Today I Learned That One Of Reddit's Most Active Moderators Is A Social Media Marketer/SEO Spammer
reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b72yd/reddit...Posted Feb 28, 2010, 5:19 AM UTC
Posted Feb 28, 2010, 5:19 AM UTC
Gets paid to submit to reddit? That's cool, but check this, I get paid to browse reddit.
Your caps are off? WHY?
He also get paid for that.
Upvoted for living up to the expectations pronounced by your username.
starts chainsaw...
[deleted]
Adorable.
...Didn't you hear about how he got a new keyboard?
Since this is the #1 comment currently showing up on this thread, I just want to ask that we don't turn this into a Saydrah crucifixion. I've been given the 4chan treatment on Reddit before and it's no fun. I put this up because I believe that the moderator system is unfair for both the users and moderators and lends itself to heavy editorializing and abuse of power. Moderators like Saydrah aren't the problem per se, but the system that allows cliques of power users granted moderator status to effectively control what shows up on Reddit.
BURN HER!
BUT WE CANT! NO ONE HAS SAID "SHE'S A WITCH!"
"SHE'S A WITCH!"
Sudo BURN HER
It's far too late for that.
If I had links to back her up I would try, but in her defense I would like to point out that at least half of the awesome stuff that has happened on reddit has had her hands in it. From getting that girl her hearing aid all the way on through to the redditjetbluetravelers. I've been there for both of those two and several other projects trying to help out but in no way as much as she did. Hopefully someone can present this argument better than I can because there's something to it.
[In a fiendishly evil way] "I'm afraid it's far to late for that, darling!"
This is completely untrue. There are far, far too few of us to be able to control what gets to the front page. There is no way 8 - 10 upvotes is going to make or break a submission, which is about how many moderators there are active at any given moment. There is no way to "push" a submission to the front page without lots of upvotes from legitimate redditors.
Take a look at the front page right now. Is it bombarded with posts from moderators? No. It's from random people who submitted articles that people found interesting and relative to their interests.
Moderators don't have much power- basically we can "ban" or "unban" posts, meaning that they will or will not get seen by the general public.
If a submission gets banned for some reason, it still acts like a regular submission in that the same link can nat be reposted.
We ban spam, and unban posts that get stuck in the filter. Occasionally, we ban spammers. That is all the power we possess. Also, we are in constant contact with the admins. They are aware of everything we do. We all talk to each other, even if we don't moderate the same subreddits. When issues come up, we deal with them.
It's actually a much more mundane job than everyone is making it out to be. We are glorified janitors, nothing more, and we don't kid ourselves that we are anything different.
I wish the truth were more exciting than that, but it's not. :)
Unfortunately, this type of thing has exploded a couple of times in the past, no matter how big this gets I think the admins will always side with Saydrah.
The limits of what's acceptable conduct are constantly pushed, but every time, they deem what Saydrah (and perhaps some others have done) as acceptable conduct.
In a way, Saydrah has discovered how to game the system while mostly staying in the system. I have almost no doubt at this point that despite some technicalities in how she words what he/she does and does not get paid for, Saydrah makes money for the work done at reddit and for teaching others how to work the system.
There is no way 8 - 10 upvotes is going to make or break a submission
One thing I've noticed about submissions is that most don't get anywhere unless you get really really lucky, or a friend upvotes you within a minute or two of the submission. If the submission gets a quick upvote, it's upvote per time posted shoots the submission up of the page.
As you can tell from my own link karma, I don't abuse the system. Most of this is from observation of other posts and tracking interesting posts and counting votes/time to see how far they go based on any initial burst.
For anything Saydrah really wanted to promote, it's quite easy under the current system to have a few SEO friends/followers upvote it two or three times instantly to shoot something to the front page of at least a subreddit, then let things take off if they will. This way it's not gaming the system "much" but at the same time leaves a significant advantage to those who've studied and understand the system.
Of course if the content isn't inherently interesting in some way shape or form (or doesn't have a creative "front page title", which I'm sure Saydrah has mastered by now) it won't go anywhere.
Yes, the submissions on the front page are not from Saydrah (or else things would look rather suspicious), that's why Saydrah has said repeatedly in those posts that he/she teaches others how to work within the system. There's no telling if at least some of the top posts are from "random" people who are taught by SEOs how to push a topic.
TL:DR A well timed 8-10 votes at the beginning of a submission can bump it to the top (or at least the first or second page) of a given subreddit where it where it can sink or fly.
Closing Comments: I can't say being a moderator gives Saydrah any special powers over us, but understanding the system and teaching others how to work it does.
I am a mod. I don't necessarily side with Saydrah.
I have always liked Saydrah, unaware of any of the allegations here. As somebody else said, she's seemed like a godmother of Reddit.
As both a mod and longtime Redditor, it bothers me for someone to be doing something that would be seen as disingenuous to the spirit of Reddit.
In a vacuum, if somebody asked me out of the blue, I would say that SEOs and viral marketers and people who present themselves as legitimate without being so, are the scum of the earth, as people feel towards spammers.
It is only the understanding that there are real people out there doing it that tempers that.
I don't think that Saydrah deserves the bashing she's getting here - but, if the things that are being alleged here are true, I would also feel that that isn't particularly acceptable conduct. At least, not being open about it. - (But, the real question is, is that the situation, or are people just jumping to conclusions?)
Anything that causes people to question the legitimacy of what other Redditors are doing is harmful to the spirit of Reddit. - If people start looking at genuine submitters and say, "I wonder if that person's working for somebody," then we're all a little less trusting.
And, of course, obviously, we need to be a little less trusting now. It's not just one single person. BUT, the problem can certainly be overexaggerated.
Most people are still legitimate, and most people aren't out to make a buck.
I know people feel mad about the situation. But I don't think a caring, sharing, long-time Redditor should just be kicked to the curb.
But I think there are a number of things that will hopefully be addressed as a result of what's going on today. In time, the anger will level out, and things will be better than they have been. But lost trust is a hard thing to get back, both for a person and for a community.
One thing I've noticed about submissions is that most don't get anywhere unless you get really really lucky, or a friend upvotes you within a minute or two of the submission. If the submission gets a quick upvote, it's upvote per time posted shoots the submission up of the page.
As you can tell from my own link karma, I don't abuse the system. Most of this is from observation of other posts and tracking interesting posts and counting votes/time to see how far they go based on any initial burst.
Honestly, all you really need to push a link to the front page is an interesting link and a sensationalist title. Check out my submission history , I've got quite a few in the bag (though you won't be able to see back further than 6 months or a year or something), and the thing all the highly-voted (>400) links have in common is the appealing title.
Good content doesn't need friends to help with a vote or two or ten. It will find its way there, if it's relevant to reddits interest, and posted to the correct subreddit.
We are glorified janitors, nothing more
Except you are more powerful than the average janitor and every other redditor.
Moderators don't have much power- basically we can "ban" or "unban" posts, meaning that they will or will not get seen by the general public.
That's not "much power"?
They are aware of everything we do.
What do you mean by this?
We all talk to each other, even if we don't moderate the same subreddits.
So does anyone who moderates a subreddit, even if it has 1 subscriber, get to take part in the "talks"?
batman comic effects time
Except you are more powerful than the average janitor and every other redditor.
*POW*
That's not "much power"?
*KERBLAM*
Well, not really. We can see what other moderators have banned, first of all, and if there's a problem, we bring it up with each other. There's a considerable amount of checks and balances that occurs. We can unban things that other mods have banned, although we try not to until it reaches some sort of census to do so. Usually it's like, "hey Pappenheimer, why'd you ban that link?". "it looked a little spammy to me, krispy, what do you think?" "meh, it looks ok to me, mind if I unban it?" "sure, no problem."
Pretty uninteresting, unless there's an underlying issue, we can bring it up to the other mods for more discussion.
We have a private boring subreddit that most all mods are invited to, where we discuss things and ask each other opinions. It's usually quite the snooze fest. The admins are invited, and are well aware of our discussions. Sometimes they interject opinions, but usually they have better things to do.
Except you are more powerful than the average janitor and every other redditor.
Probably less healthy, too.
OK, fair enough, but you are in constant contact with each other, not users. Posts get deleted and banned all the time, but only the the high profile ones get addressed (think the Fuck Sears post and fall-out). Regular users have no clue what gets banned and what doesn't, and for what reason. Everything might seem obvious to you as an insider, but it seems nefarious and opaque to anyone on the outside (aka most everyone on Reddit). There just seems to be zero transparency for moderators actions.
Like I've always told any user that has come to me: after you submit, give it a minute, and check the "new" queue in the subreddit you posted to. If it's not there, chances are it got stuck.
Did you notice the fancy new "message the moderators" button? We moderators fought hard for that. We were tired of everyone having to message us, one by one, until you found someone online and willing to help. Now you can message us all at once, and get your questions answered much more quickly, and get your post unbanned if that's what the problem is!
To be honest, we usually have no clue why some legit posts get banned and some don't. We just do our best to unban the non spam and get your post seen. It's not a big conspiracy, more of a faulty algorithm. I think.
You are extremely naive if you think that no mods use their position for personal financial gain.
Moderators don't just work with moderators. Spammers work with spam gangs who upvote things en mass. Companies like the bacon spammers have advertising budgets, hiring a hundred Philippinos to upvote their spam is pretty cheap.
[deleted]
...me link can nat be reposted.
can not be reposted, right?
Yep. Pardon my spelling errors, it's 5am here, I have terrible insomnia, and have been typing all this time in bed on my iPhone. It makes proofreadimg nearly impossible :)
Effectively control? That's laughable. If something is banned explicitly, there is usually a discussion to go behind it in a secret channel.
SECRET! HA I KNEW IT! I bet you guys are all like "he is not a pure Redditor, his grandfather was from Digg. BAN HIM" then all put own Owl heads and run round a fire chanting scripts.
chanting omens
...I've said too much.
Regardless of her background, or if she thinks she can exploit a community like reddit, she is still submits alot of quality articles and comments, and is involved in more community projects then anyone. She was a driving force behind The Jet Blue Trip, the Reddit Calendar, Redditgifts, and she has a fucking horse: http://static.redditgifts.com/images/uploaded/helper-thumbnail/saydrah/menembercloser.JPG
I'd like to say that I try to abuse my status as a moderator of r/Lovecraft by linking to that subreddit whenever possible. It has barely worked out.
For all of the people that go "lol, cthulhu" hardly anyone is a member of the subreddit of the author that created it.
if you didn't want this to be a saydrah crucifixion, you could have just posted your main points and examples and never brought them into this. you definitely will only get a saydrah crucifixion now, and your points will never see the light of day. so good work, you got the exact opposite of what you wanted.
if you didn't want this to be a saydrah crucifixion, you could have just posted your main points and examples and never brought them into this.
So, it's conglomerate?
Wake up sheeple!
I agree completely - but I'd be really surprised if this ended well...
[deleted]
Nice try, Saydrah.
[deleted]
echoed for truth
But this all just so fucking outrageous!
[deleted]
In all probability he means that he just browses reddit a lot at work.</jokeexplainer>
Which doesn't change the awesomeness of ALL_CAPS' job.
almost as good as getting paid for taking a dump.
I like to call that "consulting".
Dropping the kids off at the pool.
I can understand. Everyone should be paid to browse Reddit; it's so bloody painful with all its liberal, atheist, homosexual propaganda.
Don't forget Islamofascist and communist. Also misogynist and pro pedobear.
You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We call it "home" :)
The most downvoted comment I have it one where i explain what pedobear is and ask people to reconsider voting up references to it over and over.
Yeah those homos, always trying to shove their turgid agendas down your throat.
That's not my agenda...
Then WHY THE FUCK are you still hanging out here? Some sort of masochist? I so much want to believe you are legit, but I just can't. You have no place here. People just don't hang out around places they don't fit in, with people and opinions they cannot stand.
[deleted]
I can pretty much do the same thing. Do we work in the same IT dept?
[deleted]
[deleted]
You work for CNN?
Alright, just looking at some of saydrah's past submissions, there are some that could be seen as paid submissions. Here's just one example, which is an adorable picture of a koala bear:
http://www.reddit.com/r/aww/comments/b6xlf/koala_honkshuuuuu/
The website that this picture is hosted on is http://www.prelovac.com. If you go there it is a 'WEB 2.0, MARKETING, ANALYTICS, WORDPRESS SEO' blog. How exactly does one come across an adorable picture of a koala bear on this 'web marketing' site? I went back, way back, and I couldn't find it.
Then I came across this link, if it tells you anything: http://www.prelovac.com/vladimir/reddit-adventure
I'll leave it up to you to draw any conclusions. Investigating is fun :D
Edit: Okay, I just want to say that I finally came across the picture, all the way back on page 28. Remember, this is just one example. I'm sure if you really spent some time researching, you could still find more suspicious links. I mean, what is this 'timeidol.com' domain? Not one, but three consecutive submissions to this ad ridden site (linked directly to the images though, does that still help their SEO?).
Oh wow nice find! in fact some of her submissions to r/pics is not imgur hosted - either she is lazy or increasing the google juice of those sites.
I see your point, but if a pic is already somewhere, or you are willing to use your own hosting space, you shouldn't need to re-upload to imgur.
Well to play the devils advocate, it does mean that link won't die and the pic wont be taken down.
[deleted]
I went through this same thing about six months ago, but I have some advice for you. Just prune away the main reddits, stop subscribing to them altogether. Go hard, rip them all out, only subscribe to the reddits you actually like.
Then check in every so often on what everyone else is seeing by going to:
It is also worth cruising through r/bestof, r/tldr and r/newreddits. There are a few other good ones that are similar. but i don't think i'll be posting them here.
Point is, reddit's subscription feature means that you can make of it what you want. If you want to be subscribed to nothing but r/frugal and r/zen, then go for it, you can be that spartan monk, sitting with your empty bowl under the tree of knowledge.
The main reddits will devolve into spam and rubbish, and as each reddit grows it will become polluted and dilluted, but there will always be new reddits and small reddits growing up to replace them.
Those are excellent points. Thank you
The only way you could get reddit to be the way you want, would be to change / cull some of the users. The system is designed to have content the users want. Evidently we've attracted the type of people who like drama and bitching. I wonder how one could stop this phenominem happening. I'm sure some of the vintage comunity has moved to another site. Where did they go?
they probably ascended like starbuck or Daniel Jackson
The only way you could get reddit to be the way you want
...would be to unsubscribe from the popular reddits like r/reddit, r/wtf, r/politics, r/funny, etc, and only subscribe to the smaller, more specialized subreddits.
[deleted]
Ok but you're missing the SEO scam going on here. Sure we've attracted some whiny kids and whatnot, but we're constantly being influenced by armies of marketers with products to sell, who march in lockstep. In my experience, most people that frequent elsewhere still check certain sub-reddits from time to time. Reddit is still freaking huge, and has great links to lots of things.
But no, we're not telling.
I recently got a new computer, and as I went to reddit in my clean, cookie free, unlogged in account, I was so surprised at the kind of shit that is on the front page now a days. I've thought that the quality in my subreddits has decreased, but logging out, it seems like reddit is a cesspool now.
You create your own front page, you do realize? Remove the trash subs, you remove the trash. I find a lot of intellectual discussion in threads stemming from the front page. In my opinion, you're doing it wrong.
Let us quit together. You make a good point. I am done too now.
don't let the door hit you on your way out
Yeah, hypocrite much? She attacked this guy for not using imgur: http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b7yf2/by_request_dear_saydrah_love_rob_in_gallup/ and then BANNED HIM.
This is hardly surprising. Internet marketing is becoming a pretty mature business, and the marketers are becoming quite refined in their ability to game these sites without drawing suspicion.
I think many people have the mistaken impression that Reddit is the end-game. It's not. Let's take a walk...
I am the owner of a site, who wants to increase my SERP ranking for some search terms. In order to do that, I need to make my site authoritative, and in the world of google, that is heavily weighted on the number and quality links from other sites. Google and others have done a good job of detecting link farms, so people wanting to promote their own sites have a tough time going it along. Fortunately for them, there is reddit and digg.
I contact a marketer, who generally is or employs someone who has strong authority on digg, reddit, etc. They know the audience well, and recommend something to submit.
The content/picture/whatever is posted on the site to be promoted.
The marketer submits the link and their reputation & possibly army of illegitimate up-voters sends the link to the front page or at least high up.
Google certainly pays attention to the link being on the front page of digg & reddit, but that's not where the magic happens. Once a site is on the front page, and the linked content is cute/funny/infuriating, the marketer KNOWS that dozens, if not hundreds of other sites run by redditors will post a link to the site being promoted. Some of them are automatic copy-cats of reddit, some are people with sites that are all about cute pictures of cats.
Now, a swarm of new sites have links to the site being promoted. Repeat this a few times for the site, and now it is easier to target the key words.
I..., but, no... sigh. I have to go with Bill Hicks on this one. "If you're in marketing or advertising, kill yourself.
Oh that's a good one. The suicide market. Now that's a hot market... yeah, I loved the way he did that one.
"Ooh, the cry for sanity dollar, that's a huge dollar."
i just finished watching that like 10 fucking minutes ago. "revelations" fucking brillitant!!! not sure about the goat boy bits haha.
So all those cute Saydrah r/aww submissions were SEO?
:<
If true, no, not all. Part of being a mole is spending most of your time not looking like a mole so that when you need to be a mole you can do so without getting caught.
The Mole was a great show.
Yes it was.
Anderson Cooper's career has changed so much.
Dennis Rodman beat the shit out of the other celebrities in the celebrity edition. It was glorious.
Like the one on your inner left thigh?
I had that removed. It chafed with my testicles. Thanks for your interest.
Plausible deniability.
Mole-y Mole-y Mole-y... Mole...
Fuzzy baby animals are forever tarnished in my mind.
This is so fucking outrageous!
I know that we can't watch after every spammer, but here the spammer is a moderator. So i think nobody will care, but if saydrah stay moderator i'm going to leave reddit. And we should all do the same. I just hope the whole reddit team didn't know about that.
YEAH! I'll only be posting with my alt henceforth until this infiltrator is lynched!
Marketers are gaming reddit through r/pics. That get cheap pic karma and use it to launch front-page spam. Reddit needs to do some work on how karma from one subreddit applies to others wrt link sorting or this will become digg.
Reddit needs to do some work on how karma from one subreddit applies to others wrt link sorting or this will become digg.
Maybe it should be weighted against the number of subscribers in that subreddit (as of the submission/post)?
Oh Boy!
I am trying to write an article about social marketers on twitter. I couldnt find any proper material on those people.
Maybe you guys could help me out to understand this rare species. As far as I understand the only mechanisms they use to game the system on twitter is: - random friending people, - excessive friending, - hashtag spamming, - friend churn, - message spamming, - creating auto-accounts that follow back.
The goal is to gather as much genuine followers as possible, but what are they worth? And who pays those people? Does it only work with affiliate programms? How the heck do they make money with this? What is a typicall social media marketer or spammer?
There are plenty of Social Botnets with 10s of 1000s of accounts on Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube amongst other websites. There are scripts for tasks such as friending, following, subscribing, commenting and even limited chat functions. OCR scripts help the operators get around the captcha codes on new accounts and a little bit of know how into the user operations of the site helps mature the account of time and put it to work.
There are also botnets that compromise authentic accounts which they put to use in more subtle ways, most often just for the chat function or posting on a friend's wall at rare intervals, lest the account owner catch a wind of it.
These botnet operators work on a reference basis, so if you know someone who knows someone who knows them, you can get introduced to someone who can negotiate fees for what ever service you require. Some of these botnets have some quite prestigious but innocent clients who outsource their online campaigns to media agencies who in turn outsource it to shady characters.
Can you link to these agencies?
No, otherwise they would no longer exist and enjoy their indemnity through anonymity.
For a second I thought you were going to write an article on twitter.
haha
thanks for the follow-up article.
[deleted]
Vladimir Prelovac owns the SEO, so I presume he's based in Eastern Europe? Reminds me of the small start-ups there and in SE asia that write custom college papers. The hourly cost would be too prohibitive to be profitable here, but the exchange rate between our currency and theirs makes it worthwhile. Something like that might be at work here.
(Total speculation following) They might have a person(s) assembling material to post to sites like this (ex. the koala pic), and another person who posts the material (hence the unnatural rapid-fire posting by our spammer).
EDIT: the wording of the first sentence was taken wrong. Rephrased.
figures there would be an eastern european angle
Fucking racist
Projection much?
Prelovac is the owner of the SEO she's working for.
With the exchange rate of currency, this type of business is far more profitable based in eastern europe and SE asia than it would be here.
Met-Art. Who couldn't like eastern european girls? (and by extension the eastern european guys required to produce them).
Projection? You jump at a name to declare "figures it those eastern european criminals". You're just a step above "dey tooook arrr jaaabs". Most SEO SPAM comes from america but for some reason for you "it figures it EE".
Oh, lord. I've enjoyed her submissions and comments-- look at her comment history for Christ sake. She's not just shilling, she's participating and taking a little back.
I'm over it. Downvote stupid submissions, upvote good submissions.
Sherlock congratulations, you found out a site that has no commercial offers whatsoever, no ads, the author has numerous free wordpress plugins and is a book writer and has tens of photo galleries on the site from one of which a photo was submitted without his knowledge (and how in the world koala has anything to do with marketing). Yes and that's me.
Thanks for the reply, but I let reddit draw their own conclusions based on the information I presented.
I knew there was something up with this Saydrah person.
When I go through a couple of front pages of links, every other link is from her - sometimes pics. So many of them.
As a matter of fact, I played a little game of showing my disapproval at her stupid links for the past couple of days.
But if she is getting paid for links, she is hiding it well by flooding it with nonsense links(pics).
It's just too fast to submit at such a speed. Way too fast.
Looks like I know what I'm going to do, instead of 'hide'ing her stupid links.
But I must say she's masking her stay here, if she's doing that. Dude, she's a calendar girl! '
Anyone got a screenshot of her from the calendar?
edit 1 AM PST
defrost below says the higher the link karma the shorter the delay, but it's one thing to submit interesting links, it's another to flood the thing with pics. I have seen a few other high-karma accounts(could they be spammers?) but I guess they submitted mostly links to sites about news, indicating they probably read them(hopefully).
But if you read her submissions, you will notice that the headlines are forced - it's as though she's submitting content just to meet a daily deadline. Pretty strange.
I'm actually very unsettled... Calendar girl, multiple subreddit-moderator... I thought she was Reddit's Godmother. Well, she just maybe a do-gooder Godmother making money off somewhere. A fffffffuuuuuu by WTFalreadytaken below sums it up... http://i.imgur.com/xoXh8.png
edit 1.20 AM PST
Smoking gun? little bit down, redditisfun finds what could be a smoking gun: her submission http://www.reddit.com/r/aww/comments/b6xlf/koala_honkshuuuuu/ of a koala bear leads to a blog which is actually an SEO blog. Moreover, they owner of that blog even wrote a post http://www.prelovac.com/vladimir/reddit-adventure on how to push to the front page of reddit - '- there is a human editor (topic moderator) who is promoting the story they like to the front page'
edit 1.30 AM PST
Well the above submission is recent, but the blog post is 8 months old.
Saydrah works for Associated Content as some sort of social media consultant, and is paid to submit articles from their website. Her LinkedIn profile says that she is an expert at becoming an "authentic" member of social media communities (i.e. actively participates, rather than just submitting every link), so that her submissions will be more likely to be promoted.
What a sneaky bitch.
Also, how do I get that job?
Wow, totally off subject - isn't your account name based on a W40k figure?
most women are
This is really the best concise summary of the issue; it's too bad that it isn't rated higher.
She's not authentic until she does a couple in r/gonewild
Did you see her video? I wouldn't be upset if we didn't see those r/gonewild submissions.
just because her face is smushed? her tits look like they could be alright...
insult to injury...no shame
Do you have a link to her LinkedIn profile?
PM'd.
Thx!
Expert at becoming authentic.
Has Holden Caulfield weighed in on this ?
[deleted]
Well, let's suppose that her "brand" value drops to zero. As long as she didn't invest more than she made and the total return thus far was worth the total time investment thus far, it was still worthwhile, right? I mean, she could presumably just start another account with no links to the previous one and do the same thing again.
If you had a good time at the bar, does it matter?
I've been suspicious of Saydrah for a while. She first came to my notice one day when I followed her username back to her comment history and was impressed by her prestigious "trophy case". I wondered "wow", how does one "win" so many awards on Reddit since the whole 'trophy case thing' was only instituted 5 months ago?
I mean, there are a hell of a lot of people here on Reddit who have been around for a long time, who have never received so much as a simple 'nod' in their 'trophy case' for what they have contributed. Yet Saydrah's trophy case is overflowing with awards. I found myself wondering, who bestows these awards on commenters?
I began to feel there was something "iffy" about Saydrah's account. To learn now that Saydrah is a paid spammer is not what surprises me. What does surprise me is that this "model" redditor is a paid spammer and an elevated persona scoring a trophy case award every week. And this person is a moderator, which I surmise, helps one's trophy case immeasurably.
I'm not the bitter guy with an axe to grind. I could care less about the trophy cases and the karma ( true...then why am I talking?). But, I think it's a fair point to raise. If there's going to be a hierachy around here, and Reddit does insist on promoting such a hierachy with karma points and trophy cases, then it is only fair to wonder why someone who is a moderator is overburdened with trophies while redditors like 1smartass or nixonrichard have no trophies except the mandatory two/three year club. I could name many more Redditors deserving of a nod for their myriad contributions. I just picked these two esteemed Redditors at random from my friends list. I just feel there is favoritism and "insider trading' going on around here, and the exposing of the Saydrah account is the excuse I needed to mention this.
The great thing about Reddit is the community. There are a lot of brilliant people here that I care about and know, yet, they do not know I care about them and know of them. They are just usernames on a computer screen. Ideas are shared anonymously. We are "in it" because we care, because we are human beings and because we want to share. Handing Saydrah, who is well connected, trophy after trophy defeats the purpose of this website. Let us all vote on best comment and submission every week or disband the whole hierachy altogether.
Reddit is awesome because its readers decide what has merit and what does not. They vote with their arrows. I want to keep it this way.
the trophy case is algorithm-based; no one sits and decides to award them. she gets her trophies by having the top-voted link, or the aggregate top-voted set of links, or similarly for comments, or one of a few other metrics (go read the trophy list page) on any given day. she has so many of them because she posts a lot of links.
You're right, she's just awesome at spamming. I've read thousands of comments on this website that unfortunately do not conform to a few other metrics and go unnoticed because they fail on the algorithm.
It doesn't mean the current system is not wrong.
you're confusing the trophy system with the display algorithm, though. some excellent comments do go unnoticed because the thread display algorithm doesn't bubble them to the top (because, ultimately, they didn't get enough upvotes early enough to let the feedback loop kick in), but that's a separate problem. the trophies are meant for the user to feel good about his or herself; they only show up on your userpage.
[deleted]
thanks. if reddit ever institutes a "nice try" trophy (perhaps for the parent post of the most upvoted comment starting with the phrase "nice try") i'll be in the running for 20100228.
p.s. gave you an upvote to help my chances along.
Actually, he's right, follow his link. Most, if not nearly all awards are algorithm based.
... And it is her job to post links. And she loves her job! Yea!
right. i don't care much about her either way (other than r/happy she doesn't post much to the parts of reddit i feel involved in), and there's certainly a lack of aesthetic appeal to her job (SEO is intrinsically declasse), but she's done nothing wrong. just the opposite, in fact - the amount of karma she's amassed means that a large number of redditors feel that she contributes actively to the site, and appreciate her contributions. so what exactly is being complained about here, other than vague fud from people who are sure that because she gets paid to be involved in reddit she must be doing something wrong?
also, note that noname99 and qgyh2 have also gotten shit in the past for "spamming" reddit. this sort of witchhunting is nothing new, and it does not reflect creditably on the userbase.
I think her trophy case is a testament to the fact that when your job is Redditing, you can get much better at it than the average redditor. It's not her mod status or even her personal ingenuity, though the latter may help her as well.
I would LOVE to get paid to Reddit. Can you imagine? Where do I sign up?
Strange. I can't see her trophy case.
yup same here
is this some kind of joke post? those topics at the top are just about as important as the topics in the bottom left. it's all just mind-numbing entertainment, either section could be flipped and you could make the exact same post.
The point is that the 'community-driven, free speech, interesting, intelligent' links he's looking at turn out to be marketing ploys.
ah okay. that makes a lot more sense then.
If you're at all curious about the "way to fast" part there's an easy answer - reddit reduces the delay between submitting as your submisiion karma goes up.
Not just for Saydrah, but for anybody that has consistently submitted enough community approved content that's rated well.
The delay is there to stop "out of nowhere" accounts flooding the site - as an account is accepted (measured by link karma) the barriers fall.
Except the subreddits she moderates. Moderators do not have time limits on submissions to the subreddit they moderate.
Thanks for clearing it up, yet her rate is just so high, as though meeting a daily deadline. Also, given that she's offered to promote links in the past, we cannot rule out that she's slipped one link through now and then and profited off of it. Friends do tend to upvote peers' submissions more than they downvote right?
It takes me approximately 8 minutes, at this point, before I'm able to post a new submission. For one year's time, that's not a bad place to have reached. Sadly, however, it's about as random as the lottery. I simply (and re-)posted a link to a Louis CK clip on youtube and, BAM! That's responsible for the majority of my karma, single-handedly.
If I chose to take complete & full advantage of the opportunity to post every 8 minutes, every day-- my odds of another random "front page" submission would increase dramatically. The waiting time between submissions would decrease and, in theory, my odds would eventually have increased nearly exponentially.
Regardless of having no mod status or connections to "important" people, I'd still feel like quite a dirty whore. Here's a great example of what I'm talking about.
(Edit: Quotation marks seemed reasonable in my usage of the word 'important', above)
so you have no proof, but you won't rule it out. great idea, Glenn Beck.
How fucking high does it have to be? I have around 40 posts in more than 2 years and I get that shit with over 2600 link karma and 16.5K comment karma.
They should measure an account's acceptance by comment karma. Link karma might continue to serve in sorting links.
Here's a cache of the blog article. You know, just in case.
Moreover, they owner of that blog even wrote a post http://www.prelovac.com/vladimir/reddit-adventure on how to push to the front page of reddit - '- there is a human editor (topic moderator) who is promoting the story they like to the front page'
Wait, I'm lost…
Let me know if I'm misunderstanding anything here…
Well it's not just that.
Is she violating some holy law? Probably not. But I do not believe that she should be in charge of moderating powers as she has shown that she can misuse that power to advance her links.
The important word here is 'can'. It is a conflict of interest. http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b7e25/today_i_learned_that_one_of_reddits_most_active/c0lc5js Here, on her linkedin page she boasts about increasing traffic to a site disabloom.com. Check out the domain page for it: http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b7e25/today_i_learned_that_one_of_reddits_most_active/c0lc8pe It's links from her.
For every 40 links or so(wild guess) she slips in a paid link. As a user, let her do it. But she should not be moderator for subreddits.
It's not the link you have quoted, but her interviews and her linkedin page. She specifically mentions 'becoming part of the community so your links are accepted better', which, is, gaming the system. I'm willing to guess that she started r/aww just so she could do SEO.
You're trying to change the subject. I was asking specifically about part of your 'Smoking Gun' claim. Surely your 'Smoking Gun' is smoking enough to not need a change of subject when someone questions it, right?
Oh I'm sorry I didn't see the context.
I edited my post to include that part of the comment which I read further down the thread. At the time I was unexpectedly the top comment so I edited my comment to include part of that comment.
As the later edit shows there is a significant time difference.
Now in light of a lot of more evidence(the linkedin page, the disabloom.com blog, the interviews), I may not have the smoking gun, as I thought another redditor had, at 1 AM today.
there is a human editor (topic moderator) who is promoting the story they like to the front page
The guy may think so but moderators have no such powers.
I agree. But we suspect he may have had dealings with moderators who get the job done for him - getting it to the front page, with unknown methods - which make him believe moderators have that power.
As a mod, I know there's no such way. Maybe those he spoke to tried to impress him or something.
thrillhouse > Saydrah
- there is a human editor (topic moderator) who is promoting the story they like to the front page'
you're being pretty misleading here dude.
The guy's blog did not make that statement as fact...he prefaced it with "I believe".
You've taken it out of context.
Doesn't help the case against Saydrah, just makes us look bad.
Wait a minute, I won't stand for any bashing of Vladimir!
Mr. Prelovac is one of the most talented and generous individuals currently publishing open-source templates, plugins, etc... His point of view is that Reddit seems to have a human editor pushing things to the top, but as anyone who has repeatedly been to the front page he also says that all it really takes is a good, quality story relevant to the site's interests.
Maybe I'm wrong, but I don't see any proof of a conspiracy between these two. Well then again, I wouldn't be terribly surprised either because I have seen submissions completely disappear in the minute or two before mods go on their own submit sprees. I got caught in that outflow once and can't even submit to certain subreddits anymore :(
But its also not too far fetched to assume that anyone who publishes websites has also spent some time browsing Vladimir's site or downloading his free software offerings, and may even be compelled by his generosity to help him out in some way. I mean crap, look at what I just spent 5 minutes writing because I used one of his templates once.
Anyone got a screenshot of her from the calendar?
I'll do ya one better. Boom- headshot!
Beware: What is seen cannot be unseen.
Photo is negatively edited and vandalized in 5, 4, 3...
It makes sense that she's friends with Sarah Jessica Parker.
I guess she...
puts on sunglasses
... got on my horse.
Terrible, truly terrible
Things only get upvoted if people like them. Why is it that big a deal what happens outside of reddit if we still only see the links people like?
I don't know about you, but I sure don't hang out on Saydrah's user page desperately clicking every link she submits. I click on what makes it to the front page. And that's the good stuff. Who cares if she gets paid for it? I feel like there is a difference between "spamming" and sparingly promoting.
This is part of the moral question over her role.
I made a comment in another thread about how after 2 sets of front page links, a ton of stuff - usually pictures - is from Saydrah.
Is she violating some holy law? Probably not. But I do not believe that she should be in charge of moderating powers as she has shown that she can misuse that power to advance her links.
The important word here is 'can'. It is a conflict of interest. http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b7e25/today_i_learned_that_one_of_reddits_most_active/c0lc5js Here, on her linkedin page she boasts about increasing traffic to a site disabloom.com. Check out the domain page for it: http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b7e25/today_i_learned_that_one_of_reddits_most_active/c0lc8pe It's links from her.
For every 40 links or so(wild guess) she slips in a paid link. As a user, let her do it. But she should not be moderator for subreddits.
I can understand the issue with her moderator role, although I don't think there's a significant risk of abuse - it's not like mods have the power to zoom things to the top of a page. The worst she could do is delete similar posts, but if what she's posting is promotions for a website, why would someone else be posting the same material? Plus, I think the posters of anything deleted would start an uprising.
Saydrah's ability to get link traffic is more based on her status in the community, not her mod powers.
"conflict of interest"
I'm paid to bring retards from /b/ to reddit. You notice all that decline in quality? All me buddy!
While we're on the topic of bashing various redditors, I have a bone to pick with you too! I've seen your comments, and they are usually witty and thoughtful. I suspect you aren't the real ambassador from 4chan.
That's what he wants you to think! For now..
It's really Kevin Rose
Like there's one.
[deleted]
No, this guy is
Hey, I posts hundreds of pics from 4chan to reddit every week. I should get a little credit for the decline in quality!
[deleted]
I'm 12 and what is this?
[deleted]
your work has certainly been noted.
Yes, I've been watching you.
Thanks. :)
Hey you said you'd give me money if I posted here. Where's my cut?
Hey /b/rother. How's harmony harmony coming along?
It all makes sense now.
Reddit.com was an inside job.
wake up sheeple!
Grazing grass is an outside job.
Smoking grass is an inside job.
Acid dosing is an outside job =D
It's too early.
I can neither confirm nor deny this.
THE ENTIRE INTERNET WAS AN INSIDE JOB.
(Dude, you've gotta go all the way.)
EARTH WAS AN INSIDE JOB
(ALL THE WAY IS NOT FAR ENOUGH!)
Reddit.com was an inside job.
he whispered. It all makes sense. It's not too late! he dropped his bag and sprinted back towards the tower that he narrowly escaped with his life just moments ago. He burst through the lobby doors and headed towards the stairs, but this time, he went to the basement.
The door swung open, and he was standing there, and all his worst fears had come to fruition. It was you all along? Why No answer. Just a lifeless stare. It was all about the clicks, there was no truth, no pursuit of knowledge, just clicks? The stranger's hand casually depressed the ominous button in the center of the console, and brought a world of darkness for us all. Bastards he yelled out, and was forever silenced.
But that's just what they want you to think!
THEN WHO WAS PHONE?
(Psst, guys, am I doing this right?)
You're so daring <3
You mean posting a meme and not contributing to conversation? Yeah, ace job.
BETTER NATE THAN LEVER LOL
[deleted]
I thought this was a known fact among many of the old users of reddit.
When you first start on this site, we all get kinda impressed by the amount of content/comments and karma and shit these 'top players' like Saydrah have and toe whatever line they put in their comments, but then it just hits you down the line and its all social media manipulation just like on any other media outlet.
Not to mention the amount of marketing data reddit produces for Conde Naste. Reddit is really a focus group at this point.
Umm, I dont really care about marketing data the site produces, I mean, thats done by everyone out there. Its the special aura that surrounds these power users. The majority of content being promoted by them, and then the self-righteousness when they are called promoters, we do a lot of work as mods, this is a thankless job, blah blah blah.
The only true content creators (by which I mean most of good commenters) like cuntsmellersinc, necrophiliac, klienbl000, bozarking, flossdaily, and so many out there, are the true heroes of reddit, not these karma whoring leeches.
i really think mods shouldnt be able to post stories/links..
What a modest proposal. I think that's an excellent idea.
Unfortunately that would not solve much, because they would simply create another account and promote their own stories on their sock account(s).
as a moderator of r/formula1 and r/redditalbum
that's a fucking stupid idea
So that they need to create a separate account in order to do that? :-)
Dude, if you create a reddit, then you are the only mod. You mean if I create a reddit for my Wow Guild, I shouldn't be allowed to post in my own reddit?
To expand on this, I would appreciate a "counter" of how many submissions a moderator has "hidden" or "banned" (meaning they "will not get seen by the general public") within a certain timeframe (say, one month?).
It would be completely anonymous, seeing as we'd only see numbers.
I'm sure it wouldn't be difficult to create a second account.
They'll just create a new account for that. This is spam at heart.
thinking it through, you did not.
Couldn't have said it better myself. If the mods were quietly dropped from each subreddit, content would still be king. Fuck the power users and their trip; they exaggerate their importance here.
You exaggerate YOURS!
...
Not really. It just seemed like something a villain played by Jeremy Irons would say.
Most mods I know don't exaggerate their importance at all. They basically monitor the spam trap and remove abuse. Mods aren't power users; they're trusted janitors.
Pity that all these commenters give up their accounts with no indication and they never boast in their karma glory. As against the other high karma folks, who leverage on that who get to be mods and fast submit proof.
As Lewis Black said though outta context here: "The good die young, the pricks live forever."
I am not a hero? :( I always comment on stuff, hell, I probably spend more time on here than the mods do!
Sorry General you're only a hero in the south.
We're having the Digg problem all over again.
Thanks for the shout-out.
I just want to say, though, that while I certainly understand the outrage here, I think it's important that we remember that Saydrah has been a friendly and thoughtful member of our community for a long time. Just because she made some money off of it doesn't mean that her interactions with us weren't genuinely heartfelt.
I think we all need to take a deep breath and try to remember that she spent a lot of time helping reddit to be a better place. She isn't the villain we're making her out to be.
Yes, she tarnished an otherwise wonderful reputation. But I think we should make an effort to weigh the good against the bad. I think she's done more far more good than harm.
If reddit is a focus group, I need to re-check my understanding of the word's definition. Most of these people are using reddit as a pretend to focus on real work group, as far as I ever could tell.
All that Reddit has on you is an IP and a lot of freeform text data.
Freeform text is notoriously difficult to mine for useful marketing information.
Don't get me started on that Sears fiasco.
You mean all the joy, education and excitement i got out of reddit all these years was fake?
No. It's been a progressively worsening situation. Remember sending Helen Thomas flowers? Good times. Why wouldn't people attempt to exploit that kind of energy?
If you're agreeing or disagreeing based on someone's karma, you are an idiot. You're also an idiot if you assume that everyone on Reddit has the same ideas.
Agree.
Disagree.
Neither agree nor disagree
I thought this was a known fact among many of the old users of reddit.
It is. There are other well-known mods who spam in other ways, like linking to their personal Amazon Affiliate accounts. You'd be surprised what goes on behind the scenes on Reddit.
But how do yoiu feel about what's been going on behind the scenes? Does it upset you? For me I'm not too concerned and I feel like if they wanna link to whatever sites for money or traffic increase then that is their prerogative. I however think an effective deterrent would be to start a subreddit all about identifying these "for profit" submitters.
I personally don't care. Here's how it breaks down for me:
The admins' jobs depend on the success of Reddit, so whatever actions they take or don't take I have to assume are in the best interests of Reddit.
I enjoy providing entertainment to the subscribers of my reddits. As long as Reddit continues to be viable, I can continue to do that.
There's a huge amount of drama that goes on behind the scenes in the "big" reddits. I moderated one once, and they're drama queens nonpareil. That's why I stick to my ever-growing stable of smaller reddits.
I can understand where you're coming from. There are exceptions I think.
Well maybe just one: r/woahdude I think is drama-less. And I was gonna say r/askreddit but since I'm part of r/askusers I know its not true.
Any thoughts on the subreddit idea? It certainly would be a game-killer for some. Idk if I'd ever do it cause I wouldn't want haters pissing all over my game.
At the same time tho- I aint gettin paid by saydrah for the upvotes I give her...
And she hasn't even come in here to say:
"Yes this is my job. But I owe it all to you guys, the users, who have my back and what-not".
And that's kinda beat.
Don't be sneaky, just give credit where credit is due.
This is just so fucking outrageous!
bless you for saying 'toe'
Foot fetish eh?
[deleted]
I am pretty sure the fact that saydrah was an seo-type was a pretty wellknown "secret". I wish I could find the comment thread where it was discussed
Well fuck me in the butt with shaved beef and call me a man hoagie. Who knew.
Well Man Hoagie, SirOblivious seems to have a lot of information regarding the whole thing. It's very interesting, actually. Don't know what to make of it. But man, I'd love to be paid to summit stuff.
Hell, who am I kidding? I'd just love to be paid...
Yea I'd love to get paid to climb mountains.
I'd love to get paid to sit on the couch and have a butler watch people climb mountains.
How do you know she's paid to submit stuff? And if she were, why would it matter? People who submit their own work to Reddit are encouraged to do so.
...WTF? When did I ever say SHE was paid to summit stuff? Can't you read? I said I'D love to be paid to summit stuff. So get off your high horse and stop accusing people of crap they haven't done.
My apologies, it seemed like you were making that assumption. There were plenty others claiming she was getting paid to submit at the link.
Do you always run to defend your queen?
I just get pissed off when people start jumping on seriously sketchy bandwagons at someone's expense without any solid proof. It sickens me.
It says so right on her LinkedIn profile.
Everyone? It's pretty common knowledge, she's never denied it. I still think it's bullshit, but it's no secret.
She says that she's paid not to spam, i.e. she submits Associated Content links in a non-spammy manner.
Personally, I don't buy it.
[deleted]
I doubt that's the case, I imagine she "recruits" people to write articles for the AC website.
God I wish I could save comments.
[deleted]
You're not fucked in the butt with a shaved beef and called a man hoagie... sadly?!?!
[deleted]
$5 footlong indeed.
[deleted]
Meh, I'm just here to make jokes. Unfortunately I'm not paid for it.
SirOblivious found this out?
...What???
Is going on? Where am I?
What are you doing, Jim?
I wish I could upvote this more than just once lol
Saydrah wakes up this morning, has a cup of coffee and lets the dog out. Then she sits down to check reddit and FFFUUUUUUUUUUUU.
There, that was my first and only one of those.
Jeez, for some reason I was expecting you to say, "Saydrah wakes up in the morning feeling like P. Diddy". That fucking song is on the radio too much.
[deleted]
I met you once... still weird to consider you making this comment.
I mean nothing by that, it's still just funny and weird to me. Carry on. You seem like a pretty awesome, beer-drinkin' sort of guy.
maybe we will get lucky and she will slit her wrist out of guilt for bullshitting and manipulating people : )
Sociopaths are incapable of feeling guilt.
Ok that's a little harsh. Personally I don't care if she makes $ submitting links. She puts a lot of effort into the community.
Here's from her most recent comment
I spend most of my work day finding people who are spamming Reddit and other sites and getting them to stop.
Ahhhhhhh...
Eliminating competition.
-choo!
So she can edge them out and take their place instead.
[deleted]
If she were a man, I'd call her a fag.
That doesn't make it okay.
Yeah, it's only okay when you follow it up with "...not that there's anything wrong with that".
"Gay used to mean happy and when I was a kid it meant lame. Now it means a man who makes love to other men."
-Michael Scott
That's gay.
She owns a Harley?
cunts ride harleys, she is a fucking whore cunt who lies
I agree that slamming someone for being a feminist is not okay. But I never thought 'bitch' was sexist. You call a woman a bitch, you call a guy an asshole. Equal but separate.
Slamming her for being a "feminist" in the context of her arguments in r/MensRights is like calling a politician "Conservative" or "Liberal" sometimes a label is simply a label and not an insult in and of itself.
For example, I wouldn't be insulting Obama to call him a "Liberal" even though I am a conservative.
You know, I was thinking the proper comparison was "dick" but now that you mention it, I don't think "asshole" sounds right for a girl. Huh. The sentence "she's an asshole" doesn't sound right.
If you put boxing gloves on a pig, well... that pig won't be getting too far very soon.
Well said. Yet, I've read tons of comments from people who get pissy when subreddits like r/twoxchromosomes/ call redditors out for upvoting sexist, vile comments.
Also, from what I'm reading Saydrah is actually a man, not that it really makes a difference.
manbitch
he-bitch
Do you mean like a tranny-man playing as a woman (I see no problem with that), or a man-man pretending to be a woman for the purposes of this site? 'Peculiar' would be an understatement if that's the case. (I can't find the comment/link with the 'man' info).
So both Saydrah and MaryJaneBrewington from the calendar are transexuals?
I didn't read about any of that until you posted it. But I have gotten into some discussions with her where she is unapologetically bordering on misandry. Maybe others have as well, I don't know. But I agree, that's a separate ad hominem issue altogether.
Look, deal with the fact that the language tends to work this way. Women get called bitches a lot, guys get called dickhead more often. Sorry that like every other fucking language on the planet, English has some words that are (I can't believe I'm explaining this for insults) more feminine or masculine.
All of the posts I see about her "feminist" background are from people complaining about her arguments with people in the MensRights subreddit. It has nothing to do with gender, sometimes you have to call a spade a spade, would you complain if in a political debate someone dared to use "conservative" or "liberal" to refer to someone's political leaning?
The word bitch, when used pejoratively, has nothing to do with sex/gender. Nothing. The word can be used to refer to men or women just like motherfucker doesn't necessarily mean someone who fucks mothers. It's just one of those vague words that can be used to mean whatever you want it to mean. In some unusual contexts, motherfucker and bitch can even be used among friends. It doesn't need to mean something negative either. In other words, these terms can be whatever you want them to be.
Sometimes I call my mom "motherfucker", but in a friendly, chummy way.
If it was a guy I would be just as angry and call him a dick.
I once called shannanigan on IAMA post about two Japanese guy, one claiming to be ex-yakuza and another guy (DOGA) claiming to be zen/sword master who used to be gay porn start. They immediately deleted their posts to cover their tracks.
S immediately came to defence of these two, calling me a Douchebag.
I wonder what they were trying to do. I noticed that S and DOGA are moderator of Equality subreddit. So DOGA must be on this spamming too.
That seems particularly damning. As far as her responses go, suspicious is the least of it.
My rule on IAmA is until there's a gold star, the submitter is a troll. Sorry, too many liars ruined it for everyone else.
Just, WOW.
I've pointed out the Conde Nast Digital copyright doohicky notated at the bottom of every reddit page more than once, only to be downmodded.
Love it or not, reddit is a capitalist venture. Social media is a capitalist playground.
Bring it on.
I've pointed out the Conde Nast Digital copyright doohicky notated at the bottom of every reddit page more than once, only to be downmodded.
But that's proper notice. Reddit doesn't try to hide their affiliation and will speak openly about what it means for them to be owned by Conde Nast.
But if you think the bottom line isn't profit, you're kidding yourself. Maybe reddit itself isn't a profit center, but the UGC is a potential gold mine. For example, if I were Conde Nast, I'd be using linguistic parsers to analyze reactions to submissions in real time. Knowing the pulse of a community's opinion as it unfolds is a marketer's wet dream.
But but she was one of us!!! We TRUSTED her!!! :P
Only the foolish trust people in power on the internet. They're normally 12 year old boys with an axe to grind.
Not too capitalist, one ad with several of them being meta ads
[deleted]
[deleted]
They certainly have more leeway to do these things, being a privately held corporation. Reddit is probably a lot freer than if it was public.
This is just a non sequitur though. It has nothing to do with why people are mad.
People are mad because she betrayed the trust of the community, was dishonest, and cynically manipulated and gamed the community.
Reddit.com is just the building we hang out it...whether or not it is a commercial enterprise is not relevent here.
If you found out one of your friends was a mole sent by a corporation, you wouldn't rationalize their dishonesty by saying "Oh well we are standing in a shopping Mall, which is a for profit business....and that magically makes being two-faced ok...we're fair game since we entered the mall.".
Even if it were relevant, as others have pointed out...they are up-front about it.
All that said, I think people are over-reacting a bit.
So, she's kind of a bitch.....didn't we already know that?
You're likely to run into corporate wonks when you hang out in a corporate building.
In case you are wondering where this thread went, I deleted it before I headed to bed because Saydrah's info kept getting posted. Even if you don't like what she did, I don't want her harassed in real life for this.
I don't want her harassed in real life for this.
I agree 100%. However there were over 500 comments in that thread, the personal info is out there now (can't put it back in the bottle) in multiple threads, and it seems like a disservice to the people who posted good comments, pro and con, to remove access to such a passionate discussion.
Of course, it was your submission and therefore your prerogative to delete it.
Unfortunately, the fact that deleted posts are not-really-deleted and the vague way they are tagged ("submitted 12 hours ago by [deleted]") makes it look like either a reddit mod deleted it (which will get more panties in a bunch) or that you deleted your entire account.
Considering how dodgy the whole saga is, I can't think of anything more suspicious than deleting the original thread. Now it just feels like there's this invisible hand controlling everything behind the scenes.
[deleted]
Next time, try not to invite the dudes with the torches to yr witch-hunt.
You did the right thing, albeit a bit too late. There isn't much you can do about it now. Also, sorry you're being downvoted so heavily- I guess people really want to see a good lynching.
Uhhm... deleting submissions do nothing to make information forgotten. All it does it remove it from the front page and change your name to [deleted]. It's still all here, all in Google, etc. All you did was get scared you were going to get in trouble or something and chickened out.
Also it doesn't matter when people's info gets posted. Do you have a phonebook? Business cards? Our info is everywhere, just because some people's info is right there in public view does not make it any more right to use it to harass or harm the person it is connected to.
[deleted]
I wouldn't want my personal info to be publicly connected to my reddit account.
Why don't people understand this? I've made this point a couple of times and it totally goes over people's heads. I think, maybe, the answer is that I'm getting old (33). I bet the people who see nothing wrong with linking a reddit account to personal info are teenagers. They've grown up in a world where they never new what privacy was.
Since you have the power to delete posts despite the fact that you're not on the list of moderators, why don't you address the issue rather than simply deleting this post?
he has the ability to delete it as he was the original poster. You also have the power to delete your own posts if you so choose.
You reap what you sow. Welcome to real life.
I'm just sick of seeing this, people whining about slow Reddit, and Saydrah all over the front page. Really, isn't there anything better out there?
Even if you don't like what she did, I don't want her harassed in real life for this.
I agree with this, but you should NOT have deleted the thread. That's ridiculous. It's not like we wouldn't have otherwise found out.
I don't care about her personal life and I don't think she should lose something in that life. I would like her to voluntarily stop using Reddit. That's all. I don't want anything to happen to her in her personal life.
Doesn't matter, info's already out there. Nothing you can do about it now...
why
Fuck you.
Asshole
Even if she isn't getting paid (which it looks like she is being paid for some of her submissions), she's still a spammer.
http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/abp64/reddit_kitteh_gets_famouz/c0gsc9r
Here she admits to providing a fake name to the DenverPost, then claims she did it because she doesn't want her username associated with her real name.
Granted I'm sure plenty of Reddit users don't want their username associated with their real name, but we're not talking about a regular user. This is Reddit mod with deep ties to the community who is gaming Reddit for SEO and mass posting affiliate content. This is also someone who has the power to remove other people's content from some of the most popular subreddits.
This is exactly the reason why many of us left other websites to come to Reddit -- to get away from "power users" and censorship.
Even if she hasn't done anything "wrong" there are simply too many conflicts of interest at this point. She should step down and remove herself as a moderator from all subreddits. If she does not, I truly hope the Reddit Admins do the right thing and strip her of the ability to mod any and all subreddits, if not ban her from Reddit completely. This should not be ignored.
Final note: Linking to an image on your server, even if you are directly linking to the image still boosts SEO, hence why she rarely uses any image hosting sites.
P.S. I realize Reddiquette does allow for self promotion, and self linking. That is not the issue, the issue is the quantity of submissions that makes it spam, she is posting links for the purpose of SEO, and she is potentially being paid for submissions.
Edit: Wanted her name to simply find more info to see if it can lead to more proof of paid submissions. It appears since I've gone to sleep other Redditors have done this for me. Thank you kind sirs.
Edit2: Again, I was curious about Saydrah's real name for investigative reasons only. I'm a former tech journalist and was simply going to look into the allegations against her. Nothing more, and no I will not reveal her actual name.
Does anyone know her real name?
I don't get it, why is this personal? I mean, she's a spammer, sure, but why is it necessary to get personal? Just downvote her or whatever and let her live with the shame. Am I missing something?
I don't think she is a spammer. Her content is interesting, from original sources and usually well liked.
I don't get it, why is this personal?
Eh, you never can tell why mentally ill people take things personally.
Mentally ill? A person can be mentally ill. This is an online community that is otherwise remarkably rational.
I find it very strange that, in this entire thread, very few people are standing up for Saydrah and those that do aren't highly modded. I find it confusing that someone calling her a cunt is currently at positive karma. I find it confusing that a community that has usually valued reasonable discourse over ad hominem attacks has launched quite a few personal attacks against her as a person rather than her behavior on reddit. I find it confusing that the reddit community is taking it very personally when they can do what they've always done - downvote spam. I find it confusing that people indicate users like Saydrah as destroying reddit when her submissions - spam or not - are upvoted by the community at large. And I find it confusing that all of this is done with remarkably little evidence. Not gonna lie, I expect better from reddit.
This is an online community that is otherwise remarkably rational.
Uhm, I would have to disagree with you. I don't see them as rational. I see a great many misfits who can't function at a normal level so they come on here for the majority of their interaction with the world. They don't know how to ask others out on a date, they can't make the simplest decisions without having to run it through a thread, many have esteem issues, and so on and so forth. I see a lot of mentally ill people on here. I think that this is why there is so much interest devoted to her personal info. This is exactly the kind of crowd that likes to lurk in shadows, stalk and then render ill to someone or their posessions.
The sheeple thing. They see a few running in this direction or that, and they jump in and run with them. They don't know why they are running, just that everyone else is running so that must be the safe thing to do. They don't dare risk saying anything against the rest of the flock, for fear of being thrown out there with the predators, and they aren't equipped to deal with them without the flock support. Anyone that has ever worked with herd animals (horses, cows, sheep) understand that herd animals feel it is a far safer thing to be at the lowest echelons of the herd, than to be cast out into the wild without the herd.
I don't expect better of reddit - this is about exactly what I expect from reddit. There will be a few people that are supportive of her, but the rest are going to stay in the flock, and voice opinions that are of the flock mentality.
But I would like to thank you for being supportive of her. I believe that she is one of the most valued redditor - for her interesting links, her support on a personal level with people, and just everything she does on here.
I just found her real name (was curious, took about 3 minutes). Based on her LinkedIn info it's pretty clear that her main job is to promote content on sites like Reddit (for a couple of companies). I'm not saying her name, I think that's a shitty thing to do.
post it god damn it, why is everyone tip toeing here, post the linkedin profile
Too late...
too late? wtf does that mean? post her name and/or linkedin, why are you people bitching about her and then protecting her
i wish people would stop calling her a "reddit mod". she mods a few subreddits; that's a purely community thing and doesn't give her any particular advantage when it comes to reddit.
dont confuse moderators with admins..
she is indeed a reddit moderator, in that she moderates at least one subreddit on reddit
that's my point - she merely moderates a subreddit or two. calling her a reddit moderator implies some sort of official, privileged position.
And it makes all mods, even those who have worked hard at building up their new subreddits, look like crazy power hungry users. Look people, the worse thing I can do as a mod is ban you and even then the other mods would be all 'wtf' and unban if it wasn't a spammer. If I kept doing that, I would be given the 'ol heave ho.
I think the issue here is twofold:
Reddit has a cool kids club and it gives people a reverse boner.
People have no idea what a moderator can do. Mods are basically second line defense spam filters.
I implore anyone who has any questions about how much 'power' a mod has to create a subreddit and test it out. Anyone can do it and the best subreddits here were created by users with a genuine interest in the subreddit topic and who participate and comment with class and without power issues.
[deleted]
Granted I'm sure plenty of Reddit users don't want their username associated with their real name, but we're not talking about a regular user.
Who are we talking about? The terrorists? Harassing people in real life is so much worse than spam. Not because it makes you a bad person, but because it really will ruin reddit.
She's a moderator, not a regular user.
I didn't harass her in real life. I asked her some valid questions publicly in her AMA and didn't use her real name. That is all.
This is purely unacceptable.
Admins please demote this user immediately.
I agree. This is so fucking outrageous!
[deleted]
There is already 560 comments, so this will probably never get seen but:
Saydrah, it's not that we care that much. It's the fact that you either ignore these accusations and/or shrug them off. If you would have just came out and said, "yeah, hey I get paid to submit some of my stuff". You would have been perhaps jostled around, but it would have dissipated. Unfortunately for you, hiding from the situation backfired. If you were really the super-redditor SEO you've claimed to be, and know the community as well as you claim too, you would know that being forthcoming is preferable to hiding. If you would have admitted it months ago, this post wouldn't have made the top page. Since it would have been common knowledge.
We/reddit love mysteries, and the more you create one by staying silent, implying that you are 'innocent' and 'not justifying these accusations', the more guilty you look. It's one thing to ignore ad hominem attacks. It's quite another when someone backs them up with facts. You failed to see the difference. In short, you caused this yourself by staying silent, hoping your 'supporters' would defend you. They tried. The evidence was just too strong.
If you're reading this, Saydrah, think about doing an AMA.
Although, I can just imagine the self-righteous poo that would be flung if you did. Anyone have a better idea?
edit: typo...
If she did this she'd probably be downvoted to oblivion.
It's kinda funny how she claims to know the community so well and is very close to it...
Yet this all blew up because for once, she didn't choose her words just right, with a person who is basically beloved by Reddit (TheOatmeal).
Don't fuck with TheOatmeal.
She actually did post alot of stuff. It all got downvoted to about -100 each, though, so you have to expand it to see it.
Actually when there is a mass downvoting like this, the system take stuff like this into effect, and even though you give her a downvote, an up vote will still reflect in her karma. Today, every time I said something that made sense, but was against popular grain for the thread, my comment karma went up with each downvote. I don't know why the system works that way, but it does. Probably because of incidences like this. Also an indicator of downvotes being made from each person's user page. A downvote from the user page doesn't work - it has to be from the thread from where the comment was made. :)
This is business. Do you know how much spam is on Reddit now? Reddit is quickly becoming like Digg, but not as bad. They hide it a little better on Reddit.
I work in the corporate world dealing with media. There are many websites and private companies who get paid to, successfully, get stories to the front page to drive traffic to the targets.
You are all nothing but walking bags of cash to these people, never forget that.
Actually, I don't even give a shit. I am spending my time surfing the Internet. If some company is making money by them invading my line of sight for the 5 seconds I spent on that site, then so be it. Some idiot is stupid enough to be paying them for that, which by the way, has never encouraged me to actually buy something.
All I really care about is that I get to read and see interesting things that can somehow inspire me to see the world a little differently. This may come in the form of a Kazakhstani cover of Katy Perry, or breaking news coverage of the Chile earthquake. The truth is that this is a community. Some people, including Saydrah, see business opportunity. I say let them do what they want, and we, the consumers, can decide whether or not we want to see something she has to submit. My only problem is if she abuses her power to promote herself more than others.
tldr; make me a cash whore, and ill dance for you, baby.
You are all nothing but walking bags of cash to these people, never forget that.
I remember being kind of disappointed when I learned that J-Ro did professional Web promotion of healthcare stuff. It wasn't as if his comments were just written with an intent to, say, provide neutral information.
I am trying to write an article about social marketers on twitter. I couldnt find any proper material on those people.
Maybe you guys could help me out to understand this rare species. As far as I understand the only mechanisms they use to game the system on twitter is: - random friending people, - excessive friending, - hashtag spamming, - friend churn, - message spamming, - creating auto-accounts that follow back.
The goal is to gather as much genuine followers as possible, but what are they worth? And who pays those people? Does it only work with affiliate programms? How the heck do they make money with this? What is a typicall social media marketer or spammer?
I'll bet that if you email Saydrah or MrBabyMan, they could point you in the right direction.
jeez, I haven't been to digg, well active in the community forever, do they still allow them to post? If so, and if Reddit lets this woman(?) keep posting, well...
Business is all about hand shakes and winks, isn't it? ;-)
I guess there must be thousands like them. It seems nobody really studied that whole scam in detail. I think an interview with those guys might definitely be interesting.
[deleted]
A comment that has been deleted now posted links to websites that provide social media marketing services. I had no idea that sites like this exist. It seems really to be a business. If people are willing to pay 1$ per vote or 25c per follower on twitter, i have underestimated the value of social media.
Don't forget the whole "Ink" fiasco
EDIT: Shit, it was in one of those links... Fucking jooes, always too quick to post...
I'm not overly concerned about this whole thing, but if she was somehow paid by Kiona Winans, that would have to be have to be one of the most blatantly unethical things I've run across in a while.
Kiona Winans directly solicited donations in that IamA, and given reddit's giving mentality, seemed to do awfully well. It's one thing to spam r/pics, it's another thing altogether to take advantage of the good nature of the community in such a despicably self serving manner...
How was that a "fiasco"?
I like the word so I try to use it whenever it's appropriate, even if only slightly so.
Yeah, but, following the link all I see is a fairly interesting IAMA post. I'm trying to understand what makes it a "fiasco."
I guess I was expecting to see something like the reaction to the dude with no kid posting a pic of "his kid" dressed as Link where the tone of the comments suddenly pulls a 180...
That was just like the start of it, check this out for more (follow V3rtigo's comment, because I can't figure out the whole "context" thing)
'fiasco' has a pretty negative connotation. what fiasco? Even if she was paid as a social media consultant to put him on the site and help him understand what the site is about, I don't see the problem with this and that she is also a mod.
Saying it is a 'fiasco' might be considered slanderous. What fiasco?
Slanderous: I don't think that word means what you think it means.
A bit bland. Could use some salt.
lol, that one is pretty blatent, wow, what a cunt
Here is the THE SMOKING GUN on Saydrah:
Her real name is Jelena XXXXX*:
Here's her video interview for Associated Content! She mentions REDDIT at 5:50 & 8:35 & 14:40 & 19:15
Here's her Linkedin
Here's an interview she did
Here's an article by her on Associated Content
*myspace linking Lisa Droesdov to Jelena
Edit: After thinking about alecb's comment I've decided to omit her last name & replace some links with screenshots. I think her name is relevant to anyone who wants to investigate it themselves, but I also see how this could lead to harassment. Screenshots still provide the damning evidence, and if you really want to investigate it further, the info is easy to find through google.
This needs to be the top comment, for two reasons:
Scary good investigative work.
If you skim through her interviews, you can really see her side of the story. A touch duplicitous, yes, but otherwise quite genuine. She recommends "spending hours in the community" and "occasionally link to the best of your material". Some more money quotes:
...
...
So, it sounds like most of her participation here is "authentic," but with a little bit of whoring here and there, right? Overall, that means that we come out ahead in the deal, don't we?
Tell me what to think, Reddit Hive Mind!
NICE TRY, SOCIAL MEDIA COORDINATOR
LOL. :-)
If only my life were that exciting....
Sounds like an awful lot more than a "little bit" to me. She gets paid to whore out Reddit. This place would collapse if we started allowing that. There is no way to do it, but I personally think anybody who gets paid to manipulate Reddit should be permanently banned. The best we can do in this case is at least delete her account.
Isn't the whole point of reddit that the rest of us can just downvote the content if it isn't interesting?
Look at your history. You don't even submit. You are like a leech that sucks off of other people's submissions. You are one of those people that don't contribute to the community - you only take from it.
To me it sounds more like a Ted Bundy being authentic to the neighbors. True authenticity is something she is incapable of, so she gives us her best fake authenticity. When Ted Bundy counsels young sociopaths to occasionally do nice things for the neighbors though and to "be on their best behavior", this doesn't make it nice.
They're still trying to hide their murdering ways.
so you think she's social-media sociopath?
I agree with you. As long as the vast majority of content submitted by this person is genuine I have no problems and benefit from most of their "work".
No conflict of interest then? Moderator privileges? I don't know enough about how it works but I would suspect that if you're a paid contributor you probably shouldn't have heightened privileges.
Nice try, Saydrah.
I suppose you don't mind a few chunks of bacteria-laden catshit on your pizza either. I mean, it's mostly pizza, right?
I'm sorry but the wording in your post is very manipulative. You're leading the answer with the whole "but everything is alright, isn't it?", and then you go on to suggest that people who are concerned that someone might be gaming the system are just part of the reddit "hive mind". I think these are legitimate concerns, so there's no need to downplay them.
Nice try, Saydrah.
It wasn't funny the first time you said it.
Every true and successful artist and craftsman is a whore. I'm not sure why society thinks of it as a negative trait - most of, if not all, our enjoyment comes from "whores." Hell, all pencil pushers are also whores in their own respect.
EDIT: The "whore mindset" is prevalent in most modern jobs in society - any of those with some kind of form of hierarchy. It is unfortunate that the more obvious whore jobs in the world (artists) are taking all the blame, while the businessmen and the profiteers are hiding their respective shame.
TLDR: "Whore" is a strong word; it has too much of an undertone.
I agree wholeheartedly and I think picking on somebody who has been a real contributor just because they have found a way to monetize reddit.
I used to write for a college magazine and I'd definitely submit my best stuff to the appropriate subreddits (on an older long ago deleted account). If people liked them then they could be voted up, if not then they weren't. I feel no guilt for those actions as they were well received a few times and provided some information that others may not have gotten. I actually only started doing this after someone else submitted one of my articles and it made it to the top of a subreddit and the "reddit-effect" crashed the magazine's website... I was so proud.
It sounds like you like her and her submissions. Therefore she does no wrong.
Actually, I don't pay attention to individual redditors. I'm generally more of an apolitical lurker.
My original point was simply that if she actually contributes in a positive way overall, we benefit. I guess that would mean we're using her just as much as (if not more than) she's using us. Also, I'm not really sure what proportion of her submissions are blog-spam though, so it's hard to know how self-righteous to get over this.
Definitely the fact that she is a moderator is a problem, as others have pointed out.
Looking at some of the quotes people linked, I get the feeling that she loves social media and would hang out here even if it weren't a job. The fact that she's figured out a way to turn it into an occupation is interesting. Too bad it involves an unhealthy dose of deceipt. :-(
In the interview the first thing she does is say be upfront that you are blogging and promoting, but she has been backpeddling like crazy.
I've looked at her comments on her user page, she doesn't seem to be backpedaling. Could you point me to something specific?
Maybe backpeddling is not the best phrase. She used to make it like she was just submitting material to reddit purely like she liked using reddit. Then once in a while, oh yeah I guess my friend is doing that indy movie I submitted, or I guess I did work for the company whose link I submitted but I am just a reddit user.
Now it comes out that submitting to reddit is part of her job.
http://i.imgur.com/c4tkS.png
????
But weren't there pics of speed posting? Doesn't gel with a theory of "occasionally link to best material"
And then pretend to do that.
Nice try, Saydrah.
Find your favorite social media site and try to destroy it. Brilliant.
It's not black and white.
Not to mention Saydrah's relationship advice is usually shitty.
Saydrah actually told me to shit on my girlfriend.
And this is where the majority of the backlash will come from: she gave advice, protected subreddits, was knee deep in the fighting between r/mensrights, r/equality, r/askme-
When someone takes a prominent reddit social role like that here, there is a hope that they are genuine about it and not to just foster some page views. This is why this goes all over the website. Saydrah has been up the butt of reddit socially for a while now.
No chance that someone can be both?
Wisest comment I have seen about this whole dramatic clusterfuck.
Saydrah actually shat on my girlfriend.
Saydrah poisoned our water supply and BROUGHT A PLAGUE UPON OUR HOUSES!!!
She told me to poop back and forth with my girlfriend. Forever.
Alaskin Pipeline style?
)( <-> )(
...w-what?
Look at her, how many relationships do you think she's been in?
[deleted]
I asked you in PM and I'll ask you here: can you remove her real name and LinkedIn link please? I don't like it either but I don't want her to get fucked with in real life over this. I rather this be a conversation about why the moderation system needs some quick fixes than a witchhunt against Saydrah.
From her LinkedIn
It's relevant.
http://www.reddit.com/domain/disaboom.com
Who are "HopefulNebula" and "theophania79"?
Also seems to link there quite a bit (and both appear to be women)...
The latter is:
http://www.disaboom.com/authors/tiffiny-carlson
The former:
http://hopefulnebula.dreamwidth.org/
raaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaggggggggggeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
OOPS http://www.linkedin.com/in/jelenawoehr
[deleted]
Also http://patricerutledge.com/blog/jelena-woehr-disaboom/
They are significant in building a case against her. I seem them more like evidence.
I think this is relevant information, frankly. She manufacturers good will on social media sites for her own financial gain.
So did The Oatmeal; should we burn him too?
Is he a mod here? THen I think people should know that, and take it into account when they see links submitted to his page.
Why'd you delete the post?
[deleted]
Whoopse http://patricerutledge.com/blog/jelena-woehr-disaboom/
[deleted]
Take it easy folks, this is a lynch mob of the cyber variety.
At the end of the day, how severe are these ostensible transgressions?
i don't believe in lynch mobbing, but this person should be removed from being moderator for subreddits like r/pics because of conflict-of-interest. for example, a moderator has the power to hide any submission. if they see a pic submission they think will do well, they can hide it, then they can create a new blog post for that pic (hence a new link, so it won't be seen as duplicate) and submit it. whether this person has done it doesn't matter. this person is being paid to promote links so there is a conflict of interest to be a moderator.
↑↑↑This is a copy and pasted post from within this very thread - why does it not surprise me that it's pro-saydrah?
go on...
I really want to hear you defending spamming.
I don't think people are accusing her of spamming and yes I'm aware of the title of the story, but I think this has more to do with people feeling she shouldn't be a moderator.
here is 11 posts in 20 minutes. If spam is not the right word... speedposting crap?
[deleted]
as posted above if 11 submissions in 20 minutes is not spamming, you can call it speedposting crap. Don't care what you call it, just keep in mind that when next big-ass-billion-dollar production will be hitting the silver screen, your frontpage will be littered with shit for the whole week, just like it happened with Avatar/Twilight. You can call spamming - social media marketing for all I care.
youre getting a bit too dramatic...
Dude, don't question the internet hate machine.
the horror..... the horror....
(drops dead)
You blacked out her name on the linked in image but not on the section where it says "Jelena Woehr's specialities"!!!
You wrote information you knew he was trying to keep private but did not use a PM!!!
To be as honest, and generally about the whole subject, in the most succinct manner I can: I dinnae give a fook.
I haven't revealed anything that wasn't already available or that she (Saydrah/Jelena) hadn't revealed herself.
He wasn't keeping it private but obfuscated it so as not to be the source of a backlash/witch hunt.
Holy shit.
I found her use of the word compelling twice in one sentence was quite redundant.
[deleted]
That interview shows her last name immediately. You might want to correct that. You must've missed it.
[deleted]
is she a transvestite? serious question
I think you forgot to blotch out one instance of her last name, here. First main section, towards the bottom - a sub heading.
Depending on the pronunciation...massive irony.
[deleted]
Why do you find it necessary to insult her appearance?
She may have been playing us all along, but that doesn't give any of us the right to insult her like that.
Who needs rights? Her voice is annoying, too.
This is impressive research, but I've had interaction with Saydrah and it has all been positive. She took a lead in the reddit JetBlue trip which ended up being a ton of fun and wouldn't have happened without people like her taking the lead.
Unless you can come up with evidence that she has hurt the reddit community, I just want to say I'm with Saydrah!
It isn't about her hurting the community, it's that there is a conflict of interest in her being a moderator
Ugh, the reddit hivemind pisses me off sometimes...
Saydrah is not some evil malicious spammer who has somehow corrupted the system to her advantage. She's one of the few names on here that I recognize from consistently seeing so many helpful/insightful comments from her. She's compassionate, smart as hell, and very very good at what she does for us as a moderator. It's just funny to see a whole thread dedicated to trashing her because, reddit is usually so anonymous, and she's one of the very few people that I feel I can comment on specifically, that I even recognize. Spend a while reading through her comment history and you'll get a very different picture of her than what is being painted here.
I like NOT seeing the same usernames over and over. I like the diversity. Power users like Saydrah take away this diversity by creating such a large presence. She is far from the only person to do this.
There's no diversity or "such a large presence" created by any individual unless they provide valuable content/comments. There are plenty of people here who post every day that you've never seen. Heck, I've got over 30k of comment karma and I bet you've never read one of my comments or recognize my name (though readers of certain subreddits certainly do). I'm not saying this because I'm one of the "power users", far from it. Just saying that the people who get recognized are the ones who contribute the most time and energy into the developing community, and are therefore the antithesis to the trolls, who are the real problem.
PS. Your username is one of the most powerful users of all time. Ironic!
Are you sure "power user" is the best way to describe a person who consistently puts out high quality comments and submissions? There is a reason why people like Karmanaut, Flossdaily, Necrophilia, Saydrah, and the like have been successful; they have been very active and contributed huge amounts to the community. The reason why you see their comments more often is because they often give the best responses. Would you rather listen to a hundred songs from a hundred different bands, only a few of whom were any good, or a hundred songs from one good band with lots of originality and good material?
Two downvotes, no counter-arguments or even replies in general. Does this not speak "hive-mind" to anyone else?
YES. I'm not understanding this mob's beef at all. Saydrah is not gaming the system or posting an avalanche of penis pill spam blogs from sock accounts. Her job involves teaching companies and organizations how to make and present content that we like. (And if we don't, we down vote it just like anything else.)
Saydrah participates in the comments and community (she's on the reddit calendar for crying out loud) and people have liked some of the things she's posted (at a better rate than people have liked my posts). Professional != abuse.
Every mechanic hypothetically has incentive to rip you off for fixes you don't need, but until they do they aren't disqualified from fixing your car. I think we need to put away the pitchforks and torches.
How is she not gaming the system? She openly admits she seeks "goodwill" in order to drive traffic to sites (disaboom, etc.) who pay her to do so. Spam is spam. Spam from trusted members/moderators is far worse (it's a breach of ethics, not to mention trust) thatn the garden-variety.
i live close to this chic, i am gonna drive over and ask her how much she makes, ha just kidding but i hope someone does it, i hate fuckholes who game the system
i spend most of my time at other sites now, reddit and digg are gamed to actually take seriously but still fun to visit to see what these sites become : )
edited
fine, I will spare her
I understand your anger, but please don't go to /b/ for this. We should keep this within reddit and whatever action is taken should be limited to reddit. All this information is publicly available and she made a mistake of linking her two names, but I don't believe her tricking is worthy of any action in real life.
I hope you back down...
not your personal army
how about you don't. this is just some dumb chick trying to make a buck. we don't need to ruin her life. not to mention /b/ would probably enjoy reddit getting shit on.
fine
Thanks for editing that post. I'm curious: are you xx or xy?
Ha. Figures it's a woman.
novelty troll fails novelty.
Real name of the spammer: Jelena Woehr
Linkedin: http://www.linkedin.com/in/jelenawoehr
Blog: http://www.disaboomlive.com/blogs/Saydrah/Default.aspx
Photo: http://www.petlvr.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/05/jelena-menembercloser.jpg
Location: Lakewood, Colorado, U.S.A.
Went to Jefferson County Open High School, graduated in 2006.
Dude why do you need to post her personal info?
Why not? I fucking hate spammers.
Reddit needs to fight invasive social-media advertising at every turn, lest be become Digg II. If you care about the community, things like this need to be fully exposed.
lol. Just finished reading a book about communist China.
She graduated from high school in 2006? She looks much older. How could someone who graduated from high school in 2006 have so much relationship experience?
[deleted]
[deleted]