r/AsianBeautyβ€’
foir

[Discussion][Guide] AB Sunscreens: Comparison Masterlist and Resources

Discussion

#Sunscreen Comparison Spreadsheet

  • Disclaimer: I am not an expert. I also rage-quit this project more than a few times, meaning that mistakes have been made and the spreadsheet still needs work. If something is of interest to you, confirm independently. If you find mistakes or want to add any relevant info, please help me out and let me know!

  • Chemical, Combination, or Physical UV Filters may be obtuse categories (as linked below under general discussions), but I stuck with them anyways for ease of sorting.

  • You're not gonna get a 'physical' sunscreen with no white cast. It's just not gonna happen. Best you can get is no noticeable white cast. I will eventually go through and mark unnoticeable whitecasts with an asterisk, like so: Y*.

  • I do not mean to imply that any one ingredient is 'bad' or should be avoided.

  • You can sort any category by hovering over the preferred column for the arrow to appear, click the arrow, and then click Sort Sheet A-->Z.

  • Reviews and mentions were linked in the order I found them in.

  • Prices are very, very approximate, with shipping factored.

  • Request a sunscreen, Contribute Info, Report an Error Form - If you'd like to add a sunscreen not yet listed, add extra information to an existing entry, OR you've found an error you'd like to report, use this form!

Right, I think that's everything. So, dive right in to the AB Sunscreen Comparison Spreadsheet!


#Routine Megathread Tallies:

This was a quick and rough run-down where I tallied every mention of HG to see which got the most. Keep in mind I did not weigh RP or WNR in scoring but there were certainly users for whom one's HG was a WNR. I also didn't count non-AB HGs.

  • January 2017:

  • 9 HGs: Biore Aqua Rich Watery Essence

  • 6 HGs: Biore Perfect Face Milk

  • 4 HGs: Biore Watery Gel

  • 2 HGs: Missha All Around Safe Block Essence Sun SPF45, Canmake Mermaid Skin Gel UV, CosRX Soothing Aloe Sun Cream

  • 1 HG: Allie Extra UV Gel Mineral Moist Neo, Goodal Mild Protect Natural Filter, Holika Holika Dazzling Sunshine, Innisfree Perfect UV Triple Care, Mommy UV Gel, SkinAqua Sarafit UV Essence, TCFS Jean George Llong, Thank You Farmer Water Sun Cream, Mentholatum Sunplay Super Block

  • October 2016:

  • 10 HGs: Biore Aqua Rich Watery Essence

  • 5 HGs: Shiseido Senka Aging Care

  • 4 HGs: Biore Perfect Face Milk

  • 2 HGs: BiorΓ© UV Aqua Rich Watery Gel, Kose Suncut UV Protect Essence, Canmake Mermaid UV Gel, Menturm Sun Bears Super Strong Plus

  • 1 HG: Etude House Sunprise Mild Airy Finish, Kokutousei Morning All In One Gel, Mentholatum SUNPLAY Super Block, Skin Aqua UV Super moisture Gel , MISSHA Around Safe Block Essence Sun SPF 45, Hada Labo UV Creamy Gel , Holika Holika Dazzling Sunshine Waterproof Sun Cream, Goodal Mild Protect Natural Filter, SUNKILLER (Kiss Me) Sunkiller Perfect Strong , Sunkiller Perfect Strong Moisture SPF 50+ PA++++, Koh Gen Do Watery UV Gel SPF 50 PA++++ , Shiseido Senka Mineral Water UV Gel, Hada Labo UV Perfect Gel, Anessa Essence UV Sunscreen Booster


#Potentially Interesting Discussions

###General:

###Sunscreen Application:

###Physical:

###Matte:

###Waterproof:

###Ingredient Specific:

###Best Acne:

###Alcohol Free:

###Body:

###Misc.


Feel free to submit links for any of the above parts, discuss your HG sunscreens or any above discussions, or let me know any requests/corrections! Happy Valentine's, AB :)

Posted Feb 12, 2017, 11:22 AM UTC

59354
SleepySundayKittensN18|Acne|Oily/Dehydrated|UKβ€’

You. Are. Amazing! Everybody please all thank you for your wonderful contribution to this sub so you don't leave, ever!

Ok, I have had this question for a while and please correct me if I am wrong but I haven't seen this addressed clearly: I came across someone mentioning that layering some sunscreens can render one or the other filter less effective. Is this true? I wouldn't be bothered by this normally since I use one sunscreen at a time, but since a lot of makeup bb creams have sunscreen filters also, does that mean applying sunscreen then a bb cream with different sunscreen filter will render less sun protection...?

Edit: happy valentine's day to you too!

59
darkmilkmoonβ€’

Layering sunscreens can render the final mixture less effective if the sunscreens involved use chemical filters (specifically avobenzone and octinoxate) which can destabilize one another. This site explains the science pretty well.

Physical filters are always photostable. The problem is that most cosmetic products that aren't dedicated sunscreens usually contain chemical rather than physical filters. So if your primary sunscreen includes avobenzone, for example, and your bb cream octinoxate, the two will destabilize each other and render the SPF protection you're getting much less effective (I've gotten peeling and mild burns this way so I speak from experience, layering sunscreen is no joke!). Now I try to get around that by using a primary sunscreen with physical filters. That way, no matter what makeup gets layered over it, the photostability won't be comprised. Yes there is a white cast, but it gets covered over anyway, and I'm willing to put up with a little discoloration in exchange for stable sun protection.

4
juiceyjoyceβ€’

From what I've heard, layering anything on top of your sunscreen lowers its SPF even if it's another layer of sunscreen of lower SPF. It's like mixing two foundations with different shades together on your hand so you get a shade in between. If the amount of sunscreen in one is different (say SPF 50) from another product (say SPF 35) and you mix them together, you would get an spf in between those numbers, ya get me? Someone correct me if I'm wrong!

3
nightraindreamβ€’

I kinda get what you mean but if you're layering and the first one has set, say you wait 30 minutes would this still affect it?

2
juiceyjoyceβ€’

i believe so O: since it's recommended that you reapply sunscreen every 2 hours with full sun exposure anyways so the effectiveness of sunscreen diminishes with time

1
thebirdisdeadβ€’

I layer my sunscreens, though I hear this all the time too. The only sunscreen filter that is unstable enough to get rendered ineffective is avobenzone. You should not layer this ingredient because it is unstable and degrades when exposed to zinc or titanium dioxide. I don't think honestly there's any problem with layering sunscreen otherwise, just try to make sure your sunscreen has time to set a bit first if you can. And if you're going to put makeup on over your sunscreen anyways it definitely won't hurt that it has spf in it, unless it has ingredients that degrade your avobenzone. Note: spf isn't cumulative, so if you layer 2 spf 50s, you'll still only get spf 50, not spf 100.

3
SleepySundayKittensN18|Acne|Oily/Dehydrated|UKβ€’

Thank you, u/darkmilkmoon and u/foir for your clarification. I shall keep an eye out for avobenzone to be safe!

2
perplexedbananaβ€’

I know this post is old, but if you do go the layering route, make sure to research for any other ingredients that are prone to degradation. Also remember that these ingredients can have many synonyms.

1
foirOPβ€’

Hiya! Adding onto previous comments, SCA also has a handy UV Filters Chart that's worth a driveby, and there's also an in depth one in pt 2 of u/vanityrex's series.

Avobenzone is arguably the one to keep in mind. Uncoated zinc oxide and titanium dioxide will degrade avobenzone, yellow and black iron oxides degrade avobenzone, and octinoxate will degrade avobenzone. Other UV filters can instead stabilize avobenzone. From what I've read, most sunscreens do use coated zinc/titanium dioxide, butttttt I also don't know how one would 100% guarantee that claim.

2
temporary_wishesNC35|Pigmentation/Dullness|Normal|DEβ€’

Mods, please sticky this :0 you did great work u/foir!! May I suggest freezing the top line so that the labels are always visible, and perhaps adding sort filters?

13
GalyndeanNW15|Acne|Dry/Normal|USβ€’

You can also make a copy to your drive and finagle to your heart's content.

2
foirOPβ€’

Ah, smart ideas, thank you!! Top line labels are now frozen, I think I added sort filters but you can only access them when you're already inside the temporary filter view. Hmm, I'll have to futz around with it some more to see if that's something I can improve P:

2
PetiteMadeliefjeβ€’

Wow, this is seriously amazing!!! I'm glad you didn't actually rage quit but I can see why you wanted to. When you've had some time off I can submit the info/ingredients for the sunscreen I use. It's not a super common one but it may be helpful.

8
foirOPβ€’

Please do! πŸ’œ Common, uncommon, any submissions are all super appreciated! I'll add some more options to the form to make it easier for people to submit, some have had to cram a whole lot of info in the comments section because I just did not think that through, whoops.

2
corndogsareeasyβ€’

I am such an idiot- I just realized that you meant for us to add the info for the sunscreens under comments. I thought the form was to decide whether to grant us access to edit!

2
TheLittlestRed23β€’

Super well done! I'm glad you didn't rage quit, but I totally wouldn't have blamed you. Mods, can we get this in the sidebar?

8
RazzBerylliumβ€’

This is so great! Thank you!

Also, yesssss to this:

You're not gonna get a 'physical' sunscreen with no white cast. It's just not gonna happen. Best you can get is no noticeable white cast.

Maybe it's just because I'm old and distrust newfangled things - but a physical sunscreen with absolutely no white cast kind of worries me (like, is it real? How do I know it's working?!)

edit: u/foir -- Would it be possible to freeze the top row so we can see the column headers as we scroll down? I think only someone with edit access (you) can do that. I can't do it from my end.

7
boo82muchβ€’

This is amazing! I'm new to this sub, but loving how organized, knowledgeable and helpful everyone is.

5
theCuriousAmericanNC25|Pigmentation/Dullness|Dry|USβ€’

heck a lot of us are scientists like close to 200 active users

2
foirOPβ€’

Just to clarify, I'm not one of the scientists, I just try to blend in as much as I can :)

2
Verisadeβ€’

This is so awesome! Thank you so much for doing this!

4
Peter_789β€’

Thanks for the links, interesting post about the amount of sunscreen you need to apply. Does anyone know an AB sunscreen, that doesn't contain Alcohol, Fragrance or Octinoxate btw?

4
satisphoriaNC42|Acne/Pigmentation|Combo|UKβ€’

You absolutely rock for putting this together. Take my upvotes, get thee to the sidebar etc. Thank you!

4
petitoignonNC50|Pogmentation|Dehydrated/Normal|USβ€’

😱thank you so much for this awesome resource! I'm definitely adding it to my list of things I send to people when they first venture into AB!

3
lizziejo82β€’

Wow this is great. I'm trying to find a sunscreen that works for me right now so I will definitely be using this.

2
ayakokiyomizuβ€’

Damn, thank you for this amazing compilation. Finding a good sunscreen is my number one concern.

2
Deecodedβ€’

This is awesome! πŸ‘ Thank you!

2
sharmtoasterβ€’

I haven't read through everything yet but thank you for taking the time to do this! β€οΈπŸ’œπŸ’™πŸ’›πŸ’š

2
midfallsongAging|Dry/Sensitive|USβ€’

Thank you for this collection of resources!

2
dearhanβ€’

This is awesome. I will be reading this soon as I'm looking for a new spring sunscreen =]

2
MsMerriamNW13|Pores|Oily/Dehydrated|USβ€’

Thank you for taking the time! This will be useful to link back to for the hundreds of sunscreen questions that are about to flood in as the weather warms up.

2
[deleted]β€’

[deleted]

2
Irenita89β€’

This is truly amazing!! Thank you so much for your hard work!!!

2
Jeviaβ€’

Great write up and link organization, thanks!!

2