kleinbl00•

So... here's a question.

Am I a "Power User?"

'cuz I feel about as powerless as anybody else. When I submit or comment in a new subreddit, I'm held up the same as anybody else. Stuff I submit languishes like a turd in an unflushed toilet all.the time.

But I'm well into the 5-digits karma-wise. I've been around a while. I value this community. And I've gotten into terrible snits with any number of people.

Not only that, but if you look at my submission history on, say, a Wednesday morning, it looks kinda like Saydrah's. No conspiracy there; that means I'm done with my run, am drinking my coffee and going through my RSS reader looking at stuff. If it looks like stuff that others might like, I'll submit it.

Hell, I've got my own subreddit that looks for all the world like spam on a stick. It's not, believe me - I ended up following a bunch of bubble blogs and the stuff in them doesn't fit squarely in r/economics or r/business. If you look in there, it looks very much like I'm pushing traffic to calculatedrisk or irvinehousingblog. Which I am - I think people should read them.

So is the dividing line that I'm not getting paid? 'cuz I'm totally not. But then, I can't imagine Saydrah is getting paid much if she's getting paid at all. And why no torch'n'pitchfork reception for, say, IAmPerfectlyCalm?

The answer, I'm afraid, is that Saydrah annoys people. She comments a lot and gets on a lot of people's nerves. She's been the subject of witch hunts before. And I worry that that is the bottom line.

Anybody who depended on Reddit for their income would go out of their way not to piss off Reddit. Saydrah has her own hate-stalkers. And I don't think it's because of what she submits - it's because of what she says.

I'm not going to tell anybody to like Saydrah. But I would like to remind everybody that she's just a community college grad in her early '20s. This whole thing seems a little overblown.


EDIT: This comment was in the negative single-digits for most of yesterday and fostered little discussion. Overnight, a whole bunch of substantive arguments have come up and I would like to address them.

I agree with the argument that I'm not addressing the conflict-of-interest. It didn't seem important to me. It is clearly important to others, however, and their arguments are convincing and of merit. The problem with conflict-of-interest, however, is that it's very difficult to substantiate.

I think the biggest problem is the real or perceived betrayal of trust. It seems that Reddit thinks Saydrah misrepresented herself and used that misrepresentation for her own personal gain. I have no idea if that's true or not; more importantly, I don't think it really matters in the grand scheme. I think that Reddit is a site governed primarily by good intentions and that there are many users here who feel Saydrah is not observing that governance. I don't feel that this issue is one that can be addressed by the admins, or by the users, or by the general structure of Reddit in general; I think it's an issue that can only be addressed by Saydrah.

And with that, I'm afraid I have to step out for much of the day. This stuff is important to me but today, of all days, I appear to have a life.

266
SirOblivious•

I don't think its overblown, because I feel it ruins the democracy of reddit with a conflict of interest, she gets paid to submit and is a mod.

How is that fair to users

42
kleinbl00•

Well, that's the discussion, isn't it? I would argue that what you're doing is advancing the democracy of reddit. I would argue that me saying it's overblown advances the democracy of reddit. In a strict democracy, the majority rules - and I think today, the majority is on your side.

For the record, I'm not picking sides at all - I merely want to point out that Saydrah is probably getting more flack than her actions really merit because she does rub a lot of people the wrong way. And that, frankly, anyone who needed any potential paycheck would likely be careful not to do that.

51
Prysorra•

Is IAMPerfectlyCalm a moderator of anything? Because as long as he/she doesn't have moderator control, the powderkeg that is the setup of hierarchical power in any social dynamic doesn't apply.

18
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
kleinbl00•

I think the whole "disguising" thing is what blew it, really. Say what you will about The Oatmeal, Matthew has been pretty up front about the fact that a) his career is in SEO b) he started doodling comics to get out of it and c) he'd be an utter and total dumbass not to use his skills from column A on his desires in column B.

Nobody likes being manipulated for money. But at least if you're up front about it, people can't accuse you of duplicity. Perhaps the problem is that we tend to reward those who bring us their own works (so long as we like them) but those who farm out their "buzz-building" skills leave us cold.

I dunno. I think Saydrah tends to draw down a lot of hate and she makes little effort to dissipate it. This sort of thing is pretty predictable when you account for that; all anybody needed was a righteous excuse.

14
[deleted]•

I merely want to point out that Saydrah is probably getting more flack than her actions really merit because she does rub a lot of people the wrong way.

I agree 100%. But that doesn't negate the concerns.

anyone who needed any potential paycheck would likely be careful not to do that.

I've seen this happen dozens and dozens of times IRL... people who need paychecks not being careful... smart people... I'm not sure why online would be any different.

3
kleinbl00•

You are twice right. For all my pissing and moaning, I am, at heart, an idealist.

5
randomb0y•

Other than banning other submissions there's not much a mod can do to promote their own stuff. If your submission gets banned for no good reason there's plenty you can do about it, like complaining to the other mods or reddit admins.

10
infinitysnake•

Being a mod comes with at least a little implied trust, though.

4
MisterNetHead•

How does it ruin the democracy? You've spread the word well enough now, and people can make an informed choice about whether to downvote or upvote her submissions.

5
krugerlive•

It's fair because Saydrah has been a positive member of reddit for some time. I've known that she's been getting paid for some posts for some time. She made that known a while ago, I think sometime last year. It makes sense that it's her job given how much she's on reddit. Hell, it might as well be my job too considering how much time i put in here. She found a job she clearly enjoys and if she didn't provide value to reddit, she wouldn't be this well known of a member of the community. Here on reddit, we're going to have people from all types of employment. It's perfectly natural for this to happen. Getting all up in arms about this is pointless and silly.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
apotheon•

power users ruin the democracy

Nah. Democracies ruin themselves.

3
The_Cake_Is_A_Lie•

There should be more tools to highlight 'rogue'/'cancerous' posters. Reddit needs an immune system!

1
Sunny_McJoyride•

You're saying democracies don't have conflicts of interest, but aren't conflicts of interest exactly what political democracies are attempting to deal with.

1
squidboots•

I posted this over here, but I may as well post it here too:

You sidestep one huge issue: conflict of interest. I am definitely not crazy about all the Saydrah hate around here lately (no one deserves to be called those nasty things, regardless of what they have done), but all of this coming to a head has brought up this issue and it needs to be addressed.

I accept that some moderators are prolific submitters. However, I draw the line when a moderator submits content for profit, especially when the person is as "high profile" as qgyh2, Saydrah, even you. People like that have people who love them and people who hate them, and like it or not, this does affect voting.

This problem of being high-profile, a moderator, and submitting content for profit defeats two things that I believe for the most part work on reddit: the checks-and-balances between moderators & spammers, and voting on a submission based the merit of its content and not the reputation of the submitter. What really rubs me the wrong way about this whole ordeal is that Saydrah clearly violated both of those things, and even worse, she was not transparent about some of her motives for being on reddit and lied when confronted with hard evidence.

The solution IMO? She should relinquish all of her moderator privileges and carry on like nothing happened. She has a right to be here, no matter what transgressed. She has a right to submit content for profit (many people here do). She has a right to be hated and a right to be loved. However, she currently oversteps herself by being in a position where she can bypass the filters and suppress the submissions of others when she has a vested financial interest for doing so.

That's my two cents on the whole thing.

39
tuutruk•
  1. The ability to bypass filters, such as the filter which limits submissions in a certain time, is available to everyone if the community accepts that person (by karma, for example). Her modship does not change that.

  2. All moderators of a subreddit can see what she is doing. Mod tools: http://i.imgur.com/IVqI5.png (The mailbox is communal. A complaint about something is a complaint all mods will receive)

http://i.imgur.com/e5oTK.jpg spam page. "Banned" is the spam filter. "Banned by X" is a human created ban.

You cannot say she suppressed any links of others in order for her own links to gain attention. It's not right for you to say that without proof.

15
squidboots•

To address your points:

  1. Fair point, but it doesn't change the fact that she pushed through a lot of submissions in a short period of time that she had no motive to submit other than personal profit. This is spamming. As I understand it (and I could be wrong), the spam filters can catch this kind of behavior and block these entries from appearing on "New". As a moderator, it is within her ability to un-block these submissions and have them appear on "New".

  2. This is good to know, and I hope that moderators are more vigilant at watching one another.

I think you are misconstruing what I am saying. I am not accusing her of doing these things or having done them in the past, but I am pointing out that, as a conflict of interest, this is a situation that should not be allowed to exist.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
kleinbl00•

You're right - I didn't address the issue of conflict of interest. It's not because I don't think it's important or because I don't think you have a point, it's because I simply didn't think of it.

A confession: I barely understand the internet. I can't code. I can't write HTML. Dreamweaver baffles me. If computers ran on vacuum tubes I'd probably understand them better. In a nutshell, the future doesn't belong to me.

It follows, then, that I don't really understand spam and hadn't really considered the issues you raise. I think you raise valid concerns and you raise it in a clear and unequivocal fashion.

If you put it to me that way, I'd step down from moderating with nary a qualm. I have no idea what she's doing or how, or more importantly, if. But the hypothesis of impropriety can't be easily disproven; the quickest, fastest way to unruffle feathers, I think, would be to abandon moderation.

Thanks for pointing out the "over there," too. There's some substantive discussion to have.

8
BrickSalad•

You know? You make a lot of posts that cause me to think or reconsider, like this one. I guess I didn't understand what the whole hullabaloo was about, people here tend to overreact to just about anything, but his evidence seemed pretty damning at least. Anyways, a dividing line is that she's getting paid. I can see why that's upsetting: we don't want profit motives degrading this community to the same commercial drivel that has infested the majority of the internet. The reaction has been a bit ridiculous, I can't understand why people hate saydrah, and I think that's because users have unreal expectations of how pure this place is

18
Sunny_McJoyride•

Several of the moderators of r/programming are also getting paid.

13
cocoon56•

For what, specifically?

5
kafene•

Probably programming.

14
Sunny_McJoyride•

For running reddit.

1
Poromenos•

What the hell? Why didn't anybody tell me you can get paid to reddit?!

4
Sunny_McJoyride•

Anyone who reddits at work is getting paid to reddit.

8
big_cheese•

Nihilo sanctum estne?

2
metamorphosis•

The answer, I'm afraid, is that Saydrah annoys people. She comments a lot and gets on a lot of people's nerves. She's been the subject of witch hunts before. And I worry that that is the bottom line.

This is spot on. I have no idea (I don't read usernames) what Saydrah posts or who she was/is for that matter, but I can see how she pissed off some people when she posted this and hence started all this internet drama. The irony is I upvoted her comment (at that time it was well above 150 and among top ones) as it had its merits. However, people who knew who she was and what she was doing behind closed doors got pissed off... and rightfully so. Not only that but I also felt somehow betrayed as someone who upovoted her comment for what it is.

In all honesty I don't know how she had balls to make such a post...and only through that post I can see how she annoys people on other maybe unrelated subjects. Plus, she went to /r/TwoXChromosomes to get sympathy from girls over there...again ballsy move..that willl only annoy people more. EDIT: In other words she got herslef into this mess...her comments about oaksmeal SEO past/activites with tone of criticism..are downright shameful. I mean how the fuck she can say something like this (without pissing people off):

I think it's important to note that Reddit is a site that explicitly invites self-promotion when it's conducted in an appropriate manner

It reminds me of my ex and her double standards when she was giving me a lectures about our relationship...tctct..

11
[deleted]•

Thank you. This has probably been said, but you can put things that I or other people are thinking in a much more intelligent and eloquent way.

10
Little_Kitty•

I see your name quite a lot, probably as I visit many of the same subreddits, but I don't have a strong opinion about you, and wouldn't be more likely to read your comment or up/down vote you. The comment yesterday about architects was a good read though.

I've had people say that they like my posts before and recognise my name, that always surprises me (in a good way), but I have no desire to become a 'power user' as the only thing I see down that road is drama.

9
Shaper_pmp•

You have a point, but I think you're missing a lot of the issue. I tried to sum it up for raldi here, but the quick version is:

  • She is a spammer, as she frequently spams the new queue. The only difference is that she's paid to spam lots of different sites, rather than just one, which necessarily makes it harder to spot.
  • She is a viral marketer, as her job is to post links to stories for pay by third parties. (This has been established beyond a shadow of a doubt by her own words on-line and in interviews, and by her own CV.)
  • Although reddit sensible lacks any kind of "power user" infrastructure, by being careful to hide her profession and cultivate her reputation on the site she's managed to create a fair approximation of a voting clique by having a large group of friends and fans who downvote anyone who questions her legitimacy, spammer-hood or motivations for posting, and who often upvote her links... and she quite intentionally uses this position and reputation to push paid-for submissions to the front page of reddit.

I agree that some small part of the vitriol is likely caused by people who already didn't like Saydrah due to earlier interpersonal conflicts, but I think the overwhelming majority of it is because we just found out one of the most active mods on reddit is paid to submit links, and by her own admission uses her reputation and position on reddit to push stories to the homepage which wouldn't otherwise get much attention.

It's not about "sexism", or "people who already hated her", or any of the other flack she's thrown up in an attempt to obscure the issue - it's a naked expression of anger at the violated trust of the community she duped for years.

Reddit doesn't have power-users the way (say) Digg has them, but she's still a well-respected member of the community, she still has a lot of power and sway in the community, and she's still quite intentionally abusing that position for professional gain.

And although I never had a problem with her before today, I'm not the only one who finds that digsusting, abhorrent and utterly lacking in integrity.

TL;DR: She's a moderator who spams herself and conceals her profession, convicted as such by her own words - she admits her job is to submit stories to redit and use her position in the community to get them voted up.

This is legitimately abhorrent to the reddit community, so while witch-hunts are dangerous and I agree we need to be careful not to jump to conclusions, writing it all off as "sexism and sour grapes" seems to be very ill-informed position to take. <:-)

8
kleinbl00•

You're right. I'm missing a lot of the issue. This is probably due to my newfound inability to consider moderation to be Serious Business™ but I can plainly see that others concisely, defensibly and convincingly disagree.

Based on your input, Squidboots' input, and the input of several others, my new, improved, more nuanced position is that Reddit relies heavily on trust. Further, arguing that Saydrah hasn't violated that trust would be difficult indeed. If I pissed this many people off, I'd be pretty concerned about unpissing them off and stepping down as moderator voluntarily would, I hope, go a long ways towards that.

11
Shaper_pmp•

Fair play. I've previously posted about the issue of trust in social networks like reddit here (raeg alert ;-), but I'm impressed with your reversal and nuanced position.

I'm not claiming she should be lynched or imprisoned or anything so extreme (I fought shy of advocating she even be banned in my reply to raldi), but think I we can both agree that she was disingenuous, misrepresented herself, has repeatedly, intentionally and diverted attention away from her (arguable) role as a paid shill in the past (I've even seen her ban people or scream "sexism!" when people accused her of being a shill), and roundly violated the trust of the reddit community for crass financial gain.

And I think that's why so many people are pissed at her. ;-)

-1
kleinbl00•

Fair play. I've previously posted about the issue of trust in social networks like reddit here (raeg alert ;-), but I'm impressed with your reversal and nuanced position.

I remember that statement. I upvoted it then and still agree with it - I added nothing to the discussion because you covered the issue quite succinctly. I created and moderate r/favors - if that's not a big ball'o'trust waiting to go wrong, I don't know what is. Your concerns are very much mine.

I think it comes down to this: Saydrah pissed off a lot of people. Legitimate grievances have been aired. The trust of the community requires Saydrah to soothe those people and address their grievances and the fact that she has not and is not is exacerbating the issue.

I don't follow Saydrah. She irritates me (and MMM's a friend; I couldn't see injecting myself into the last dustup being productive in the slightest). I've long known she's in SEO; she hasn't made much of a secret out of it. I would argue that Reddit's trust was fundamentally misplaced which is why this all seems overblown to me, but I can also see why it would sting like a sonofabitch once you figure it out.

I just edited my original comment to address your (and others') concerns. I believe you raise many valid issues that are quite worthy of discussion.

7
jh99•

thanks, this is my thinking exactly. quite frankly i find the shitstorm going on now much more embarassing / damaging to the reddit community than what one spammer with one account could ever have done.

7
[deleted]•

I think it's a culmination of a lot of bad sides of reddit at once, each one propagating another worse side.

first we have the fact that in some way, people feel used/betrayed that someone might not be their real friend. As if what goes on on the internet has to be 100% genuine. This of course leads into the general conspiracy/paranoid side of reddit, who claim that she abused her powers as a mod (which as all conpriracy's go, have no evidence and only endless insinuating questions). Then the fact that it is Saydrah herself already means that people are looking for an excuse to hate her, some from the MMM incident, some from r/Mensrights, and some just because they don't like her in general. This is where the "The only question I want to ask is when she will GTFO off reddit" come from.

It ends up being an overall witch-hunt and call for blood...and reddit as a community ends up looking pretty bad for it. It's comments like kleinbl00's that keep things moderately tolerable.

2
anarchman•

i don't care for this witch hunt, but I am curious, what is the MMM incident?

1
ropers•

I would have no problem upmodding a genuinely good Saydrah submission if its title started with "[AD]...". Do her submission titles read like that? No. Why? Probably because they wouldn't get much love from most people if they read like that. So she's pretending to be something she's not in order to be looked upon more kindly. It's not the fact that she gets paid; it's the dishonesty. It's the same thing as a fake "here's my daughter" or "here's something I/my friend made" submission. People don't like being taken for a ride.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
rocky_whoof•

So is the dividing line that I'm not getting paid?

yes. that is the definition of conflict of interests.

2
cynoclast•

Who the hell is Saydrah?

2
DaRam4U•

But I would like to remind everybody that she's just a community college grad in her early '20s.

And what is your problem with community college, huh? </troll>

2
deadaluspark•

actually, honestly, the community college thing explains a lot.

2
[deleted]•

All I've got to say is that if you turn out to be lying, I'm going to be real disappointed, 'cuz my friends list includes two people I don't know from outside of reddit, and one of those I can't remember precisely why I added.

1
kleinbl00•

All I've got to say is that if you turn out to be lying, I'm going to be real disappointed

Dude, you and me both. Money is way the fuck too tight right now; if I am spamming for anyone they're way the fuck late on my payoff checks!

2
[deleted]•

There is only one way to know for sure. Dunking Test!

1
MattKronik•

Does she weigh as much as a duck?

1
[deleted]•

Only one way to find out! Find out if she floats!

1
VulturE•

wanna go get tacos?

0
Gravity13•

I'm fucking disgusted about this whole thing. This proves to me that reddit is just a bunch of immature sexist twats these days.

-14
AnnArchist•

whoa whoa sexism has nothing to do with this issue. unless you think epic beard man proves reddit is racist.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
Gravity13•

Are you sure they haven't? Or is everytime somebody mentions anything slightly on Saydrah's side immensely downvoted?

6
sje46•

Saydrah is a feminist, and a somewhat vocal one at that. That is what I thought of when kleinb00 said that many people find her annoying.

4
kleinbl00•

To be honest, I do find her brand of "feminism" to be annoying. But I find many of Saydrah's brands to be annoying.

Diff'rent strokes for diff'rent folx and all that, though, you know. The fact that she treats 2X like her own personal Internet Army is the primary reason I don't visit there much; I think it's a valuable community that doesn't have to be Bizarro World r/MensRights but that seems to be where she wants to take it. However, I lack the necessary genetic makeup to have much of a say.

6
klarth•

But, but but but guys! She's doing this for the community! Won't someone please think of reddit's beautiful community? We're a band of close friends struggling against adversity, and we're making a difference in the world, and HURRF DURF BACON!!! NARWHALS! AHURR HURR 27 CUILS! I LIVE IN A BASEMENT

151
[deleted]•

Now the real question is : did the reddit team know about saydrah? If so, why didn't they tell us about this? That's their website and they do what they want, but we have to know the rules.

51
[deleted]•

From a business perspective, the more advertisers interacting with Reddit is better for them in the long run. Even if it's not a conventional banner ad, it still makes Reddit more relevant.

Or maybe it's a huge conspiracy and Reddit also gets a cut of her profits. Waa...Waa...Wooooooooow!

28
[deleted]•

It's a conspiracy, also designed to keep us indoors on Reddit. Welcome to the NHK.

13
[deleted]•

But it's easy : when a post is an add they just have to make us now! There's nothing wrong with that, just let us know.

2
[deleted]•

It's a real conundrum. I want to see the Reddit founders doing well, but I can't stand those 'sponsored stories' that Digg has. Just cheapens the place I reckon.

6
kleinbl00•

And it really is. If I had something worth selling, I'd totally spend $20. The problem is, if you're trying to get traffic to your site you're doing that dozens of times a day.

5
J-Red•

What I want to know is : How high does this really go? Was the president involved in any way? I think it's time for a national enquiry.

9
tctony•

What happened with saydrah? Mind filling me in?

6
[deleted]•
13
alphabeat•

Isn't the chain of events funny. This all happened because of the success of a web comic.

11
butteryhotcopporn•

Redditors stirred up a bunch of e-drama beause we're afraid our list of the freshest silly CAPTCHAS, silly cat pictures, hyperbolic political BSing and Facebook based "Pwnages" will be corrupted!

-4
alecb•

But.... screen captures have what Redditors crave!

7
alphabeat•

Saydrah's activities have been outed before, there was minor outrage, not so much as this. Then things went back to normal, ie HURRF BACONNED NARWHALS, USE YOUR FLASHBANG.

6
Rubin0•

What rules? Did she break rules?

3
[deleted]•

Well, when you post a koala picture only to direct a redditor to a website, that taking him/her for an idiot/a worker. And i'm sorry but i'm not coming to reddit, i'm not using my free time to work for anyone else. Of course, i guess there's not any written rules, but you have my opinion.

3
davega7•

i'm not using my free time to work for anyone else

Preface: I do not know Saydrah. I don't think I've ever at any time talked to her, although she did reply to something I posted a long time ago. I'm just someone who doesn't understand the moral outrage and vitriol being thrown out around here in the last couple of days.

That said......

If in your free time you say, play golf, or xbox, or go to the movies, etc., aren't you making someone money? What does it matter that it's her?

Ok, ok, so someone will probably say "I consciously spend money on those things, but I didn't know I was making Saydrah money, therefore didn't choose it on my own." Ok, fair point....but, you're not actually giving her any money of your own if you happen to click on one of her links, right? So I still don't see why this war has been started.

Like I said, I'm truly curious because I'm sure I've clicked on a zillion links of hers (not because it's her, just 'cause they looked interesting), and if I ask myself what harm it caused me, a regular user of Reddit, the answer is 'nothing'.

-1
[deleted]•

I doubt it. Check out the work they do in the Report the Spammers subreddit. They tend to hate people gaming their site.

2
alecb•

This is less about she then it is about the Reddit moderating system. This could have been anyone because the moderating system leaves too much open to exploitation. Yes, there are some really good mods (masta, krispykrackers, the whole WTF team) and consistent/honest mods (Pappenheimer/BritishEnglishPolice), but content decisions should be more open and transparent across the board.

29

http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/b7hpb/re_the_alleged_conflict_of_interest_on_reddit/

Here is a thread to allow more transparency into our actions. I and qgyh2 are currently responding.

29
buu700•

I guess I should link to this semi-recent thread here (at the risk of getting it blasted with a stream of anti-Saydrah rhetoric):

http://www.reddit.com/r/relationship_advice/comments/ayoke/there_has_been_some_concern_expressed_as_to_the/

1
[deleted]•

Ah yes krispycrackers, my former favorite mod till she started defending saydrah's actions.

13
themusicgod1•

This is less about the reddit moderation system than about the particular moderators on a particular subreddit, or at worst a few subreddits. This is internal politics to those subreddits. It doesn't affect, for example, /r/anarchism

6
TheEllimist•

Upvoted for plugging the excellent moderation system at r/anarchism.

1
stilesjp•

You forgot Soapier.

7
[deleted]•

I have my pitchfork at the ready. We attack at dawn.

107
4Chan_Ambassador•

You have my army!

77
[deleted]•

Send my regards to Supreme Commander Mootle at his fortress in Mootxico.

28
[deleted]•

You fool! You fell victim to one of the classic blunders! The most famous is never to get involved in a land war in Asia. Slightly less well known is to never go in against a Sicilian when death is on the line. And even more slightly well known is this: never let the dark eye know that you exist, unless you enjoy ceiling cat watching you masturbate!

22
antico•

Can I take this opportunity to kick you down a well shouting 'THIS! IS! REDDIT!'?

18
SmartAssX•

My friend you could that any time and i would praise you.

4
[deleted]•

You accidentally the do.

3
GeorgePB•

And my axe!

8
paro•

And my slacks!

9
DwarfGimli•

Whose axe?

3
Dr-No•

Thanks but I think I'll bring my own deodorant this time!

2
svullenballe•

And my racks!

8
ShawnGupta•

And my cock!

Yes, this is usually funnier if someone says "My sword", "My bow", and "My axe" beforehand.

-1
randomb0y•

Sweet, I'll bring the cross and the nails! Or should we just burn the witch instead?

5
GeorgePB•

I'm still trying to grasp the irony of a guy name Sir Oblivious figuring this out. Surely we must make him a Lord.

107
OsoGato•

Haha... and all this time I thought it was SirObvious. I can't read.

22
eridius•

You were, dare I say, oblivious?

19
Shaleblade•

YEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

8
prajo2•

Shouldn't we demote him because he failed to be oblivious?

7
ixid•

What would be the point? He wouldn't even notice.

34
[deleted]•

Man, this sort of thing really pisses me off!

I guess I'll just have to relax with a good cup of one of the many relaxing teas from www.tealand.com. or perhaps even take a trip to Six Flags, America's favorite amusement park. In fact, maybe we should all take a trip to Six Flags-they offer great group rates that would allow us all to enjoy extra perks and special savings!

82
[deleted]•

Man, paid shills like you piss me off so much! I just want to open an ice-cold Sam Adams® brand lager beer. It'll get you drunk!™

32
[deleted]•

Did you just mention The Shills? They're my favorite band, I can't reccomend them enough!

14
mitchandre•

I don't always drink beer, but when I do, I prefer Dos Equis.

5
dabears1020•

The funny thing is, I actually did click the Tealand link and did end up buying something from there just now.

10
[deleted]•

CHA-CHING!. That's a .00457 of a cent commission for me!

A.B.C. baby!- that's Always Be Closing, which you may know from the Academy Award nominated film, Glengarry Glen Ross, now available in the Special Edition.

2
admiralteal•

Wasn't she the one who lead a coup against the founder of IAmA (MMM, I think?) and created a huge stink a while ago?

edit: baconn was kind enough to actually link to one of the threads in question to clear up any misunderstandings.

Good god people, when someone asks a question that you can correct, that's how you do it. You don't just go "YOU'RE SO WRONG IT'S AWFUL." And yes, she and MMM were the two moderators-at-war in that whole scandal, it seems, and both did a bunch of horrifically stupid things to each other.

75
Little_Kitty•

Yes, MercurialMadnessMan

28
Measure76•

To be fair, MMM wasn't a very good moderator. Before the IAmA dethroning, MMM had been forcibly removed as a mod for r/atheism after going on record stating he didn't want to see the subreddit growing.

27
[deleted]•

MMM was actually the first one to accuse her of this, if I remember correctly. It's all in the r/AskMe subreddit.

19
qgyh2•

I think MMM was removed by the founder of that reddit. Saydrah didn't cause him to be removed.

8
BrickSalad•

I don't think she lead the riot against MMM, but rather a third person had taken offense to how he had acted during their spat (he made an empty threat to leak verified IAMAs' private info) and lead the riot.

3
romcabrera•

There are too many wrong statements on that sentence.

-8
dearsomething•

Exactly.

-7
dearsomething•

That could not possibly be more incorrect.

-17
admiralteal•

Care to clear up the names, or are you stating something worthlessly unqualified?

18
baconn•

Here is the thread on that one.

15
dearsomething•

Before I go into my explanation, I'll explain why you are the one making "worthlessly unqualified" statements, and mine is actually quite qualified.

  • I'm one the moderators in IAmA. Making me qualified to tell you how wrong you are. That's your first mistake.

  • All you need to do is go to IAmA, and see it was created by 32bites. Second incorrect statement.

  • Saydrah led no "coup". It was a group opinion based decision. 32bites enforced MMMs removal. Exemplified in one of the many "disaster-recovery" threads in IAmA. Another incorrect statement.

  • MMM was "double-dealing" so he could be restored as moderator in AskReddit (I believe). He was also of the opinion that since he was a moderator, he was effectively an equal with 32bites regarding IAmA. My opinion on that matter is 32bites gets the last say. It was his (absolutely brilliant) idea.

  • Throughout that point I was pretty neutral. Then MMM threw a fit and threatened to leak all sorts of private information about verified submissions. I was no longer neutral.

  • baconn's thread is a part of the story. Not the whole thing.

Get your shit straight before you launch into a tirade of stupid, sensationalistic nonsense against people you don't even know.

-17
[deleted]•

[deleted]

19
djepik•

Dude, you didn't give any details at first. That was the problem. Nobody is going to take the time and open your user page, find where you post often, open those subreddits, scan the moderator lists, find that you are a mod for IAmA, see that you were there when the original shit went down and then come to the conclusion that you know what you're talking about.

You could have just stated what went down in your first response instead of getting indignant.

Admiralteal said: "Care to clear up the names, or are you stating something worthlessly unqualified?" He wasn't even implying that you were worthlessly unqualified!

9
ccs29•

I have no stance in this petty debate other than being disgusted by the amateurish back-and-forth displayed here. I understand that it's not a democracy and only other moderators can kick you out and what not, but really reddit deserves higher quality moderators in such an interesting and popular subreddit.

Here's a tip: Don't respond. Don't get into these silly arguments. Maybe one post and a response; limit it to that. This back and forth and back and forth is so middle school. I know you can have opinions and what not, and you aren't an official representing reddit, but really, grow up. Because the reddit community looks up to moderators, like it or not.

1
BrickSalad•

Okay, on the second to last point, let me add in what I recall. MMM threw the fit because he had designed certain elements of the subreddit, and upon his removal, the moderators kept the content he designed. He felt this was theft of his work, especially since he wanted to use the elements he designed on his own subreddit. Of course, this was kind of silly because the elements he designed were crap like stars and shit, really easy to replicate. After his fit was ignored, he threatened to leak the private info, and was still ignored. Shocked that they didn't even do anything about such an admittedly horrible threat, he posted about it in some rant he made. Some dude picked up that he made this threat, freaked out, and lead a reddit-mob against him.

1
theycallmemorty•

Interesting.

I'm now ready to hear the other side of the story. Or to hear from the reddit admins.

45
Anthropoid1•

In case you didn't see it, Saydrah had this reply to the accusations. Here's the million dollar question, to which Saydrah also responded.

tl;dr: Saydrah says that contrary to spamming, she spends most of her work time stopping spam on Reddit and other sites. Redditors wonder why a third party would pay her for that.

29
SisterStalin•

I'm reserving judgement...but it's pretty damning when she brags in a "resume" that she is an expert in driving traffic on websites like Reddit (mentioned explicitly), mentions cultivating a following in a way that purposely evokes the image of someone cynically herding people towards sites, and then also mentions that she is paid to drive traffic to sites (or seeks employment driving traffic to sites).

11
jevon•

So would things be fine if she wasn't a moderator?

5
fox_wesley•

I think so, because we could ban her like we do other spammers.

It's more the sense of 'being used' that I get from her page; her bragging on her linkedIn resume that she's 'built a large following on reddit', and claiming that her job is to 'drive traffic to AC'. She's been a respected member, and has personally given me advice, but knowing that at least part of that was simply to 'build her following on Reddit', makes me feel like a two bit whore after a gangbang. I feel like I've been fucked over and abused.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
superiority•

Saydrah's trying to be clever with her answer to the question. Part of her job is to drive traffic to the Associated Content website. Overt spamming of links (i.e. submitting every single new article to a dozen subreddits) would be ineffective, as such behaviour would probably be recognised as spamming. To perform her duties, she must make sure that this doesn't happen. She submits links to Associated Content articles in what she considers a "non-spam" fashion. Therefore she must "stop" spam to perform her duties.

8
Grantismo•

I'm sure it's an aspect of business that allows the site to run. Unfortunately, I fucking hate "professional" social-networkers, and hope they burn in an eternal hell fire as wide as 4chan is crazy.

23
retnemmoc•

Yeah they make me sick too. Making money using only the interwebz. While the rest of us have real jobs and have to get up at.....

WAIT?!?? You can make money simply using the internet!!?!!?!?

FUCK THIS SHIT!!!!
I am now Retnemmoc "Profesional Web Surfer"

fireworks

Do I have money yet?

13
frak_your_couch•

Agreed. I'm now over my visceral outrage and ready to move to either permanent outrage or acceptance depending on reddit or Saydrah's response to this.

2
sirfink•

I and my squire, Sir Downvote, shall join Sir Oblivious, fellow knight errant, on the battlefield in this most righteous cause!

41
YesImSardonic•

Why does your squire have the title "Sir?"

30
LaszloK•

Ah, good to see Sir Donic has joined the fray!

42
[deleted]•

♪♫ Sir Robin ran away... ♪♫

7
the_hound•

You and your sers can go and shove swords up your arseholes for all I care.

4
[deleted]•

FYI this is a reference to A song of Ice and Fire. I don't think he really wants you to shove swords up your arseholes.

2
[deleted]•

Too late!

3
[deleted]•
30
ani625•
26
[deleted]•

Wow, in that digg link she describes herself as a "power user on reddit". Power users were what we came here to get away from, but now I think about it they've existed here for quite some time.

:(

25
Shaper_pmp•

I can call myself Lord High Generalissimo of reddit if I want, but it doesn't mean anything.

The fact is that while Saydrah has a lot of pull with the community, and is moderator of several subreddits, reddit simply just doesn't have the kind of infrastructure that Digg has to support voting blocs - no easy friend- or group-shout-outs, no weighted voting, nothing. Moreover, reddit has a whole suite of systems to check for suspicious voting patterns, and disregard votes if they look suspicious (eg, voting down all comments on someone's user-page, always voting up submissions by one user and no others, etc).

Sure you can get a lot of people together off reddit and/or develop a lot of fans on reddit who will tend to upvote your posts, but that's a long way from being a "power user" in the way Digg has them... and it's arguably close to the unavoidable minimum level of background-conspiracy that any social site will be subject to.

More likely, when Saydrah was boasting about being able to get "anything" to the homepage she was either exaggerating, or hinting that she thought she had enough pull with the community to do so for some submissions. Nothing on reddit I've ever seen suggests anyone can get "anything" to the homepage, except the site-admins (who , IIRC, have magical "pinning" powers to stick a story to the top of the homepage).

TL;DR: Don't automatically believe everything you read, especially from a known fraud.

28
[deleted]•

Yeah, I guess I'm probably overreacting to her comment slightly. Everything you said is (to my knowledge) true and, simply by the nature of the site, reddit isn't as open to 'power user' type abuse as other places. It's just the fact that she advertised herself as a power user, as someone willing and able to game the system.

I always thought of reddit as the kind of site where nothing remotely like that kind 'social media expert' spamming happened. Naive I know, but I wanted to believe.

8
fuckingtroll•

WHO THE FUCK CARES ASSHOLE

-8
Sugarat•

That link has been deleted, no more comments allowed.

12
Grantismo•

Yes, the conspiracy is growing.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

29
Failcake•

I hated her before it was cool!

32
retnemmoc•

Were you also pretending to be a hipster before pretending to be a hipster was cool?

3
[deleted]•

Yeah so do I! You should make a shirt!

2
Failcake•

Hmm, good idea. I wonder where I can get a cheap, custom shirt.

2
belandil•

It seems that she should have her moderator privileges revoked.

28
thepensivepoet•

I think what's most damning is the fact that I met Saydrah on TotalFark.

26
RobotBuddha•

Ah totalfark. The only social website I've ever left because the mods were just too batshit insane to stand.

19
LawyersGunsAndMoney•

Do you play Cybernations?

4
RobotBuddha•

Farkistan was 'just' after my time. I left in the great eye blindness/shadowbanning fiasco.

4
LawyersGunsAndMoney•

Ahh. Well, it still sucks. There are so many forum rules that it is just safer to discuss things on IRC. Since forum-bans can eventually result in nation deletions.

3
thepensivepoet•

My account is still active and paid up but I haven't been bothered to go there in, shit, maybe 2 months or so now.

I met a few cool people through it, but it really is a boring circlejerk 24/7 these days. I hope they miss me.

2
SirOblivious•

She works for Associated Content http://www.associatedcontent.com/

These are the final nails in the coffin

Her Resume

http://i.imgur.com/qr7Go.png

Video Interview For her Job

http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/2168114

The video tells all details

23
MysteriousCraic•

Not that I care...but you missed blacking out her full name on her LinkedIn profile, next to specialties.

4
big_cheese•
4
colorblindzebra•

Why would you black out her name at all?

1
Grantismo•

Finally. I always thought that she was a boring obtuse whiner. You've got my ax.

19
DirtyHerring•

Can someone post some submissions by her that qualify as spam?

I'm all for burning spammers alive, but the evidence I've seen so far seems a little questionable.

17
romcabrera•
6
DirtyHerring•

Thank you, but that's not quite what I was asking for. I'm looking for links submitted by Saydrah, that are clearly spam. The ones in the first post to associatedcontent qualify only with proof that she actually works for that company. And the second link only contains links to links to discussions about links...

To participate in a manhunt I really need a little more than that.

26
Grantismo•

She is a self described "power-user" or reddit, interested in gaining revenue through self promotion and the promotion of others. Her links have content, albeit often old and reused. If you have no problems with submitting, for the sake of "power" in our community, then there won't be any information I can cite which would convince you that she's a spammer.

Anyone who submits more than 10 links a day, is highly suspicious in my opinion. The vast majority of casual users, have way more comment karma, than submission karma, as there's only so much new content an individual can uncover on their own. For that reason, I can respect a user like karmanaut, but find the behavior of Saydrah offensive.

4
Gravity13•

She is a self described "power-user" or reddit, interested in gaining revenue through self promotion and the promotion of others.

This isn't exactly something I'd go to war over... Hell, if I were jobless in an economy like this and willing to give away my online identity, I might also say the same thing (though I probably wouldn't act on it).

The beauty is that reddit regulates itself. Mods don't get privileges. If this were any other schmo submitting blog-spam we'd downvote it and move on, but no, this is a "poweruser" and reddit loves being the stereotypical "proletariat underdog" - which explains it's disdain for powerusers - so suddenly comments like, "Good, I've always hated that bitch, she has boring posts" are being upvoted. WTF, reddit - Saydrah almost always has sound advice and contents, she is one of r/AskReddit's most prolific answerer's and she rarely ever responds unless she knows she can give a good reply (at least from what I can see).

11
DirtyHerring•

interested in gaining revenue through self promotion and the promotion of others.

[citation needed]

And seriously, that would be good enough for me to join the cause.

The rest of what you describe sounds more like karma whoring. And most of what you say could describe qgyh2 in his legendary days.

4
jerrygofixit•

There was a TIL on the front page this morning all about it that got deleted, I'd like to know why.

17
zem•

the poster deleted it because some people started posting personally identifying info about saydrah on it and it made him uncomfortable

11
jerrygofixit•

When a post gets deleted if there are comments on it the post remains but the username is deleted. In this case it was deleted from the front page which means it would've had to have been done by an admin.

1
superiority•

No, when a post is deleted by the submitter, it is removed from the front page (and from search results, IIRC), and the only way to access it is by direct link or the submitter's user page.

7
jerrygofixit•

Is this something recently implemented, like say the past few months? I distinctly remember seeing posts on the front page with [deleted] users.

1
alphabeat•

I recall a website somewhere detailing the different kinds of ways things disappear and how to spot it. It could be deleted, it could be autobanned, it could be banned by a mod...I can't say for sure what would be the case here though. Maybe somebody can remember the page?

2
superiority•

I imagine you're thinking of violentacrez's unofficial reddit wiki, but that doesn't go into detail on what happens when a user deletes one of their own submissions.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
pavs•

All this started because the Oatmeal guy got called out as a spammer.

More WTF. Guy is a douche. I used to like (some of his) comic.

12
Little_Kitty•

He's very open about what he does though. You can find a link on theoatmeal site which goes to a description of him and what he does. He's also not submitting in the same way as Saydrah, and has never lead a personal campaign against someone in the way Saydrah did to MercurialMadnessMan.

23
[deleted]•

Plus he's able to create content.

21
garyp714•

And he's not a Mod!

11
Little_Kitty•

Very good point, I feel silly for not including it in my comment :(

5
alecb•

Wow, where did you get that image of Oatmeal fucking with a Reddit user and bragging about his social media muscle?

10
pavs•
8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
[deleted]•

Same thing here. It appears, it disappears. Don't know why.

3
11
SirOblivious•

I really hope you guys do something about it, as you can see the community is not happy about it.

10

Do something about what? The whole community suddenly decided to go on a witch hunt against Saydrah with unsubstantiated claims that she was abusing her power.

-5
SirOblivious•

She works in social media , paid to spam reddit and is a mod. She boasts about how she does it

Her Resume

http://i.imgur.com/qr7Go.png

Her Video Interview

http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/2168114

Also Please read this comment from her, so you can see the abusive tactics

http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/akcmm/hey_did_we_ever_get_our_questions_to_roger_ebert/c0i1zte?context=1

This is not a witch a hunt, I have no problem with her as a person or submitter. I do have a problem that she is a mod that opens potential for abuse.

10

How do I know this is Saydrah?

9
angryboy•

cool story bro

4
[deleted]•

Thank you so much Sir Oblivious! You liberated us from Saydrah. I remember times (well until yesterday) when we weren't allowed to tell things she wasn't ok with; times when the rage of Saydrah could have cost you one hundred downvote by his little court. Now that we're free, i think we have to identify every member of the Saydrah's court, every person associated with her spam/upvote - disagree with her/downvote terror. They have to publicly apologize.

That's humor, but i'm pretty sure some of us kinda feel that way.

10