The community has spoken: I've removed Saydrah from the moderator list here.

There's been a trial, and a verdict, and it's obvious that nobody in this community is comfortable with Saydrah being a moderator here anymore. In order to maintain the integrity of the position of a moderator, I have taken everything into consideration and will be removing her from her moderator status (*edit- from /pics, and from /comics, where we are both moderators).

This is in no way a means to justify what you all are accusing her of, and I am terribly disgusted in some of the things that have gone on the past few days regarding her. Maybe she's been spamming, maybe not. The admins have already stated that she has done nothing against the terms and rules of reddit. She has not cheated the system or the algorithm in any way. But the fact remains, there is a conflict of interest between what she does for a living and her position of power on reddit, that cannot be ignored.

She is a great girl, and I have a lot of love for her. She's my co-calendar girl, and we've taken a lot of crap together from you all for that. I call her a reddit friend, and I hope that this doesn't change that. She's tough and I'm sure she will find a way to get through this, as she does with most things. She was an excellent moderator, and it will be difficult to see her go.

But the bottom line comes to the community, and the trust you have in us. I don't want our future decisions as moderators always clouded by her presence here. I think it would be absolutely okay if she remained a moderator on text-based subreddits (AskReddit where I will not be removing her, RelationshipAdvice where she is invaluable, etc) but as for anything based on links submitted... she should just be a regular user and nothing more.

If another moderator has a problem with this, and re-adds her to the mod list, there's not much I can do. This decision is neither unilateral nor is it unanimous, but I've had enough support from my fellow moderators to make me feel this is the right thing to do.

Posted Mar 2, 2010, 9:45 PM UTC · edited

1.1K1.8K
trabo•

I demand you put her back! Just kidding, I don't give a shit about any of this. :)

2.3K
Cituke•

That's what they want to hear. "I just made a tough decision and came out on the side that preserves reddit's integrity and comes out against moderation abuse"

"Meh"

575
ntou45•
193
eridius•

If you join that subreddit, you're not qualified to be in that subreddit.

251
[deleted]•

Hmm. You think so?

Whatever. I don't even care.

120
fancy_pantser•

I wouldn't be in any club that would have someone like me as a member!

17
Kream1•

I joined it cause he provided the link. I wouldn't care to go searching for it, though.

1
reddit_user13•

The first rule of the apathy subreddit is..... don't join the apathy subreddit.

1
[deleted]•

I would never want to be a member of a subreddit that would accept me as a member.

1
baddox•

I wouldn't want to be a part of an apathy club that would accept me as a member.

1
ducttape36•

catch-22

1
ivantheterrible13•

You're probably right.

1
kanon14•

Catch-22 of the subreddit

1
munklunk•

You're thinking of the "Emo Street Cred" subreddit.

1
jib•

The trick is to join before you're qualified, then become qualified, then not care enough to leave.

1
hcice•

My sister was using my computer and she subscribed me to that subreddit. It's just that I don't care enough to unsubscribe.

1
kokey•

is it like being on r/suicide for more than half an hour?

1
Rockytriton•

what? Reddit has moderators? What the hell do they do, just delete spam?

28
Fat_Dumb_Americans•

They ban users and hide submissions.

23
[deleted]•

Yeah, pretty much. That, and unban what the spam filter wrongfully catches as spam.

20
[deleted]•

Apparently they make lots of money via political rent to and from the landed gentry.

0
imarobot•

Thanks, my entire evening is now filled with meh.

9
danstermeister•

Add a 't' and get the party started buddy!!!

21
[deleted]•

"I don't want to be a member of any subreddit that would have me as a subscriber."

7
TehSlippy•

Aren't you automatically not apathetic (that sounds really funny to me, but not sure how else to word it) if you subscribe to that reddit?

1
ntou45•

so?

9
smpx•

What if you want to learn to be more apathetic? Or is only interested in finding more about apathy?

1
davidhaha•

if you're not apathetic, does that make you pathetic (by taking off the "a-")?

1
rmeddy•

That is a blackhole of irony right there.

It's like when you divide by z... O SHII

1
Devilboy666•

why bother

1
AndroidHelp•

232,872 subscribers is not enough?

1
[deleted]•

Like I care about your subreddit...

1
THEJP•

Ya, not many people care, but a train wreck is always fun to watch.

1
reddithatesjews6•

Reddit hates Jews, are you gonna do anything about that? oh i forgot, keyser and karmanaut are racists!

-12
[deleted]•

All this talk lately about banning people, and this fucking clown is still here.

I love this place.

2
[deleted]•

I smell a jew. Someone call karmanaut!

-3
baddox•

Silent majority, man. Remember that this is all just a bunch of mostly anonymous people socializing on a website on the Internet.

7
fireburt•

I'm pretty sure there was a lot of "Meh" being shouted loud and clear before this post, it was just being downvoted to oblivion before and the mods didn't see it.

2
ToughNoogies•

I like how Reddit has grown to the point that it's politics parallel real life. This is a classic debate over regulation vs the free market. Do we need moderators, or should there be a free for all? Are the mods corrupt, abusive of their power, or working in everyone's best interests? Some chose one side, some the other, some live in ignorant bliss of what goes on behind the curtain.

Edit: There's another thread debating the importance of the SEC (here). That debate isn't as popular as this one though...

1
[deleted]•

I just need something to distract me from the work I am being paid to do.

1
jugalator•

That's what they want to hear. "I just made a tough decision and came out on the side that preserves reddit's integrity and comes out against moderation abuse"

"Meh"

So when truth hurts, we should shut up?

1
Cituke•

does my ass look fat in these jeans?

1
k3n0b1•

I think "Meh" is the best outcome for the situation so that it can go away. The community will see a resolution and quit voting up stories about the situation, it is now old news. Saydrah will not be able to submit or comment as there will be those that remember the name and automatically downvote. She has ruined her good name.

0
lolbifrons•

I, for one, upvote and downvote based on the quality of content/post, not based on who posted.

1
dropcode•

How the fuck does this 'preserve integrity' or come out 'against moderation abuse'. If anything this is mob rule prevailing and a show of disrespect for the actual rules.

0
Cituke•

are you familiar with what actually happened?

She promoted links that her friends (and possibly she) benefited from financially and then banned a redditor for linking to a blog claiming that he reposted the picture to his blog so he could make money from it. This being despite that he took the picture himself.

If you're sitting there thinking "What reddit needs is more moderators who mess around with reddit to make cash and then ban people because they incorrectly think they're doing the same thing" well, go eat dog dick.

0
dropcode•

last I read this was all based on theory and propagated by spam hate which reminds me way to much of salem mass. If there was evidence that she acutally was abusing mod powers then I'll gladly eat crow, I was just going on what I read and the fact that admins deemed her innocent.

0
sleepygoldenstorm•

I have to say, I'm more turned off by the witch hunt than I am by what they are accusing this person of. Otherwise, it's not even on my radar.

178
splidge•

Yes, it really is enough to make one think twice about the nature of this "community".

I also take exception to use of the phrase "nobody in this community" as if the lynch mob comes close to truly representing everyone here.

58
[deleted]•

I prefer to think of it as a society. r/math and r/Drugs are communities. The big reddits are just discussion boards.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
[deleted]•

Bye, please take the spam all you new users brought with you.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
neoumlaut•

Nooooooooooo.......... come back!!!! WE NEED YOU magic5ball, you are the joy in my heart every morning!

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
CalvinLawson•

rabble rabble rabble!

2
hans1193•

It's not really a community if the wishes of said community are not taken into account.

1
gukeums1•

It's not a community. It's the internet. You're delusional if you think the internet is a community (though lots of people share your delusion, it is still a delusion). It's an artifact. It's as much a community as a book or image or hologram is. Reddit cannot supplant a real community, no matter how much it might seem that it can, because it is not human interaction. It is you, interacting with a computer. You don't have to deal with anything like what a community requires.

-5
notaloop•

The witch hunt has actually made me ashamed to be a part of this community. I always considered Redditors to be above the antics of 4Chan with more maturity and intellect, yet the posting of personal information, harrassment, and lynch mobs proved me wrong. This is no more than a high school version of 4Chan.

19
up-upsidedownis-dn•

Complaint + brief mention of 4Chan and/or Digg + same complaint = karma.

I don't get it, but whatever.

34
notaloop•

Mocking someone's complaint = karma.

Formulas are fun!

17
KevRose•

sounds about right.

1
kleinbl00•

Reddit = /b/ + daylight

10
darkon•

Starting to look that way, isn't it? It's certainly different from when I created an account. I can still find interesting things, though -- but sometimes I have to search more than I used to.

1
energythief•

So does that make 4chan Elementary School? shudders

4
PrettyCoolGuy•

...You guise talking about 8-year-olds?

3
notaloop•

More like middle school.

2
IOIOOIIOIO•

Well, the school mascot is Pedobear... so... Yes.

1
J05H•

How dare you accuse the Internet of maturity!

2
notaloop•

Yeah, I guess it was foolish of me in the first place. I was already pretty disgusted with the disinformation with piracy, this just kind of sealed the deal.

1
rmosler•

It doesn't sound like you have ever been to 4chan.

1
notaloop•

Both communities show the same fervor and use the same tactics to attack a person who has apparently wronged them. Its not just enough to outcast them, they must also be attacked and spammed irl.

2
dkdl•

I agree with you. I have yet to make a conclusion from all the pieces of evidence users have provided, but I do know that, during the past week, part of Reddit turned into a mob that could not be reasoned with. All for the sake of a witch hunt.

The first sign that showed that these users were not open to reason was their blind support for robingallup (poster of the Duck house). He tried to use deceptive tactics to bypass his ad through the spam filter. He tried to post a picture with a google ad next to it. The spam filter rejected it. He was warned by Saydrah to post the image by itself without the google ad. He instead posts a false image link that immediately redirects to his ad (driving traffic on his ad up 30,000% according to Rob himself).

However, the users against Saydrah blindly follow him just because he is opposed to her. They think that he is innocent, and that it was absurd his post was banned. The guy who tried to sneak his ad through the spam filter is now a matryr. Someone will reply (or downvote) to this by saying "there's nothing wrong with putting a google ad next to a picture post to make some money." I'm not talking about whether the google ad was right/wrong. I'm talking about the fact that his post with the deceptive link was banned.

As you can see, he is not innocent. But he has thousands of Redditors following him, with the reasonability of a mob.

edit: I've tried to make this post to show that not all of Reddit is part of this angry mob. http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b8lv4/has_the_community_spoken_or_the_mob_if_you_were/

19
Talking_Head•

I despise blogspam; but I define blogspam as stolen content put on a site to do nothing but generate hits and revenue for the theft. Original content is what makes reddit work, regardless of how it is presented. If you feel honest about your content then serve it up without re-directs. That said, no mod should be killing posts (or banning users) based solely on the format that they submit their content.

9
dkdl•

His redirect was a second attempt to post. He realized that he had to trick the spam filter in order to show his ad. So he did so by posting a false link that immediately redirected to his ad.

It's more that he was trying to be sneaky with the spam filter than anything else.

2
Shambles•

The situation with Robingall up had nothing to do with the lynch=mob at the start, it was SirOblivious' dubious list of links.

0
jedisparrow7•

Agreed

4
Azured•

I'll tell you what though, I'm sure going to miss those koalas.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Aphid•

You have to face the fact that this drama serves to entertain the category of internet users who have little better to do than sit in front of a computer and hope for something remotely tantalizing to pierce the bubble of their otherwise dark, uneventful lives. Let them have their cyber-victory.

1
[deleted]•

It's not a witch hunt if you're dealing with an actual witch.

Or in this case, a dishonest bitch.

-2
[deleted]•

If that's true, then you never understood what it was about in the first place. You can't have people being paid to submit content to subreddits they moderate.

You can't have moderators banning people who compete with them.

Saydrah did BOTH

So sorry if people defending their space against leech moderators 'turns you off'.

This is one of those situations where if you're not outraged, you don't understand what's going on.

Your ignorance and apathy doesn't make her actions right or defensible. It wasn't a witch hunt. It was a well deserved backlash. Unfortunately, you and others of your ilk cannot understand that.

Paid content submission should be on your radar. Why? Because paid content submission turns you from a community member into a little money earning unit. But hey, what do you care? Just mindlessly click on whatever they tell you to (or more precisely, allow you to,) laugh at the approved pictures of cute cats and enjoy your ignorance. You are what is wrong with the world.

-8
butrosbutrosfunky•

Because paid content submission turns you from a community member into a little money earning unit. But hey, what do you care? Just mindlessly click on whatever they tell you to (or more precisely, allow you to,) laugh at the approved pictures of cute cats and enjoy your ignorance. You are what is wrong with the world.

Oh, fuck off. Your melodramatic, condescending bullshit is what's wrong with the world.

14
sleepygoldenstorm•

Hey, I'm glad you have something to be passionate about. I still don't care. And, I still think that people found a little too much joy in destroying Saydrah. Like I said, it's not really on my radar.

13
dallasbabcock•

This was all I had to see: "The admins have already stated that she has done nothing against the terms and rules of reddit. She has not cheated the system or the algorithm in any way."
I agree that it's a good thing Lorax found something to be passionate about, we get it, you're pissed, but just because some of us are not pissed is no reason to be so catty. She either violated the rules or she didn't, looks like the Admins determined she didn't, congrats on getting her canned anyway, you should be very proud.
They'll probably sing songs about you for generations to come, Lorax the savior of reddit...

12
ConfusedRedneck•

You are a Jonas Brother Fan? I will never read any of your comments ever again. Your opinion means nothing to me. Nobody here cares that you don't care. You are a clicking faggot.

-1
NotSoToughCookie•

And, I still think that people found a little too much joy in destroying Saydrah

So because you believe this to be a witch hunt, it justifies Saydrah's actions? Sure, some people went overboard, but the facts that were presented are sound. I don't see what's so bad about the community wanting to keep reddit honest and above bar.

There was a conflict of interest and a lot of people were hurt when they found out a member they look up to was potentially contributing to the community because it was part of her job.

All she had to do was step down in the subreddits she mods, and this whole situation would have been over days ago. Saydrah has brought this on herself. She is dragging this out herself.

Don't blame the community, blame Saydrah.

-2
cwm44•

It's not so much that she didn't do anything wrong. She seems to have made a mistake in banning at least that one fellow. What's disturbing is the degree of moral outrage over it.

10
[deleted]•

She gets PAID to submit.

I don't get this. There were six threads of outrage, and now I am being downvoted because I remind the Pollyannas that their idol has feet of clay paid for by Associated Content et al.

Fuck reddit, you have the memory of a minnow.

-1
paulfromatlanta•

I agree the essence of the question is "being paid for posting on Reddit" - that creates an unresolvable conflict that IMO lessens the value of any contribution. But that doesn't excuse some of the over the top behavior that went on in response.

6
nathan1313us•

I completely agree. People are too complacent. Maybe for those that don't take a stand on anything this isn't the place to start, but for those that hold their ground and understand that they can influence the world around them without taking the corporate cock in the ass while browsing a site that simply allows other to share links this is normal to hold people who abuse their powers accountable.

-2
sleepygoldenstorm•

Wow, corporate cocks up the ass and not understanding you can influence the world--you told me! You go! But, I still don't care.

3
gukeums1•

do you know who owns reddit?

ps they have a nice fat corporate cock

3
dmalice•

seriously. Shit, finally now the pages of reddit can cease being clogged up by this irrelevant bullshit. Isn't reddit supposed to be the place for "What's new on the internet?" Who fuckin cares about this nonsense?

67
PrettyCoolGuy•

Reddit should really just be "What's new on Reddit"

38
emmster•

"What's new up our own asses."

7
PrettyCoolGuy•
2
[deleted]•

Yo Dawg!

1
PrettyCoolGuy•

I heard you like Reddit, so I filled it with self-posts. Now you can browse yo reddit while you browse yo reddit.

2
nraustinii•

I herd you like to Reddit while you Reddit.

-2
williamhgates•

Who fuckin cares about this nonsense?

Uhm, you do realize a bunch of computers were not posting all of the things you saw on the front page and elsewhere right? There were people behind those postings. They care. If it means nothing to you, fine, but at least take a minute to answer your own question. It means something to many other people, including me (I didn't create any of the threads, though).

18
NotClever•

What?

-6
drew3000•

I came here for the irrelevant bullshit.

2
[deleted]•

Isn't reddit supposed to be the place for "What's new on the internet?"

Exactly. It used to be "Who's new on Associated Content's client list?"

That got fixed.

1
[deleted]•

People that don't want 'What's new and fed to you by corporate interests'?

1
gliscameria•

If the top comment was anything but, "I don't give a shit about any of this." I would have lost all respect for reddit and started operation Troll Thunder. You are a hero, and not that faggy giving to charity or working in a soup kitchen hero, I'm talking covered in gore with an erection visible from the heavens hero.

52
smpx•

covered in gore with an erection visible from the heavens hero.

So a Japanese hero?

(I kid, I kid!)

19
DOGA•

Damn right.

2
coconutcream•

So a Japanese hero?

You can barely see japanese erections from... let alone..

(I kid, I kid!)

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

operation Troll Thunder

I would like to subscribe to your newsletter.

6
[deleted]•

When I want to hear about fags and trolls, I go to 4chan. Get out my reddit.

4
gliscameria•

When I want to read bullshit posts with no content, I go to 4chan.

2
Doomed•

You got 1100+ comment karma from one comment. That is probably the most you have ever got from one comment. This is the peak of your reddit career. Karmanaut (and Karmaknotte, and Etab) would kill for that kind of karma. An African family of four lives on that much karma for three full years.

Don't spend it all in one place.

39
Garage_Dragon•

To hell with that! You should take all of that karma and $1.50 and go blow it all on a cup of coffee. Just go crazy with it.

7
Cituke•

I'm psyched I placed second, how the shit did that happen?

3
trabo•

Seriously unexpected. It feels good to have struck a chord with the crew but it's beyond belief at this point. I'll be frugal, don't worry.

1
pingveno•

Flaming time!

1
[deleted]•

I don't think Karmanaut and Etab care at all about their Karma at this point and that's what makes them cool, not caring.

1
[deleted]•

Maybe dedicated, but definitely not cool.

1
under_dog•

Wahoo! Someone who talks sense, who gives a flying fuck

20
SloaneRanger•

That first part is actually a valid point even though you obviously made it as a joke.

In what way has the "community spoken"? I didn't ask for her to be removed, and I doubt the vast majority of redditors did either. Basically, the only people who really made a big deal about it were those baying for her blood. So essentially the angry mob rules the decision making process and those who are indifferent (again probably the majority given the hundreds of thousands of people who visit this site) are expected to accept comments like "nobody in this community is comfortable with Saydrah being a moderator here". I couldn't care less. As far as I recall, I saw a post from a reddit administrator yesterday saying there was nothing particularly wrong with the way she moderates.

I'm not saying that the decision was right or wrong. I just don't like the justification for making it. What I will say though, is that I hope this brings the whole sorry episode to a close. While it may have started with some pretty underhand actions on the part of one person, the screeching and baying overreaction from some people was embarrassing to watch.

18
skippybinladen•

All in favor of removing Krispity Krcks?! Aye! Where's my pitch fork?!

1
[deleted]•

I signed in just to say the same! Who gives a fuck?

9
IndIka123•

I never understood why it matters that she works in social media.. so lets say she gets payed to post links for companies right? If you see something you don't like, down vote it. Problem solved right? How does her being a moderator affect what gets to the front page? Do people mindlessly up vote things posted by moderators? I agree with you, who cares. The site is a pure democracy, unless she is using botnets or multiple accounts to cheat and up vote her own posts/links, it doesnt matter.

8
LeiaShadow•

People were saying that she was banning posts that competed with her own, so hers would get more karma and make it to the front page. I never saw any evidence for that, though. IMO, If she had been banning legit stuff, the other mods would have noticed. But meh, drama finally over now.

5
mmm_burrito•

More importantly, the Admins never saw any evidence of illegitimate bans either, nor did any mods of any of the subreddits she moderated. Funny how the frothing mob tends to overlook that.

3
thedarkhaze•

It really depends on the type of person you are and if you believe in preemptive action. If you believe that a potential problem is a problem then you'd want her out. If you believe that until something bad actually happens everything is good then it'd be fine. It's very easy to take both sides of this argument to extremes and I'm not here to debate that. I'm simply stating that it's a problem for some people and for others it's not because of how they perceive problems.

2
Sidzilla•

I don't know Saydrah and wish her no ill will, but the conflict of interest was there. I likened it in a previous post to a member of the NY Yankees front office staff also being a part time umpire at the Yankee's home games. Even if every call he made was strictly by the book there would be no way anyone would think the calls were fair. To me that was the only problem, not in any action she ever took. As far as people calling it a witch hunt, yes some people went too far, but Saydrah herself was arrogant, offensive, and denied any possible conflict of interest until it became apparent that she was literally desperate to retain her moderator status for some reason. That became an issue in and of itself in my opinion. Almost everyone handled themselves in a less than mature manner, yet any moderator who speaks up on the issue wags a disapproving finger at only the members of Reddit and not at Saydrah. That is bullshit, because there is plenty of blame on her part as well.

1
[deleted]•

I never saw any evidence for that, though.

There's evidence of it ON THE FRONT PAGE TODAY.

It's called the duck-house.

Saydrah's been thoroughly exposed. It's over for her on here.

0
LeiaShadow•

One guy said he had been banned and provided evidence. I don't consider that evidence of her regularly banning unreasonably. I think we need at least more than one example of questionable behavior before we can say that she's been "thoroughly exposed".

1
[deleted]•

Conflict of interest -- look it up.

Would you like it if the president of the US were being paid off by the Taliban?

That would be a conflict of interest too. Same principle.

-4
butrosbutrosfunky•

That is the most asinine analogy and justification for the shitfest foisted on her that I have probably even heard here.

1
[deleted]•

Your inability to explain why the analogy is unjustified is proof that you're just trolling.

-5
DouchesWild•

Seriously, the amount of bullshit coming out of people over this absolutely blows my mind.

Being a mod isn't like being a fucking senator or some shit, chill the fuck out people.

5
rogerssucks•

I gave two shits at first, but then took them back.

5
mooxie•

Here here!

4
hearhearnotherehere•

-_-

40
mooxie•

No, but I meant pay attention to this thing HERE that...

Oh, bother.

4
youngluck•

I just read that in a Pooh voice.

4
sciencebepraised•

It's actually "Hear! Hear!"

4
GoinEasy9•

No, I actually think, like many others, that the post was just saying he/she was here. ☮

1
CommentMan•

Exception: when mooxie finds something I lost.

1
dr_pyser•

then perhaps you should join the new subreddit:

http://www.reddit.com/r/whoissaydrah/

4
browncow9•

No seriously, this moderator did the right thing, everyone in the world is accountable for the actions they take. Also, she might be a very good person, however the language she used to reply was a bit off the mark.

3
[deleted]•

Easily a contender for comment of the year. And it's only March.

3
trabo•

I am shocked by the response.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
emmster•

I don't give a shit what you demand.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
emmster•

I don't give a shit if you don't give a shit if I...

Oh, who gives a shit, anyway?

1
dbasch•

meh.

1
ltjboy03•

WELL SAID!

2
[deleted]•

I like the cut of your jib.

2
YouAreCorrect•

The perfect comment!

2
grandmoffcory•

I didn't know anything was up with the moderators, and, really, I don't care.
They're just moderators. We have no personal connection, and they have no impressive power to worship. They're reddit users like everyone else.

As such, big emotional posts about the removal of a minor position of editing power weird me out. This is the internet, not a corporate takeover.

2
guyincorporated•

Thank pie, I thought I was the only one.

1
yugomer•

Cheap LOLz. Reddit is made out of them.

1
link2009•

Haha, this is so true.

1
abs85•

Agreed

1
unthunk•

I'm not even sure what's going on.

1
kriegsdrachen•

Yup, this.

1
DarkSideofOZ•

ROFL, my thoughts exactly.

1
Richard_Judo•

I was gonna go with "Shut up you fucking babies" but I like this apathetic version better.

1
Milfburger•

yeah, Blah blah blah. I wish I had never read this.

1
[deleted]•

I personally don't care if she used her moderator privileges to spam anything on reddit, I just want her to suffer for being a miserable human being. It's people who work in the spam industry who are ruining the internet.

1
lovesthetrees•

I agree. It was a lot of drama by a bunch of kids who think they own this community.

none of the drama should have even reached the front page, it should have been something internal.

1
snapp3r•

Holy bananas, someone else who cares little for internet politics! Have an upvote!

1
[deleted]•

Ha. I lold

1
Astronoid•

Amen! I think some people take their reddit a little too seriously.

1
texacer•

cant she just change her name?

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

No kidding! This makes the Tiger Woods bullshit look like the moon landing as far as "news" is concerned. Get back to posting geeky shit and porn Reddit!

0
[deleted]•

No kidding. Some people take this fuckin' website way too seriously. Am I the only one who comes here solely to find retarded pictures to make me laugh?

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

We used to have a reddit that was worth caring about. Your comment, in all seriousness, is a perfect example of why it has descended into the shitty shit hole it is today; the kind of site that produces as much drama as it has over this Saydrah situation. We've become a place people go to find "retarded pictures". Thank jeebus for the subreddits.

To clarify, I'm not condemning your personal participation in the site, or suggesting you made it this way or whatever. I'm just pointing out that the attitude you expressed in your comment is evidence of reddit's great decline, and part of why the situation you're lamenting is happening.

0
[deleted]•

Reddit is a democratically run organization, at least as much as a website with an anonymous user base can be. Each user -- or account, rather -- gets a single vote on all content. There are clearly people that game the system, but let's pretend that it comes down to one-person, one-vote. It seems that such a system would provide the content that its users want. Reddit descending into the "shitty shit hole that it is today" appears to be a byproduct of your dislike for the content that the masses seem to want. That's not a descent, it's just the evolution of the group.

This is all natural in the progression of any democratically-run organization as it scales. The lowest and greatest common denominators tend to separate. You seem to want a community comprised of intellectuals-only without any of the riff-raff just looking for a chuckle. That's not going to happen in an open forum like Reddit. You have to take the good with the bad. Otherwise, you'll need to build walls around your preferred group and have specific criteria for membership, a system that also clearly has its disadvantages.

I do see your point, and I'm sorry to be so bitchy. But I can't stand it when people complain about the great downfall of Reddit when, as far as I can tell, it's providing exactly the kind of content its users, as a whole, want.

0
[deleted]•

I agree that reddit is providing the content that its users, as a majority, want. I also wouldn't want to see reddit become a members-only site any more than you would. But, where I disagree is in that the content on the front page today vs. 3 or 4 years ago is due to the evolution of the group. I would say it's due to a corruption of the group. That word has connotations I don't mean to imply, but think of corruption in the sense of a hard disk or digital file. We've introduced "artifacts" (i.e. users most interested in r/pics) to the "data" (i.e. user base). You could call that evolution if you'd like, but I still see it as a decline in overall quality.

Other people have expressed this before and the solution always comes back to subreddits. They are indeed great for providing specific, user-desired content. It's just that these stories used to be on the front page, is all.

1
kstar•

It is pretty pathetic that this comment got so many upvotes.

-1
transgenmom•

I would have preferred that they kept Saydrah personally. It would have been interesting to see if the current popular reddits with the Saydrah group would have been left in favor of new ones.

-9
robingallup•

Oh shit. As promised, I have to take my wife and kids to a fancy dinner. Pics forthcoming.

447
karmanaut•

You better make sure those pics are on imgur.

386
donwilson•

or she'll ban your.... oh, wait.

317
ialsolovebees•

Teehee.

153
b33r•

Too soon?

172
new_meme•

Fool! When the mods smite Saydrah down, she will become more powerful than you can possibly imagine!

10
robingallup•

Lol.

39
Ijustdoeyes•

Touche

24
tinadoesmath420•

Touchebag.

35

My bag?

3
Luminaire•

maybe 10% of the imgur links have worked in the last day.

1
EGAgraphics•

your wife knows what Reddit is?

35
robingallup•

She's been following the drama from her computer but I don't think she has a Reddit account. Inwardly, she probably rolls her eyes and doesn't understand why this is important to me, but outwardly she's been nothing short of awesome about it. I have the best wife ever.

138
robingallup_wife•

Right back at 'cha babe

210
robingallup•

NOT my wife. But Lol.

184
gbo2k69•

Ooh, she called you the best wife ever! Are you gonna let that stand?

33
Sle•

Enjoy your dinner :)

10
quattrofan•

Upvote for the same profile name _wife.

Now when you have kids I want to see:

robingallup_child1 robingallup_child1

and on to

robingallup_child1_of_child1

etc

2
KazamaSmokers•

"she probably rolls her eyes and doesn't understand why this is important to me.."

Wait... you didn't write that Father's Day CraigsList post... did you?

11
kleinbl00•

Are you, out of curiosity, in Gallup? 'cuz if so, I'm honestly curious what qualifies as a "fancy dinner." To be perfectly honest, I usually have a hard time finding "fancy gasoline" while blitzing through on the 40.

33
robingallup•

Yup, Gallup, New Mexico.

The only thing that remotely qualifies as a fancy dinner here is a place called Zen Steak & Sushi. If you exit I-40 on the west side of town where the Walmart is, and go north on Hwy 602 about two miles, there's a building on the right-hand side that's home to both King Dragon Chinese Buffet and Zen Steak and Sushi. King Dragon is meh by normal standards and good by Gallup standards, while Zen actually has very good food and surprisingly great sushi made from fresh fish that they import daily. They're only open for dinner, though. 5pm-9pm.

29
[deleted]•

5 til 9 every day til I see you... it's a date!

19
badbrownie•

Sushi in New Mexico sounds questionable or very expensive. Here's hoping it's the latter for your wife's sake!

14
maldio•

Why would you want her sake to be very expensive?

24
mrdelayer•

When I was in AZ a few months ago, sushi was cheap and of utmost quality. Which is far more than I can say for the sushi here in San Antonio. :[

1
[deleted]•

Someone stalk him at that restaurant and take pics as well!

8
robingallup•

;)

10
CommentMan•

I love it when Walmart is a town landmark.

3
J0llyR0ger•

I bet you stole these directions/ratings from another site and are reposting it here. You should be banned.

3
bmlol•

Sizzler.

2
kleinbl00•

I grew up in Los Alamos. Sometimes we'd go to Farmington for Thanksgiving. I never felt safe eating sushi in New Mexico. Too much trauma from my mother's experiments with squid and Orange Roughy.

1
LeroyJenkems•

When I was there, the fanciest dinner I had was Cracker Barrel.

1
corevirus•

I think you should invite the guys who live in the Duck House too!

1
Sylveran-01•

If I may, I humbly suggest the following compromise:

A nice table for two, with a crisp, white tablecloth draped over it. Silver candles. Full compliment of silverware. Crystal glasses. A nice bottle of red. Fine china. Both you and your wife dressed elegantly to befit the occasion... .

.

.

In front of the Duck House. (you might need to ask for permission from the owner - explain it's for the Internetz).

(of course, we'd want pictures... in imgur if possible ) :P
1
[deleted]•

Upvoted for Gallup. I went to high school at GHS.

1
fishbert•

there are fancy cars with lights on top of them around there, though, so be careful while you're blitzing through.

9
FU_Troll•

I'm sure your wife is very proud of you. Make sure you tell your kids what a difference you've made.

13
FiL-dUbz•

Did you get your Google Ad-Sense account termination rescinded?

4
Idontknowmuch•

Hold it there buddy.

That is a picture of MY house and I have a patent and copyright on its design. I politely ask you to remove your unlicensed picture from this reddit thing or face legal consequences.

/just kidding... although it would be hilarious. Would it create a meta-drama?

2
[deleted]•

Take 'em to that really good steak place in Grants...

1
ProbablyNotToday•

Don't forget to buy your kids a fancy bottle of wine. Oh and get your wife that happy meal you promised her.

1
laja2•

You should toast to cleansing all the bile and nastiness the community's vomited all over itself on your behalf.

-8
AloysiusSavant•

I agree. The hate machine is now just looking for the next thing to hate, with or without reason.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
laja2•

I'd love to, actually.

"I propose a toast to the joys of the idle mind, the world of infinite time and the pleasures of the layabout. I raise my glass to fucking off, fucking off well and fucking off constantly. Hell may await us, but until we reach that day, grant us thousands more hours of leisure and boredom."

Does that suffice?

7
fireburt•

That was great, I may have to use that the next time I'm at dinner with friends. I'm afraid my upvote won't be enough to stop the storm that is heding your way, but know that I tried.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
j3w3ly•

You do realize that all this shit did NOT start because of robingallup...right? Just saying, maybe you owe him an apology. Accusing him of starting all this is pretty, well, nasty.

1
ryanvsrobots•

I don't know much about this drama, but if it came to this then she should have stood down days ago. Simple as that.

275
thatguydr•

The fact that she didn't is what really cements all of this. Ah well. Kudos to krispy.

180
nathan1313us•

I can't believe she is still allowed to be a mod of anything. Forget what she posts for profit but the way she speaks to the users of the site is enough for her to be removed fully. She is still a mod.

82
rooktakesqueen•

Mods are community-level, not site-level. Reddit's admins are totally hands-off about who is a mod of what.

Besides, since when is "the way she speaks to the users" grounds for not being a mod? Fuck man, BritishEnglishPolice is a mod of several prominent subreddits, and he's not among the less abrasive members of this community.

82
tdehnel•

he's not among the less abrasive members of this community

Those are strong words.

Just kidding.

12
thatguydr•

I don't like BEP, because he's annoying, but he's never an enormous dick to a large swath of users here. Also, he doesn't profit from his participation here. Overall, I like having someone like BEP as a moderator, since he's anal and likely quite responsible, even if he is a little hard to swallow on occasion.

6
nathan1313us•

I'm not saying the mods are in charge of that I'm just stating that she should be fully removed. The more you abuse your visitors the less they will come. Just seems like you can moderate without being a dick/bitch to your users. Shouldn't there be a level of respect between the user and mod? And if that level of respect breaks down it should always be on the users side rather than the mods. A level of professionalism should always be maintained.

3
Shambles•

I don't think somebody should have to pretend they're all sweetness and light when they're dealing with an internet community, it's not very fair. We all know the amount of scumbags round here can get frustrating, and they spend all of their time cleaning up that mess.

1
grammarazi•

BEP is a lovable rascal.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
Suicide_Guy•

You must've missed the memo that caps, excessive swearing, and ad hominem attacks make you look unintelligent and cause the people you're trying to influence to close themselves off to your ideas.

4
tunah•

The fact that she didn't is what really cements all of this

And if she survives the drowning, she must be a witch. Burn her!

-1
GoofyBoy•

All this drama, both ways. She really should have stepped down at the beginning from all modding (and therefore less drama. Did you really think people would drop it?)

But what I don't understand is how the others mods have reacted. It took how many days? And how many stuck up for her and how many were and still are clueless about this whole situation?

My biggest question is how can you have a mod that thinks 90% of people here are shitheads? (Odds are she is talking about YOU.) How can you mod fairly with that in your head? How can you stick up for a person who thinks like that?

42
whatev_kev•

90% of people are ARE shitheads (myself included)

14
otherwiseyep•

I have a proven ability to develop authentic relationships with shitheads that I think you may find useful in getting your message to them...

1
R0CKET_B0MB•

IT'S NOT YOUR FAULT

0
melodramatic_monkey•

and 80% of those 90% are half retarded.

-2
[deleted]•

According to her way of thinking, anybody that doesn't help her make money is a shithead. Anybody who isn't a groveling minion of hers, anybody who doesn't perform thankless, unjustified upvoting and lapdogging, just so she can rack up karma which she can then indirectly cash in for dollars, is a shithead.

Per that definition, I am honored to be a shithead.

Fuck Saydrah.

6
daramel•

Who cares? This is reddit; I don't have to like you guys, and you don't have to like me. So she insulted the community. Big deal. I think a lot of redditers are cruel, and too-ready to fling insults at people who disagree with their opinions. I also find most redditers to have this really negative view of women in thinking that women only choose to date assholes. Does this mean I wouldn't be a fit moderator?

0
GoofyBoy•

Does this mean I wouldn't be a fit moderator?

The role requires you to be open-minded about things you might not agree on, that way you don't ban/delete/remove (whatever the term is here) things that are potentially good points.

To say that 90% of people are shitheads implies that 90% of what is submitted and posted here are ban/delete/remove - worthy (you can only judge people on this website on what they submit or post, no one is judging me on the colour of my shirt). What she said was a bit more wider than just "most" people have a "really negative view" of another group.

3
daramel•

No, saying that 90% of the people here are shitheads in an emotional manner is not saying that 90% of the things submitted here is ban-worthy. That's just silly. One thing does not equal the other. And I can tell you that at this point, my view of the reddit community is getting worse and worse. Does that mean that I don't respect what we are trying to do here? No! I like it that everyone has a say; I like the arguments and discussions that arise; I like all the interesting, unique, and sometimes offensive things I can find here. I think you are going too far in assuming that her calling 90% of people here shitheads some how equals 90% of the comments and articles to be ban worthy. You can be angry with Saydra for a lot of things, but this one is just silly.

1
sirnoobius•

not to mention that if I was her employers (associated content or whatever the fuck else it is) I wouldn't want my name tainted by her. I mean now every sydrah, every AC post or anything that looks like sydrah is gonna be down voted automatically.

and you know they'll say yah they'll forget in two weeks, new people come etc... but those people don't vote/comment, we do and WE WILL NEVAR FORGAT

15
frreekfrreely•

We are Legionnaires.

1
[deleted]•

I don't know much about this drama, but if it came to this then she should have stood down days ago. Simple as that.

She's not paid to stand down.

12
DoTheDew•

Exactly. You can't expect someone to fire themselves.

9
ryanvsrobots•

Touché

2
IrrigatedPancake•

Simple as that.

That's a little too simple for me.

2
Haiavaha•

I don't know anything about this. Can someone fill me in?

1
metamorphosis•

I agree. I am one of those people who really don't care whether she stays or goes. But if I was on her place I would've stepped down as soon as community went berserk .

Two reasons:

-you give respect to community opinion even if they are "90% shitheads" (her quote) or wrong.

-you preserve your self integrity if you feel that you are wrongly accused.

In other words its win-win outcome wihtout to much drama.

1
daramel•

She offered to, but her fellow mods asked her to stay.

1
ryanvsrobots•

How do you offer to stand down? You either do it or don't.

0
daramel•

What do you mean? She told her fellow mods that she could stand down, they all told her not to. That's how you offer something.

3
ryanvsrobots•

I guess you're right, but I think that's stupid. What I should have said was offering to stand down has no real impact compared to actually standing down.

1
Mr_Red•

this all feels like highschool

1
dpower•

That's exactly the problem - there's a time to talk it out and there's a time to let shit blow over. She shot herself in the foot.

1
SirOblivious•

Thank you for listening to the community, I feel Democracy prevailed. Thanks everyone for time and trouble in hearing this out.

I will be keeping a personal eye out for any other abuses

Great Justice! If I could buy you all a beer I would

EDIT: We must still keep an Eye on her. Here is why, She is still a mod of r/comics and r/IAmA see Below

http://i.imgur.com/ii8iQ.png

255
ungoogleable•

Democracy didn't prevail because there was no vote. Our overlords just caved to public pressure and shot the elephant.

Let's be clear: the admins have no interest in extending democracy to moderators. In their minds, moderators have absolute authority because they went to all the trouble of securing the name early on. Never mind all the other people who have contributed to the subreddit over time, they don't count.

113
Boco•

I have to agree with that Ungoogleable. If anything the Admins should have hosted an honest debate on a real issue that Saydrah admitted to over and over.

Teaching spammers how to spam properly (i.e. by alternating with at least 4 posts unrelated to your own to pretend you're not spamming).

On top of a clear conflict of interest noted by SirOblivious, is it really okay with the community to have a mod that teaches spammers how to work around spam filters, by pretending to be a contributing member? Some might have argued it's ok as long as content was good, I'd argue spam is spam no matter how it's veiled.

Ultimately Admins didn't care to have either and just pretended the whole thing was a non-issue b/c there wasn't blatant cheating.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
Phocas•

Real Talk...

1
ResilienceMOD•

C'mon, I was the Founder of r/Pics and added people that seemed to contribute. It's a bit harsh to say that I parked the name.

That beeing, I'm not outspoken as a mod, so I think it's good that there are people that do what I can't.

11
ungoogleable•

So can I ask you what was the hard work you put into launching r/pics? The way raldi describes it, subreddit founders are akin to entrepreneurs whose single-handed dedication makes the difference between success and failure. You say people "seemed to contribute". I take it that means you didn't have to recruit them, you just noticed that they were already there contributing because they found the subreddit on their own. And from the size of the current moderator list, I assume you decided you had enough moderators at some point.

I know it sounds like it, but I don't mean to denigrate your contributions. But I'd like you to recognize that you had many advantages as the first mover with the common name. If you tried to create a new pictures subreddit, it would take much more effort, the kind of effort that raldi is talking about, and it probably wouldn't ever be as successful as r/pics.

1
redreplicant•

Thinly veiled jealousy, huzzah!

5
ungoogleable•

I don't want to be a mod. As I told raldi, I don't want to play capitalism in miniature. I just want organized content.

5
[deleted]•

yes, it stuck me as a case of "oh shit, we are perceived as a group of kevin rose's best act quick to preserve our reputation and integrity".

Glad to see some action has finally been done.

2
IOIOOIIOIO•

Democracy didn't prevail because there was no vote.

How did submissions about this get to front page and how did the comments calling for her ouster get to the top of those submissions? Are you familiar with the function of the grey patches above and below the white "H"?

2
catfightonahotdog•

There's only so much democracy you can take before you better stop being silly and start getting things done efficiently.

1
junkit33•

Democracy didn't prevail because there was no vote.

People voted overwhelmingly with those tiny little arrows to the left. It wasn't close.

0
fishbert•

I will be keeping a personal eye out for any other abuses

Bloody hell; you mean there might be more of this reddit lynch mob bullshit down the road?

Seriously, I'm completely with krispykrackers in the sentiment, "and I am terribly disgusted in some of the things that have gone on the past few days regarding her." And you (oblivious or otherwise) are responsible for whipping up a lot of it.

To reiterate what kk said above, she was removed due to a conflict of interest, not because of any 'abuses'. Nobody has been able to show any cases of her abusing her moderator status through any of this high school level melodramatic crap.

62
[deleted]•

I was terribly disgusted at her 2x post, but lets ignore that and fling shit at the mob.

9
Gravity13•

Because the mob is the real victim here...

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Rubin0•

I am batman.

-1
voltagex•

Exactly, ok, it's pretty much over, time to take some Valium now. Sheesh

1
SirOblivious•
-3
[deleted]•

I wonder if all this support she is receiving is the fact that is she is a calendar girl. If it was some greasy dude they would be calling for his balls to be ripped off.

20
[deleted]•

BBbbut Lynch Mob! If I say Lynch Mob enough, people will forget that someone did something wrong! Nothing will stop me from White Knighting!

4
rooktakesqueen•

So she doesn't get to claim she's being unfairly persecuted for being female, but you get to claim she's being unfairly shielded for the same reason?

4
[deleted]•

You clearly haven't seen her.

3
Nerdlinger•

Wow, nice picture. I especially like the poll at the bottom that has a whopping 115 votes in favor of banning her. Wow. That's a lot.

20
centipeed•

Hey! Enough of your sarcasm! When 0.046 percent of Reddit speaks, concerning wild accusations of altogether unimportant acts, backed up by vague evidence, the moderators should damn well listen!

I say we get the torches and burn some houses down! And also kill some witches!

28
fishbert•

I know... it's like the whole reddit community had spoken

7
[deleted]•

Its a nice picture that very clearly contradicts the "nobody has been able to show any cases...". That's all it needs to be.

6
mrmaster2•

Yup, an mysterious, unpromoted poll that does not have any sources.

I'll believe whatever it says!

6
Devilboy666•

It's not his fault if you didn't bother to vote!

0
[deleted]•

Where was this poll posted? It doesn't really seem like enough people voted on it to use it for any actual data.

10
Gravity13•

Even then, it's clear there's confirmation bias - the people willing to go seek out a poll to ban Saydrah are probably much more likely to vote to ban her...

Even then^2, when the fuck did a poll ever mean shit on the internet?

10
fishbert•

a)
She's not being paid to post stuff to reddit, and even if she was, that has nothing to do with her activities as a moderator (which, according to other moderators, is exemplary). She occasionally posts things that are hosted on the site for the company she works for, but as has been pointed out before, she does not get any sort of commission on any revenue associated (or not) with it, it is not part of her job description, and there is nothing wrong with people submitting things to reddit that has something to do with their field.

As I posted elsewhere, I shit from time-to-time while at work, but that doesn't mean I am being paid to pinch loaves.

Besides, if deriving monetary gain from reddit submissions truly was an issue, then why did the ruckus blow up over Saydrah, and not GiantBatFart (aka, The Oatmeal guy) when it was pointed out that he works in SEO and does nothing but pimp his (rather good) site on reddit?

b)
The "90% of reddit is shitheads" comment is exactly how I'd expect anyone to respond after being the subject of such a vicious witch hunt and having your personal details posted online for people to abuse ala 4chan.

c)
She isn't the one who banned (deleted, rather) what's-his-face's duck house pic submission. His submission was deleted because he was acting "spammy" (some other mod's words), and the submission was re-instated upon review (and with the blessing of the mod who did delete it originally -- again, not Saydrah).

d)
She hasn't been "caught" doing anything wrong here. Pursuant to point a) above, people are calling for her moderator head, despite not abusing her moderator status in the least. Even krispykrackers in this post announcing her removal from the r/pics moderator list says the only reason was a conflict of interest with her real-life job, not because she did anything wrong.

Here's an interesting question: she works for Associated Content... has she ever posted anything from Associated Content to the r/pics subreddit? I don't know, maybe she has. But if not, where's even an appearance of a conflict of interest here?

e)
Aside from being a poll of a lynch mob, that is a textbook example of bias in the wording of poll options. Whoever came up with that has a future in political surveys. The creator was obviously firmly entrenched on one side of the question and designed the poll to put pressure on the other reddit moderators to carry out the will of the mob. Once again, there is precisely zero evidence at all that at any time was Saydrah paid to submit anything to reddit (nevermind that the poll assume this as fact).

2
smpx•

I like your post, so I'm going to reply to it.

a) GiantBatFart isn't a moderator, as far as I know. The idea is that anyone can pimp their sites, their employer's sites, or their clients' sites, so long as they're not tipping the system in their favor or cheating the system.

b) I didn't like the comments, but I understand why she made them.

c) There's several threads dedicated to this.

d) Her job does pose a pretty significant conflict of interest, and for a long time, it was based on trust that she would not use her powers in a negative manner. The same issue occurred with another mod who other mods had reasons to believe was using it in a negative way, and he was removed for the same reasons-- because that trust was broken. When the trust that Saydrah carried vanished, conflict of interest became an issue.

Think of it this way, we trust the Admins would not engage in shady acts, at least that they would not engage in acts against the spirit of reddit without announcement. If they did, however, you would likely see another shitstorm. For future purposes, it would be a good idea to just snip it at the bud and just say those who could pose a conflict of interest (at least the appearance of one) should just steer clear of power positions unless necessary.

e) The poll was limited, yes, but I think it's fair to say that enough people felt there was an issue here.

3
splidge•

Yet another poor deluded soul who seems to believe that facts have any bearing whatsoever on this whole debacle.

For what it's worth I also find it slightly disturbing that the term "conflict of interest" is being bandied about as if she was some important politician or judge or something rather than a moderator on an Internet site.

I really feel for you. Keep fighting the good fight.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
jcy•

who cares, she was a bitch and she had to go. end of story.

-3
verifythisforme•

And thank you for initially pointing it out and letting us all see it for what is was. The evidence showed me that a conflict of interest was at hand and the people have spoken.

So cheers to you SirOblivious.

54
fas2•

It has been pointed out before though, right? Just nothing came of it.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

25
RoboBama•

she was just removed from r/comics. i feel my work here is done.

btw www.reddit.com/r/whatofsaydrah

you saw that right?

2
Jeed•

Yes thank you I wasn't sure what was going on until I saw that picture.

6
notaloop•

I lol at the conflict of interest arguments. Did she ever submit links to subreddits she was a mod for? I didn't see any in SirOblivious' post.

-3
weblypistol•

She submitted an Associated Content post to relationship advice at least ( you can check when reddit search decides to work) , something directly against statements she has made about being a mod and conflict of interests. The conflict of interests line is a distraction though. She is a spammer.

0
notaloop•

Okay, so in this one instance, I will agree at the conflict of interest. As to her spammer status, several mods stood up for her and said her role as moderator in several subreddits was invaluable. Regardless, action has already been taken against her though, so there is little point in discussing it anymore. The lynch mob has spoken.

2
weblypistol•

I've been keeping out of this, but having looked at it all, I don't think anything has really changed. Sure she has been douchey to some, I have to those that irked me. She can call 90% of users shit if she wants, be hypocritical in askmeanything, flood new posts. She can fall back on discrimination against people with mental health issues in passive aggressive posts despite being for equality and the cuddly animals. The duck face house man did do something sneaky in redirecting. That link had one ad though, yet his history indicates an interest in ads and marketing.

Let's get real though. What exactly is spamming? Blogspam is frowned on, ok. People pushing links for private gain results in banning. Whilst Saydrah has submitted a lot ( and arguably that's part of her strategy), in that there have been a hell of a lot of certain links. It's not ratio, but the numbers of the dubious links hidden in that. Other spammers get banned for it. Her private messages show she doesn't like it. It's not even a conflict of interests thing. Still doubt? Do a search with her name and the domains that suggest advertising issues, petlvr , disaboom, and associatedcontent.com and look at the posts submitted. Particularly the last and when she started employment with them and how disaboom links tailed away. Other spammers would be kicked pronto, even if they did try to claim value posts or that they were upfront. An Associated Content post even found a way into relationship advice.

Edited to remove ads and spellungs

Edit2 Search not playing ball, but Associated Content links started around 8 months ago and were at around 130 posts ( thought it was more ). Disaboom, which stopped being posted 8 months ago were at about 120 posts. Petlvr I can't remember.

29
Spaceman_Spliff•

Do a search with her name and the domains that suggest advertising issues, petlvr , disaboom, and associatedcontent.com and look at the posts submitted. Particularly the last and when she started employment with them and how disaboom links tailed away. Other spammers would be kicked pronto, even if they did try to claim value posts or that they were upfront. An Associated Content post even found a way into relationship advice.

The admins have "investigated" it. A lot of moderators don't care. This is probably a lot more conman than most realize; there is more $$ changing hands behind the scenes than most know about.

7
RoboBama•

She should be removed from r/comics.

5
szopin•

Your input is welcome in redditconspiracy

3
Spaceman_Spliff•

Okay, I'm in.

1
ShawnGupta•

90% assholes on an Internet forum is not that bad...

2
Nerdlinger•

No, democracy did not prevail. There was no vote, only loud yelling and ranting by a tiny fraction of the community.

This is not justice, great or small, this was squeaky wheels getting what they wanted in order to shut them up. Enjoy your grease.

23
[deleted]•

I thought all the upvoting was supposed to matter? This submission has far more upvotes than down, as did all the stuff you claim was "yelling and ranting by a tiny fraction". Clearly this only matters when YOU agree with it.

24
Nerdlinger•

Now compare the number of upvotes to the size of the subreddit. It's less than 1%. And the number of upvotes is only a bit more than twice the number of downvotes. There's hardly a consensus in the community that this is what should have been done.

2
furburger•

Now factor in the number of inactive accounts, then factor in the number of people who don't log in every day. A community of 80000 members will usually only have 1000-2000 people online at any given moment.

7
yul_brynner•

Did you expect the whole subreddit to come in and cast a vote at once?

5
[deleted]•

well remember that 90% of reddit are shitheads so perhaps the 10% is the squeaky wheel he refers to ?

2
[deleted]•

As has been noted many many times, pretty much every non-spam submission receives roughly a '70% like this' figure. This is how large masses of people vote, it's predictable and not indicative really of whether or not people like it.

On very very controversial topics, you sometimes see it dip to '60% like this', sometimes.

2
Reductive•

I thought all the upvoting was supposed to matter?

Dude, here's what upvoting is for:

Moderate based on quality, not opinion. Well-written and interesting content can be worthwhile, even if you disagree with it.

1
wtfimdrunk•

Because, clearly an Internet upvote is a fair and balanced approach. Nothing can go wrong there, nope. I guarantee you the vast majority of Reddit doesn't give a shit about this issue, just the bumper crop of stupid rejects like yourself. Have a pleasant day.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
TravelingChef•

Whoa whoa, I think you're traveling down the wrong road here. This is how reddit works. More up than down actually does has some significance. However small, it is still how the front page of every subreddit (sans tldr) operates. I will be ignoring your post soon when it enters the oblivion.

2
mrmaster2•

Just to play devil's advocate, where do you get the idea that it was only a "tiny fraction of the community?"

While the Reddit community is large as a whole, the fraction that actively and regularly contributes to it is much smaller. Of these people, it certainly seemed like many were "upset" by the entire situation.

It looks like there was a sizeable portion of Reddit that was upset with her, a portion that was upset but decided not to post, and a portion (probably the largest) that was apathetic and wanted this whole thing to go away.

I think only a tiny fraction of the community actually did not want to see any action taken at all, and as such, they did not receive their grease.

2
Nerdlinger•

where do you get the idea that it was only a "tiny fraction of the community?

From the fact that we are seeing on the order of thousands of upvotes (and running only about a 2:1 up:down ratio) for these submissions and posts in favor of banning/removal from on the order of hundreds of people, while there are hundreds of thousands of people in this subreddit. I know that not all of them are active, but that is still a woefully small fraction to base a decision like this on.

1
mrmaster2•

So you assume that everyone who is silent does not want her removed? This is faulty.

The best you can do is compare everyone in support of action being taken vs. the people against action being taken (an extremely small minority), assume most of the silent people are apathetic, and go from there.

Considering the massive amount of highly upvoted posts on this issue, it was clear that the Reddit community spoke, like it or not. It's disingenious and naive to assume otherwise.

4
Vitalstatistix•

A-freakin'-greed. This 4 day witch hunt has been absolutely pathetic. I thought our community was above this pitch-fork crap, but I guess not.

1
tsuga•

Jesus. Some of you people obviously take all this shit way too seriously.

Seriously.

18
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
voltagex•

OK mate, are you going to calm down now that you've achieved your goal?

9
daramel•

No, he's "keeping an eye" on her. Apparently, it's unacceptable that she moderates anything, even subreddits that are text-only.

6
voltagex•

Ya know, IRL that's called stalking.

4
skooma714•

She can't spam a subreddit that has nothing but self posts that follow a strict pattern. Deviating from that pattern would immediatly raise eyebrows, especially after Saydrah-gate. What damage could she possibly if so inclined (which I doubt on all counts) there?

9
daramel•

It's a witch-hunt. This guy just showed us all his true colors, and people are still congratulating him.

5
Silver_•

Are you serious? Why the fuck haven't you been banned yet? Online harrassment is a crime, right?

8
[deleted]•

Call the internet sheriff asap.

9
ohmyashleyy•

Seriously, he needs to just shut the hell up already. Alright, you've accomplished your goal, now get over it.

2
Silver_•

Yeah. But it's patently obvious that this guy has some sort of vendetta against her. If I were a mod/admin, I'd get rid of him because of all the dangerous shit he's doing, and because he has an obvious agenda. Focusing all this hate on one person is harassment, no matter who they are, and it really can't be tolerated.

4
[deleted]•

I hate you.

Am I bannable now?

Get real...

0
[deleted]•

What's the difference between an angry mob out to lynch someone and Democracy?

I guess you're actually correct. There isn't one.

8
SirOblivious•

Well when this happened months ago, it wasn't an angry mob when it was discussed, the mods did nothing.

This whole thing that came up is not new, I don't think a lot of users know this. It has went on for 6 months or more . And not all started by me, lots of other users caught on to things here and there that she would do, make posts, and mods would ignore or others would ignore.

It just slowly turned into all the facts on my one post, then I was flooded with messages of support, and evidence against her.

True, some people went overboard and did things, but thats not on my account, most of us just wanted reddit to be fair, thats all. I've said in many posts that I hold no hard feelings against her personally. But just her actions here, were extremely unfair to the community.

I and a lot of others felt that way.

Shortly after she made some mistakes of her own and lost a lot of respect from her own communities and subeddits.

I don't feel that just posting a sob story and pretending to be a victim is any way to gain respect.

When it was first reported months ago she should have stepped down, for a while, to sort things out. I would imagine that even for a short time that would have corrected any issues or misunderstandings

But it seems she dug herself the hole she is in, with lies

1
DrHenryPym•

I feel Democracy prevailed.

I feel this is more of a lynch mob getting their way.

Congratulations.

7
ugnaught•

Sir Oblivious is a user for about 2 weeks and has been leading the charge. If this doesn't smell of a planned attack...

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ThickGreenPuke•

So that means methods of a lynch mob actually provide results when compared to democracy.

Hey everybody! Who wants to join my new "Lynch Mob" party?

6
[deleted]•

We had one of those little over 40 years ago. Not really the best time to live in the South.

1
[deleted]•

Something isn't it.

1
RoboBama•

Haahah yes!

/robobama passes siroblivious a cyber-guinness

6
SirOblivious•

The community prevailed ! Thanks for your work, team efforts paid off in getting the information out to everyone

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Gravity13•

You're heroes among men!

Now let's circle-jerk!

*tools.

-4
Telemachussneezed•

Came here specifically to upvote for great justice.

I give it to you instead.

5
reddit_sux•

http://i.imgur.com/ii8iQ.png

It’s great that you’ve exposed her and all, but seriously, who goes to this trouble? You’re so concerned about conflicts of interest, well, what’s your interest in all this?

4
[deleted]•

A functioning community that isn't full of spammers? Reddit not turning into Digg?

3
gukeums1•

I hate to break it to you but Saydrah is the fucking tip of the iceberg if you really want to go down that road

6
reddit_sux•

You believe that?

5
[deleted]•

Nice work, Detective. The coup de grâce has finally been delivered.

4
Gravity13•

Oddly enough, it wasn't Saydrah that got hit with the coup de grâce. It was any sense of having a composed community. Nice work!

4
hans1193•

Do tell, how should a composed community have dealt with it?

3
Gravity13•

Well, first, not by calling for blood. Second, not by downvoting everybody trying to bring reason to it (including Saydrah herself). Third, trying to get the other side of the story before taking some random guys words for heart.

2
daramel•

She's not going to make any money off of IAmA. Why do you care about that one?

4
SirOblivious•

Not so sure about that, she did just so happen to know that movie director

Better put this way, she offered that she knew a movie director to do an IAmA and they did, but it was some sort of push for money to be donated , its like the guy posted but begged for money and reddit gave it to him, all setup by her

A lot of others called her out on the thread. Most want her gone from it as well, but I will remain open minded until I can see something otherwise

-1
gnosticfryingpan•

The movie had made the news due to the amount it had been downloaded iirc. It had already been on the frontpage and was famous for the wide circulation it had got through p2p.

4
scrumbud•

Damn, you're right! I gave some money to that director! Granted, I really enjoyed the movie, and at the time, totally felt that I got my money's worth, but now I feel ripped off!

I'll likely get downvoted for this, but even if she did make money by setting up that AMA, I don't care. She helped bring a great movie to my attention, one which I probably would not have heard of otherwise.

3
VelvetElvis•

Make her wear a scarlet S on her chest?

3
SirOblivious•

A scarlet $ dollar sign maybe

1
sabowski•

Since when is Reddit a democracy?

3
SpaizKadett•

You're an unforgiving arsehole!

3
yelirekim•

It does feel good to witness voices being heard. I don't really even care about the issue at hand, but obviously there are a lot of people here who do and it makes me smile to know that what this community thinks matters.

1
Technohazard•

SO SAY US ALL.

1
frack0verflow•

What really grates me is that everyone is playing her game... sure she DID NOT contravene the TOS but that is her modus operandi.

This new for of evil lurks amongst us posing as one of us when in fact it is nothing but.

She rationalises what she does using semantics and loopholing the TOS but that does not change the fact that what she does is obvious to us all.

Let me remind everyone:

"...create authentic [sic] relationships..."

"...maximise promotional potential..."

This person is a cancerous force of marketing, no matter how much relationship advice (with what fucking qualifications I might ask- she seems a bit nutty TBH), no matter how many cute pics she posts IT IS ALL THERE TO MAXIMISE 'HER PROMOTIONAL POTENTIAL' ...never forget that.

1
wtfimdrunk•

This is not a democracy. You didn't win from a just position, like you want to believe. You simply caused a lot of noise, ended up on the front page and continued your tirade against an online user until the admin decided to move her to change subjects. The core issue was not resolved. You are a simple person just smart enough to raise the blood pressure of other simple minded rabble on this site to make them flood to your crusade. Fact is, there was never a public debate about this with the admin's known presence, no polls, just a lot of noisy-ass throwaway accounts screaming 'Witch, burn her!'. If that's democracy, I continue to assure myself that democracy is a shame and doesn't work. Anyone who follows a hustler like SirOblivious is just as much foolish as any other follower of the numerous political/religious/social groups that Reddit oh so loves to piss on with impunity. Have a pleasant day.

1
notaloop•

I lol at the conflict of interest arguments. Did she ever submit links to subreddits she was a mod for?

0
BatmansHairstylist•

I'll probably get a few downvotes for this but SirOblivious, you are an obnoxious piece of shit!

The fact that you have had the time lead such a thorough investigation can only lead me to believe that you have zero life outside of reddit. I feel sorry for you that you probably have nothing better to do with your life. It really is just sad.

0
drew3000•

Thanks sheriff. If we had a hall monitor badge, you'd be the one wearing it.

0
guyincorporated•

Yeah, I'd hate to see associated content articles start showing up on IAMA.

I hope you enjoyed your 15 minutes of e-fame.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
SirOblivious•

Have you ever had sex before? You should try it, with a women sometime.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
SirOblivious•

Dad

-1
johnlennin•

I think you can take the day off. Or just stop blabbering in general.

Why is r/IamA related at all anyway?

-1
ramijames•

I would say mob rule prevailed.

-1
AThinker•

the part that 90% are shitheads, totally inaccurate.

i'd say 40 percent are shitheads, but rising.

-2
romcabrera•

http://i.imgur.com/ii8iQ.png

Wow man, you really have no life... Either that or the Internet is serious business for you.

-3
centipeed•

The actions of a woman he's never met before, which will in all likelihood have no effect on him or anyone else for that matter, are VERY important to him, and you shouldn't mock him like this! It's despicable!

1
romcabrera•

It's a pity to see that (right now) he has 168 net karma for that comment, and I am downmodded. I have 3 years on reddit, sadly we have come to this...

4
[deleted]•

Yeah, principle never matters. Ever.

0
STILLADDICT•

*** If another moderator has a problem with this, and re-adds her to the mod list, there's not much I can do.

  • I'm not a Genius or anything. but couldn't you just remove her again?
246
smpx•

It would create an infinite loop, causing the universe to collapse.

182
thingamagizmo•

He did say he wasn't a genius.

107
UnnamedPlayer•

He also said that he is not 'anything', which is a logical impossibility. That leads me to doubt that he may indeed be a genius and just trying to hide his awesome brainpower by commenting on a waste of an issue about a moderator on a news aggregator site and the supposed non-vanilla stuff she may or may not be doing ON THE INTERNET!

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
norm_•

Much like googling the world "Google"

6
xx3nvyxx•
6
Jawesomist•

It's the infinite versions of yourself via mirrors trick all over again!

1
ElliotNess•

You gotta be "feeling lucky"

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
perezidentt•

Divide by zero?

1
Aikidi•

That seems kind of petty to me.

1
PhillyWick•

You ask me for a hamburger.....

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
D3adp00l•

If another moderator has a problem with this, and re-adds her to the mod list, there's not much I can do.

Seems to me someone is just trying to cover their ass when another Mod returns Saydrah back to power.

30
wardrox•

"power". Hmm, mods carry buckets and mops rather then crowns, unless I've been horribly mislead all this time.

23
Gackt•

Yeah, but when a mod uses all of his cleaning liquids on his own bathroom and doesn't use in your bathroom, then that's a bad mod.

2
wafu•

And that mop is diamond-encrusted.

1
GrammarBeImportant•

Wouldn't that put her on the opposite side of the MMM fiasco though? Which I think even a psyco bitch would be smart enough to avoid.

1
melodramatic_monkey•

Yeah, couldn't she just Saydrah back in and no one would be none the wiser?

1
[deleted]•

Have you ever seen or read the Sneetches?

22
[deleted]•

total upvote for the Sneetches name drop, very applicable too.

1
fireburt•

I would think krispy has better things to do with his time than get in a remove/add battle with another mod.

18
[deleted]•

Simple solution: remove all other mods. Then you can do what is best for the community without their interference.

22
fireburt•

Good idea. While we're at it, Obama should just remove congress so he can implement a health care system.

3
lameth•

Brilliant!
I think this idea should be adopted in other walks of life: school, economics, politics
oh wait

1
[deleted]•

I would think that if other mods respected Krispy, as they should, then they will not add her. If they do not respect Krispy, why are they mods?

7
spherecow•

her time! krispy is one of the calendar girls.

1
fireburt•

Damn, I stopped before I posted to think if I knew if it was a man or woman, but I wasn't sure so I just went with the "he" I saw other people using.

1
Fauster•

If she's added again, shit will blow up again, and reddit can change its catch pharse: "reddit: Where you'll find all the news on Saydrah, all the time" Don't know who Saydrah is? Don't worry. We'll tell you again and again because we care so much about keeping crappy and uninteresting content off of the front page.

3
Derris-Kharlan•

DIVIDE BY ZERO

2
itsnotlupus•

I'm going to take a wild guess: This was done to get the angry mob to cool down and maybe take a few days to reflect on what just happened, and everyone's role in it.

2
ycc2106•

That exactly what I wanted to highlight.

Hope other mods also consider the community... she must have enough mod friends no?

Just saying, I don't even know who she is. All I know is what I read yesterday: that many have considered her to be balancing things her way.

2
Revvy•

Now where's the internet drama in that?

1
Jinno•

I'm not a Genius...

What the hell does working at an Apple Store have to do with reddit?

1
[deleted]•

I'm fairly new here, but I know her from another site she posts on and I have this to say:

Saydrah is invaluable at giving relationship advice?? That's incredibly frightening.

238
[deleted]•

At moderating the relationship_advice subreddit.

80
[deleted]•

Is it just me, or is that subreddit a bit....sparse?

24
junkit33•

Taking relationship advice over the Internet is probably not the best idea. It's nearly impossible to give good advice to somebody without knowing both people in the relationship. Thus everything you're going to hear is lopsided, made up, or based on one's own previous experience which typically is not very relevant.

27
[deleted]•

Often, I feel the best advice is "Why are you taking advice from people over the Internet? Aren't you supposed to know this person best? Maybe it's not a good relationship if you have known this person for years and don't know how to tell these basic things?"

There are questions where that's not the answer, but they're few and far between compared to "How do I tell if my man..." or "I want to tell my girl..." questions.

1
nolander•

Those of us with relationships don't want to share our secrets?

5
habbazoot•

Oh that's not true. Take a look at AskReddit.

1
ntou45•

Which means... she's doing a great job at keeping out the spam?

3
dieselmachine•

And the legitimate posts!

0
doctor_alligator•

A lot of relationship advice ends up on askReddit. Like the Theo fiasco.

1
Fatvod•

Asking for relationship advice from reddit is like asking a retarded monkey your next chess move.

1
[deleted]•

dating != relationships.

1
[deleted]•

Updated because apparently it is actually r/relationship_advice

0
buu700•

Anyone can moderate a subreddit. As the creator of r/relationship_advice, I assure you that her advice is why we need her.

5
anonymous1•

Anyone can create a subreddit. As the person who never visited r/relationship_advice, I assure you that I care little more than r/apathy does about the value of her advice.

14
buu700•

Anyone can create a subreddit.

Whether or not it's difficult is irrelevant; the point is that I've spent a lot of time watching her give great advice.

As the person who never visited r/relationship_advice

Oh, I'm sure you're not the only one.

I assure you that I care little more than r/apathy does about the value of her advice.

Were you to desire some you would care.

2
j3w3ly•

You have to be a mod to give advice? I'm pretty sure she would still be able to make comments without mod status.

1
buu700•

The latter is correct.

1
williamhgates•

From the subreddit info page:

"Submitters: Please use proper English."

I am trying to contain the grammar Nazi in me. Please, there's no such thing as "proper" English. There is standard English and there are non-standard English grammars (yes, grammars - plural), but there's no such thing as "proper" English. Ask any linguistics professor if you want to verify what I am saying.

-1
buu700•

From Oxford:

proper
• adjective 1 truly what something is said or regarded to be; genuine. 2 after a noun strictly so called: the World Cup proper. 3 suitable or appropriate; correct. 4 respectable, especially excessively so. 5 (proper to) belonging or relating exclusively to. 6 Heraldry in the natural colours.

2
tits_and_skippy•

Wait, we have a relationship_advice subreddit? I should hang out there more often!

1
itsnotlupus•

no, both, actually.

Go dig up some old relationship_advice threads. Saydrah's advice is pretty consistently the most thoughtful in any given one.

1
nikdahl•

I will probably be downvoted for this. But Saydrah gave incredible advice - relationship or otherwise. I will always respect her opinion. I've never had a bad experience with her.

But whatever...that's just me.

15
williamhgates•

I've never had a bad experience with her.

What is she? Amazon or Newegg? You're not buying anything from her. Evaluating your prior experience with her seems silly.

17
BrianRCampbell•

A++++++++++++++ WOULD EXPERIENCE AGAIN!!!!!!!

18
sirnoobius•

son, I am experience.

1
otherwiseyep•

DEVELOPS AUTHENTIC RELATIONSHIPS WITH SHITHEADS A+

1
[deleted]•

We're supposed to be banning her for what she's done in the past. Yet, I'm with nikdahl here. I've only known her from XX and Relationship Advice and she's been nothing but helpful.

1
devedander•

She has to. By her own rules it's 4 non sponsored submissions to every 1 sponsored one.

Realistically she was probably actaully giving you good hearfealt advice, but I feel sorry for anyone who got advice that was just her fulfilling her quota of 4 to 1 ratio.

-4
fireburt•

but I feel sorry for anyone who got advice that was just her fulfilling her quota of 4 to 1 ratio.

What? So you think she was giving heartfelt advice to people who were reaching out to this community for help, but becaue she was giving this advice for the wrong reasons you feel bad for the people receiving the advice?

Now you can think she is a bitch for only doing it to "fulfill her quota" (though I believe she really enjoyed it), but the people getting the advice still got the good advice so why would you feel sorry for them?

12
devedander•

If it was really good advice, then that's great. But if it was just filler and not hearfelt or well thoughtout advice just to meet a quota or build a relationship... that's like a therapist who says nice things to you so she can meet her billable hours. Even if it makes you feel good, it's not necessarily good advice and in this case might undermine the value of the well thoughtout, solid advice from others.

This is the problem with being caught out like Saydrah... it starts to cast shadows of doubt on anything you do.

8
davega7•

but the people getting the advice still got the good advice so why would you feel sorry for them?

Exactly. Here's a copy and paste from part of a comment I made the other day which says something similar:

A while back I used another name to post about a problem I was having. She, along with a few others, not only gave me good advice, but also made me aware of other aspects I hadn't considered. Did she do it simply because she's a good person concerned about another human being? Or was it because she's getting paid to 'worm' her way in here? I have no idea, but I do know I sure as hell didn't pay her for the advice she gave, and I'm still the one who received the benefit regardless of motive.

8
rooktakesqueen•

How many people do you think got served relationship advice from Associated Content's servers? I can't imagine it's many.

4
devedander•

I don't know, I suppose it's possible AC's affiliate blogs or sites were linked to at some point as advice?

But more directly (and what I was actually saying) was that it would be bad if you recieved a half assed/not thought through/filler of an advice response just so the poster could get some more posts up.

1
[deleted]•

Saydrah is invaluable at giving relationship advice?? That's incredibly frightening.

Let me tell you why this is frightening. Whenever someone has a bunch of scared, depressed, angry people at their disposal -- it's very easy to push any products you want on them. They are needy.

Power corrupts. Moderation is thankless. SEO is evil.

6
anonytroll•

Judging by her video at associated content, she seems socially awkward and certainly not the type of girl who has guys all over her. I don't see how she's the least bit qualified to give relationship advice or why anyone would take her advice seriously.

3
ContentWithOurDecay•

Seriously, she is the last person I would take advice from.

1
[deleted]•

Most people upvoting this probably never hang out in r/Relationship_advice. She really does nail it most of the time.

-2
williamhgates•

Nail it most of the time? Without knowing any of the people personally? That's because it's a bunch of Dear Abby type bullshit. It's so formulaic, it's ridiculous. That's all non-personal relationship advice is anyway. If you want good relationship advice, ask people who know you -- not Saydrah (an Internet stranger).

Besides, please help me out here. Another Redditor claimed that Saydrah graduated from high school in 2006. How can someone so young be so good at dishing relationship advice? At best, she has been in relationships for a little longer than a decade (most of that time was spent on puppy love/middle school/high school relationships). What kind of quality relationship advice are you going to get from someone who has that little experience? Not only is she too young to have a thorough, varied relationship life, the advice -- at best -- is formulaic and predictable....something you could buy from a vending machine.

5
yaen•

She gives absolutely incredible relationship advice. If she only graduated HS in 2006, that is quite shocking for how sound and mature her advice was for my relationship (yes, you don't ask the Internet unless you're desperate and you've exhausted your irl resources and/or you can't talk to people you trust for conflict of interest reasons).

However, I've come to learn that wisdom comes early in life for some people, especially for the people coming of age right now. I am excited to see what that generation does for our world. I respect them a lot more than the generation above mine (I'm 28 this year.) I would not disregard advice or insight based on age. I've gotten some great advice from 5-year-olds.

-4
dpower•

You're fuckin' high!

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
ibrokereddit•

Your boyfriend cheated on you? Well, he was a shithead and so are you!

-3
Azured•

Thank you for making the right decision.

202
[deleted]•

It is worrying how difficult it was for this person to make the right decision.

100
Fat_Dumb_Americans•

Very true, and then there's the matter of the celebrity mods who openly supported her position.

43
wardrox•

Quick whilst we have this mob assembled, let's go after some more people!

RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE!

15
Hypocriticizer•

Says a mod who was also on the side of companies ruining reddit a few months ago;

Cough Destructoid turning the gaming reddit into the Destructoid reddit cough

5
sirfink•

Just what exactly has that so-called "doctor" been working on in that gloomy old castle of his, eh?! I say he's up to no-good!

4
woodengineer•

Yeah lets get rid of this wardrox guy...what a pain in the ass!

Edit: I take it wardrox can't take a joke..jeeze maybe I was right.

0

have a list of the celebrity mods so I can avoid them in the future?

0
randomwolf•

Thank you. I came here to say just that. I've been only slightly aware of the situation, but it was instantly clear that there was, at least, the appearance of a conflict of interest.

Removing mod status based on that ALONE is an easy straightforward decision to make.

Had it been immediately clear what here relationship and employment status, and restrictions put in place the prevent the conflict, there would be no problem.

However, the situation was found out independently, and only then did a mea culpa appear.

I feel bad for her, and thank her for serving in the thankless job of a moderator, but for the sake of the site, the decision to remove her as such is a no brainer IMHO.

16
KevRose•

Just because Hitler saves a cat down from a tree doesn't mean we should glorify him for his 'thankless job'.

9
DaGreatPenguini•

Godwin!

4
CommentMan•

You just compared a reddit mod to Hitler.

Really?

Do you work for the Star-Telegram perchance?

0
electricboogaloo•

Mods have jobs, families & lives outside of Reddit. They're in different time zones all over the world. Given those circumstances and their desire not to get swept up in the latest fad (thank you mods), taking a few days to figure out what's going on is prudent. If krispykrackers had removed her from mod status right away, someone else would've put her right back on the list.

What worries me is that any mod can put her right back on the list. At any time. In this subreddit or in any other. I feel like I'll constantly have to be watching out for the "spammer mod". -- Is that a fair lable? Is it earned? Maybe/maybe not. There's no way to know for sure and no amount of name calling is going to change that. I'm disheartened.

1
centipeed•

Indeed. Especially since they ended up not making it.

0
PSteak•

Personal loyalty is important. I should hope it would be a difficult decision to strike down a friend.

0
Gravity13•

To cave in to the angry mob or not to cave in - yeah, that's not a very easy decision to make.

-3
Ijustdoeyes•

I agree.

You can't brag about gaming it and then turnaround and say you cared.

Thank you for making the right decision.

48
pgdx•

You do not speak on behalf of the Reddit community.

-53
donwilson•

Neither do you.

45
[deleted]•

No one does. They all speak for themselves. I'd be happy to hear why you disagree though.

43
danstermeister•

<cricket>

10
junkit33•

The karma seems to make it look like he speaks a lot more accurately for the community than you do.

28
Veteran4Peace•

He didn't say "On behalf of the Reddit community, blah, blah, blah...."

14
anonid•

She has not cheated the system or the algorithm in any way

In her reply to the original Oatmeal post that called her out (can't find it now since apparently all these threads have had 50% of posts deleted), she says (direct quote) - "Being a mod gives me no advantages except a free pass past the SPAM FILTER". For a person that submits a lot, sometimes a dozen times in a spam of a few minutes, that would be cheating the system, period. And it kinda pisses me off personally since I've had zero success slipping the most innocuous Yahoo News story past this magical mysterious filter.

202
Rhyono•

sometimes a dozen times in a spam of a few minutes

That typo is acceptable in this situation.

129
IkeArumba•

How about 'I am so dick of lesbians!'?

35
[deleted]•

a Freudian slip is when you say one thing, and mean your mother.

16
ki11a11hippies•

Freudian slip is when you enter the wrong hole, but it was secretly the one you were hoping for.

1
FUCKY_DOODLE_DANDY•

Actually, typo is more likely, the brain is still thinking of the word spam.

1
dakboy•

Paging Dr. Freud!

0
wardrox•

If you're having trouble with the spam filter message the mods. If they suck, I'm a mod for r/pics and r/gaming (I think I mod comics too... need to check) and am always happy to help :)

11
jooes•

It's pretty inconvenient to do that, though. Like, the less I have to talk to people, the happier I am in life.

42
IrrigatedPancake•

Glad to have you as part of the community!

14
wardrox•

Well, yeah, but until the Spam filter is 100% accurate and never goes wrong (totally doable btw), it'll still need the mod's gentile, loving caress to keep things rolling.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
killiefish•

Oops, I read the last line as "keep things trolling." Lol

1
wanderingmind•

Doesn't work. I submit stories, they get caught in spam filter, they notice and unban it, and it appears at the slot in New stories list where should have appeared when it was submitted. No one sees it then.

In popular subreddits, when unbanned, the submission appears on the second or third page of New subs.

2
wardrox•

Well, that's the best system we've got. The filter is designed to learn over time, so even if it screws your submission, getting a mod to unblock it will help your future submissions.

1
Detry•

Ah, so /that's/ why you're never in IRC no more :P

1
wardrox•

Haha, that and I'm hanging out with the cool kids in #ng ;D

1
butrosbutrosfunky•

I'd be very interested to see examples of her 'spam' because her posting history looks like nothing but quality, and the link submissions were more or less only once a day. This is also considering the Admins seem to have no problem with her posting habits either, and said so in their blog about the whole fiasco.

This whole thing sounds like bullshit to me.

5
lambardar•

cannot upvote you enough :(

2
BenPS•

For a person that submits a lot, sometimes a dozen times in a spam of a few minutes...

hehehe

1
Haiavaha•

Then shouldn't the spam filter be enabled for mods by default? Obviously, a mod ought to be able let a post pass the filter if necessary, but posts by mods shouldn't by default be allowed past the filter.

1
xinu•

whether it's allowed by default is irrelevant. as a mod, they themselves have the power to let it through the filter

1
Shambles•

I'd love to see the original quote, because I'm pretty sure mods don't get a free pass past the spam filter. And the submissions people are complaining about weren't submitted to any of the Reddits she modded.

1
radient•

It's weird I've started submitting articles more often recently and I've yet to encounter this spam filter that everyone complains about. What exactly is it filtering? random blogs or something?

1
z3ddicus•

sometimes a dozen times in a spam of a few minutes

I see what you did there.

0
itsnotlupus•

For a person that submits a lot, sometimes a dozen times in a spam of a few minutes, that would be cheating the system, period.

Yes, but no.

  1. She was speaking hypothetically, as in the most thing mod access to a subreddit would allow. for a given subreddit.
  2. Folks have checked if it actually happened. Admins have said as much. They saw no evidence of it.
  3. She mostly submits stuff in subreddit she is not a mod in, which means she can't fix any spam flagging in those subreddits anyway.
  4. The frequency of stuff she does submit in subreddit where she is a moderator is most certainly low enough to not trigger any reasonable spam filter, particularly one that would take into account the account age and karma.

None of this would be very hard to think through yourself, but hey, the witch hunt lives on.

0
[deleted]•

sometimes a dozen times in a spam of a few minutes

[citation needed]

-1
SVTBert•

Citation has been provided in other threads, in case you haven't been following all of this.

1
[deleted]•

I haven't. Mind linking me?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

201
[deleted]•

What is this women that you talk about?

30
tits_and_skippy•

Oh, believe you me, we exist. ;)

4
gregny2002•

YEAH RIGHT. The last time I fell for that one I ended up in an embarrassing picture that circulated around the entire net. It was called Lemon something-or-other.

5
[deleted]•

Tits and skippy, eh...

...What are you doing saturday night?

3
juma606•

Sounds like a labrador.

8
Nourn•

It's a kind of carnival game, with sticks and hoops.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
darksabrelord•

I guess I don't follow reddit as closely as I thought, what was the calendar drama?

17
[deleted]•

I think a lot of it was in this thread discussing the calendar.

7
jskeetjr•

Sounds like she was the one making all the good points there.

3
[deleted]•

this is a good point?

"Deny it all you like, the only people you're hurting with your criticism are the twelve women who freely gave their time and images for use in the calendar. If you enjoy saying hurtful and hateful things to women who make independent choices about what to do with their bodies, bully for you. But don't ask me to consider you some sort of advocate for women's rights because you're here criticizing me for my choices as a woman. I'll consider you an advocate for women's rights when you attack people who harm women, not when you attack your women for their decisions."

9
chairface•

Thank you. I try to avoid the places Saydrah frequents because of her ridiculously confrontational manner, so I have less experience with her than some. But, I do find myself wondering what experiences these others have had, who claim that she's just awesome wherever she comments. Are we reading completely different sides of the same person? I am genuinely confused.

edit: spelling

7
williamhgates•

She's been the bottom of the barrel of redditors since the rest of us women finally got on her case and asked her to keep her attitude in check when it came to the calendar.

Can you tell us more about this? I didn't follow the whole calendar thing and what may have transpired.

2
nathan1313us•

She is still a mod just not for r/pics. My adblock is still running strong I suggest everyone else runs theirs as well. Hit them in the pocket until she is gone and banned. Account deleted and karma gone.

-1
wardrox•

Whilst I like your sentiment, I'm not sure that's quite how it works.

As best as I understand (and worded simply because I'm hungry) ad money goes to Reddit's owners. Below the owners are the Admins who have already stated they didn't find reason to remove her, and moved on with their lives a few days ago. Below them are the Mods, one of which removed her Mod status.

Ad block impacts this situation about as much as [insert witty your-mom joke].

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
voltagex•

Give it a rest, will you?

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
EthicalReasoning•

is it true that women have vaginas??

-3
phudabulah•

I heard their periods attract bears... the bears can smell the menstruation!

11
Rhyono•

I apologize on behalf of reddit for the children who are downvoting you. Someday, they will watch Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy and understand the greatness of your quote.

1
PSteak•

I upvoted him for the sheer oddity of his/her non-sequitur. Your post seemed to indicate that is was merely a pop culture reference. This severely diminishes my opinion of the comment, and enough so that I find myself downvoting it for the sole reason that it is just from some movie. Congratulations for ruining it.

3
Sle•

I can't believe that it took this much appealing, drama and evidence to get a simple thing like this done.

To those bleating about the level of drama: There would have been next to no drama if this had been stamped out.

I fear the real reason for the dragging of feet is solidarity. Think on that, and be scared.

139
[deleted]•

It isn't solidarity, actually. The mods aren't a cohesive group. They shared their individual opinions in various topics, but no one stepped forward to take an officially declared position partly for fear of the shit that would reign down. It wasn't the public outcry that caused this removal to happen, but the result of a lot of deliberation.

30
[deleted]•

That and the fact that krispy has a pair. Good on her for doing the dirty work others were loathe to do.

52
[deleted]•

Damn straight. I'm proud of her, and I've told her so. It wasn't easy to do this, but she stood up for what she felt was right, even though Saydrah was a friend of hers.

32
[deleted]•

She is still a friend of ours. Believe it or not, she's stronger that a little bit of Reddit drama.

8
junkit33•

but no one stepped forward to take an officially declared position partly for fear of the shit that would reign down

In a way that almost bothers me more than anything. If true I give major credit to krispykrackers for taking the bull by the horns and respecting the community's wishes. Nice to know that somebody represents who they are supposed to represent.

35
[deleted]•

Actually, I should amend that. That was pretty goddamn rude to the other moderators, and I apologize for that. It's not that simple. Saydrah was friends with a lot of us. She was a nice person, and I think a lot of people couldn't believe the allegations at first. It was less painful to hope someone else would step up than to decide a friend of yours had been lying to you all along.

13
junkit33•

I certainly understand that, but the primary interest of mods is to protect the community, not to protect other mods. If it's the job of the mod to drop the hammer on another mod, then that job needs to be done, no matter how difficult it may personally be. In this case all we were seeing was mods looking out for themselves and the other mods.

32
frack0verflow•

Not just lying - she manufactured the friendship in order to whore it out at a fee.

Spade a spade n all.

1
Sle•

Ok. What I meant (or what the conspiracy theorist in me meant) was that it might be solidarity due to similar career choices.

15
[deleted]•

I doubt this, but I can sympathize with your mistrust. I can't say I'm 100% certain either, and I'm friends with some of them. It's this seed of doubt that will be the most damaging effect of this incident, in my opinion. It's also why I feel she had to be removed.

13
Sle•

Yeah, it's just that, a seed of doubt.

2
nathan1313us•

Oligarchy

  • A self perpetuation leadership group - inner circle
  • Leaders often grow away from the main stream
  • If inner circle grows too far away from the grass roots may encounter revolution
14
gukeums1•

reddit is not a revolution and will never have a revolution and by its very nature cannot facilitate a revolution. that is some grade-A self-inflating bullshit.

0
nathan1313us•

I thought it was interesting. Being a college student and having that in my sociology notes from my last class I couldn't help but paste it in. Seemed like a good fit.

3
SirOblivious•

I posted in r/reportthespammers of some other associated content spammers, that only submit to reddit from associated content

I see you are the MOD there, will you be banning those users?

8
[deleted]•

I cannot ban them from anywhere except Report the Spammers and Ideas for the Admins. It's up to the mods of the subreddits they submit to ban them, and it's up to admins to remove their accounts.

6
sanswork•

Be scared? Seriously? Of what? That my ability to post to another random news aggregation site won't be as open? Oh the horror of horrors why once the mods have full control what shall we do for they will control the only source of information in the world!

8
erez27•

It's a source some people put a lot of time and effort into, with the sole hope of making it better.

2
sanswork•

So then start another pics sub-reddit picsnosaydrah blam you can now distribute all your pictures just as you would like to with no fear of her influence.

0
erez27•

That's a great advice. Reminds me of the time my neighbors made a lot of noise, so I moved out.

2
nathan1313us•

NOTHING got done. She is still a mod. Just not for this subreddit. Take her karma and ban her from the site. This shit will not stand. Throw her to the wolves otherwise welcome to Diggit.

0
[deleted]•

The mods cannot take her karma or ban her from the site; that's up to the admins. Appeal to them if you wish, but I doubt they'll change their position.

6
nathan1313us•

At the very least remove her from being a mod. Forget about her making money from her submissions, the way she speaks to the users is bad enough to get her removed as a mod.

-2
emmster•

Take your case to the mods of subs that have not removed her. Hint: jokermatt999 is not one of them.

0
lameth•

The analogy I'll give you is like saying "There would be no tea parties (teabaggers) if the lousy democrats would just stop trying to change our healthcare."
That's what this has looked like, an angry mob not caring about what the admin research has dug up, or what the actual situation is, but what they're told by extremely vocal individuals, correct or not.

0
simianfarmer•

Thanks for posting this, KK.

I greatly respect your decision to listen to the voice of the community for the sake of the cohesion of the community. And by that I mean choosing to bolster the "integrity of the position of a moderator" over personal feelings.

It's too bad so much of it turned into a personal attack and a witch hunt. I hope Saydrah can separate this from the rest of her presence here (eventually), and the torch- and pitchfork-bearers go mill about someplace else.

112
kleinbl00•

It turned into a personal attack and a witch hunt because of the lack of professionalism on all sides from the very beginning. This whole "Saydrah-SEO" thing is months old; nobody (particularly Saydrah) did anything and it festered. Then over the weekend it exploded, and still Saydrah did nothing. Finally, [M]s did nothing followed by the [A]s doing nothing and the end result was 32 point bold-italic rabble rabble.

When MMM fucked up, he tucked his tail between his legs, sulked, and got on with his life (mostly). Had Saydrah said "my bad" and given up moderating anything with any potential conflict of interest, all this shit would have blown over in a matter of hours. Instead, everybody runs around with their hair on fire, Saydrah and damn near every other mod gets all passive-aggressive and shame-on-you about it, and the end result is a gajillion bytes of drama over the ownership and AdSense of a house that may or may not look like a duck, for fuck's sake.

Maybe it's 'cuz I'm not a "cool kid." I don't hang out on mod talk. I don't IRC about this shit. I've had exactly three off-line conversations about whether to ban somebody or not. But I really don't see what the big deal is about mutherfucking stepping down from a mod position when a substantial portion of your readers don't trust you any more.

If I were Saydrah, before this, I would have stepped down from all my moderator duties, licked my wounds, and kept submitting whatever the hell I was submitting. After this, I'd make me some shill accounts and start pushing stuff that way. Really, the only real leash on anyone's behavior on this site is their own conscience; the fact that this much drama went into whether or not someone can ban images (in a group of what? 14 mods?) only goes to show how much ego got wrapped around the driveshaft.

Saydrah - step down. Demod yourself from everything. You can either own this or it can own you. Your choice.

267
General_Lee•

Well put. I believe the reason for the witch hunt was because of her reluctance to correct her ways, and people finally had enough of her ignoring the fact that there was a massive conflict of interest which she just seemed to not care about. Had she either resolved that conflict or stepped down as mod, none of this would have happened.

Now that she is generally untrusted by those Redditors who frequent the site often, it's going to be hard for her to do anything without being criticized to kingdom come. She should just abandon her current account if she wants to save face and start over (In my personal opinion, of course).

And that house, it does look like a duck. Duck support forever!

67
spoolio•

If Saydrah is really writing a thesis on Internet dynamics, she would do well to understand this. She probably would have still found a lot of people who would defend her before this. But here, it became a focused dispute between two people, and she held her ground and let the dispute happen. She started arguing on the basis of rules.

The rules don't matter. What matters is that one party in the dispute works for Associated Fucking Content. The other one took a picture of a house that looks like a duck.

It is completely obvious who the Internet will side with.

Next round: a lolrus vs. Dick Cheney. Who deserves custody of the bukkit?

49
[deleted]•

moot. Obviously. psshh

4
Fluck•

No, don't encourage her to abandon her account. She should keep her account and her karma, she just shouldn't be a mod with her conflicted interests.

If she abandons her account and makes another one, a couple of months down the line this whole thing is going to happen again and people will be saying she was trying to hide what she was doing.

A lot of people on this sit doubtlessly have conflicted interests but to kick people off just for having different reasons to submit things is just as bad as letting conflicted people moderate those decisions.

15
General_Lee•

I'm not saying kick her off, but to her own benefit, I advise she try again with a fresh start and not repeat the same mistakes. That's what I've done in the past, I once made a comment that offended quite a few Redditors, and abandoned the account so as not to be a person who people could hate. I've since changed my ways, and the benefit to that is that old person is no longer me or associated with me. If Saydrah were to do the same, people could love the new her (As long as they don't actually know it is her) because she would have that extra shield, internet separation from real life. No one knows who I actually am here, which is much to my benefit.

2
RadInfinitum•

Saydrah and damn near every other mod gets all passive-aggressive and shame-on-you about it

Most annoying part of this entire waste of time.

That and how she said she didn't care about being a mod, but also wouldn't step down voluntarily.

35
danstermeister•

It's called "getting out in front of the problem".

She needs to learn how to do that, regardless of what happened (whether she did right, wrong, or even both).

Everyone turns their nose up at the term 'damage control'.

Well, I bet not anymore, eh? ;)

24
loosethread•

"...the end result is a gajillion bytes of drama over...a house that may or may not look like a duck, for fuck's sake." That was perfect. Thank you for making me laugh out loud.

18
[deleted]•

It did look like a duck.

1
descartes84•

I would upvote you a hundred times if I could. This should have been a tempest in a teacup. Instead, it became the biggest shitstorm reddit has seen in ages. I'm glad the the issue was finally resolved for r/pics.

14
tits_and_skippy•

If you make a hundred accounts, you can do just that!

3
sumzup•

Although it won't really work because reddit has mechanisms in place to deal with that! Still, it's the spirit that counts, right?

2
squidboots•

Thank you, kleinbl00 for putting that in better words than I could have. This is why you are one of the few people whom I have dubbed [F].

I'm really astounded at the number of people who can't take a step back and see the big picture of this whole situation - guilty parties included. Way too much hubris goin' on up in here.

8
Chetyre•

Thanks for this post--it's exactly how I feel about the whole issue. I think it's pretty low of Saydrah to (instead of responding to the issue) run to 2XC and post how 90% of reddit are shitheads. If she really felt that way, she should just remove herself from the site (or at least the popular subreddits that she moderates).

7
ohstrangeone•

and the end result is a gajillion bytes of drama over the ownership and AdSense of a house that may or may not look like a duck, for fuck's sake.

GODDAMNIT THAT FUCKING HOUSE DOES LOOK LIKE A FUCKING DUCK STOP TRYING TO SLANDER ROBINGALLUP YOU BASTARDS!!!!!

4
fishbert•

When MMM fucked up, he tucked his tail between his legs, sulked, and got on with his life (mostly).

I seem to recall a different MMM reaction than what you describe.

http://www.reddit.com/r/reddittrolls/comments/a6nus/mercurialmadnessman/

2
kleinbl00•

No, I remember that. The community then came down on it, HARD, and he sulked. My point being: MMM figured out that the herd did not approve of his actions and he let it drop. You'll notice that his drama started out private, he took it public, and everyone said "not cool, dude." On the other hand, this whole drama with Saydrah has been full of back-channel bullshit and everyone putting on a game face. Most importantly, I don't remember Saydrah doing a single thing to assuage the concerns of Reddit in general. Mostly she's been leaning up against other people and expecting them to defend her.

I don't think even MMM defends himself much anymore. I think he's got some legitimate beefs with the way he was treated, and the people who treated him that way had legitimate reasons to do so. He acted inappropriately - and he's acknowledged that. It's that acknowledgement that's missing and will, I believe, continue to be AWOL in this case.

31
PandemicSoul•

Yeah, the problem with this is the fact that there's no way to tell who the fuck is saying what. I don't think there was a conflict of interest, and plenty of people agreed with me. Plenty of people disagree. If you look at her AMA, "54% like it". How the hell is anyone supposed to get a clear view of "what the herd" did or not did not approve of? How do you figure out what's the signal and what's the noise?

I think the "I'll let my fellow mods decide my fate" was pretty weaselly, but honestly, there's no way to tell what the hell public opinion is around here.

2
fishbert•

Most importantly, I don't remember Saydrah doing a single thing to assuage the concerns of Reddit in general.

Really?

-5
psrivats•

There are many reasons why the name Kleinbloo appears with a [F] on my login. This just went way up in that list. This is the most sensible post on this from a moderator. Thank you.

2
kleinbl00•

This is probably a good time to point out how pointless the title of "moderator" is - make a subreddit and BAM! average sized moderator. The subreddits I've got are tiny and silly; the biggest is a hair over 3k subscribers.

Where things get srsbznss is when you've got "232,914 gawkers!" and fourteen people attempting to keep things organized to their satisfaction.

By that definition of "moderator" I'm anything but. I barely even read r/pics and find my attempts to submit in here generally skunked within minutes. I didn't contribute one iota to this dustup, and that makes me happy. If I were one of the thankless individuals listed at right, I would have had to. I don't have to agree with their handling of the situation but I do have to empathize with the position they found themselves in.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
sidewalkchalked•

Excellently put. I want to know that the site is run by adults.

The problem is that Saydrah put he mod status on her CV, and probably discussed the status at her job interview. If I were her, I'd be afraid of repercussions at work if I lost my "sway" with reddit.

That's why she isn't acting like a reasonable adult by stepping down, but it is also exactly why someone should step up and kick her out.

2
elephantorgy•

The end of the end result makes it all worth it.

1
chairface•

kleinbl00, I've said it before, and I'll say it again. I fucking love you.

1
mitchandre•

Banning images is an important function in as much it teaches reddit you are a spammer and can permanently leave your submissions in spam limbo.

-3
kleinbl00•

Yes, but freaking balls over who bans what images is anything but an important function.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
fas2•

The witchhunt made me feel very uncomfortable. Sometimes this happens when the victim is relatively innoccent (example: the secret santa troll).

10
kleinbl00•

The witch hunt made me uncomfortable, too. I've been stalked on here before and it's really not cool. I feel sorry for Saydrah and I would not have seen her put through any of this.

The reason it happened, however, is that people do things to get a reaction. The reaction the angry mob got, from Saydrah, from the mods, from the admins - was "truth will out, stiff upper lip, straight on 'til morning, bring me that horizon."

Pre-internet thinking is "don't dignify it with a response." This mentality is archaic because if the internet proves anything, it proves that everyone has a response and if it isn't yours, it'll a thousand that you'd rather not see.

What this dilemma needed was some riot control. Saydrah could have tamped it down but she didn't even try. The other mods could have tamped it down but they didn't even try. There was a whole bunch of "democracy will save the day" while PMs flew all over... and lo and behold, the average un-posting, un-commenting redditor expressed merely rage.

Don't fuck with angry mobs. When you see one, run the other way. When one is running towards you, don't try to argue with it - give it what they want, lick your wounds, and live to fight another day.

28
[deleted]•

Stalking? Man, you just have to change your username pretty regularly. Karma doesn't mean shit ... that's how this whole mess starts. "Well my E-Dick is twice as big as yours!"

2
kleinbl00•

I did for a while.

I'd get a couple PMs a week saying "I miss U!" from people I'd never communicated with.

And I've got a very distinctive style; even changing usernames once a week, I'd get a PM every other week from someone asking "Are you kleinbl00?"

You reach a point where you either live your life or you don't.

5
frack0verflow•

No.

The reason it happened is becuase she manufactured "authentic" relationships in order to whore those relaionships out at a fee to online marketing companies.

Her fucking LinkedIn said as much in her own fucking words!

It is kinda sickening.

2
PandemicSoul•

IMHO, it's not whether the victim of a witch-hunt is innocent or not, it's that a witch-hunt is occurring and is being led by a mob carrying pitchforks and torches. The way people behaved during this whole thing was absolutely criminal - posting her name and address and using her gender as a means for misogynistic slurs and name calling. I don't care if she is "standing there with a knife and covered in blood" (as someone said) - acting like a mob of crazed lunatics over what amounted to something completely inconsequential, and then behaving as if your entire worldview has come crashing down because SOMEONE could be so unkind as to ban a spammer is the very definition of hysterical insanity.

When your mob consists of 12-year-olds insulting someone's person, as opposed to their actions, you're nothing better than a common thug. You don't deserve justice; you deserve public shame.

-1
ex_oh_ex_oh•

Exactly. This will all eventually settle down, and the rabble rabble of the pitchfork bearing crowd will find another target to rage on. Even though the banning of robingallup was not cool, hell, we're all just people who make random mistakes.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

10
[deleted]•

Finally. I and I'm sure many others would continue all of this if she had remained. I never liked her in the first place but after seeing the crap she does justified my dislike. That was even before I saw the 2XC post. I was completely disgusted with her. She seems like a sociopath from the video of her to the way she tries to exploit her feminism.

103
Eyeheartawk•

THIS.

It also doesn't help the reputation of TwoX being full of man hating militant feminists, to have her spewing garbage advice much less moderating. You should have seen her unleash hell one time when somebody admitted they were wearing a bra to bed from her, as if that person had single-handedly set back women's suffrage a millenia.

23
[deleted]•

I don't think TwoX has that reputation. You're thinking of r/women. They are vastly different communities.

34
Chairboy•

Q: How many r/women subscribers does it take to change a light bulb?

A: THAT'S NOT FUNNY!!!

17
[deleted]•

A. You’d just love for me to “screw” that lightbulb in, wouldn’t you? That’s all women are to you, right? Just receptacles for your oppressive male “light bulb.”

10
emmster•

I thought it was funny. Maybe r/women ought to de-mod me, then.

Seriously, though, if you think we're militant, you haven't seen many feminist sites. :/

1
Grue•

Shouldn't that be "womyn"?

1
Alanna•

2X unfortunately gets tarred with the same brush as r/women and r/feminisms. If Saydrah's comments are the ones I'm remembering, she is a little on the wacko feminist side for me, though she's generally civil and I don't mind disagreement as long as it stays civil. I somehow missed this entire controversy though, unless it was before I renewed my interest in Reddit about a month ago. I got the calendar thread, but I'm seeing all kinds of stuff about a conflict of interest with SOE and whatnot. Anyone have a link to a summarization of events?

1
[deleted]•

In a nutshell, Saydrah commented on some thread chiding somebody for posting spam. Then somebody else revealed that Saydrah works for Associated Content and showed that her linkedin and resume both brag about being able to manipulate the social media system to drive traffic to her employers.

The mob began to scream about this being a conflict of interest, and that one could assume Saydrah would use her powers as a mod to push certain links for $$, but many made the point that Saydrah was a great mod and had never abused her power.

But then some guy who took some pictures spoke up and claimed Saydrah banned him for posting his own pictures with a google ad next to the pic. Neither of these statements are true, as the post was caught in the spam filter, and was not banned by Saydrah, but Saydrah emailed him about it when he inquried and got the bad rap. She recommended that he remove the ad, and people perceive that as hypocritical since she is purportedly paid for traffic.

All in all, removing Saydrah as a mod in r/pics seems to have staved off the foaming mob for now and everything has calmed down...

0
redreplicant•

She was never a mod on 2X.

15
jerrygofixit•

She is a mod on equality though.

6
redreplicant•

True. This is no reason to suggest that 2X is "full of man hating militant feminists"-- the facts deserve to be gotten straight.

19
voltagex•

Post a link to back your rant up.

12
GirlWithRedHair•

No, it doesn't help the reputation of 2XC when people like you make generalizations about a subreddit you never actively participate in let alone visit.

Don't dump us all into the same category. I happen to be feminist and love men. Also, get your facts straight; she was never a mod there.

12
PHermas•

“If I stand here, I can see the GirlWithRedHair when she comes out of her house... Of course, if she sees me peeking around this tree, she'll think I'm the dumbest person in the world... But if I don't peek around the tree, I'll never see her... Which means I probably AM the dumbest person in the world... which explains why I'm standing in a batch of poison oak.”

5
williamhgates•

Do you have a reading comprehension problem? Here's Eyeheartawk's post. Point out the part he/she claims Saydrah was/is a 2XC mod:

THIS.

It also doesn't help the reputation of TwoX being full of man hating militant feminists, to have her spewing garbage advice much less moderating. You should have seen her unleash hell one time when somebody admitted they were wearing a bra to bed from her, as if that person had single-handedly set back women's suffrage a millenia.

-4
GirlWithRedHair•

It also doesn't help the reputation of TwoX [insert some misogynistic crap here] to have her spewing garbage advice much less moderating.

Giving advice and moderating where? In the context of the sentence, it is safe to assume s/he meant TwoX.

I'm not the only one who thought Eyeheartawk meant modding on TwoX. Look above. Perhaps redreplicant and I need a reading comprehension lesson from you.

3
[deleted]•

Do you have a link?

9
electricboogaloo•

When this first blew up and Saydrah ran there for sympathy, TwoX showed a lot of class by calling her on her sexism.

9
[deleted]•

TwoX dealt with Saydrah in the following manner : 20% of the posts were supportive of Saydrah, 60% were critical, and 20% were downright offended that she holds women in such low regard that she went to them expecting full support merely on account of having a vagina.

8
SamFuckingNeill•

I support women having vagina

1
frack0verflow•

Agreed - she is a total cooze but I don't see 2XC as having such a reputation.

Saydrah might have been attempting to socially engineer such a reputation but I certainly don't think she came anywhere near achieving that.

3
I_Downvote_This•

Hello.

1
[deleted]•

What video is this?

1
[deleted]•

http://www.ustream.tv/recorded/2168114

[Here's most of the other proof] credit to SirOblivious.

1
a-lady•

I never liked her in the first place but after seeing the crap she does justified my dislike. That was even before I saw the 2XC post. I was completely disgusted with her. She seems like a sociopath from the video of her to the way she tries to exploit her feminism.

WTF does that have to do with anything? There was a conflict of interest and that was the issue.

-1
[deleted]•

It has to do with her involvement as a person and moderator since she lets personal issues get to her a little too much.

The last part based on what I've heard around reddit anyway.

2
Gravity13•

The last part based on what I've heard around reddit anyway.

You probably shouldn't trust the things people say in the heat of the moment.

1
[deleted]•

I trust what multiple redditors that have built up my trust in them and their opinions.

2
gukeums1•

So you just don't like her as a person, thanks for being honest anyway

-1
[deleted]•

And as a moderator that has conflicting interests.

And as a person that I think is a bit shady and shouldn't be trusted with the powers to ban anybody.

2
gukeums1•

The "conflicting interests" bit is a weaksauce argument. I've said it in other places, but this is the very tip of the iceberg in terms of things to get huffy about.

-2
Doozer•

She's tough and I'm sure she will find a way to get through this, as she does with most things.

This is borderline The Onion right here. Moderator of web site loses position, becomes destitute within days.

99
enamore22•

Reddit 90210.

90
[deleted]•

Generic Sax

12
boltzmann•

** radical 80s riff **

8
zydeco•

Yakkety Sax

0
the_school_bully•

i'll give you generic sax

0
bhaller•

FOR REALZ! Some people just need to go outside every once in a while.

1
akatherder•

If used appropriately, moderation "powers" have no benefit to the moderator. It is a thankless task. Saydrah should be happy she no longer has to spend time filtering spam and cleaning up childish messes, which is all a moderator should be doing.

88
[deleted]•

[deleted]

16
acetv•

Do people really care about karma that much?

17
Jamon•

archived('c0lhmiv')

22
acetv•

I don't follow. How does high karma score translate into more traffic? Your own karma has no effect on how visible your posts/comments are. I assume it doesn't factor into the Reddit algorithm at all. It's just a number on your info page.

2
Mr_Red•

lol "celeb People"

thanks for that

1
[deleted]•

I build up my karma and then spend it by posting really unpopular comments that get heavily downvoted.

5

losers mostly.

0
selectrix•

Okay, but I think the transparency provided by posting mod names in the comment section outweighs the mischeif-incentivizing potential that any hypothetical karma gains would provide.

And let's not forget that simply being a mod earns you a certain number of enemies, whether they be people whose submissions you (or other mods) have banned, or people who simply dislike authority figures.

7
wardrox•

I was an avid user of Reddit gaming for a year or so before I became a mod there. Honestly, I've found I was much more likely to get down-voted within a few minutes after becoming a mod, which is a pain in the arse. That said, this may just be because r/gaming does <3 the down-vote.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
friendlyfire•

Actually, moderators' submissions never get caught in the spam filter.

So.....yeah.

1
jamonterrell•

anyone notice there was no mod drama before the retarded colored posts thing?

1
FUCKY_DOODLE_DANDY•

That is the point, moderators ban people for opinion and comments they don't like.

User moderators, ANY moderators, beyond the WHOLE POINT of reddit (voting) is FUCKING RIDICULOUS and NOBODY ELSE MENTIONED IT.

1
[deleted]•

...I am terribly disgusted in some of the things that have gone on the past few days regarding her. Maybe she's been spamming, maybe not. The admins have already stated that she has done nothing against the terms and rules of reddit. She has not cheated the system or the algorithm in any way.

Okay. So, I'm just going to go set up an SEO deal with some company, spam r/pics with huge volumes of pics from obscure websites to increase their search rank, and when everyone sees the evidence of my spammy ways I'll shout "witchhunt! lynchmob! You people are despicable! I am disappoint!"; and I take it you and the admins will come to my defense and denounce my accusers because the evidence against me shall be inconclusive? I have your guarantee I won't be banned, then?

The fact is that the standards according to which others are judged are much more inclement that those according to which Saydrah is and has been. If I posted just one link like one of those thousands(?) that she did (links to images on a small static set of obscure websites) I'd probably be banned without any questions asked. Am I mistaken?

76
Grunyan•

Before I found out what she does for a living I really just took it for what it was: a moderator who fucked up.

You will always run into that in the internet. However a moderator who is in a conflict of interest because they get paid to submit links from websites she gets money from?

And she is still a moderator in some subreddits which still gives her power over her submissions?

I was hoping not to expect this stuff on reddit. I expect it on digg.

*edit: I also hope I'm mistaken.

13
DubDubz•

Like was said in the post above, she is now a moderator of subreddits that only allow self posts. She can in no possible way submit links to anything ever in something she moderates.

1
Azured•

Oh great, and I just bought this pitchfork. Come on gang, lets find another witch.

68
seydar•

apostrophe first, then witch

51
demented_pants•

Capitals and punctuation first. Then, apostrophe. Then, witch.

35
jgarfink•

She turned me into a newt!

8
Depafro•

Don't sentences need a verb?

2
chakalakasp•

Pants first. Then, shoes.

2
[deleted]•

He didn't use an apostrophe in the appropriate place! He's a wizard! BURN HIM!

1
p0tent1al•

I don't know about all the accusations about "gaming the system" but she definitely made some very, VERY questionable comments that in my mind justify her removal of mod status. The moderation (or warning, forget) of using image links with ads, claiming that people shouldn't be posting for financial benefit (when it's what she does) is grounds for it alone.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

59
havesometea1•

and whores

10
joshrh88•

And my axe!

5
[deleted]•

...at the same time.

4
[deleted]•

SNORTING TURTLES OFF A WHORES ASS.

3
anotherDocObVious•

This sounds like a rather good repartee "Do I look like I give a flying fuck about snorting turtles off a whore's ass ??"

2
[deleted]•

This actually solves a rather unique problem I have. See, I have always wanted to do a line off a whore's ass but when I actually attempted it and there were certain logistical problems with too much flab and such. Using a turtle as an aid, which I could put that on that flabby whore's ass and make the whole concept chic and sexy again! Edits to do list

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
bongwhacker•

I like dragon flies

-6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
qxcvr•

♫you other brothers can't denyyyy♫

-2
88leo•

I want a crunchy taco in my fist, and a cinnamon twist

1
terrenceistheman•

combo breaker?

-6
ConfusedRedneck•

Did robingallup's account get unbanned from here? Oh, nvm....welcome back, ducky-duck-duck-house-face.

56
FiL-dUbz•

I know their google adsense account was terminated as a result of this bullshit... and all clues point to Saydrah. That's a very real consequence of her abuse of power, firing off on the commenter and subsequently getting their adsense account banned.

28
[deleted]•

[deleted]

18
butrosbutrosfunky•

More highly substantiated and linked conspiracies involving Saydrah. Or not.

Do you have any evidence, or is this just more of the same pitchfork and torch hysteria that has fanned this whole affair? It sounds like it.

Good job on the upvotes though, toeing the mob line seems profitable here.

4
IrrigatedPancake•

As I understand it, she did not ban robingallup. She just sent the message explaining why she thought he had been banned. He was banned by someone else, who doesn't want to be named right now.

Secondly, how would Saydrah be able to get someone else's adsense account terminated?

0
FiL-dUbz•

First, she threw a fit and tried to delete all of Rob's posts; 2nd she's riddled reddit with her bullshit claims of him spam blogging his own picture; 3rd, yes, anyone after that point could've notified Google and linked them to the proper subreddit where a mod (Saydrah) was actively trying to get another redditor's post taken down... could careless about the ban, because that's what reddit's easy as sign up is for. But Saydrah made it clear to all of Google caches that she was going to get her word in on a social networking site, then either her or someone else fired off the email's saying Rob was spamming social networking sites... ask Rob.

so suffice to say, it was Saydrah's fault. Now, why would someone else contact Google? Dude followed all rules, it was his own picture, it's just that it wasn't on Imgur?

1
Ma8e•

You are delirious! robingallup's post was banned because he tried to trick the system. He was not banned by Saydrah, according to the other mods. The reason he got banned by adsense is probably because he tried to trick that too. Blaming Saydrah for that is just spreading more lies.

-4
FiL-dUbz•

I DRINK Delirious, but Im also aware of the facts behind this.

So, yeah, I think you did it Say... Ma8e.

1
Ma8e•

Your "facts" come from robingallup and his minions. How come that those "facts" are so different than those coming from the admins and the moderators?

-2
Gravity13•

Wait, what? You're bitching that a mod banned a spammer because he was exploiting adsense?

If I didn't guess any better, I'd think you'd want to sit there and click his ads yourself.

-11
[deleted]•

I'm under the impression his account was never banned, just that one submission of his ages ago.

14
[deleted]•

That's because many mods keep stating it as fact, when in fact, they can't.

57
[deleted]•

Are you implying that he was banned and then unbanned?

6
[deleted]•

I'm saying that no moderator can tell if that happened. Maybe he was, maybe he wasn't. The point is, since Reddit keeps no record of bans and unbans (at least not one available to BEP and other mods), they cannot state with any certainty that he was never banned. And that's what they're doing (with a green 'M', no less); stating as a given fact, something they can't be sure is true.

I thought the whole problem here was a lack of trust in moderators. Doing things like this only serves to weaken people's trust in moderators.

69
mitchandre•

Your account gets pseudo-banned when your submission gets banned. The reddit engine treats you as a spammer, thus placing submissions into spamland.

13
BritishEnglishPoliceMOD•

He was never banned.

-16
[deleted]•

That cannot be stated with any certainty (unless you have access to some sort of internal admin audit trail that the rest of us don't). You can say "he wasn't banned last time I looked", or "no one has admitted ever banning him", but it is impossible for you to verifiably state "he was never banned.

46
EatSleepJeep•

On top of that, when a mod is removed from a sub, their bans get erased as well.

EDIT: This statement is likely absolute bullshit.

-1
[deleted]•

Absolute bullshit. I just logged in as HoLeeFuck, banned you from r/modtest, logged back in as VA, and removed HoLeeFuck as a moderator. You are still on the ban list.

Where do you people get this shit from? Fortune cookies?

1
atheist_creationist•

See, this is what we're talking about. What are mods hoping to accomplish by telling us something we know they don't know for sure?

10
KoNP•

AAAANnnnnd here with us on the scene, we have reddit moderator Mr. BritishEnglishPolice with another overly-asserted fallacious claim.

8

Fallacious? Explain how so.

-4
KoNP•

You say "he was never banned" with such certainty and yet you're completely lacking evidence. Yet the person who claims they WERE banned is able to show that they were incapable of posting as a result.

Fallacious:

Adjective

fallacious (comparative more fallacious, superlative most fallacious)

Positive fallacious

Comparative more fallacious

Superlative most fallacious

  1. Characterized by fallacy; false or mistaken.
  2. Deceptive or misleading.

There ya go, hope that helped.

6
burnblue•

If his every submission was caught in a spam filter and never showed up, I'm sure it'd be the same thing from his perspective

5
RoboBama•

Krispykrackers! Your tone is implying she's a victim, turning her into a martyr. SHE. IS. A. LIAR. I don't care how good of a friend you are to her. I think she's a good person too!

But that's irrelevant. And if you take her off here, you need to maintain your integrity as a mod and TAKE HER OFF /R/COMICS

She's taken a lot of crap

She's a hypocrite and furthermore subversive. She's an embarassment for this user base.

If krispy, if you really respected the community you would listen to the community and have her removed from modding all together.

54
DomMk•

Your tone is implying she's a victim

This really ground my bones,while I applaud the moderators decision to remove her from the moderating team, she is certainly NOT the victim in any of this.

33
RoboBama•

Not only do I agree with you, I need to point out that saydrah has recently been caught copying redditors comments and posting them on other sites to help increase that disgusting "pull" of hers. Check it out, all evidence to this is in a post on this subreddit

www.reddit.com/r/whatofsaydrah

Should be the bottom post.

20
SirOblivious•

I wondered why that Gravity13 was always harassing anyone that questioned her! now we know!

8
demeteloaf•

Hrmmm, IANAL, but i'm 99% sure this is violating indivdual users copyrights on their posts.

If you read the TOS, unlike Digg, reddit posts are not public domain, and users only grant a license for conde nast to do whatever they want with what users have posted. However, that license doesn't carry over to random other sites unless conde nast has specifically given them permission....

7