Reddit, I got a book deal! Thank you. -The Oatmeal
theoatmeal.com/misc/p/statePosted Feb 27, 2010, 4:40 AM UTC
Posted Feb 27, 2010, 4:40 AM UTC
So did Hitler, you monster
Things Hitler ruined for everyone else:
Vegetarianism
Painting
Autobiographies
Annexing neighboring European nations
.
Thanks a lot, Hitler. Dick.
You forgot the toothbrush mustache.
And genocide.
and the first name "Adolf"
You can also add eugenics and the swatiska to this list.
And antismoking campaigns (and, by extension, public health)
Eugenics doesn't work anyway. Too bad about the swastikas, though. We could all be wearing fashionable windmill esque shapes right now!
Not to mention the name Adolf, imagine if he'd been Joe Hitler.
Then we'd have had to deal with a lot of bullshit about Adolf the Plumber.
syphilis too
[deleted]
Well, try as he might, he hasn't ruined barbecues.
Unless you use gas.
[deleted]
I do none of those things. Phew. Wait, did Hitler ever use Reddit? If so...fuck.
You've never annexed Austria? Man, you haven't lived.
And the VW Beetle bug... because everyone tells me he designed it.
Adolf, you ruined my Polish vacation, you bastid.
I can never seem to remember the title of his book, though.
Nobody Hess any clue.
stop having fun with my Hitlerphobia...the fear of Hitler
Thanks for explaining that word, as I was unsure of its meaning.
You're lucky you don't live in this world!
Thanks for teaching me how to properly use a semicolon; I use them in comments sometimes.
"Here is a lesson in creative writing. First rule: Do not use semicolons. They are transvestite hermaphrodites representing absolutely nothing. All they do is show you've been to college."
-Kurt Vonnegut
Thanks, programming, for saving semicolons from obsolescence.
Thanks, programming
Throgramming.
I'm confused. :(
If a hermaphrodite has both sexes than how can it be a transvestite? I am afraid to put these words into the google.
You should master then vs than before focusing on semicolons.
I'm sorry, English is my third language and I was using my blackberry and I'm blind in both ears.
You should master properly adding the period in "vs." before moving your focus to ask others to focus on semicolons.
Er, you dropped this: .
I read "A Man Without a Country" too. It's funny because, on page 134 in chapter 12, he goes on to say, "Those of us who had imagination circuits built can look in someone's face and see stories there; to everyone else, a face will just be a face. And there, I've just used a semi-colon, which at the outset I told you never to use. It is to make a point that I did it. The point is: Rules only take us so far, even good rules."
Virginia Woolf could do beautiful things with a handful of semicolons; and, let's not forget rare Ben Jonson...
(By the way, I'm too lazy to check this, but I think The Oatmeal teaches that the above is improper use of the semicolon--i.e. with a conjunction; this is not the case at all.)
All the do is show you've been to college.
Unfortunately, that is no longer applicable.
[deleted]
I use semicolons all the time, they are one of my favorite punctuation marks to use; In a related manner (but unrelated), do you really have an IndigoFerrari? I would love to see a pic!
No it was my call sign during childhood fun. We had to pick a color and a noun basically. My friend was Black Cock
Jesus Christ. You couldn't figure out how to string two independent clauses together without some picture website explicitly telling you how?
In your first comment - that you deleted but remains in my inbox - you said:
I can't believe you couldn't figure out how to use a semicolon without being taught by a webcomic; It's really not that difficult. Seriously, does anyone read books anyone?
Did you delete it because you realized you capitalized "it's" incorrectly? Not so easy is it, hater. And for the record I knew how, I was being polite.
'It's' is correct in his usage, since it's short for 'it is'.
Also, if you really want to know how to use semicolons correctly, you need to know all about conjunctive adverbs, which aren't on the webcomic.
Nope. He capitalized it. That's wrong.
We can't all be as cool as you =(
See? Spam does work!
It didn't take long for the Reddit hive mind to turn on the Oatmeal. One minute the hive mind loves you the next you are some scum sucking spammer.
I've always thought he's a spammer, and never understood why he didn't get blocked.
It's not like he's a redditor who contributes regularly, and also happens to have a website. -- in that case I'd give him my full support.
But the only reason he's here is to market his website. How many posts and submissions by him can you find that are not self-referential?
Do I enjoy his comics? Sometimes. But Reddit is not about marketing your website exclusively, regardless of how much people will like it. -- You can link to it from time to time if you made something you really think is worth sharing--I do--, but you can't come here for the sole purpose of promoting your product and then try and sell me this wide-eyed-innocence B.S "ZOMG, guys, thanks to you little old me got a book deal!"
I've submitted a ton of content to reddit from all over the web, just not my own.
^ . And even if he were just submitting his own content, you know what, I LIKE his damn comics. This is why I come to reddit - to see interesting content and to enjoy my time here. If Giantbatfart contributes one god damn second of possible enjoyment to my day then yes, Giantbatfart deserves to not only post but be respected. And thus I type a sentence I never thought I would type - Giantbatfart has my support. His shits interesting and I want to click on it. That is all.
I've always thought he's a spammer, and never understood why he didn't get blocked.
Robots are pretty much the only ones that get banned. And cr3.
If he wasn't contributing, he wouldn't be getting upvotes.
The Reddit hive mind still loves the Oatmeal. There are just plenty of us around here who thought it was stupid from day 1.
Spam is advertising. Advertising is not all bad.
For a real life example: I receive crap-loads of junk mail into my mailbox each day. In general, it is wasteful and obnoxious because it gets tossed and I didn't want it.
However, I love browsing through a couple free catalogues that I regularly get, dreaming about what I might buy one day when I'm rich. Silly? Yes. But I don't have a problem getting these catalogues.
If you see crappy blogspam posted to reddit, downvote it and report it to r/reportthespammers.
This wouldn't work with The Oatmeal, however, because people ENJOY it. They want to read comics about bacon and working for obnoxious clients and buying printers. This is the great thing about the internet. All-you-can eat free content, but you have to put up with advertisers and marketing schemes. Nobody likes to feel they have been duped by a marketer, but the truth is they should just do what they like and view what they enjoy and not worry too much about how the content became available.
PS. This doesn't mean that one shouldn't consider the fact that any information people have, people have because someone paid them to have it. This mind frame will encourage skepticism without encouraging people to hate on all self-marketers.
Edit/ TLDR: Don't be ashamed Oatmeal, do yo thang. Just make sure you ahead o the game.
How much you enjoy spam has nothing to do with it being spam.
According to your logic, if I need and want my dick to be hard, all that unsolicited viagra e-mail is suddenly not spam.
Brilliant.
[deleted]
So, I have to get angry at the message for it to qualify as spam?
That's retarded. The very reason spam is still used extensively by obnoxious assholes is because a very small percentage of recipients will respond favorably.
It's still spam.
I look different from how I draw myself, so don't go looking for an obese bald guy. Look for this guy instead.
The Oatmeal to me has always been a bald fat guy chowing down on buckets of oatmeal and drawing comics. How dare you break my illusion! This handsome, well dressed white male is just a clever ruse!!!
[deleted]
Not only that but it was Dennis all along.
Also is it just me or has The Oatmeal:
So, what's left?
Didn't the last guy to post a link to his facebook profile on Reddit get a couple of thousand friend requests?
Yep, guy's a marketing genius.
Way to go, dude! Now - if I buy one of your old books, will you sign it?
yep, just email support and I'll make sure they ship you a signed one
Hurry, quick, before all of them are gone! They'll be worth hundreds per case soon!
*edit: btw, I just want to make a disclaimer that some might not pick up on the fully intended sarcasm of this and hate me. I am just kidding and I honestly do think that it would be a good investment to pick up an original Oatmeal book.
Stop being a pussy and say what you want to say... I hate when people see their Karma falling and backpedal like motherfuckers.
Man up.
Yeah! Grow redditballs.
The best kind of balls.
Big hairy redditballs.
People should be able to explain themselves when they are misunderstood.
Stop being a pussy .. motherfuckers ... man up.
Stay classy.
For some reason I read your edit in Cartman's voice
July 2009?? That's amazing for such a short period of time. The power of the web to reward talent and effort can bring a tear to your eye.
Take that view and do a 180.
I think it's fucking spectacular how quickly those who are talented and productive can get noticed on the net. Now if I could only figure out how to do one or the other.
...that's exactly what I was trying to say.
Hence my login name.
I totally misread your comment. As I was reading through the comments and found myself in the "hate zone" (where your comment was at the time), I read just the opposite of what your wrote.
So, now I retract what I said and restate in agreement.
It's fucking amazing.
As I was reading through the comments and found myself in the "hate zone"
So, now I retract what I said and restate in agreement.
It's fucking amazing.
Upvoted.
Congrats! It'll make a kick-arse coffee table book at my place.
that comment woulda been better with a throwaway like "Kramer" ...
rushes to check if "Kramer" still available
Was it‽
The Oatmeal provides a refreshing and sometimes insightful perspective on things. Its also a testament to how one person can make a living doing what they love.
Personally, I love the one about printers.
I never thought about punching dolphins until he gave some reasons for it. Now, I want to punch them all the time!
In light of recent events, I don't recommend this.
I liked that one where he made a list about stuff!
Digg???
Hey! Digg is reddit's rival!! Let's get incredulous about them being mentioned in our presence!
Hey, they're our rivals!
They can be your rival. We have none.
Hey, who are you to call him out on that. You didn't even know what an interrobang was until 18 minutes ago! Look out everyone, he must be a spy sent from Digg! Get the pitchforks!
I'm still slightly stunned.
Boy, we really hate Digg, don't we?
the diggbar has bad karma
Well, let's face it
I want to formally thank Digg and Reddit for being such spectacularly awesome communities.
BUT HE SAID DIGG FIRST
You'd think someone of his talent would have posted 2 separate links - one on D-gg with D-gg mentioned first, and the other on Reddit with Reddit mentioned first.
Ah nuts, I just did it, too.
Read the whole thing - he mentions Digg first in one sentence, and Reddit first in another. Plus, Digg does come first alphabetically.
I love it when I drunk-comment something, and get a bunch of responses.
BTW, Digg sucks!
This thread is a perfect example of why it's wonderful to be able to see the number of upvotes and downvotes separately, via the greasemonkey addon and Reddit Uppers and Downers Enhanced
Apparently The Oatmeal has a bunch of butthurt followers who spend their time on Reddit downvoting anyone who says anything positive about the Oatmeal.
It's nice to be able to see that a decent comment with a score of +4 actually received 18 upvotes, but that every pro-Oatmeal comment has 14 downvotes.
I expect this comment will be downvoted as well, because I'm spamming in favor of oatmeals and greasemonkeys.
I was actually thinking just the opposite. It's nice to know not every one likes this shit.
Maybe I'm just old-fashioned, and don't see why people express their opinions in the form of a downvote carpet bomb instead of using their words.
Then again, I still cling to the archaic Reddiquette of upvoting those who contribute to the discussion, even if I don't agree with them.
I don't particularly care for the Oatmeal's stuff, but I won't downvote his commenters because of that.
I agree that people shouldn't carpet downvote or downvote based on disagreeing with a post but at the same time a good half of these comments are simply "I think this comic is great" or "congratulations". I fail to see how a comment saying "this is great" is any different from posting "LOL". This also relates to one of the reasons for upvotes: if someone has already stated the thing you came to post, you can simply upvote them instead of making the same comment again.
I used my words, I'm at -43 points right now.
I was wondering why every single comment posted had a shitload of downvotes. Thats sad, why cant people be happy for others? Good job giantbatfart! May the farts of bats grow even more gigantic then they are now!
I've never really found the oatmeal very consistently funny. At best it's maybe on par with some of the vaguely tolerable university newspaper comics I've seen.
Given the scale and opportunity, I say good luck to the Oatmeal. The guy has worked hard to get where he is and if it can make him a small fortune then be happy for him. I don't understand all the hate and envy on Reddit regarding the success.
Yes Digg and Reddit have been excellent platforms, but he is not pushing out spam. Are people so naive that people do things out of the kindness of their own hearts?, of course not. But what separates the two is providing good source of information or service. See XKCD , Reddit , IMGUR . Yes they are trying to make money, but at least they meet peoples needs in some way.
The hivemind loves the underdog, hates massive companies. Eventually the underdog hits economies of scale and becomes big. Decisions are being made for the benefit of profit in unethical ways. See Microsoft, AT&T, Nestle. So what happens? We hate them. I'm sorry but we live in a capitalist system and that's the way it is. There is too much cynical-ism with being labeled 'bad' to make a profit. You want a good life?, then go out and earn it and make as much as you can. If not then some other dude will.
LoveGiantBatFart made a comment regarding GiantBatFart (wtf am I writing?) about knowing how to game the system. Now the only reason Digg and Reddit have been openly accepted on nearly every site (digg this, reddit it) is because its a fantastic method of driving traffic to websites. If it had no effect then Digg and Reddit would not have become so popular.
Essentially what I'm trying to say is that the evolution of businesses all hit for that shiny profit button, that's business. If you won't take advantage of popularity and make some money off it then you are a fool.
The only quip I have is the bloody 'Fertigo Pro' font in the logo. If that becomes associated with the Oatmeal then I WILL RAIN HELLS FIRE UPON ALL THAT BEAR IT!
if it can make him a small fortune
It will probably be small. I don't think many of the people who get book deals based on their websites make all that much money for them.
I know two authors who have been down this path and neither has quit "their day job".
Good luck to The Oatmeal nonetheless.
Dear Mr. Oatmeal, First of all, job well done on the book. I'm sure it will be filled with awesome oatmeal recipes that I can share with the Quakers I have locked in my basement.
They're an alright bunch, especially Jacob, who has seamlessly braided his beard with his butt hair. I pretend not to be amused since I am his master, but I have to tell you, it is a sight!
Secondly, I send you tweets everyday but you never respond and this makes me cry giant crocodile tears. It is ok though, I have Jacob's ass beard to dry them.
Kevin
Sorry about the twitter thing. Everytime someone takes one of my quizzes, they post the results to twitter with @oatmeal attached to it, so it becomes really tough to differentiate real tweets with the quiz ones.
Sorry about the twitter thing. Everytime someone takes one of my quizzes, they post the results to twitter with @oatmeal attached to it, so it becomes really tough to differentiate real tweets with the quiz ones.
Ask people, in the quiz pages, to use #oatmeal (or even #theoatmeal), instead of @oatmeal when posting their results, or when posting stuff about The Oatmeal.
Zaffle's a genius.
Have the quiz generate a link you can click on on the results page to automatically submit an update to twitter that says something like "I took x quiz at #theoatmeal and the results were y".
That's quite alright.
BTW, I just killed Jacob.
And at any rate, I would like to propose to you an idea for a children's book. I will write it and you will illustrate it. It's about a talking bear who lives in a van. I think it would be very popular.
hasn't 4chan already illustrated that book?
Sick. You've got a sale right here.
Yay for mediocrity
Your shit sucks.
Well, that is amazing. I will be purchasing your book as soon as it is released!
YOU deserve it, your stuff is great! thanks for giving all us other artists hope! CONGRATULATIONS :) I'll will def buy the book :P
Congrats man! Love The Oatmeal.
He is a former SEOmoz guy, he knows his way around to game the system and draw traffic. I have seen some of his work during his time with Seomoz and also after he left them. I think he also designed the original Seomoz site (which was nicer than the current one). He also made a dating site (I think in one week) called mingle2 which he later sold it.
When he started making these comics, each comic had their own unique domain name and he would get them on the digg frontpage. Usually after digg frontpage the traffic was still coming in so he would link them to mingle2 website to drive traffic there. I think I have seen him link to other sites too, possibly his other clients (including an insurance company, but I could be wrong, that was more than a year ago).
The reason I am telling you this, because I think its important to put things in to perspective. He is an SEO guy, he has been around for some time and he knows how to "game" the system.
It doesn't take away the fact that some of his work is genuinely very good and funny and I have personally enjoyed them.
Edit: Some notes I could find after short googling
This guy is much much better than I will ever be. But its good to have some perspective and knowledge. He knows the system inside out, while you guys are being amazed by raptors he is doing his thing.
I am writing this from my disposable account, because I seriously fear this guy and I think he can do some harm to me if I post from my regular account. Because I use the same name for my other online identities.
By the way, Congratulations on the book deal. I actually bought your self-published comic last year.
Edit2: I am proud of myself knowing that I have such good memories. Remember the insurance company I mentioned earlier? Here is the digg submission by him to StateFarm Insurance website from 2007. More Gems, if you have the patience to digg around.
Last word before I am done with this comment. Please do take me seriously when I say this, Reddit is as much prone to "gaming" as digg. It might not be as easy, but it is most definitely possible. You really think when there is $100,000s potentially on the line in the future to get something viral someone won't invest on few dozen machines (renting unique ips is literally peanut money) with unique ips to get their story/business/blog/ in to more eyes? It happens all the time, now they are just good at it.
We like to believe that Reddit is not prone to gaming, because we love reddit. It can't possibly happen. If you have some background on how SEO viral marketing works, you would also think like me and be skeptical about certain things.
Food for thought.
Edit3: http://twitter.com/Oatmeal/status/9719405603 | Screenshot
You certainly know your history.
One thing i want to clarify though, I'm not "gaming" anything. When I create a new comic, I go to reddit, enter in a URL and title, and click submit. Seriously, that's it. The only real "trick" I know is that if you title it in the first person (ie: "Dear reddit, I [insert something here]") it tends to get more upvotes. I've covered this before.
haha..seriously? "The oatmeal is good at social media, HE'LL EAT YOUR CHILDREN WHILE THEY SLEEP."
Everything else you said I pretty much summed up during my AMA:
Whenever anyone seems to be doing suspciously well on reddit, we have certain tests we do, certain things we check, to make sure they didn't find some new way to cheat that we're not yet detecting and stopping. After your repeated early successes, we took a good long look at where your votes were coming from... and found absolutely nothing out of the ordinary.
So I'll say this for all of reddit to hear: GiantBatFart / TheOatmeal has found the ultimate way to game reddit, and has been doing so extensively for quite some time now. Here's his secret trick:
It's absolutely foolproof and evades all our anti-cheating measures. We encourage all SEO / spammer types to follow in his footsteps.
Edit: By the way, I can't speak for the entire reddit community, but we the admins don't care what anybody's past is. I don't know whether or not you were the evil kind of SEO guy in the past, but you aren't now (or, at the very least you aren't in your dealings with reddit), and that's all that matters. We believe in second chances and clean slates, and that anyone can turn themselves into a productive and beneficial member of the community. Even violentacrez.
Then why did you ban cr3?
This, this, and more this...
When kn0thing bans someone for "viral marketing" for making something comepletely original and cool, just because they're from samsung, and another admin basically says "what that guy did is perfectly fine" it just makes me think something really really sketchy is going on behind the scenes at reddit....
Who was cr3? I don't remember that one...
After looking into this, I am wondering the same thing.
kn0thing no longer works for reddit, and cr3 did nothing wrong. Give him back his account.
If you know him, have him send me a private message.
That and then there's this. I'm not sure why he felt the need to send that to me because I don't like his work and make it a point to tell him that, but he did.
A screen cap of a message taken out of context?
Oh my, send in the troops now.
balls
Wait, I just saw this and because you stated that opinion he sicced his 'followers' on you saying "This is why I hate reddit"?!?
Reddit, I don't think that's to be defended
Because you're a colossal idiot. That's why.
Kewl. It's positive how you (the admins) give immediate feedback about this issues. Now, would you please express an official stance (or at least your opinion) about this? Thanks.
http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b7e25/today_i_learned_that_one_of_reddits_most_active/
What part of it? If you're asking if I'm aware of any evidence that Saydrah is participating in "you guys vote for my stuff and I'll vote for yours" rings or cheating in any other way, no, I haven't seen anything like that.
If you're asking for my personal feelings about all this, it's disturbingly like a witch hunt. What exactly is she being accused of?
When does it stop becoming self promotion and start becoming "gaming" (or whatever the evil version is). Is it when you submit other people's stuff, as opposed to content you created? (I actually have no idea).
http://www.reddit.com/help/faq#Whatconstitutescheating
Whoah whoah there. If I recall, violentacrez was in a several month long spitting contest with another user on reddit.
Oh? Was it me?
Humm
I'm onto your evil game, Oatmeal. How dare you produce original content and then increase the number of people who see it by the nefarious means of submitting it to sites that are designed for that exact purpose?
THIS AGGRESSION WILL NOT STAND.
posted from fake account behind eight proxies. you wont get in my facebooks with your php skills
Oh really... Peter?
:O
a hacker.
shut.
down.
EVERYTHING.
I know this is off-topic, but every time I read one of your comics, my family thinks I am insane because I start cackling loudly in my room.
Most of the time I don't believe these sorts of statements, but with you, I don't have to think...I know that you're telling the truth. Now I'm imagining an insane and cackling honest person. The mental imagery is amazing.
I mean EVERY time. It's like this guy has a direct line to my sense of humour.
I find his comics to be absolute shit, really. They are all the same thing: mix some facts with some non-sequitors, illustrate, and promote. I'm really sick of non-sequitors.
I wouldn't be surprised if the top commenter is you. He has certainly built you up into a superman. Getting mingle2 out the way you did is pretty inspiring, makes me want to consider switching to RoR to see what the fuss is about.
Well, technically I started out with CakePHP, but when I sold the site and it merged with it was ported to RoR. Both are great frameworks though.
I'm drunk, and I'm a very honest drunk. I like your comics. I upvote them because they are amusing.
But yet you do enjoy using your fan base to go out and do your bidding
You're charles fucking manson... except I'm guessing that your followers are even more socially mal-adapted than his were.
He creates comics that I think are funny therefore I up vote him.
Fuck all that other shit. Unless he roasts babies on a spit and eats them I'll keep up voting his stuff.
And even then... I mean, his comics are pretty funny. As long as he isn't in your face about how everyone should roast babies, I think we're ok.
No, I would probably even upvote a video of him roasting babies on a spit and eating them, but simultaneously upvote the post condemning the man who posted a video of himself roasting babies on a spit and eating them using my alternate accounts.
Would that really stop you? Thnk of the little bitch-ass crying t-rex.
Good for him. He puts a lot of thought and effort into making sure his work is seen by the people who would like it. That is literally the goal of every single entertainer in every medium throughout history. That is entirely what the industry is about.
More worryingly, though, is the fact that this thread crops up on the day he posts about his book being published. Why does Reddit often seem to hate success? You're going after him like the clever workarounds and dedicated effort he's shown make him less worthy or his accomplishments less impressive. Like working for it separates him from the true Reddit somehow.
I myself am an editor and writer for a site that appears on the frontpage pretty regularly, and I though I never really submit it, I certainly always support our stuff when it crops up. I got the editor job four months ago, I started writing regularly for them about a year and a half ago, and I just got my two year badge on Reddit. I'm a bit of a lurker, but I was here first.
For Redditors who have work cropping up here: It's not that we are people exploiting Reddit once we succeed, we're just Redditors that are also succeeding. You should be rooting for him and holding him up as an example of the great lengths that success in your field requires. He's a great example of the reality of an entertainment career. You cannot just draw something funny and assume the world will beat down your door; it's work. If I'm reading this correctly, he held what is essentially three jobs - a full time day job, a job creating this content, and a job promoting and marketing this content - for a very long time before the book deal and any sort of measurable success.
I say he earned it.
Exactly. I think it's great that Reddit can allow an individual's work, like his, to reach people without even needing some large corporate backing. If anything, this is an example of something Redditors should be proud of.
Just like indie music: if he makes money out of it, he is a bad guy.
tl;dr; for the above post: reddit shall not be used in any productive way.
He fully admitted all this, including the SEO stuff, in his IAMA.
Saydrah essentially said what I wanted to about his "gaming the system", but more betterer than I could.
Pfffft... Melodramatic much? He seems like a nice enough guy and you didn't say anything that he hasn't openly admitted to. Read his IAMA.
p.s. If you want someone to fear, it's not an SEO guy like BatFart, it's a former computer forensics tech like myself who has a knack for tracking people down via their handle. There are also a few fraud investigators I've met on reddit who do that for a living. That wasn't mean to be a threat BTW. I just wanted to point out how silly and melodramatic this guy is for trying to make it seem like SEO guys are Eeeeeevil and Scaaaaaary and have magical internet Powwwwwers!
So let me get this right. you're okay with putting down Bat as conceited and patronizing, but you boast "If you want someone to fear... it's [someone] like myself." Well, humble is not exactly oozing out here.
I was being facetious. I'm just illustrating the fact that there are much worse things and people to worry about on the internet than an SEO specialist who draws comics for a living. The worst that GiantBatFart could do is set an army of downmodders on LovesGiantBatFarts main account. Oh God, the horror!
done and done OH THE HUMANITY
Sounds like fun - is there a stalking subreddit?
[deleted]
I would join.
So all of this time I've been gamed into seeing comics I like?
NOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You think he would hurt you over this? Aren't you going a little too far?
No. When you have internet full of blind followers behind you, you have the authority to do some real damage to people (not physically). He is fairly tech savvy he should know how to get information about someone just from a handle (esp if that handle name is used often for other online services).
See also:
I also heard the PBFcomic guy is good at making webcomics, and Maddox got on digg a couple times. THEY'RE OUT TO GET YOU, LOVEGIANTBATFART.
cue the hard copy intro music
I was on the front page of Digg and Reddit on the same day once too, Oatmeal. I will tell you more about it at the Masonic Lodge this weekend.
I guess I just don't understand what you think his motive to go after you would be?
He's going to want revenge because you said he's good at using sites like reddit to promote his content? I don't understand why he would do that. It seems like you gave him a compliment.
[deleted]
I remember when that guy who wrote Goobs put a craigslist hit on the guy who writes Perry Bible Fellowship.
Yeah, you know he's capable of it, he knows SEO.
The groups that make coin from gaming digg clicks, would just as frequently use their buddy nets to gang bury opponents. Maybe "hurt" is a little strong, but censor/bury/downvote - sure, it's a common practice.
[deleted]
This is why 4chan remains the most 'neutral' of all message boards.
And it's frightening.
Did you really think you were going to get away with a reference like that on Reddit? But I do have to give it to you for trying: Clever girl!
He can't see us if we don't move
[deleted]
All of this can be found at http://0at.org/ it's no secret.
So basically what you're saying is this guy is successful because he knows how to make good content. HOLY SHIT NO WAY
SEO has absolutely nothing to do with why I personally find his comics enjoyable. It might have a great deal to do with why they are popular, but not why they are enjoyable. As a student of web development myself, if anything, any "gaming" of the system that has taken place just serves to make the creator of the comic more interesting in my eyes.
This is an interesting comment, but I am having a very hard time trying to figure out what made you think it would be appropriate in this thread aside from just attempting to hate.
Um... you act like SEO is black magic or something when the truth is it's more like common sense.
Wow. What a fucking Douchebag with a capital D. Not you, but Inman. I liked his comics and the site, but not anymore. Not that I have a problem with the whole 'gaming the system' but that twitter post made me lose any respect for him.
Edit: In addition to design, linkbait, and viral marketing, - dooooooooooooooooooooooooche
I remember when he said he was quitting doing something to work on his 'baitlink' business.
Very interesting, thanks. Mind explaining how the Oatmeal could harm you?
My view is that non-deceptive self-promotion is fine. Renting unique IP's is NOT OK.
Yeah I love listening to people justify whoring out their words for some company.
"Oh look! I made money, that's all that matters!"
Honestly everything you are saying is true, but is that really a reason to hate on him?
I don't hate him....
[deleted]
[deleted]
wow, talk about paranoid a-holes in the interwebs. So, yeah, the guy has done the same thing in a variety of formats and under different nicknames, blah blah. Do you really think he is going to punch you in the face or somehow harass you because you "exposed" him?
teh internet is serious business
So "unique IPs benefits SEO" is not a myth? Could you please clarify?
I googled and foi a post from Matt Cutts from 2006. He says that this isn't a factor that could harm PR.
[deleted]
You know as much thought as you put into about this guy, you could develop your own content.
[deleted]
I already knew a bunch of this stuff. He's got SEO down to a fine art, just like his comics. Good stuff.
There's lessons to be learned here.
Please! This is supposed to be a happy occasion! Let's not bicker and argue over who gamed who...
Please expand on this. How can someone "game" us into liking stuff that we don't like? The Oatmeal is funny, people upvote it and like it, but how can you make us upvote something we don't like? I guess you can do the old "hey, let's hate this!", but no other method comes to mind (not just because I'm hungover).
Let's say that we put something on the front page that can be considered viral in a business way, is there some reason we wouldn't like it just because of its background (making money)?
It's very simple, you get a bunch of "friendly" accounts to upvote things early on, so it seems like everyone else likes the link and it snowballs. You have to be somewhat naive if you don't think this happens, even the people doing it brag about how many eyeballs they can move. Sometimes, it's just that they have a larger "natural" social group, and other times it's because they're an organized group "gaming" the system.
People dumb enough to upvote something they don't like just because it's popular really don't deserve anything better than being "gamed".
I don't know about the other side, but I click on things that sound interesting, the only thing that the front page does is that I click on it sooner than the other stuff. If out of 25 items of my front page, one or two are "gamed" or manipulated in some way - I'll live with it and just won't click. The choice we all have.
Even when you go to a subreddit, the screen you're looking still shows posts that are gaining momentum or have a large number of votes. Most users go to the default "what's hot" page, and never see things that haven't been clicked up for them a few times by others. Someone who wants eyes on their site, doesn't care if they miss a few thoughtful people like yourself, it's purely a numbers game. Anyway, even while gaming a "social" site, it's hard to get "just anything" to fly - the content usually has to be good enough to at least stop people from downvoting like crazy once it starts getting more hits.
One or two?
Just won't click?
Does it really matter that much? His content is good.
@LoveGiantBatFart: UMADBRO?
People like what they like. Even if the Oatmeal is "gaming" the system, I wouldn't have added the site to my RSS feed if it was full of vapid, boring content. Like you said, the Oatmeal is a genuinely good site, so what's the problem?
Damn http://www.seomoz.org/blog/widgetbait-gone-wild has gone "page not found", hmmmz...
You are a crazy person. That's totally okay.
sounds like your hating dude
.
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]
No lolin' or trollin'.
I upvoted you, but I think it's important to note that Reddit is a site that explicitly invites self-promotion when it's conducted in an appropriate manner. I personally don't find most of The Oatmeal's comics very funny (though the one about why he hates talking on the phone made me chuckle) but he's a friendly fellow who is nothing if not honest about that he's promoting his own sites and making money. He's also a decent cartoonist and seems to be a hard worker.
In short, if he's "gaming the system" by creating original content that people like and presenting it in an attractive manner that's not full of gratuitous ugly ads, more power to him. I'd rather have 100 like him on Reddit than the people who start a blog and post one stolen image at a time with five or six Google ads per page and then spam it to r/pics.
[deleted]
I'd like to know more about this.
An issue came up not long ago, about Saydrah. She gets paid to submit to reddit, and boasts to her employers about her position at reddit. Saying she has a large following and can get any content she wants to the front page of a website with millions of hits
This wouldn't be an issue except she is a mod, so she adds that to her resume, she is paid to submit to reddit , so how do we know she doesn't abuse it? No one check up on her
here's an upvote to help stem the down votey tide of down votes.
Here is the THE SMOKING GUN on Saydrah:
Her real name is Jelena XXXXX*:
Here's her video interview for Associated Content! She mentions REDDIT at 5:50 & 8:35 & 14:40 & 19:15
Here's her Linkedin
Here's an interview she did
Here's an article by her on Associated Content
*myspace linking Lisa Droesdov to Jelena
Edit: After thinking about alecb's comment I've decided to omit her last name & replace some links with screenshots. I think her name is relevant to anyone who wants to investigate it themselves, but I also see how this could lead to harassment. Screenshots still provide the damning evidence, and if you really want to investigate it further, the info is easy to find through google.
I don't like this Saydrah person. I didn't like her after that whole ex-moderator releasing private info debacle, I thought she acted inappropriately.
EVIL
Oh my fucking god are you serious
She's pretty much saying "I'm a spammer but I occasionally submit content that's actually useful so I don't get blocked" Jesus.
tee hee, her surname is an anagram of whore.
Reddit: WTF? GTFO!
Saydrah: Time to reroll LOL!
Wow, she appears to be a total fucking bitch.
Jelena->Lisa link quoted, lest she take it down:
(Where [name] is the name of an apparently-unrelated third party.)
Holy. Shit.
What that's front page almost everyday.
qgh2 is pronounced quiggyh2. huh, who knew. I mean...wait...sorry...BURN THE WITCH.
Hiding her surname doesn't really do anything. A Google search for Jelena Disaboom or similar will provide the surname immediately anyway.
Then again, maybe you're just trying to prevent Google's spider picking up on this and returning this thread if someone searches for her?
Can someone explain what's so wrong about what Saydrah is doing?
She is not faking votes on her submissions, she is not lying about what she does, she is participating in parts of reddit unrelated to her work, she follows reddits rules.
True, she gets paid to surf reddit, and occasionally submits a link to her associated websites, but those links are on an equal footing to mine or yours.
If I saw evidence she had a voting ring spamming her paid links to the front page I would join in the witch-hunt, but all I see is stuff that doesn't effect my enjoyment of reddit, or it's integrity.
It's very ethical of you to block her last name, good sir. There's one that was missed out in the LinkedIn pic though.
So, she isn't a "he"?
Sighs in relief...
Jelena Woehr - You fuckin' pussy.
You Forgot to omit her name in the article about business and technology. It say her last name is Woehr right at the beginning.
You sir win the internet's!
Not to mention that you can see a damn reddit bobblehead in the bottom right corner.
You, sir, deserve a white hat, some hat at least.
Funnily enough, she looks exactly like I pictured her.
edit: also - I really want to know what she needed to tell Alyssa that was so important she had to create a fake myspace profile to do it.
[deleted]
she kinda looks like a blonde donkey or possibly Joe Camel's illegitimate daughter.
LOL...Is that the Reddit alien at her left elbow in the AC interview??
[deleted]
Wow, what a dog.
Just FYI, I think this is wrong, but you should remove the linkedin link if possible, because I found her in about 3 seconds searching the contents of it. Blame Linkedin for indexing the whole text on the profile.
Just so that it doesn't escalate.
Her name is Jelena Caroline Woehr. She lives here: http://maps.google.com/maps?q=80403+GOLDEN,+CO&oe=utf-8&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:unofficial&client=firefox-a&um=1&ie=UTF-8&hq=&hnear=Golden,+CO&ei=dqaKS9vMO5CK_AbTp-zpBg&sa=X&oi=geocode_result&ct=image&resnum=1&ved=0CAgQ8gEwAA
She may be into bestiality with horses and hamsters.
Damn that bitch is fugly.
WHAT. THE. FUCK. REDDIT.
Iceberg, tip of.
SirOblivious, if you're ever in my part of the world I'm going to bake you something. This just made my night.
Sounds good, I just really worry that the democracy of reddit will be ruined.
By things like this
http://i.imgur.com/qr7Go.png
Saydrah must be removed from her post at once!
She must be shat on. C'mon on reddit, who's in for a collective dump on Saydrah?
I don't see how this isn't worthy of account deletion.
This leaves a sore taste in my mouth. =/
This has destroyed my faith in reddit . gonna have to consider alternative sites
A "sore" taste? What does a sore mouth taste like? Insert inappropriate joke here
Could I interest you in trading that "e" for a different vowel and moving it to the left a bit?
There's lots of them. It's been happening for ages, and on most social media websites.
E.g. How many people really believe the whole Internet spontaneously came together on the side of a corporation hiring a guerrilla/viral/astroturf marketing firm engaging in vandalism? Really?
http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/awd9j/013107_never_forget/
Virtually all negative comments get downvoted/moderated out:
http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/awd9j/013107_never_forget/c0jquft
If the marketing firms do a good first response, as they did extremely well in this case (lots of other guerilla marketing companies joined in -- bad press from something like this could kill the fledgling industry), this gives the appearance of unanimous Internet consensus. People tend to follow crowds -- almost no Democrats in Dallas or Republicans in Boston. At this point, it becomes obvious, popular truth that not only law enforcement messed up (which it did), but that false corollary that Turner/Interference Inc./the vandals did nothing wrong. The few people who think deeply and critically about what happened exist, but are few enough and don't care enough to overcome the swarm of marketers on reddit.
Now you've got a successful viral PR campaign (in this case, damage control, but in other cases, political, or sales, or whatever).
I picked one example, but this kind of stuff happens all the time. You've got to be critical of anything you see on the Internet, but especially of comparatively anonymous, gameable things like reddit, digg, and slashdot. If someone has money -- and not that much money -- they can create 100 accounts on each major social media website and keep them going. Given crowd dynamics, that's way more than enough for any viral marketing campaign. I know of no way to prevent this. I can hire 100 people in India, China, or Africa to post comments on social media, periodically promoting client firms, for an order of magnitude less cost than running a Superbowl ad.
This one is only special in that she was stupid enough to get caught.
I'm a little nervous to say this but here goes. I'm in the 'social media marketing' business. And here are my thoughts on this BS.
While I'm not directly involved in any campaigns at the moment (I'm more metrics side of things) when I worked more strategy side spamming reddit/dig/any other site NEVER , I repeat NEVER came to mind. Why because its spamming people and doesn't make any real business sense, all it is is cheap hits.
Hanging out with other Social Media marketers Reddit doesn't even come up on people's radar. What Social media is is the creation of space on the internet where people can talk about brands/ the management of a corporate brand on the web. While I encourage bloggers/websites to us a social link tool to make their content easier to share with people who legitimately want share their content gaming any social sites just so you can have massive traffic is a waste of time and money.
All in all Saydrah should take any mention of Social Media w/e off of her online profiles as that is completely not what she is. She is a SPAMMER! Not someone who connects companies and interested consumers together to create value (wow this sounds so corporate....I'm sorry) she's just looking to give websites a quick hit of traffic and exposure.
TL:DR Saydrah is a spammer. Social Media Marketing isn't gaming reddit.
Agree, except for this.
Just to follow up, when this thread was posted, the comment linked to (http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/awd9j/013107_never_forget/c0jquft) was waaay downvoted and impossible to find from the main reddit story (-8 when I saw it, and presumably lower before). As of now (presumably as a result of people reading forcing_factor's post), it is at zero.
There isn't a delay between the submission of 2 links? Because the pics of her posting is simply insane.
Exactly 3 min apart is fast, I don't think you could it 20 times in row that quickly each time
I've enjoyed her posts in r/awww
But that image you link showing the frequency of posts - that has disturbed me. It's not in the spirit of finding a few nice links and posting them. It looks at best compulsive, at worst organised/deliberate.
I don't know what to think any more because she posts a lot of interesting stuff, but that image of the quantity and frequency of posts really reeks of wrongness.
Yeah that's not the posting of someone, at least to me, who enjoy sharing and talking about stuffs. It's impossible to find, read, and submit so much links so quickly.
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
I guess now we know - SirOblivious does.
Well, damn it. Now, quis custodiet ipsos SirOblivious?
What actually can moderators do which others can't? Can they cancel accounts? Click the down arrow more than once and have it count?
Epic work my friend. One down, a few thousand to go.
I won't be satisfied until Saydrah voluntarily decides to leave Reddit once and for all. Forcing her out won't work, because she can always create another account.
This is so fucking outrageous!
Won't somebody think of the children?!?!?!
How do we know you're not actually Saydrah posting this stuff about yourself from another username?
This is really fishy indeed.
How do we know YOU'RE not actually Saydrah posting this stuff from another username?
Your theory would explain why she created a subreddit that is a prime example of the mainstream media "enlightened middle" scam (accuse two groups of being extremes, pull together a group of 'moderates', refuse to uninvite guests despite deplorable statements and behavior, insist that honest active-voiced comments are arrogant, and praise only the language of the co-opting concern troll) called 'equality'...
Wow - I never even considered that sort of scam shit going on. That would sure explain a lot of stuff I've seen in the past.
Wow, just wow.
Fascinating thought, but you can expand on it? Tell me more about the enlightened middle thing and mainstream media and where I can read more about this concept. I find things like this fascinating, and I want to read more about it.
Erm, simply put?
Bestofed here Sir.
this can be easily fixed, every time you see a new link by saydrah, down vote it to hell
And don't click on it.
The irony of this all is that all this extra attention is bound to get more clicks for her submissions.
[deleted]
Sharp intake of breath
....Bitch.
Yeah, I will check it to see if they blame it on misogyny.
So, the question here, is who is filling SirOblivious's coffers? Come on! Somebody dig up the dirt on him!
Agreed, if I were to spam reddit I would be banned, not promoted to Moderator.
He has 1 link karma...
Who does this?!
People who make a living out of it?
Saydrah.
jelena woehr
All of this has happened before and all of this will happen again.
Report the Spammers - Saydrah
Post her Linked-In profile please.
It was deleted, probably for nefarious purposes. The Hivemind was getting wise to the magnitude of the spamming.
Yes Sir
http://i.imgur.com/qr7Go.png
Hey... you're lying to reddit, you're not really oblivious. You just use that name to lure us in to a false sense of security and them Bam! dirty laundry everywhere.
Sorry, I couldn't stop laughing at the fleshlight reference.
This is possibly the most interesting thing I've read on reddit in months. Thank you for your attention to detail.
I've noticed the attitude from Saydrah/Lisa Droesdov a number of times, but I never understood why...now I do.
Thanks again, SirOblivious, you did a noble deed today.
Was this deleted off the original thread? - I did not see it.
Wow. I'd always enjoyed her relationship advice.
Dude, her advice is always canned, useless dear abby type of shit.
So it's decent content then? I've not seen it myself, but if you enjoy the content then really, what has changed? Every bit of content on the web is there for a reason, and 99% of the time it is there to support some money-making activity.
nominating this post for POST OF THE YEAR 2010
The most interesting thing about this thread is seeing the other power users view on this whole thing. YES I SEE YOU GUYS IN HERE!
You forgot to black something out in the first link...
Bestof 2010 nominee.
You have added her as a "friend" though? Crazy.
That way you can easily spot her submissions and comments.
[deleted]
Only long enough to track the submissions
Yeah Ashamed with a capital A!
But she's Ms July on the Reddit calender!
So you can't really call yourself oblivious now, can you? :)
By the way, how's Saydrah?
Saydrah comments a lot in relationship_advice and that doesn't seem to have anything to do with spam. Just saying, she isn't pure evil.
You're misunderstanding what she's doing in those non-spam subreddits. Watch this video of Saydrah:
http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/2168114
She mentions that, in order to not appear like spam, you submit several links to someone else's content for every link to your own content. This makes the community think the person is being authentic -- the exact ploy that you've just fallen for. Because you see that the majority of what she posts is not spam, she can get away with posting spam once in a while. This is what she mentions in the video. Go through minutes 5 through 11. Her comment on this should be within that time frame.
Elsewhere, she mentions the need to create "authentic relationships." She is clearly trying to do this with Reddit, because her non-spam persona (relationship advice, occasional comment here and there, etc.) is established well enough to allow for a minor spam persona. See what I am saying?
Yeah well Hitler built a lot of schools and shit.
Going old school on this one "Don't hate the player, hate the game". You have to admit that if your job was to browse Reddit all day...which you already do...then you would be in heaven.
So while it is important to point this shit out, it's still just a website and the first day they put ads on this site was the same day that people like Saydrah also signed up...because there is money to be made.
I posted a link to this on r/reportthespammers...
[deleted]
wow, somebody did their homework!
Wow, I didn't know there was such drama on Reddit.
Edit- I think someone should be elected to audit Reddit and review the internal control system. I hereby nominate SirOblivious.
[deleted]
You are my hero. Sometimes at night I wish I was a chick just so I could have your abortion and have it be non-homo.
[deleted]
What happened between mercurialmadnessman and Saydrah?
irony alert: 99% of redditors are getting paid to post while they are at their respective jobs
this is why i like reddIt. Saydrah matter will be investigated. Full report..pronto
Listen to you people... why does it matter if she's getting paid to promote content? Did you forget that reddit as a community decides what content is worthy of upvotes?
She could post garbage all day, but if it wasn't interesting or worth spreading it wouldn't go anywhere. This is not the case. The simple fact is that people like the content she posts...
I don't understand why this is such a big deal. If the content she posts isn't acceptable, down vote it. There will always be social networking sites, and there will always be people trying to promote their content on those sites (that's the point...)
That's life.
Now downvote me because my opinion is different. K? Thx.
Anyone care to partake in an impartial vote
i hate spam as much as anyone, but the guy is doing a service for money. admittedly a really dicky service, but why should he be ashamed?
Unless she is the moderator of the subreddits she is posting in, I don't see any ethical issue at all. Further, who gives a shit if she is making money off of it, reddit lets people pay to be "sponsors" and put stuff on the front page. Quit being a crab.
so cute and shy... http://saydrah.files.wordpress.com/2008/08/overdone2.jpg?w=461&h=614
Hardly.
ick
devious
http://i.imgur.com/qr7Go.png
Also not cute
http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/2168114
SHOOT HUUUUH!
She also has massive tits, which gets her off scott free in my book.
[deleted]
tldr; spammer caught, prob not a 'she'. stop fapping.
Actually, you should be ashamed of yourself for being retarded.
I don't care and nobody should care.
WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Reddit, this is failmod b34nz's alt account where he tries to establish credibility/rapport.
The speed posting is bad because why? Who cares. None of those look particularly advertising to me.
Also, get over this weird obsession. It's been going on for a while where someone or another is attacking her motives. I'm maybe not a 24 hour redditor but I can't say I've seen a lot of submissions by Saydrah nor have I seen lots of advertising from her. The speed posting is all pictures, am I missing something?
Why are you defending her? Why do you give a shit?
It drowns other content. That's something that reddit can change via programming, I would think.
Boohoo! Cry me a river and get on with your life.
God dammit WHO GIVES A SHIT! Not one link proves anything. She is in social media? Ok. She is a mod? Ok. She submits posts to reddit? Ok. So fucking what? That's what this site is about and it's not like she is banning every story that competes with her. There isn't one example of her using her mod powers incorrectly.
Jesus Reddit, you guys hate on cops and keep spouting that "innocent until proven guilty" shit and yet you're all pretty much just as bad.
Um, she's been proven guilty and has admitted it herself.
Learn to read.
I'm not going to dignify the rest of your post by arguing with you about it, but for the sake of the other mods like qgyh2 who get attacked the same way periodically, I feel I should point out that there's absolutely no advantage to being a moderator as far as how well one's submissions do. It's a free pass past the spam filter in those specific subreddits, but it doesn't affect voting, karma, ability to be banned by other mods (and we do ban each other's posts on occasion) ability to be reported, etc.
There was a rumor when I first got to Reddit that qgyh2 was deleting others' submissions so he could resubmit the same links himself for karma, but that's impossible--moderators can hide a submission but they can't get rid of it and repost the same thing. There's also nothing that mods can do that's invisible to the rest of the group, so a corrupt moderator would have to hypnotize everyone else in the subreddit just to get, well, no benefits whatsoever aside from not having to worry about the spam filter. And I guess with the other mods hypnotized one could also ban negative comments on their own submissions. But, of course, the admins are also de facto mods in every subreddit, so even a skilled hypnotist would have maybe a couple days until the admins caught on.
(I was going to fight this out in r/cagematch, but the guy who intended to be my opponent chickened out, so now I'm over it. Wouldn't have defended GiantBatFart if I really cared that you and the rest of MMM's little gang were going to show up with conspiracy theories.)
What does this have to do with me? Nothing. I don't have secret groups of friends who do shit for me. Grow up.
No need to argue about it, you know what you do to reddit is wrong. You work your way up on reddit and then boast about it so you can make money.
You sell out the community for money, while putting on an innocent act , everyone here knows it.
I am not going to argue with you, but it should be well known to reddit about how you use reddit for money, and its not known if you abuse your mod position or not. But the fact that they let you be a mod after knowing what you do to reddit for money, is a great shame
You bring reddit great shame , Why don't you tell everyone here right now in a post what you do for money on reddit. I will let you clear it up to everyone
You could at very least directly answer the question - are you now or have you in the past been paid or otherwise compensated to submit content to reddit?
STOP MODDING IMMEDIATELY AND STOP GETTING (AND I'M DIRECTLY QUOTING YOU NOW) A "FREE PASS PAST THE SPAM FILTER" FOR YOUR FOR-PAY SUBMISSIONS.
Is that clear enough, care to dignify that with a response?
Are you in fact paid for your submissions here?
You sort of ignored the part of how you're allowed to submit all those links so quickly... is this some feature I'm not aware of?
9
Thats not true sayds. hide post, resubmit with a "?=x" tagged on the end: profit. It is entirely possible to do what you just said was impossible.
Please, dignify at least the "free pass past the spam filter" criticism part with a response. Obviously that's what anyone really has a problem with... that and the crowing.
This isn't about qgyh2, this is about you. And you, Saydrah, are no qgyh2 and never will be. You are dirty spamming scum and you should be stripped of all mod status.
Your defense seems to be that you "technically" didn't break any rules and that the other mods should have stopped you if you were a problem.
You accepted moderator status while getting paid to submit links, and you aren't dumb enough to know why that's a bit of a problem. So fuck you, Saydrah. Fuck you very much.
Nice try, Jelena.
Check the things she down votes (dislikes) on her profile page. Wow she has problems.
The nice thing about proof is that it doesn't need to be dignified.
Says the mod who gave a comment of her own 10k upvotes for the fuck of it.
I don't have a clue why her rebuttal is being downvoted, as it seems pretty fair. I love reddit, but sometimes you guys can be sensationalist drama queens. Is this a "mods are out to get us, and now's the chance to get back at them" kind of thing? Like she, or any other moderator is going to care about losing a few karma points regardless, and downvoting her response means we see only one side of the story.
I have to agree. There are people who game the system and do it in the most awful and inappropriate way possible, but I would go as far as to say that GBF doesn't "game" the system at all, he knows how to use Reddit (and Digg) to his advantage and does that while rewarding us with clever and unique content.
More power to him, even if he's not got here through 100% luck, hell I think it's even more impressive that he used his knowledge and understanding of "the system" to get here. We could all learn a thing or two from him.
The person you are agreeing with games the system most of all
oh I know, but that doesn't make her point any less valid :-D
As I was reading the OP, this is what I was thinking. He is using social networking sites, thats part of the purpose of them. I've seen Reddit used this way for many things, "Hey guys, check out my kid being AWESOME", "Hey guys, check out my cat, sleepin!", or "Hey guys, check out this thing I made that is AWESOME!".
Nothing wrong with that. I'm sure Randall at XKCD appreciates his work being mentioned on Reddit/Digg everytime he posts a new comic.
I think the difference is that Randall at XKCD doesn't mention his work on Reddit/Digg every time he posts a new comic.
Even if The Oatmeal is entertaining, the shameless self-promotion is a bit of a turn off.
I respectfully disagree. A manufactured viral marketing is still a form of spamming. You (not you specifically) are being duped in to thinking the hive mind likes it, so you must like it too!
If people are creating GOOD quality content, they should be awarded, regardless of whether it was self-promotion or not. How else is somebody supposed to start something? Even moot over at 4chan had to post his links in the Something Awful forums. Not everyone has super uber advertising budgets.
See also saydrah, the #1 spammer of reddit
Dude, now you're just being a dick. You made your point before. Don't push it.
The whole point of reddit is to create a sense of community with shared interests, links and memes. If gaming the system means using it in exactly the way it was designed to be used then I suppose GiantBatFart is gaming the system.
p.s. You're not some whistle blower who has uncovered the dark side of GiantBatFart, the guy has fully admitted all of this in his IAMA.
I didn't claim to be a whistle blower. I read and participated (with my real handle) in his AMA with questions. He also mentioned in his blog he worked for seomoz. Having information is worth nothing if you don't know how to connect the dots.
If you are glad the way things are, good for you.
if i've been tricked into thinking that a lot of people on reddit like bacon then i'll be amazed - As a lifelong vegetarian i've been very aware of the job flesheaters take in think slices of fried pig, actually it's the most common reason that new vegetarians lapse and certainly alongside steak the most common thing i will be told i'm 'missing out on' - people not just on reddit really do like bacon a lot.....
I of courses don't like bacon myself, i also fund much of the oatmeal stuff to be contrived and worn humor however some pieces have been very funny (e.g. printers) - when I hear people talking about bacon i think, wow those guys love the bacon. When i see a link to the oatmeal i might click if i wanna see light humor which for a change is actually (fairly) original content - I might laugh and click around on the site, i might meh and return to reddit for redirection.....
I see generally a few links to each really good oatmeal article and maybe one or two for the less exciting ones, exactly what i would expect on reddit - I know that when a piece is put up the oatmeal post links to digg and reddit, nothing wrong with that - i know they have a marketing strategy it's obvious from the very first time you see the page, the easy to remember name and catchy idiosyncratic design set it apart from much of the web - it's a flashy dresser in a gray suit boardroom. They are screaming out, I WANT TO ENTERTAIN YOU, is that such a bad thing? All they offer is an honest product, a page of truth or wild fancy which may or may not amuse you...
I know what sort of mood i should be in to click an Oatmeal Article or for that matter an Onion article... The basically free service we have been getting has so far asked nothing of us, we are entirely free to enjoy or ignore it as we are free to skipover the endless drama threads, my friend made, my daughter whore, your religion believes, reposted reposts and all the other endless wash of inane content...
Nothing forces you to like what others like is all i'm saying, some things are popular and these create a statistical sweet spot we jokingly call 'hive mind' - my being tricked into thinking the oatmeal is more popular than it is hasn't effected the world at all, if the gaming theory is correct then maybe some poor published hoping to jump onto an internet bandwagon will make a loss on a few books - i highly doubt it because as i'm sure most people will actually honestly agree the content in the oatmeal is much funnier than most the big selling coffee table books. Books of this nature are sold by putting them on display in shops, the customer pics them up opens them randomly and if they laugh at something they might buy it - i doubt very much that anyone will think, hmmm this books doesn't look like something i would enjoy but i seem to remember reddit liked it so i'll buy one anyway....
I've always found those meme's to be annoying. But then again, I am the contrarian. I've been saying Reddit Sucks for a long time. I even made redditsucks.reddit.com.
I'm going to have to agree with this guy.
I hate to say it, but there are very few of you on here that actually have original thoughts.
Someone make her disappear
You're involved in this sort of 'gaming', aren't you? I seem to recall that.
The internet is a fucking game retard
[deleted]
Pig. Pig = Bacon. Bacon.
Fuck, its happening again.
You can put lipstick on a pig, but it's still bacon.
[deleted]
No, then it's Sarah Palin.
Or Saydrah?
[deleted]
The first thing I thought when I read this submission is that this guy really knows his stuff when it comes to promoting himself online, especially if he can promote himself to the reddit community. We are not an easy demographic to capture.
The second thing that I thought is that if he could apply the same humor and understanding to the demographic my company sells to, he would be a great addition to our team, since we just created a SEO position.
Saydrah, I am a bit more biased though in that I love most of his work and find it hilarious. But that is just me. So, take this comment with a grain of salt.
Reddit, not an easy demographic to capture?
You include the occasional narwhal or bacon meme, address reddit as if you're talking to them specifically and make sure they know that you, the person who submitted the content also made the content, (dear reddit, this is something I made), reddit are suckers for anything that makes them feel like part of a community or a cool club. If you remind them that you are also an avid redditor, they love it too.
Say something that is generally agreed upon in reddit, but allow for reddit to forget that it is the dominant ideology (DAE think Christianity is silly, Fox news are sensationalist liars, Steam is better than a different form of digital distribution, and Australian censorship laws are bad?).
It is incredibly easy to capture the reddit demographic, you just have to start off on the right foot.
[deleted]
Dear fellow redditor, Literally
So if I grow an epic beard, and ride a narwhal as close as water will get me and then hop on a fixie and ride to your house to deliver some bacon; will you love me forever?
I've seen him being accused of creating multiple accounts to comment on his submissions. Comments like "This genuinely made me laugh." and 10 others just like it appearing near instantly when he submits. Basically, preempting a hive mind mentality. If this is the case, then underhanded tactics like that are definitely not welcome here.
After someone pointed it out, I started to notice it myself. Many of the first comments on his submissions were not 'reddit like'. They looked like comments that belong on other social media sites. Even more surprisingly, they were upvoted to questionable levels.
It's not anything fishy. He just posts the link to his twitter, and his followers go to it right away. There's nothing wrong with that.
Well that's border line spam then. If he is using his twitter feed to tell people to come HERE and upvote his articles instead of linking directly to his site, that's definitely gaming the system in a way reddit disapproves of. Thanks for bringing that to my attention.
You fuckin bitch.
Yah, I don't like the term "gaming the system" either; it is a lazy way to describe his methodology.
But the rest of LoveGiantBatFarts comment was fucking golden.
I hope to do some of the same things Oatmeal is doing, if I ever get motivated enough...
Just replace "gaming the system" with "working hard and cleverly". OP seems a bit jealous.
I don't see why those two have to be mutually exclusive.
If "working hard and cleverly" amounts to making people think something different about you than they would if you were entirely upfront about the situation, then I'd still call it pretty close to "gaming the system."
I actually didn't give a care about this guy - he got a book deal, yay - but, if he's just trying to pass himself off as a regular guy, (and he's actually somebody who makes a living figuring out how to pass himself off as a regular guy), then I'm not as cool with that. I don't think he deserves a pat on the back.
It can all be semantics, but I'm less willing to support a person who is actively trying to come up with ways to get people to support his endeavors. - It's like being a fake underdog, taking advantage of underdog status. - If you're an overdog, just be an overdog.
A big hearty ffffuuuuuuck you to you Saydrah.
No one cares what you think you shady twat.
Fuck you Saydrah.
I think you may need to look up the word "self", you fucking sociopath.
[deleted]
wow, that'll teach her to have an opinion about reddit!
I've down voted you because reddit is not a site that "explicitly invites self-promotion", it is a site that invites ordinary people to escape the kind of world in which people like you feel no shame in putting a dollar value on everything that moves. Go spam digg if you want to self-promote.
"I don't want more choice, I want better things" - Edina, Absolutely Fabulous
No shit. The way she thinks is incredibly pathological. Check it out. This was from one of her most recent comments:
Fuck. That is some seriously dispassionate shit right there. I bet she's a huge Ayn Rand fan.
Free market capitalists usually are.
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/2009/12/20/2009-12-20_diana_degette_colorado_congresswoman_other_feminists_lash_out_at_abortion_restri.html
So you're one of those "don't call me a chick", chicks eh?
I'll always love you.
[deleted]
[deleted]
Die. Go die and never bother us again.
fuck this hood rat nigger
Oh Saydrah, you're always so reasonable.
She gets paid to submit content, thats why she is boasting about it
I wouldn't care even if that were true, it doesn't matter who submits the content, it ends up on the front page based on its own merits.