The community has spoken: I've removed Saydrah from the moderator list here.
There's been a trial, and a verdict, and it's obvious that nobody in this community is comfortable with Saydrah being a moderator here anymore. In order to maintain the integrity of the position of a moderator, I have taken everything into consideration and will be removing her from her moderator status (*edit- from /pics, and from /comics, where we are both moderators).
This is in no way a means to justify what you all are accusing her of, and I am terribly disgusted in some of the things that have gone on the past few days regarding her. Maybe she's been spamming, maybe not. The admins have already stated that she has done nothing against the terms and rules of reddit. She has not cheated the system or the algorithm in any way. But the fact remains, there is a conflict of interest between what she does for a living and her position of power on reddit, that cannot be ignored.
She is a great girl, and I have a lot of love for her. She's my co-calendar girl, and we've taken a lot of crap together from you all for that. I call her a reddit friend, and I hope that this doesn't change that. She's tough and I'm sure she will find a way to get through this, as she does with most things. She was an excellent moderator, and it will be difficult to see her go.
But the bottom line comes to the community, and the trust you have in us. I don't want our future decisions as moderators always clouded by her presence here. I think it would be absolutely okay if she remained a moderator on text-based subreddits (AskReddit where I will not be removing her, RelationshipAdvice where she is invaluable, etc) but as for anything based on links submitted... she should just be a regular user and nothing more.
If another moderator has a problem with this, and re-adds her to the mod list, there's not much I can do. This decision is neither unilateral nor is it unanimous, but I've had enough support from my fellow moderators to make me feel this is the right thing to do.
Posted Mar 2, 2010, 9:45 PM UTC · edited
I demand you put her back! Just kidding, I don't give a shit about any of this. :)
That's what they want to hear. "I just made a tough decision and came out on the side that preserves reddit's integrity and comes out against moderation abuse"
"Meh"
This subreddit really deserves more subscribers, though I guess not enough people care
If you join that subreddit, you're not qualified to be in that subreddit.
Hmm. You think so?
Whatever. I don't even care.
I wouldn't be in any club that would have someone like me as a member!
I joined it cause he provided the link. I wouldn't care to go searching for it, though.
The first rule of the apathy subreddit is..... don't join the apathy subreddit.
I would never want to be a member of a subreddit that would accept me as a member.
I wouldn't want to be a part of an apathy club that would accept me as a member.
catch-22
You're probably right.
Catch-22 of the subreddit
You're thinking of the "Emo Street Cred" subreddit.
The trick is to join before you're qualified, then become qualified, then not care enough to leave.
My sister was using my computer and she subscribed me to that subreddit. It's just that I don't care enough to unsubscribe.
is it like being on r/suicide for more than half an hour?
what? Reddit has moderators? What the hell do they do, just delete spam?
They ban users and hide submissions.
Yeah, pretty much. That, and unban what the spam filter wrongfully catches as spam.
Apparently they make lots of money via political rent to and from the landed gentry.
Thanks, my entire evening is now filled with meh.
Add a 't' and get the party started buddy!!!
"I don't want to be a member of any subreddit that would have me as a subscriber."
Aren't you automatically not apathetic (that sounds really funny to me, but not sure how else to word it) if you subscribe to that reddit?
so?
What if you want to learn to be more apathetic? Or is only interested in finding more about apathy?
if you're not apathetic, does that make you pathetic (by taking off the "a-")?
That is a blackhole of irony right there.
It's like when you divide by z... O SHII
why bother
232,872 subscribers is not enough?
Like I care about your subreddit...
Ya, not many people care, but a train wreck is always fun to watch.
Reddit hates Jews, are you gonna do anything about that? oh i forgot, keyser and karmanaut are racists!
All this talk lately about banning people, and this fucking clown is still here.
I love this place.
I smell a jew. Someone call karmanaut!
Silent majority, man. Remember that this is all just a bunch of mostly anonymous people socializing on a website on the Internet.
I'm pretty sure there was a lot of "Meh" being shouted loud and clear before this post, it was just being downvoted to oblivion before and the mods didn't see it.
I like how Reddit has grown to the point that it's politics parallel real life. This is a classic debate over regulation vs the free market. Do we need moderators, or should there be a free for all? Are the mods corrupt, abusive of their power, or working in everyone's best interests? Some chose one side, some the other, some live in ignorant bliss of what goes on behind the curtain.
Edit: There's another thread debating the importance of the SEC (here). That debate isn't as popular as this one though...
I just need something to distract me from the work I am being paid to do.
So when truth hurts, we should shut up?
does my ass look fat in these jeans?
I think "Meh" is the best outcome for the situation so that it can go away. The community will see a resolution and quit voting up stories about the situation, it is now old news. Saydrah will not be able to submit or comment as there will be those that remember the name and automatically downvote. She has ruined her good name.
I, for one, upvote and downvote based on the quality of content/post, not based on who posted.
How the fuck does this 'preserve integrity' or come out 'against moderation abuse'. If anything this is mob rule prevailing and a show of disrespect for the actual rules.
are you familiar with what actually happened?
She promoted links that her friends (and possibly she) benefited from financially and then banned a redditor for linking to a blog claiming that he reposted the picture to his blog so he could make money from it. This being despite that he took the picture himself.
If you're sitting there thinking "What reddit needs is more moderators who mess around with reddit to make cash and then ban people because they incorrectly think they're doing the same thing" well, go eat dog dick.
last I read this was all based on theory and propagated by spam hate which reminds me way to much of salem mass. If there was evidence that she acutally was abusing mod powers then I'll gladly eat crow, I was just going on what I read and the fact that admins deemed her innocent.
I have to say, I'm more turned off by the witch hunt than I am by what they are accusing this person of. Otherwise, it's not even on my radar.
Yes, it really is enough to make one think twice about the nature of this "community".
I also take exception to use of the phrase "nobody in this community" as if the lynch mob comes close to truly representing everyone here.
I prefer to think of it as a society. r/math and r/Drugs are communities. The big reddits are just discussion boards.
[deleted]
Bye, please take the spam all you new users brought with you.
[deleted]
Nooooooooooo.......... come back!!!! WE NEED YOU magic5ball, you are the joy in my heart every morning!
[deleted]
rabble rabble rabble!
It's not really a community if the wishes of said community are not taken into account.
It's not a community. It's the internet. You're delusional if you think the internet is a community (though lots of people share your delusion, it is still a delusion). It's an artifact. It's as much a community as a book or image or hologram is. Reddit cannot supplant a real community, no matter how much it might seem that it can, because it is not human interaction. It is you, interacting with a computer. You don't have to deal with anything like what a community requires.
The witch hunt has actually made me ashamed to be a part of this community. I always considered Redditors to be above the antics of 4Chan with more maturity and intellect, yet the posting of personal information, harrassment, and lynch mobs proved me wrong. This is no more than a high school version of 4Chan.
Complaint + brief mention of 4Chan and/or Digg + same complaint = karma.
I don't get it, but whatever.
Mocking someone's complaint = karma.
Formulas are fun!
sounds about right.
Reddit = /b/ + daylight
Starting to look that way, isn't it? It's certainly different from when I created an account. I can still find interesting things, though -- but sometimes I have to search more than I used to.
So does that make 4chan Elementary School? shudders
...You guise talking about 8-year-olds?
More like middle school.
Well, the school mascot is Pedobear... so... Yes.
How dare you accuse the Internet of maturity!
Yeah, I guess it was foolish of me in the first place. I was already pretty disgusted with the disinformation with piracy, this just kind of sealed the deal.
It doesn't sound like you have ever been to 4chan.
Both communities show the same fervor and use the same tactics to attack a person who has apparently wronged them. Its not just enough to outcast them, they must also be attacked and spammed irl.
I agree with you. I have yet to make a conclusion from all the pieces of evidence users have provided, but I do know that, during the past week, part of Reddit turned into a mob that could not be reasoned with. All for the sake of a witch hunt.
The first sign that showed that these users were not open to reason was their blind support for robingallup (poster of the Duck house). He tried to use deceptive tactics to bypass his ad through the spam filter. He tried to post a picture with a google ad next to it. The spam filter rejected it. He was warned by Saydrah to post the image by itself without the google ad. He instead posts a false image link that immediately redirects to his ad (driving traffic on his ad up 30,000% according to Rob himself).
However, the users against Saydrah blindly follow him just because he is opposed to her. They think that he is innocent, and that it was absurd his post was banned. The guy who tried to sneak his ad through the spam filter is now a matryr. Someone will reply (or downvote) to this by saying "there's nothing wrong with putting a google ad next to a picture post to make some money." I'm not talking about whether the google ad was right/wrong. I'm talking about the fact that his post with the deceptive link was banned.
As you can see, he is not innocent. But he has thousands of Redditors following him, with the reasonability of a mob.
edit: I've tried to make this post to show that not all of Reddit is part of this angry mob. http://www.reddit.com/r/reddit.com/comments/b8lv4/has_the_community_spoken_or_the_mob_if_you_were/
I despise blogspam; but I define blogspam as stolen content put on a site to do nothing but generate hits and revenue for the theft. Original content is what makes reddit work, regardless of how it is presented. If you feel honest about your content then serve it up without re-directs. That said, no mod should be killing posts (or banning users) based solely on the format that they submit their content.
His redirect was a second attempt to post. He realized that he had to trick the spam filter in order to show his ad. So he did so by posting a false link that immediately redirected to his ad.
It's more that he was trying to be sneaky with the spam filter than anything else.
The situation with Robingall up had nothing to do with the lynch=mob at the start, it was SirOblivious' dubious list of links.
Agreed
I'll tell you what though, I'm sure going to miss those koalas.
[deleted]
You have to face the fact that this drama serves to entertain the category of internet users who have little better to do than sit in front of a computer and hope for something remotely tantalizing to pierce the bubble of their otherwise dark, uneventful lives. Let them have their cyber-victory.
It's not a witch hunt if you're dealing with an actual witch.
Or in this case, a dishonest bitch.
If that's true, then you never understood what it was about in the first place. You can't have people being paid to submit content to subreddits they moderate.
You can't have moderators banning people who compete with them.
Saydrah did BOTH
So sorry if people defending their space against leech moderators 'turns you off'.
This is one of those situations where if you're not outraged, you don't understand what's going on.
Your ignorance and apathy doesn't make her actions right or defensible. It wasn't a witch hunt. It was a well deserved backlash. Unfortunately, you and others of your ilk cannot understand that.
Paid content submission should be on your radar. Why? Because paid content submission turns you from a community member into a little money earning unit. But hey, what do you care? Just mindlessly click on whatever they tell you to (or more precisely, allow you to,) laugh at the approved pictures of cute cats and enjoy your ignorance. You are what is wrong with the world.
Because paid content submission turns you from a community member into a little money earning unit. But hey, what do you care? Just mindlessly click on whatever they tell you to (or more precisely, allow you to,) laugh at the approved pictures of cute cats and enjoy your ignorance. You are what is wrong with the world.
Oh, fuck off. Your melodramatic, condescending bullshit is what's wrong with the world.
Hey, I'm glad you have something to be passionate about. I still don't care. And, I still think that people found a little too much joy in destroying Saydrah. Like I said, it's not really on my radar.
This was all I had to see: "The admins have already stated that she has done nothing against the terms and rules of reddit. She has not cheated the system or the algorithm in any way."
I agree that it's a good thing Lorax found something to be passionate about, we get it, you're pissed, but just because some of us are not pissed is no reason to be so catty. She either violated the rules or she didn't, looks like the Admins determined she didn't, congrats on getting her canned anyway, you should be very proud.
They'll probably sing songs about you for generations to come, Lorax the savior of reddit...
You are a Jonas Brother Fan? I will never read any of your comments ever again. Your opinion means nothing to me. Nobody here cares that you don't care. You are a clicking faggot.
So because you believe this to be a witch hunt, it justifies Saydrah's actions? Sure, some people went overboard, but the facts that were presented are sound. I don't see what's so bad about the community wanting to keep reddit honest and above bar.
There was a conflict of interest and a lot of people were hurt when they found out a member they look up to was potentially contributing to the community because it was part of her job.
All she had to do was step down in the subreddits she mods, and this whole situation would have been over days ago. Saydrah has brought this on herself. She is dragging this out herself.
Don't blame the community, blame Saydrah.
It's not so much that she didn't do anything wrong. She seems to have made a mistake in banning at least that one fellow. What's disturbing is the degree of moral outrage over it.
She gets PAID to submit.
I don't get this. There were six threads of outrage, and now I am being downvoted because I remind the Pollyannas that their idol has feet of clay paid for by Associated Content et al.
Fuck reddit, you have the memory of a minnow.
I agree the essence of the question is "being paid for posting on Reddit" - that creates an unresolvable conflict that IMO lessens the value of any contribution. But that doesn't excuse some of the over the top behavior that went on in response.
I completely agree. People are too complacent. Maybe for those that don't take a stand on anything this isn't the place to start, but for those that hold their ground and understand that they can influence the world around them without taking the corporate cock in the ass while browsing a site that simply allows other to share links this is normal to hold people who abuse their powers accountable.
Wow, corporate cocks up the ass and not understanding you can influence the world--you told me! You go! But, I still don't care.
do you know who owns reddit?
ps they have a nice fat corporate cock
seriously. Shit, finally now the pages of reddit can cease being clogged up by this irrelevant bullshit. Isn't reddit supposed to be the place for "What's new on the internet?" Who fuckin cares about this nonsense?
Reddit should really just be "What's new on Reddit"
"What's new up our own asses."
Obligatory NSFW
Yo Dawg!
I heard you like Reddit, so I filled it with self-posts. Now you can browse yo reddit while you browse yo reddit.
I herd you like to Reddit while you Reddit.
Uhm, you do realize a bunch of computers were not posting all of the things you saw on the front page and elsewhere right? There were people behind those postings. They care. If it means nothing to you, fine, but at least take a minute to answer your own question. It means something to many other people, including me (I didn't create any of the threads, though).
What?
I came here for the irrelevant bullshit.
Exactly. It used to be "Who's new on Associated Content's client list?"
That got fixed.
People that don't want 'What's new and fed to you by corporate interests'?
If the top comment was anything but, "I don't give a shit about any of this." I would have lost all respect for reddit and started operation Troll Thunder. You are a hero, and not that faggy giving to charity or working in a soup kitchen hero, I'm talking covered in gore with an erection visible from the heavens hero.
So a Japanese hero?
(I kid, I kid!)
Damn right.
You can barely see japanese erections from... let alone..
(I kid, I kid!)
[deleted]
I would like to subscribe to your newsletter.
When I want to hear about fags and trolls, I go to 4chan. Get out my reddit.
When I want to read bullshit posts with no content, I go to 4chan.
You got 1100+ comment karma from one comment. That is probably the most you have ever got from one comment. This is the peak of your reddit career. Karmanaut (and Karmaknotte, and Etab) would kill for that kind of karma. An African family of four lives on that much karma for three full years.
Don't spend it all in one place.
To hell with that! You should take all of that karma and $1.50 and go blow it all on a cup of coffee. Just go crazy with it.
I'm psyched I placed second, how the shit did that happen?
Seriously unexpected. It feels good to have struck a chord with the crew but it's beyond belief at this point. I'll be frugal, don't worry.
Flaming time!
I don't think Karmanaut and Etab care at all about their Karma at this point and that's what makes them cool, not caring.
Maybe dedicated, but definitely not cool.
Wahoo! Someone who talks sense, who gives a flying fuck
That first part is actually a valid point even though you obviously made it as a joke.
In what way has the "community spoken"? I didn't ask for her to be removed, and I doubt the vast majority of redditors did either. Basically, the only people who really made a big deal about it were those baying for her blood. So essentially the angry mob rules the decision making process and those who are indifferent (again probably the majority given the hundreds of thousands of people who visit this site) are expected to accept comments like "nobody in this community is comfortable with Saydrah being a moderator here". I couldn't care less. As far as I recall, I saw a post from a reddit administrator yesterday saying there was nothing particularly wrong with the way she moderates.
I'm not saying that the decision was right or wrong. I just don't like the justification for making it. What I will say though, is that I hope this brings the whole sorry episode to a close. While it may have started with some pretty underhand actions on the part of one person, the screeching and baying overreaction from some people was embarrassing to watch.
All in favor of removing Krispity Krcks?! Aye! Where's my pitch fork?!
I signed in just to say the same! Who gives a fuck?
I never understood why it matters that she works in social media.. so lets say she gets payed to post links for companies right? If you see something you don't like, down vote it. Problem solved right? How does her being a moderator affect what gets to the front page? Do people mindlessly up vote things posted by moderators? I agree with you, who cares. The site is a pure democracy, unless she is using botnets or multiple accounts to cheat and up vote her own posts/links, it doesnt matter.
People were saying that she was banning posts that competed with her own, so hers would get more karma and make it to the front page. I never saw any evidence for that, though. IMO, If she had been banning legit stuff, the other mods would have noticed. But meh, drama finally over now.
More importantly, the Admins never saw any evidence of illegitimate bans either, nor did any mods of any of the subreddits she moderated. Funny how the frothing mob tends to overlook that.
It really depends on the type of person you are and if you believe in preemptive action. If you believe that a potential problem is a problem then you'd want her out. If you believe that until something bad actually happens everything is good then it'd be fine. It's very easy to take both sides of this argument to extremes and I'm not here to debate that. I'm simply stating that it's a problem for some people and for others it's not because of how they perceive problems.
I don't know Saydrah and wish her no ill will, but the conflict of interest was there. I likened it in a previous post to a member of the NY Yankees front office staff also being a part time umpire at the Yankee's home games. Even if every call he made was strictly by the book there would be no way anyone would think the calls were fair. To me that was the only problem, not in any action she ever took. As far as people calling it a witch hunt, yes some people went too far, but Saydrah herself was arrogant, offensive, and denied any possible conflict of interest until it became apparent that she was literally desperate to retain her moderator status for some reason. That became an issue in and of itself in my opinion. Almost everyone handled themselves in a less than mature manner, yet any moderator who speaks up on the issue wags a disapproving finger at only the members of Reddit and not at Saydrah. That is bullshit, because there is plenty of blame on her part as well.
There's evidence of it ON THE FRONT PAGE TODAY.
It's called the duck-house.
Saydrah's been thoroughly exposed. It's over for her on here.
One guy said he had been banned and provided evidence. I don't consider that evidence of her regularly banning unreasonably. I think we need at least more than one example of questionable behavior before we can say that she's been "thoroughly exposed".
Conflict of interest -- look it up.
Would you like it if the president of the US were being paid off by the Taliban?
That would be a conflict of interest too. Same principle.
That is the most asinine analogy and justification for the shitfest foisted on her that I have probably even heard here.
Your inability to explain why the analogy is unjustified is proof that you're just trolling.
Seriously, the amount of bullshit coming out of people over this absolutely blows my mind.
Being a mod isn't like being a fucking senator or some shit, chill the fuck out people.
I gave two shits at first, but then took them back.
Here here!
-_-
No, but I meant pay attention to this thing HERE that...
Oh, bother.
I just read that in a Pooh voice.
It's actually "Hear! Hear!"
No, I actually think, like many others, that the post was just saying he/she was here. ☮
Exception: when mooxie finds something I lost.
then perhaps you should join the new subreddit:
http://www.reddit.com/r/whoissaydrah/
No seriously, this moderator did the right thing, everyone in the world is accountable for the actions they take. Also, she might be a very good person, however the language she used to reply was a bit off the mark.
Easily a contender for comment of the year. And it's only March.
I am shocked by the response.
[deleted]
I don't give a shit what you demand.
[deleted]
I don't give a shit if you don't give a shit if I...
Oh, who gives a shit, anyway?
meh.
WELL SAID!
I like the cut of your jib.
The perfect comment!
I didn't know anything was up with the moderators, and, really, I don't care.
They're just moderators. We have no personal connection, and they have no impressive power to worship. They're reddit users like everyone else.
As such, big emotional posts about the removal of a minor position of editing power weird me out. This is the internet, not a corporate takeover.
Thank pie, I thought I was the only one.
Cheap LOLz. Reddit is made out of them.
Haha, this is so true.
Agreed
I'm not even sure what's going on.
Yup, this.
ROFL, my thoughts exactly.
I was gonna go with "Shut up you fucking babies" but I like this apathetic version better.
yeah, Blah blah blah. I wish I had never read this.
I personally don't care if she used her moderator privileges to spam anything on reddit, I just want her to suffer for being a miserable human being. It's people who work in the spam industry who are ruining the internet.
I agree. It was a lot of drama by a bunch of kids who think they own this community.
none of the drama should have even reached the front page, it should have been something internal.
Holy bananas, someone else who cares little for internet politics! Have an upvote!
Ha. I lold
Amen! I think some people take their reddit a little too seriously.
cant she just change her name?
[deleted]
No kidding! This makes the Tiger Woods bullshit look like the moon landing as far as "news" is concerned. Get back to posting geeky shit and porn Reddit!
No kidding. Some people take this fuckin' website way too seriously. Am I the only one who comes here solely to find retarded pictures to make me laugh?
[deleted]
We used to have a reddit that was worth caring about. Your comment, in all seriousness, is a perfect example of why it has descended into the shitty shit hole it is today; the kind of site that produces as much drama as it has over this Saydrah situation. We've become a place people go to find "retarded pictures". Thank jeebus for the subreddits.
To clarify, I'm not condemning your personal participation in the site, or suggesting you made it this way or whatever. I'm just pointing out that the attitude you expressed in your comment is evidence of reddit's great decline, and part of why the situation you're lamenting is happening.
Reddit is a democratically run organization, at least as much as a website with an anonymous user base can be. Each user -- or account, rather -- gets a single vote on all content. There are clearly people that game the system, but let's pretend that it comes down to one-person, one-vote. It seems that such a system would provide the content that its users want. Reddit descending into the "shitty shit hole that it is today" appears to be a byproduct of your dislike for the content that the masses seem to want. That's not a descent, it's just the evolution of the group.
This is all natural in the progression of any democratically-run organization as it scales. The lowest and greatest common denominators tend to separate. You seem to want a community comprised of intellectuals-only without any of the riff-raff just looking for a chuckle. That's not going to happen in an open forum like Reddit. You have to take the good with the bad. Otherwise, you'll need to build walls around your preferred group and have specific criteria for membership, a system that also clearly has its disadvantages.
I do see your point, and I'm sorry to be so bitchy. But I can't stand it when people complain about the great downfall of Reddit when, as far as I can tell, it's providing exactly the kind of content its users, as a whole, want.
I agree that reddit is providing the content that its users, as a majority, want. I also wouldn't want to see reddit become a members-only site any more than you would. But, where I disagree is in that the content on the front page today vs. 3 or 4 years ago is due to the evolution of the group. I would say it's due to a corruption of the group. That word has connotations I don't mean to imply, but think of corruption in the sense of a hard disk or digital file. We've introduced "artifacts" (i.e. users most interested in r/pics) to the "data" (i.e. user base). You could call that evolution if you'd like, but I still see it as a decline in overall quality.
Other people have expressed this before and the solution always comes back to subreddits. They are indeed great for providing specific, user-desired content. It's just that these stories used to be on the front page, is all.
It is pretty pathetic that this comment got so many upvotes.
I would have preferred that they kept Saydrah personally. It would have been interesting to see if the current popular reddits with the Saydrah group would have been left in favor of new ones.