there is someone else hating you."

  • Some random guy that doesn't like flossdaily, and didn't really care about me either way. That is a possibility. as for why he submitted two things to bestof, i can only guess that he submitted one and it was successful, and went to check my userpage later and found another.

  • My best guess: some sycophant who I don't know, but just likes me. Yes, they're out there, despite the fact that most of my stalkers just hate me. Someone who would both best'of me, and also slander what they viewed as a competitor. Wouldn't be too different from the many others who devote their time on reddit to trolling and making it worse for others.

Otherwise, this is ridiculous. I don't go around sabotaging any other well-known user. I would consider many of the people around here to be friends, or at least acquaintances, with whom I can joke around and discuss topics. Turning reddit into a soap opera is just obnoxious and serves only to make it a worse place.

Flossdaily, I liked you a lot. I like your writing, which is why I asked you for your help and advice. But I am disappointed to see you acting like this because one of my stalkers decided he didn't like you. Also, I would appreciate you removing my name, as Reddit is about being anonymous. I will also refrain from posting yours.

46
habbazoot•

THE INTERNET IS SERIOUS FUCKING BUSINESS, PEOPLE!

107
NonsensicalAnalogy•

I'd just like to say I hope you aren't Belchus, because he hates me and I love the hell out of you, like Harry loved Dumbledore.

And yes, I realize that made sense.

26
[deleted]•

[deleted]

15
NonsensicalAnalogy•

this is now my main account, I don't always make a nonsensical analogy in reply to something, just like a lion sometimes doesn't fart in space to turn on a geolocation system in a paper cup.

43
pitchpatch•

I'll just say this: I don't totally comprehend both sides of the story, but you both seem like legitimate, amicable guys, and I appreciate both of your contributions to the website. It definitely makes it an entertaining place to be.

@flossdaily: Dude, your grievances are definitely unfortunate and upsetting, but the smartest thing to do would be to hash this out in-person – or at least in private circumstances – if you guys do know each other like that.

This thread (even on r/self, the most appropriate place for it) seems to be provoking nothing but harsh sentiments on each side, and it isn't moving the argument towards a resolution whatsoever. If anything, it's just exacerbating the problem. Posting this is a good way to express your emotion, but there's not much to be gained from this except to instigate a negative rift... and that needn't be your main intent. Just work that shit out.

Hope you guys can air out issues, have a pregnant together, etc., and generally find some sort of halfway-point.

Regardless, all the best.

24
karmanaut•

Thanks. I like(d) flossdaily, and like his stories. That's why I asked him for help with my own writing. I hope we can work things out too.

I am just mad at Azured for starting this whole witch hunt, seemingly without reason. I've been trying to be nice to the guy for about a month, despite his massive ego (I'll screenshot some PMs for you all when I have time and am not on my work computer)

16
poubelle•

Reposting private email or messages isn't acceptable in any online forum I've been a part of... even when you think it'll bolster your argument.

25
RedditorInExcelsis•

I have seen a bit more of the evidence, while I started out believing that karmanaut=earworm_, now I am not so sure. I think that flossdaily got played by Azured, who seems like a shady character.

karmanaut has revealed his own picture and has met a few redditors IRL. It does sound somewhat out of character for him to do all this, but who knows. I don't doubt though that flossdaily really believes that karmanaut is earworm_ and I hope that karmanaut can successfully assuage his fears, even though he should not be under any obligations to do so if he is not really earworm_.

11
BendingUnit10110•

just hug it out, bro.

3
aeck•

"you're not someone on Reddit until there is someone else hating you."

Thanks for the tip!

Btw, the only thing that sucks more than Futarama is Zach Anner

21
abbrevia•

Let the hate flow through you.

7
flossdailyOP•

I don't feel like copying everything, so here's a link to my response when you posted this elsewhere.

http://www.reddit.com/r/self/comments/cl81x/a_violation_of_trust_and_community_values/c0td9l2

9
mjsolaro•

Karmanaut has been around reddit forever. You may not know this, but his IRL identity is extremely well-known, and he has never used his charisma for ill. He's not afraid to be downvoted and is very outspoken about his views. Leave him out of this.

23
hiS_oWn•

I'm not quite sure what the headhunter mentality on reddit is, but ever since the whole Saydrah incident, I'm finding it even more appropriate than before to keep your private life separate from your reddit account, because no matter how insignificant or ridiculous something is, you'll find 1) someone willing to employ it as part of an agenda, and 2) someone foolish enough to fall for it.

20
flossdailyOP•

Up until yesterday I shared your views exactly. That's why I feel so betrayed.

6
THE_PUN_STOPS_HERE•

Hell, I'm friends with him on facebook. This whole thing is silly.

0
esotericguy•

All that evidence you posted is circumstantial. I'm pretty damn sure you're being played.

15
thax•

I have heard that you have had like 9 abortions since you started your account. Why does karmanaut hate babies so much?

3
KaylaS•

Karmanaut, I looked up to you! Say it ain't so! You can't be the next Saydrah, what would we do without you? I hope this all blows over and works out for the both of you. I know you wouldn't do something like that, right? Right?

1
kgbyrne•

Agree 100%, fuck them all keep writing the great stories.

14
[deleted]•

One of the cool things about reddit is that drama like this can coexist mostly peacefully with a big active population of people who are blissfully oblivious to it, at least I certainly was. Usually this sort of thing will consume and ruin a site, reddit is somehow resilient to that.

7
Diggtionary•

an astute*

Writing is a art.

5
Psychologist101•

Thanks I changed it.

1
aperson•

I have similar sentiments with this comment.

3
Befall•

Don't let the drama get to you. Keep writing, know that you're amazing at it, and should never stop. Fuck Karmanaut, he's lower than you. Let's be honest: What kind of person only cares about karma on Reddit? Not one worth worrying about.

You're an awesome writer; keep going, fuck drama.

-3
unic0rnz•

I can't help but feel like this IRL shit has no relevance to the community except that it's just dirty laundry being aired in public in order to satisfy a personal desire for sympathy from the masses. I really like reddit and everything but I don't understand how so many people can buy into high-school drama like this.

91
Panguin•

because we are beings borne of conflict. Our entire existence up to this point has been one of struggle, and now that society has advanced to the point where we don't need to struggle to survive and prosper, we make ourselves get wrapped up in petty bullshit.

Or at least that's my take.

18
[deleted]•

Or maybe they're seeking validation on the internets because they're not getting the recognition irl they think they deserve.

11
V2Blast•

I was going to post something along the lines of "Cool story bro", but this basically sums it up. Why am I supposed to care?

12
flossdailyOP•

I knew a lot of people would feel that way, and it's valid point.

But I firmly believe (and I've written several times) that reddit's community is very real, and in almost every measurable way, more real than most local flesh and blood communities.

Look at what redditors do to help each other when we are in financial, legal, moral, and psychological crisis. We're constantly going above and beyond what could reasonably be expected of an internet community.

People donate their time, money, intelligence, resources, and anything else they can to help other people in need here. I've lived a lot of places, and I don't think I've been in a neighborhood yet where the residents do even half as much for each other.

Now, when one of our most prominent members (and advocate for real community value here, btw) turns out to be launching anonymous campaigns against other users... well, that just makes me mad.

The fact that he played upon my trust in a very personal way makes me even madder. When I gave him 8 hours of hard work to help him do well on his first law school paper... that wasn't just flossdaily helping karmanaut- that was a real flesh a blood law school graduate exchanging non-anonymous emails with another real live person.

He used me, and did so knowing that he had also done all he could to made reddit a really negative place for me to be.

2
RedditorInExcelsis•

Do you know who Azured is IRL? Can you trust him?

14
flossdailyOP•

No. I don't know him. But I've been in his position before... getting sandbagged by earlyworm_ out of the blue.

And it's not him that I trust... it's the case that he built and presented to me.

-14
coleman57•

so, there's no way he could have manipulated it? spell that out for me. what evidence did he present that is iron-clad and non-dependent on his integrity?

13
gukeums1•

I don't think I'm being too harsh when I say: you need some real friends. The internet is not a substitute for nor comparable to a real community - that's a naive and selfish (not to mention lazy) position. What happens if your internet connection is severed, or reddit is down/damaged, or any number of things occurs which makes it more difficult for you to access this supposed "community"? It is fragile, and it comes with none of the actual problems and rewards of real friendships. You can self-reinforce and self-validate all you want on reddit, endlessly, at all hours - that is nothing like a real community, and nothing like real friendship. I believe your ultimate flaw is in believing that this "place" is important, valuable and powerful when it is ultimately a content factory with peripheral interactions occurring. Please reevaluate your views, for your own mental health. It isn't sustainable or equitable to believe that reddit is so important as to call it a community. reddit is more akin to an addiction than a community.

[edit] that isn't to say that community can't come from reddit! but that IS to say that reddit is not itself a real community.

11
Zastrous•

You are being too harsh by making the assumption that he does not serve an active role as a social being in his own real life community. If you skimmed through his subreddit, you'd notice that he's been skirting the recent chapters of his upcoming novel aside in favor of spending time with his (pretty cool, I might add) girlfriend, amongst other activities. It's a pretty damning accusation and a pretty ignorant assumption to say that he doesn't have enough "real" friends.

2
crazyartfreak•

I'm not a popular redditor, nor am I much of a people-magnet in real life, nor do I even want to bother with someone else's personal drama, but here I am anyway, offering advice as I usually only do for those that ask it of me. No one has to read this, and if it gets downvoted out of sight, I really don't care, but I feel like it should be said anyway. (Also, I noticed that all of the posts on this thread are a few days old -I came across this through another thread- and I apologize for my tardiness and any inconvenience it may bring, but I'm still gonna say what I want because I can.)

As you said, I believe Reddit is a wonderful little internet-community-thingie, and we, as such, care for one another (as well as the rest of the world) in times of dire need. Also, I agree with you that Reddit's community sometimes does surpass that of real-life neighborhoods and people. And isn't that what we are, basically? Real people? It just so happens that we find more community-related-satisfaction on the internet as opposed to in physical being.

Ultimately, flossdaily, I am agreeing with you. Not because I believe that Karmanaut is out to get you (so to speak). Really, I am not here for accusations. I simply agree that we, Reddit, should feel that we can express our personal catastrophes and expect honest responses from those around us. The internet, especially in communities like this, brings out the best, the worst, and the most honest feelings in all of us (except for trolls, but they're honestly having fun, or they wouldn't be trolls in the first place, right?). We then feel free to write extensively about our experiences and opinions because we don't have to deal with what we've said if we don't want to. Personally, I'm much more open in writing than I am in person, so places like Reddit are a "godsend" to me because I can tell my story my way, and if someone doesn't like it, then tough shit to them.

Now, as far as my opinion goes on your situation with Karmanaut (whether he is actually earlyworm_ or not - I am not taking sides in this), I totally understand this used/betrayed feeling that you mention, as I knowingly allow many people in my life to walk right over me to get what will make them happy. While I do understand your pain, I only wish to say this in response: People suck sometimes.

I'm not pointing any fingers whatsoever, because there's no way that I could know for sure, but I wouldn't doubt that there are probably quite a few redditors out there with multiple accounts purely used to put others down. Also, I know that in the real world there are many people (who only have one real-life-account, mind you) who make it their sole purpose to put other people down. We can either take it to heart or we can shrug it off, but at one point or another we all have to deal with the dizzying amounts of self-doubt that these people bring to us.

I guess what I'm trying to say is that, at least in the way that you're feeling at this time, you aren't alone. And while others here seem to be open about not wanting to hear all of this drama, it was their decision to read and/or respond to it in the first place and they will deal with it as they wish.

Reddit will not ever be "a negative place" for you unless you allow it to be so.

3
opineapple•

It's stuff like this that drove me away from Livejournal. I can't believe it's seeped it's way into Reddit somehow. I thought this kind of drama was anathema to the community here, but that seems to be changing...

1
Dead_Rooster•

Fuck yeah.

-2
chairface•

nice try, karmanaut.

-4
randomb0y•

The drama! It's so intense!

54
Jonno_FTW•

*munches popcorn*

35
techdawg667•

*slurps coke*

6
Duodecim•

*snorts coke*

19
opineapple•

*shits on Debra's desk*

18
stile04•

Sweet, another mod witch hunt. /popcorn

46
[deleted]•

[deleted]

39
RedditorInExcelsis•

It is there is the text, but I will tldr this for you:

Karmanaut (allegedly) used alternate accounts to incite redditors against flossdaily (and others), (presumably with posts like these) all the while getting flossdaily's help IRL in editing his law school paper.

48
[deleted]•

[deleted]

27
RedditorInExcelsis•

You're welcome.

Karmanaut always seemed a little off to me, something about his James-Spader-playing-a-villain eyes.

17
OverlordXenu•

And he deletes any comment that gets downvoted.

11
unoriginalusername•

This story is not as good as your usuals, floss.

38
kleinbl00•

Dude, WTF?

"This is an open letter to Azured and kleinlb00, though I want it noted that neither of them wanted the following information to be made public."

Little disingenuous, don't you think? And maybe, just maybe, a scrupulous person might have told the people he was slandering so that they might actually respond, eh?

As a gentle reminder, what I actually said was, essentially, "breathe deep and let it go." I didn't tell you not to go post your vitriol to the world (although I assumed you'd maybe, oh, chill out). But we'll get to that third.

First, let's get to what Azured actually said:

Hi flossdaily and kleinbl00.

I'm writing you both this because I think that what I'm going to say you probably deserve, or at least would be interested to know. It probably seems weird that I'm sending you this message out of the blue, but bear with me. For a while now people have been commenting that they think I'm karmanaut's alt. Here's an example. This became more and more frequent when he stopped posting a while back and said he was posting under another name. I'm not his alt, so I decided to search around and find out who was. Before long I stumbled on bechus.

Bechus had a reasonable amount of karma, but it was going up fast, and he had just started posting a lot after what seemed to be a long hiatus. So I searched through his comments and found that he was leaving to start work in Italy. He's since deleted it, but here's evidence: [Google Cache].[Reddit link].[Screenshot]. Turns out it was on exactly the same day as karmanaut was leaving to italy for work: [Screenshot].[Reddit link]. He also made a bunch of law based posts - [Google cache].[Screen Shot].

I sent a message to karmanaut straight up asking him and linking some posts and he confirmed it.

More recently I messaged him again and we later talked about citricsquid's karmagraphs. He was worried his spike for bechus would be obvious. It's true – bechus' spike is pretty clear. - Site link.

So karmanaut = bechus.

Here's where the shit starts to thicken. The other day I took a look back at some of the comment of the year nominations for 2009 in this thread. Have a read down and look at bechus' comments to kleinbl00 and bozarking's nominations. Basically, karmanaut was using his alt to downgrade the nomination to help boost his chances. Despite those tactics, he didn't win. Since then we've shot a few messages back and forth about nothing in particular. Yesterday I got this. I didn't really know what to make of it. I noticed that I had one particularly harsh comment levelled against me that day so figured it was probably that poster reporting me.

This brings me to the redditor earlybird_ . His comment was posted against me in this thread, but he has since deleted it. It basically ripped me for being a reposter and deleting comments and being a general karmawhore. What was was weird though was that the guy had over 200 karma, but that was the only post on his profile; the rest were deleted. So I decided to google search his name within the reddit domain. The first thing that came up was other troll posts he'd made about me earlier – a bunch of them in a shitstorm that seemed to come from absolutely nowhere. Here they are [Google cache].[Reddit link].

But as I went further through the google results, I found that he had previously done exactly the same thing to flossdaily. He had made both posts and comments against him – not your ordinary “fucking karmawhore” type post, this was scathing, vehement, pointed shit. This is the submission he made deliberately against flossdaily that received 300 comments, [Reddit link] you can see flossdaily references earlybird_ throughout, and here's flossdaily's later response. [Reddit link].

At this point I had found that earlybird_ had made a bunch of comments against me, and had stirred a storm against flossdaily previously. About 10-15 comments in total, and 3 submissions – all deleted. The first submission was the one I just linked against flossdaily. The second two were bestofs. One bestof was for a pretty popular comment, the other one fairly obscure. Both bestof submissions were for the same commenter. It would make sense that he would delete troll posts, but why bestofs? This is why:

Here's the first.[Google cache].[Screenshot].[Reddit link].

Here's the second. [Google cache].[Screenshot].[Reddit link].

Take a look at the commenter they both link to.

This coupled with the bechus rips on kleinbl00 and bozarking is some pathetic bullshit.

I don't know if it bothers you, but I thought you should at least know. I don't know that I plan on saying anything other than this. I suppose I'll just keep tabs on karmanaut's alts and what he does with them.

It made me think though. When he sent me this message I can only imagine that he was trying to divert attention from himself for future troll attempts but it backfired woefully. Next time you see a shitstorm arise against someone with high karma from nowhere you'll know why.

34
kleinbl00•

Now, let's talk about what you actually said:

To Azured, kleinbl00,

Thanks for all that research into (Redacted), a.k.a. earlyworm_, bechus, and karmanaut.

His hateful postings about me gained a lot of popularity. Although his complaints against me were all lies and distortions, they went un-refuted for a day before I found them. In that time, he built a hate club of hundreds. For the next month or so, all of my comments were downvoted regardless of content, almost the instant they were posted.

The haters followed me around for quite a while after that, and eventually I all but stopped posting in askReddit, my favorite stomping ground. These days my main contributions to reddit are limited to my own subreddit.

I called earlyworm_ out as a coward- he created the account only a matter of days or weeks before he decided to use it solely for the purpose of bashing me... and apparently you folks as well.

As karmanaut he actually made some really snotty comments as well, but I worked it out with him.

In fact, at his request, I spent about 8 hours editing (Redacted)'s law school assignment.

You have some pretty damning evidence here that karmanaut is earlyworm_. I don't really care about the pettiness of downvoting to protect his karma record. What I do take offense to is that he would simultaneously take advantage of my friendship and ask me to volunteer my time and hard work to help him out with a law school assignment.

I feel really used and betrayed by him.

-flossdaily

What are you, 12?

24
kleinbl00•

Finally, here's what I said privately. I expected it to stay that way, yes, because this whole retarded shitstorm started privately. There are very, very few Redditors I know off of Reddit and I'm perfectly happy to keep it that way. I have no idea who any of you are, delight in the fact that none of you know who I am, and like to think that this is the kind of place where ideas can thrive and bitter and childish tripe such as this can be ignored. But I guess not.


Friends, Romans, Countrymen -

It saddens me whenever I see people turning Reddit into SRS BIZNSSS! because frankly it's a pretty poor videogame when you compare it to, say, Warcraft. And the points are worth even less.

But mostly because it's one of the easiest systems to game (perhaps because there's the least to gain from doing it?). (Redacted)'s got at least two names that I know of up on that leaderboard, and it wouldn't surprise me at all if he had more. qgyh2 is up there at least twice. 911wasaninsidejob is up there once, even though his account is gone, and several others are as well. I think people enjoy the game but they don't enjoy the notoriety. I also think that to enjoy the game, you have to care about the points. I really don't. If I did, I'd play Farmville.

(Redacted), however, probably enjoys many aspects of the game. karmanaut was not his first account. He started one of the most notorious troll accounts in the history of Reddit about the time he started karmanaut; while seeing how high he could get one account, he most assuredly tried to see how low he could get another. And these are just the accounts I know about. I'm sure there are more. I think he enjoys manipulating it this way and that just to see if he can. More power to him. I think you can solve that by inspection and don't derive any joy out of playing with people, so I don't. At the same time, I recognize that pretty much anybody with a vested interest in it can make the scores do whatever they want so I don't really give much of a shit.

I, for one, was delighted when somebody came up with reasons why I shouldn't be nominated for Redditor of the Year, no matter who it was and no matter what their motives were. That kind of target on your back is a pretty serious impediment to discourse - you'll notice bozarking broke under the pressure. I've tried the whole "dump your name, be someone else" thing, but I suck at it - my voice is too much my own and I rely too much on personal anecdotes (and semicolons) to stay anonymous for long. And as soon as I realized I was spending more time hiding my identity than contributing to the community I tossed the sockpuppets - but that's a choice I don't expect of everyone. dunno if y'all are new here or new names to old faces, but...

Let's pretend you're new names and new faces. In which case, congratulations on your meteoric rise. I, for one, was scared to death the first time I saw that karmawhores thing because holy shit, now there's a target on my back. I'm sure you both saw Saydrah going down in flames for assembling a flock of benign gadflies into a deadly swarm of locusts. I'm sure you've seen the whiplash love/hate relationship Reddit had with P-dub or mercurialmadnessman. As for me, shit has gotten very real in the past and every time squidgy back-channel bullshit like this gets started I worry we're on the verge of more Reddit Drama. I'm not sure if either of you have figured it out yet or not, but having a "name" on Reddit is much, much worse than being anonymous. Once the mob knows you, they know you are not the mob... and they yearn to tear you to shreds.

I'm not entirely sure why you chose to write to me and flossdaily, Azured. I'm alternately flattered and horrified. I play this game rather poorly, probably because I don't care too much about it. I'll admit - I checked earlier today because of this email and I think you were what, 800 points behind me? And now you're something like 3000 ahead? I didn't even see bechus on the board before and now he's ahead of me, too. If it's points you want, clearly points you will get. But you wrote to me, and you wrote to flossdaily, so clearly it isn't about points. So what's it about?

I have no idea who earlybird_ is. Could be (Redacted). Could be someone else. For all I know, both of you are (Redacted). If he really is getting that heated about stuff, that's a bummer... but these are the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune. If you're seriously concerned about it, take your concerns to jedberg. He's a calm, quiet, and concerned citizen and he has the Powers of April 1. I'll say this - the more seriously you take Reddit, the more seriously Reddit takes you - and that's never a good thing.

Here's my take - despite appearances to the contrary, the 280,000 odd subscribers and the 4,000,000-odd uniques every month aren't really what makes Reddit shine, it's the 1,000-odd devotees who spend their time making this site a better place. And I think we have a lot more in common with each other than we have in difference (even if we don't know the value of decent fantasy - check out George RR Martin's Song of Ice and Fire, my hygenically-minded friend, and get back to me). So whenever we choose to tear each other down, rather than build each other up, it saddens me. I think you wrote to us because you consider us to be Names Who Matter. And I think the Names Who Matter are independent of karma.

When I bailed, I got over 100 PMs from people telling me not to go. People I'd never heard from. I still get an occasional email saying "you changed my life" from a rant I had against Diet Coke 9 months ago. And then the 40 minutes you spend editing a speech goes and shaves 8 years off of someone's prison sentence. That's the shit that matters. and bechus (or jcm267, or wartexmaul, or herkimer, or any of the other trolls who chase me around) can say whatever the fuck they want, because in the end, it's the real shit that matters. And people remember the real shit.

This is fake shit. Don't get bound up in it. Remember the Names That Matter and notice that no matter what anyone says about them, they keep truckin' along regardless of score. I appreciate the heads-up, but I'd really rather everybody just breathe deep and let it go.

-(me, my name, my real life name, which I intend to keep private, much like I hoped all this bullshit would)

30
kleinbl00•
21
embretr•

Best Band Name. Ever.

13
sumzup•

my real life name, which I intend to keep private

But I want to watch your upcoming movie! (iirc)

1
flossdailyOP•

What are you, 12?

How would you feel if you gave up 8 hours of your time to help someone who was simultaneously badmouthing you?

-8
kleinbl00•

Been there, done that, got the receipt.

Dude, I've helped out people who have badmouthed me for months. I've gotten them jobs.

It's called "forgiveness."

18
[deleted]•

[deleted]

10
phrakture•

Why the fuck is this a big deal? Who the fuck cares? It's just karma. God damnit, go the fuck outside for once

29
desk_rabbit•

Who the fuck cares?

Flossdaily does, obviously.

It's just karma.

Sure, but it's all "just" something. Nothing matters on any appreciable scale. He cares about this. I bet there are plenty of things you care about that the vast majority of reddit would find little to no interest in.

11
flossdailyOP•

If you bothered to read my post instead of jumping to conclusions, you would see that my grievance has nothing whatsoever to do with karma.

-10
phrakture•

Karma, drama, whatever. This is god damned internet drama. e-Drama. Seriously.

21
alphabeat•

That's what karmanaut said you would say phrakture.

1
[deleted]•

Can we see Azured's detective work to verify this ourselves? I'm all for a well deserved Reddit E-Lynching if it's true, but in the spirit of community trust, we should get to see the evidence here.

25
flossdailyOP•

Here's the meat of Azured's email to me with all but the essential facts stripped away. I want to say again that he only did this research because he wanted to find out who earlyworm_ was, and why earlyworm_ was trolling him. I got an email to that effect a couple days ago... then I got this followup:

Azure did some clever work to find out that bechus was karmanaut's alter. Both accounts announced they were leaving for Italy on the exact same day. Additionally both accounts were making posts exposing that they were highly knowledgeable about the law. (Roy is in law school). Azure provided links to all this, but I'm only going to repost the bit where bechus confirmed that he was karmanaut's alter. ...and where karmanaut's account confirmed it here.

Karmanaut used his bechus account to badmouth his competition (bozarking and kleinbl00) in the 2009 comment of the year thread.

This is earlyworms_ deleted post badmouthing Azured. Here's [another](http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:iE2MFLmVWCMJ:www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/ccwxb/everyone_in_my_office_thinks_im_a_moron_for/+earlyworm_+site:reddit.com&cd=6&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=][Screen%20cap. And this thread- the fallout of which is the reason I stopped posting stories for the most part several months ago.

So what made Azured think that earlyworm_ was the same person as karmanaut/bechus? Well, karmanaut didn't cover his tracks very well. earlyworm_, a seldom used account which didn't do much around reddit except to badmouth people did find one redditor that he liked enough to submit to r/bestof on a couple occasions. Guess who?:

Here's the first.Google cache.Screenshot.Reddit link.
Here's the second. Google cache.Screenshot.Reddit link.

It should be noted that before earlyworm_ deleted his account, he deleted several of his more vicious anti-Azured postings... AND he deleted these bestof posts.

Azured's curiosity about the deleted bestof posts led to this damning find.

I can think of no reason to delete old bestof posts except to hide the link between earlyworm_ and bechus/karmanaut.


Detective credit goes 100% to Azured. I didn't know about any of this until he diligently worked it all out.

Once again, I want to reiterate that he has nothing to do with making it public, that's on my head.

36
DissentingOpinion•

Wait, where is the evidence that karmanaut/bechus is earlyworms_? All I see two links that earlyworms_ submitted to bestof. Even if I assume that they are links to posts by karmanaut, it seems like earlyworms_ is the one karma-whoring with nothing linking that account to karmanaut. All earlyworms_ has to do is:

  1. see a post by karmanaut,
  2. assume that it is good,
  3. post it to bestof, and
  4. reap the karma.

That doesn't link their accounts.

And no, I'm not karmanaut.

35
flossdailyOP•

All I see two links that earlyworms_ submitted to bestof.

Before earlyworm_ deleted his entire account, he separately deleted those two bestof posts. It was suspicious enough that Azured found it worth the time to investigate them.

3
DissentingOpinion•

That isn't really proof of anything. It is circumstantial at best. You've convicted karmanaut in your mind and are only trying to gather evidence that supports your conviction. Why not save yourself some time, redact this post, and acknowledge that the accusations were pre-mature.

27
RedditorInExcelsis•

Azured is playing you like a fiddle.

20
fagga•

Before earlyworm_ deleted his entire account, he separately deleted those two bestof posts.

How can one see that? Is there a hidden log or something? Or did someone made screenshots of his user page every five seconds for hours and hours?

Just curious.

4
sandrc2002•

Do you know, 100%, that Azured is not the same person? His posts and methods are extremely similar to karmanaut's. And what does kleinbl00 have to do with it all?

10
Diggtionary•

Who's to say that what karmanaut is allegedly doing/has done is not actually just being done by you/azured here? Who's to say I'm not karmanaut?

But really, it's easy enough to make an account bad mouth yourself, promote your competition and then turn around and destroy him with said account.

8
Diggtionary•

I really hope it's true though, I love reddit drama.

2
flossdailyOP•

Agreed. Azured could be a strategic mastermind who planned this whole thing out 5 months in advance.

I think the simpler explanation is that karmanaut has kept this alter around to badmouth his competition and upvote his own submissions. He picked on the wrong guy, and that guy tracked him down.

-8
Diggtionary•

simpler does not equal proof. Hell this could all be a fucking conspiracy by karmanaut himself to get karma. I can see it now on the front page of reddit, karmanaut defending himself in some giant fucking post just soaking up the karma with long well thought out responses.

edit: spelling

7
karmanaut•

Just as simple/Simpler: Azured tried to do what he does now, when you were popular. I don't believe someone gets 90,000 comment karma with their first account, only lurking for a week. Reddit takes adjustment to find subreddits and get the lay of the land.

So, he wasn't getting noticed, and you were. He sabotaged you, you recede to your subreddit and basically stop posting in public, and he starts over as the only brand new star.

6
steve93•

You stopped posting your stories because of a thread? That saddens me, I check your comments every day looking for another story and it sucks to find that's the reason there are less of them than there would be, I always just assumed you grew tired of writing them and were focusing on life. Bummer

-1
onlyaud•

I was hoping that your slow decline in posting was because of your wonderful personal life, not because some jerk made you feel badly. Knowing that you have brought joy to so many with your stories, hopefully, outweighs the actions of a self-important no-life internet attention whore. I am sad to see less of your awesome wit around reddit.

20
Grandpajoe•

I was hoping it was because Floss was writing more sterile :(

8
karmanaut•

As much as I hate being drawn into Reddit drama (I have even changed accounts recently because people were bothering me so much under karmanaut), I feel the need to explain how ridiculous this is.

I am not earlyworm. Despite the plethora of evidence that he submitted my comments to best of twice... that means nothing. Who is he? I don't know. I have never really noticed him, except for when he made flossdaily's hate thread. The one that I supposedly made to bring down flossdaily under an anonymous name? Oh, I guess the fact that I was in the thread, under my own name doesn't matter; I still needed a throwaway account. In fact, I flat-out told flossdaily what I thought of him. And it's still true. I feel like I was polite and trying to point out that commenting just to sell a book is close to spamming (yes, I know flossdaily linked this to his own subreddit, so I'm sure I will be downvoted for that, if not everything else).

As for who earlyworm is, I don't know.

  • Someone I know from reddit under an alternate account? Maybe. I have thought of a few people it could be.

  • Azured himself? Who knows. He claims this is his first username and only lurked for a week, which I don't believe for a second. He also told me that he comments for the karma, not to enjoy it. I can back that up with screenshots, if I cared. As for why he would spread shit about himself, I don't know. Someone left me a comment once saying "you're not someone on Reddit until there is someone else hating you."

  • Some random guy that doesn't like flossdaily, and didn't really care about me either way. That is a possibility. as for why he submitted two things to bestof, i can only guess that he submitted one and it was successful, and went to check my userpage later and found another.

  • My best guess: some sycophant who I don't know, but just likes me. Yes, they're out there, despite the fact that most of my stalkers just hate me. Someone who would both best'of me, and also slander what they viewed as a competitor. Wouldn't be too different from the many others who devote their time on reddit to trolling and making it worse for others.

Otherwise, this is ridiculous. I don't go around sabotaging any other well-known user. I would consider many of the people around here to be friends, or at least acquaintances, with whom I can joke around and discuss topics. Turning reddit into a soap opera is just obnoxious and serves only to make it a worse place.

Flossdaily, I liked you a lot. I like your writing, which is why I asked you for your help and advice. But I am disappointed to see you acting like this because one of my stalkers decided he didn't like you. Also, I would appreciate you removing my name, as Reddit is about being anonymous. I will also refrain from posting yours.

17
flossdailyOP•

I don't go around sabotaging any other well-known user.

Well, we know that isn't 100% true. Among the other evidence that Azured found, we have your self-confirmed alter badmouthing the competition in the 2009 best comment thread.

The fact that earlyworm_ deleted himself only a few hours after Azured subtly hinted to karmanaut that he was on to earlyworm_'s real identity is also rather suspicious.

The fact that earlyworm_'s account did little more than shit on other redditors, but did have time to bestof your confirmed alter's submissions is also pretty damning.

As for removing your name. I posted your first name only, which is hardly identifying information. That being said, I'll be happy to change it to "Roy".

16
karmanaut•

Well, we know that isn't 100% true. Among the other evidence that Azured found, we have your self-confirmed alter badmouthing the competition in the 2009 best comment thread.

Yup. I used another account to express my opinion, precisely because it is a valid opinion that people would ignore if it came from karmanaut. I don't regret it at all. Also, if I was so intent on bad-mouthing you, why didn't I do it there?

The fact that earlyworm_ deleted himself only a few hours after Azured subtly hinted to karmanaut that he was on to earlyworm_'s real identity is also rather suspicious.

I assumed one of you said something to him?

The fact that earlyworm_'s account did little more than shit on other redditors, but did have time to bestof your confirmed alter's submissions is also pretty damning.

Yeah, I wondered about that too. Haven't really checked out everything he said because frankly, I don't care too much. Got much better stuff to think about at the moment, including an upcoming vacation. I'm thinking he had another account, and maybe forgot to switch? Or maybe he's the type of sycophant that I described, who presumably just lurked except to comment around me or bash someone else.

0
flossdailyOP•

I assumed one of you said something to him?

My interpretation was that Azured had something in passing to either Bechus or karmanaut about being on the case.... and that earlyworm_ deleted himself almost immediately thereafter.

11
Yserbius•

flossdaily, internet buddy, you are taking reddit way too seriously. Does karmanaut use alts? Did Saydrah spam for cash? Did the Illuminati cause 9/11? Do I care?

I think we all need to take a step back and look at ourselves. reddit is just a game. If there is something going on that seriously hampers my redditing, I will be upset about it. But until you said so, I had no idea who earlyworm_ was and bechus was just some random username. I happen to think that karmanaut is a pretty cool guy, based on his comments, and if he cheated for karma, or whatever, it really doesn't bother me and it shouldn't bother you.

ואהבת לרעיך כמוך

28
karmanaut•

Well, being karmanaut, I can tell you that the last conversation we had was the one he screenshotted for you, of me saying that his comments were being reported as spam. After that, he said that it was the same person who was harrassing you (flossdaily), to which I guessed "wolfhoodie?" (apparently incorrectly), to which he said yes. I then asked how he knew all this, seeing as he supposedly wasn't on reddit at this point, and he said that he had just read up on some of it after joining, along with the thread where p-dub asked for money.

I'd screenshot it, but I am on my work computer and can't save anything to it.

4
StressTest•

KN-I don't go around sabotaging any other well-known user.

FD-Well, we know that isn't 100% true. Among the other evidence we have your self-confirmed alter badmouthing the competition in the 2009 best comment thread.

KN-Yup. I used another account to express my opinion, precisely because it is a valid opinion that people would ignore if it came from karmanaut. I don't regret it at all.

You're claiming you wouldn't use an alt to bad mouth him, but when he shows that you've done it to others you admit it, and say you have no regrets. Why should we not expect you to do it other times as well?

1
[deleted]•

If earlyworm__ really is just a random troll, then he (or she) is experiencing lulz beyond his wildest dreams.

16
Kardlonoc•

Doesn't this belong in r/conspiracy?

14
TheMilitantMongoose•

Floss, do yourself a favor and just say "fuck it". Karmanaut built himself popularity by essentially posting so often that he eventually had some massively popular comments. It snowballed once he essentially turned himself into a meme. He is a joke, albeit a heavily upvoted one. He became e-popular due to knowing how to appease to the hivemind. I don't think anyone really respects him, other than those of us who are so socially awkward even being internet cool is admirable.

You, on the other hand, are popular because you bring something to the table. I love your writing and I think it's really cool to see a writer get their start, a writer who I believe I would still buy the books from once they are making bank and doing tours. Despite the fact he's pulled this crap on you, many of us still enjoy your writing. I've seen you do good things for people (catscatscats, although he appears to have disappeared) and I think you might have gone to my college (irrelevant really, but I like finding co-alumni... back to my point).

You've managed to draw attention to your creativity, despite his actions. Your work speaks for itself. He, on the other hand, succeeded in gaining attention for basically being an embodiment of all the pun threads and memes and apparently he couldn't even do so without using alts to boost him up. Don't sweat it man. He might have stifled you, but you are better than him. By making a big deal of it you are bringing yourself down to his level. Ignore the fucker. The internet is full of his type. It's an uphill battle you can't afford to ignore completely. Work hard and you'll be fine :)

13
desk_rabbit•

I don't think anyone really respects him

That's not fair at all. I'm kind of disgusted that this got upvoted. He's a very good moderator and he contributes to a community you obviously enjoy.

He's a person you ass, not just a username. Christ.

Edit: If you are operating under the assumption that flossdaily's accusations are correct, I can understand why you would think your comment was ok. But - and I say this as a big fan of flossdaily - that seems more than a little hasty in light of what little "evidence" we have.

8
alu1989•

you welcomed pride, now carry the burden.

11
puppetless•

Sounds like a book or movie quote. Can you give the reference?

1
alu1989•

yes, i does sound that way. albert lu

2
thevoiceless•

I feel stupid for not even knowing about this happening, but even so, you can add my name to the list of people that have got your back, floss.

10
qgyh2•

This doesn't sound like the Karmanaut we know and love.

@OP: Any proof?

10
flossdailyOP•

This doesn't sound like the Karmanaut we know and love.

Agreed. I was quite surprised.

@OP: Any proof?

here

Those are the breadcrumbs left behind. The most damning part was the cover up, though. Why would a guy who is on a vendetta against karma whores decide to best-of someone with 90k karma? And why would he then delete the 9-day-old bestof posts? And why after 5 months, would he delete his entire account out of the blue? And only hours after Azured hinted to karmanaut that he was digging int earlyworm_'s identity?

6
RedditorInExcelsis•

You are right. I myself was shocked by this revelation in the beginning and then I went on to make some regrettable comments about karmanaut's name and appearance. But karmanaut has been an active member of this community, posted his pictures, met redditors IRL and also has done a decent job as a mod. Azured, on the other hand, is coming across as shady, the more I think. What, exactly, is his goat in this? He is playing flossdaily and the rest of us like a fiddle.

1
Diggtionary•

yea ok karmanaut we got it. You've said the same thing throughout this entire post. "Oh karmanaut he's so good he could never do anything wrong."

0
RedditorInExcelsis•

Well, read all of my comments in this thread, I started out thinking that karmanaut is earlyworm_, and my thinking stemmed from me disliking his comments generally (not as douchebaggy or anything, just lame jokes), and I also made fun of his name and appearance in this thread. So now I am backtracking either because I feel guilty about that, or the more I look into it the more flimsy this Azured guy's evidence seems, the more naive and excitable flossdaily seems, and the more shady Azured seems, at least compared to karmanaut.

2
Diggtionary•

Alright, I doubt whether the story is true or not too. Azured could have easily faked all of this and then just sent his detective work to someone who felt wronged. But I don't want people thinking for a damn second that just because it's possible that karmanaut hasn't done this that he didn't do it.

4
kickme444•

As someone who has access to names, addresses, email addresses, etc. etc. of most all popular redditors, these threads are simply ridiculous.

I don't know who roy is, but it isnt these people.

9
WhiteMouse•

Firstly: creepy.

Secondly, karmanaut made flossdaily change the name from the original first name to "Roy".

5
NegatedVoid•

Everything aside... You're the greatest, Floss.

8
RedditorInExcelsis•

The comment's (now deleted) by earlyworm_ (also now deleted) were designed to curb Azured's popularity and success on reddit

While my reddit-obsessiveness will lead me to take a look at more of earlyworm_'s comments here on the backtype archive to see the alleged incitement, I have already found something funny, him referring to himself (his alter-ego karmanaut) as a "prominent, well-liked Redditor".

EDIT: Some more detective-work has led me to believe that karmanaut was also karmaknotte (account now deleted, link to archive).

8
OverlordXenu•

In a twist of irony, karmanaut turns out to not be a group of people posting on one account, but one guy posting on many accounts.

35
jakefl04•

Booyah. I remember getting SO taken in by that post. I think it took me until I was 7/8ths done reading to realize.

1
Articuno•

There is some seriously fascinating alter-ego shit going on right there.

8
RedditorInExcelsis•

Yep, I've got some popcorn ready. This is fascinating.

6
chromolume7•

I have a good amount of friends, am very social, know a lot of people, etc. I don't like any of those people; in fact, I hate most of them.

A little creepy? (I admit to sometimes feeling the same way, tho).

Shit, I've got stuff to do today. I can't be getting sucked into this drama...but watching the fall of karmanaut...I can't keep my eyes away!

4